Whereas Australia has pursued a skills-based migration policy, the United States has privileged family-based migration. The key contrast between these migration regimes provides a rare test of how national immigration policy shapes immigrant selection and integration. Does a skills-based immigration regime result in a more select group of Asian immigrants in Australia compared to their counterparts in the United States? Are Asian immigrants more integrated into their host society in Australia compared to the United States? Focusing on four groups of Asian immigrants in both countries (Chinese, Indians, Filipinos, and Vietnamese), this article addresses these questions using a transpacific comparison. Despite Australia’s skills-based immigration policy, we find that Asian immigrants in Australia are less hyper-selected than their counterparts in the United States. Asian immigrants in Australia also report worse labor market outcomes than those in the United States, with the exception of Vietnamese—a refugee group. Altogether, these findings challenge the conventional wisdom that skills-based immigration policy not only results in more selected immigrants, but also positively influences their integration into the host society.
AlbaRichardFonerNancy. 2014. Comparing immigrant integration in North America and Western Europe: How much do the grand narratives tell us?International Migration Review48 (s1): S263–91.
2.
AlbaRichardFonerNancy. 2015. Strangers no more: Immigration and the challenges of integration in North America and Western Europe. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.
3.
AlbaRichardWatersMary C.2011. The next generation: Immigrant youth in a comparative perspective. New York, NY: NYU Press.
4.
AntecolHeatherCobb-ClarkDeborahTrejoStephen. 2003. Immigration policy and the skills of immigrants to Australia, Canada, and the United States. Journal of Human Resources38 (1): 192–218.
5.
Australian Bureau of Statistics. 2013. Microdata: Census of Population and Housing, census sample file, 2011. Canberra: Australian Bureau of Statistics.
6.
Australian Bureau of Statistics. 2018. Migration, Australia, 2016-17. Canberra: Australian Bureau of Statistics.
7.
Australian Department of Home Affairs. 2017. Australia’s multicultural policy history. Canberra: Department of Home Affairs.
8.
Australian Department of Home Affairs. 2019. Points table for skilled independent visa. Canberra: Department of Home Affairs.
9.
Australian Parliamentary Library. 2017. Migration to Australia: A quick guide to the statistics. Canberra: Parliamentary Library.
10.
BelotMichèleHattonTimothy. 2012. Immigrant selection in the OECD. Scandinavian Journal of Economics114 (4): 1105–28.
11.
BerdahlJennifer L.MinJi-A.2012. Prescriptive stereotypes and workplace consequences for East Asians in North America. Cultural Diversity & Ethnic Minority Psychology18 (2): 141–52.
12.
BiddleNicholasGrayMatthewHerzDianeLoJieh-Yung. 2019. Asian-Australian experiences of discrimination. Canberra: ANU Centre for Social Research and Methods.
13.
BloemraadIrene. 2006. Becoming a citizen in the United States and Canada: Structured mobilization and immigrant political incorporation. Social Forces85 (2): 667–95.
14.
BratsbergBerntRaganJames F.2002. The impact of host-country schooling on earnings: A study of male immigrants in the United States. Journal of Human Resources37 (1): 63–105.
15.
CastañedaErnesto. 2018. A place to call home. Stanford, CA: Stanford University Press.
16.
ChinMargaret M.2020. Stuck: Why Asian Americans don’t reach the top of the corporate ladder. New York, NY: New York University Press.
17.
ChiswickBarry R.LeAnh T.MillerPaul W.2008. How immigrants fare across the earnings distribution in Australia and the United States. ILR Review61 (3): 353–73.
18.
CrulMauriceMollenkopfJohn. 2012. The changing face of world cities. New York, NY: Russell Sage Foundation.
19.
De AlwisSheruniParrNick. 2018. Differences in occupation between ancestry subgroups of Asian birthplace groups in Australia. Australian Journal of Social Issues53 (2): 173–202.
20.
De AlwisSheruniParrNickGuo.Fei2018. Divine discrimination? How do Asian migrants’ employment outcomes differ by religion and country of birth in Australia?Paper presented at 2018 Population Association of America Annual Meeting, Denver, CO.
21.
DuleepHarrietRegetsMark. 2014. U.S. immigration policy at a crossroads: Should the U.S. continue its family-friendly policy?International Migration Review3:823–45.
22.
ForrestJamesJohnstonRon. 1999. Disadvantage, discrimination and the occupational differentiation of migrant groups in Australia. International Journal of Population Geography5 (4): 277–96.
23.
GubernskayaZoyaDrebyJoanna. 2017. U.S. immigration policy and the case for family unity. Journal on Migration and Human Security5 (2): 417–30.
24.
HirschmanCharlesWongMorrison G.1984. Socioeconomic gains of Asian Americans, blacks, and Hispanics: 1960–1976. American Journal of Sociology90 (3): 584–607.
25.
HoChristinaAlcorsoCaroline. 2004. Migrants and employment: Challenging the success story. Journal of Sociology40 (3): 237–59.
26.
HoldawayJenniferZhengZhenzhenZhangZhanxin. 2018. Different contexts, common concerns: Migration, social development and social protection in China and the US. China Population and Development Studies2 (1): 1–10.
27.
HuangTiffany. 2019. Negotiating the workplace: Second-generation Asian American professionals’ early experiences. Working Paper, Department of Sociology, Columbia University, New York, NY.
28.
HugoGraeme. 1992. Knocking at the door: Asian immigration to Australia. Asian and Pacific Migration Journal1 (1): 100–144.
29.
HugoGraeme. 2001. International migration and the labour market in Australia. In International migration in Asia: Trends and policies, 139–76. OECD Proceedings. Paris: OECD.
30.
ImoageneOnoso. 2017. Beyond expectations: Second-generation Nigerians in the United States and Britain. Berkeley, CA: University of California Press.
31.
JensenEric. 2015. China replaces Mexico as the top sending country for immigrants to the United States. Research Matters. Washington, DC: U.S. Census Bureau.
32.
JuppJames. 1995. From “White Australia” to “part of Asia”: Recent shifts in Australian immigration policy towards the region. International Migration Review29 (1): 207–28.
33.
KandelWilliam A.2018. U.S. family-based immigration policy. Washington, DC: Congressional Research Service.
34.
KasinitzPhilipWatersMary C.MollenkopfJohn H.HoldawayJennifer. 2008. Inheriting the city: The children of immigrants come of age. New York, NY: Russell Sage Foundation.
35.
KaushalNeerajLuYao. 2015. Recent immigration to Canada and the United States: A mixed tale of relative selection. International Migration Review49 (2): 479–522.
36.
KeelyCharles B.1971. Effects of the Immigration Act of 1965 on selected population characteristics of immigrants to the United States. Demography8 (2): 157–69.
37.
KiangLisaHuynhVirginia W.CheahCharissa S. L.WangYijieYoshikawaHirokazu. 2017. Moving beyond the model minority. Asian American Journal of Psychology8 (1): 1–6.
38.
KlerParvinder. 2006. Graduate overeducation and its effects among recently arrived immigrants to Australia: A longitudinal survey. International Migration44 (5): 93–128.
39.
LaiLeiBabcockLinda C.2013. Asian Americans and workplace discrimination: The interplay between sex of evaluators and the perception of social skills. Journal of Organizational Behavior34 (3): 310–26.
40.
LeeJenniferZhouMin. 2015. The Asian American achievement paradox. New York, NY: Russell Sage Foundation.
41.
LeeTiane L.FiskeSusan T.2006. Not an outgroup, not yet an ingroup: Immigrants in the stereotype content model. International Journal of Intercultural Relations30 (6): 751–68.
42.
LopezGustavoRuizNeil G.PattenEileen. 2017. Key facts about Asian Americans. Washington, DC: Pew Research Center.
43.
LouieVivian. 2004. Compelled to excel. Stanford, CA: Stanford University Press.
44.
MadambaAnna B.De JongGordon F.1997. Job mismatch among Asians in the United States: Ethnic group comparisons. Social Science Quarterly78 (2): 524–42.
45.
McAllisterIan. 1995. Occupational mobility among immigrants: The impact of migration on economic success in Australia. International Migration Review29 (2): 441–68.
46.
OngleyPatrickPearsonDavid. 1995. Post-1945 international migration: New Zealand, Australia and Canada compared. International Migration Review29 (3): 765–93.
47.
PaikSusan J.ChoeShirlie Mae MamarilWitensteinMatthew A.2016. Filipinos in the U.S.: Historical, social, and educational experiences. Social and Education History5 (2): 134–60.
48.
Parliament of Australia. 2006. Skilled migration to Australia. Canberra: Parliament of Australia.
49.
Parliament of Australia. 2010. Australia’s migration program. Canberra: Parliament of Australia.
50.
ParrNickGuoFei. 2005. Occupational concentration and mobility of Asian immigrants in Australia. Asian and Pacific Migration Journal14 (3): 351–80.
51.
Pew Research Center. 2013. The rise of Asian Americans. Washington, DC: Pew Research Center.
52.
PortesAlejandroRumbautRuben G.2001. Legacies: The story of the immigrant second generation. Berkeley, CA: University of California Press.
53.
RadfordJynnah. 2019. Key findings about U.S. immigrants. Washington, DC: Pew Research Center.
54.
RahmanZaynahPaikSusan J.2017. South Asian immigration and education in the U.S.: Historical and social contexts. Social and Education History6 (1): 26–52.
55.
ReitzJeffrey G.BretonRaymond. 1994. The illusion of difference: Realities of ethnicity in Canada and the United States. Toronto: C.D. Howe Institute.
56.
ReitzJeffrey G.ZhangHeatherHawkinsNaoko. 2011. Comparisons of the success of racial minority immigrant offspring in the United States, Canada and Australia. Social Science Research40 (4): 1051–66.
57.
SaadCarmel S.SueStanleyZaneNolanChoYoung Il. 2012. The relationship between education and ethnic minority factors in income Among Asian Americans. Asian American Journal of Psychology3 (2): 66–78.
58.
SakamotoArthurGoyetteKimberly A.KimChang Hwan. 2009. Socioeconomic attainments of Asian Americans. Annual Review of Sociology35:255–76.
59.
TranVan C.2018. Social mobility across immigrant generations: Recent evidence and future data requirements. The ANNALS of the American Academy of Political and Social Science677 (1): 105–88.
60.
TranVan C.2019. Second-generation contextual mobility: Neighborhood attainment from birth to young adulthood in the United States. International Migration Review54 (2). doi.org/10.1177/0197918319832235.
61.
TranVan C.LeeJenniferHuangTiffany J.2019. Revisiting the Asian second-generation advantage. Ethnic and Racial Studies42 (13): 2248–69.
62.
TranVan C.LeeJenniferKhachikianOshinLeeJess. 2018. Hyper-selectivity, racial mobility, and the remaking of race. RSF4 (5): 188–209.
63.
TranVan C.ValdezNicol M.2017. Second-generation decline or advantage? Latino assimilation in the aftermath of the Great Recession. International Migration Review51 (1): 155–90.
64.
TranVan C.Lara-GarcíaFrancisco. 2020. A new beginning: Integration of recent refugees in the early years of arrival to the United States. RSF: The Russell Sage Foundation Journal of the Social Sciences6 (3).
65.
U.S. Census Bureau and U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics. 2008–2012. Current Population Survey: Annual Social and Economic (ASEC) Supplement Survey. Ann Arbor, MI: Inter-university Consortium for Political and Social Research.
van TubergenFrank. 2005. Self-employment of immigrants: A cross-national study of 17 Western societies. Social Forces84 (2): 709–32.
68.
van TubergenFrankMaasInekeFlapHenk. 2004. The economic incorporation of immigrants in 18 Western societies: Origin, destination, and community effects. American Sociological Review69 (5): 704–27.
69.
VillarrealAndrésTamboriniChristopher R.2018. Immigrants’ economic assimilation: Evidence from longitudinal earnings records. American Sociological Review83 (4): 686–715.
70.
WarikooNatasha K.2011. Balancing acts: Youth culture in the global city. Berkeley, CA: University of California Press.
71.
WatersMary C.JiménezTomás R.2005. Assessing immigrant assimilation: New empirical and theoretical challenges. Annual Review of Sociology31 (1): 105–25.
72.
WatersMary C.PineauMarisa Gerstein. 2015. The integration of immigrants into American society. Washington, DC: National Academies Press.
73.
ZhouMinBankstonCarl L.1998. Growing up American: How Vietnamese children adapt to life in the United States. New York, NY: Russell Sage Foundation.
