The authors review the neural pathways mediating nociceptive flexion reflexes, the method for analyzing these reflexes in human beings, and available data on their modulation by supraspinal, opioid as well as serotonergic systems. They present results of studies of the biceps femoris flexion reflex (RIII) in pain syndromes and various types of headache. Nociceptive flexor reflexes appear to be interesting for studying the pathophysiology of head pain mechanisms and possibly for evaluating analgesic treatment.
WillisWDControl of nociceptive transmission in the spinal cord. In:AutrumHOttosonDPerlERSchmidtRF edsProgress in sensory physiology.Berlin:Springer-Verlag,1982;3:1–159
2.
D'AmourFESmithDLA method for determining loss of pain sensation.J Pharmacol Exp Ther1941;72:74–9
3.
RossGSA technique to study pain in monkeys: effect of drug and anatomic lesion. In:KnightonRSDumkePR edsPain.Boston:Little, Brown & Co,1966:91–110
4.
AmirSAmirZEndogenous opioid ligands may mediate stress induced changes in the affective properties of pain related behaviour in rats.Life Sci1978;23:1143–71
5.
BodnarRJKellyDDSpiaggiaAEhrenbergCGlusmanMDose-dependent reduction by naloxone of analgesia induced by cold-water stress.Pharmacol Biochem Behav1978;8:667–72
6.
HardyJDWolffHGGoodellHStudies on pain: an investigation of some quantitative aspects of the dol scale of pain intensity.J Clin Invest1948;27:380–6
7.
RussellWJTateMAA device for applying nociceptive stimulation by pressure.J Physiol (Lond)1975;248:5–7
8.
KeeleCASensations aroused by chemical stimulation of the skin. In:KeeleCASmithR edsThe assessment of pain in man and animals.Edinburgh:Livingstone1962:28–40
9.
NotermansSLMeasurement of pain threshold determined by electrical stimulation and its clinical application.Neurology (Minneap)1966;16:1071–86
10.
WillerJCNociceptive flexion reflexes as a tool for pain research in man. In:DesmedtJE edMotor control mechanisms in health and disease.New York:Raven Press,1983:809–27
11.
WillerJCComparative study of perceived pain and nociceptive flexion reflex in man.Pain1977;3:69–80
12.
BurgessPRPerlERCutaneous mechanoceptors and nociceptors. In:IggoA edsHandbook of sensory physiology.Berlin:Springer,1973;2:29–78
13.
HallinRGTorebjorkHEElectrically induced A and C fibers responses in intact human skin nerves.Exp Brain Res1973;16:309–20
14.
HugonMExteroceptive reflexes to stimulation of the sural nerve in normal man. In:DesmedtJE edsNew developments in electromyography and clinical neurophysiology.Basel1973;3:713–29
15.
WillerJCBoureauFAlbe-FessardDRole of large diameter cutaneous afferents in transmission of nociceptive messages: electrophysiological study in man.Brain Res1978;152:358–64
16.
WillerJCAlbe-FessardDFurther studies on the role of afferent input from relatively large diameter fibers in transmission of nociceptive messages in humans.Brain Res1983;278:318–21
17.
WallPDThe laminar organization of dorsal horn and effects of descending impulses.J Physiol (Lond)1967;188:403–23
18.
PerlERIs pain a specific sensation?J Psychiatry Res1971;8:273–87
19.
VierckCJHamiltonDMThornbyJLPain reactivity of monkeys after lesion to the dorsal lateral columns of the spinal cord.Exp Brain Res1971;13:129–37
20.
MelzackRWallPDPain mechanisms: a new theory.Science1965;150:971–9
21.
CaseyKLUnit analysis of nociceptive mechanisms in the thalamus of the awake squirrel monkey.J Neurophysiol1966;29:727–50
22.
HoleKBergeOGRegulation of pain sensitivity in the central nervous system.Cephalalgia1981;1:51–9
23.
BasbaumALFieldsHLEndogenous pain control system: brainstem spinal pathways and endorphin circuitry.Annu Rev Neurosci1984;7:309–38
24.
Le BarsDDickensonAHBessonJMDiffuse noxious inhibitory controls (DNIC). I.Effects on dorsal horn convergent neurones in the rat1979;6:283–304
25.
Le BarsDDickensonAHBessonJMDiffuse noxious inhibitory controls (DNIC). II. Lack of effect on non-convergent neurones, supraspinal involvement and theoretical implications.Pain1979;6:305–27
26.
Le BarsDDickensonAHBessonJMThe triggering of bulbo-spinal serotoninergic inhibitory controls by noxious peripheral inputs. In:Sjö1undBBjörklundA edsBrainstem control of spinal mechanism.Amsterdam:Elsevier Biomedical Press,1982;381–410
SandriniGAlfonsiECovelliVMogliaANappiGI riflessi nocicettivi di flessione come metodo di esplorazione del dolore nell'uomo.Riv It EEG Neurofisiol Cl1987;10:59–75
29.
WillerJCAlbe-FessardDElectrophysiological evidence for a release of endogenous opiates in stress-induced “analgesia” in man.Brain Res1980;198:419–26
30.
SandriniGAlfonsiEBonoGFacchinettiFMontalbettiLNappiGCircadian variations of human flexion reflex.Pain1986;25:403–10
31.
WillerJCStudies on pain. Effects of morphine on a spinal nociceptive flexion reflex and related pain sensation in man.Brain Res1985;105–14
32.
WillerJCBoureauFAlbe-FessardDSupraspinal influences on nociceptive flexion reflex and pain sensation in man.Brain Res1979;179:61–8
33.
BathienNRéflexes spinaux chez l'homme et niveaux d'attention.Electroencephalogr Clin Neurophysiol1971;30:32–7
34.
WillerJCRobyALe BarsDPsychophysical and electrophysiological approaches to the pain-relieving effects of heterotopic nociceptive stimuli.Brain1984;107:1095–112
35.
WillerJCBoureauFDauthierCBonoraMStudy of naloxone in normal awake man: effects on heart rate and respiration.Neuropharmacology1979;15:469–72
36.
AkilHWatsonSJYoungELewisMEKhachaturianHWalkerJMEndogenous opioids: biology and Function.Annu Rev Neurosci1984;7:223–55
37.
FacchinettiFSandriniGPetragliaFAlfonsiENappiGGenazzaniARConcomitant increase in nociceptive flexion reflex threshold and plasma opioids following transcutaneous nerve stimulation.Pain1984;19:295–303
38.
ChanCWYTsangHInhibition of the human flexion reflex by low intensity, high frequency transcutaneous electrical nerve stimulation (TENS) has a gradual onset and offset.Pain1987;28:239–53
39.
Sjö1undBHErikssonMBStimulation techniques in the management of pain. In:KosterlitzHWTereniusLY edsPain and society. Dahlem Konferenzen 1980.Weinheim:Verlag Chemie,1981:415–30
40.
NappiGFacchinettiFLegnanteGParriniDPetragliaFSavoldiFGenazzaniARDifferent releasing effects of traditional manual acupuncture and electroacupuncture on proopiocortin-related peptides.Acupunct Electro Ther Res Int J1952;7:93–103
41.
NappiGFacchinettiFBonoGMicieliGParriniDMartignoniEPetragliaFGenazzaniARPlasma opioid levels in post-traumatic chronic headache and trigeminal neuralgia: maintained response to acupuncture.Headache1982;22:276–9
42.
BoureauFSebilleAWillerJCBathienNDerouesneCEffets d'une stimulation èlectrique hétérosegmentaire percutanée (électroacupuncture) sur le réflexe nociceptif de flexion chez l'homme.Extrait des annales de l'anesthésiologie francaise1978;XIX:5
43.
GenazzaniARSandriniGFacchinettiFRizzoVAlfonsiESancesGCalvaniMNappiGEffects of L-5HTP with and without carbidopa on plasma B-endorphin and pain perception: possible implications in migraine prophylaxis,Cephalalgia1986;6:175–9
44.
WillerJCBusselBEvidence for a direct spinal mechanism in morphine-induced inhibition of nociceptive reflexes in humans.Brain Res1980;187:212–15
45.
SandriniGdegli UbertiECSalvadoriSMarguttiATrasforiniGTomatisRNappiGPansiniRDermorphin inhibits spinal nociceptive flexion reflex in humans.Brain Res1986;371:364–7
46.
RobyAWillerJCBusselBEffect of a synthetic enkephalin analogue on spinal nociceptive messages in humans.Neuropharmacology1983;22:1121–5
47.
WillerJCRobyAGerardAMauletCElectrophysiological evidence for a possible serotoninergic involvement in some endogenous opiate activity in humans.Eur J Pharma-col1982;78:117–20
48.
SandriniGAlfonsiEde RyskyCMariniSFacchinettiFNappiGEvidence for serotonin-S2 receptor involvement in analgesia in humans,Eur J Pharmacol1986;130:311–14
49.
BarberAHartingJWolfHPAntinociceptive effects of the 5-HT2 antagonist rianserin in rats: evidence for an activation of descending monoaminergic pathways in the spinal cord.Neurosci Lett1989;99:234–8
50.
OgrenSOHolmACTest-specific effects of the 5-HT reuptake inhibitors alaproclate and zimelidine on pain sensitivity and morphine analgesia.J Neural Transm1980;47:253
51.
SandriniGMartignoniEMicieliGAlfonsiESancesGNappiGPain reflexes in the clinical assessment of migraine syndromes.Funct Neurol1986;1:423–9
52.
WillerJCDehenHCambierJEtude du seuil de la douleur par enregistrement des réflexes de flexion au cours des syndromes thalamiques.Rev Neurol (Paris)1986;4,142:303–7
53.
PradalierAWillerJCBoureauFDryJRelationship between pain and obesity: an electrophysiological study.Physiol Behav1981;27:961–4
54.
SandriniGAlfonsiESancesGFacchinettiFBonoGNappiGNociceptive flexion reflex threshold in migraine sufferers.Cephalalgia1985;5(suppl 3):26–7
55.
SandriniGRuizLAlfonsiECraveraLNappiGAntinociceptive system in primary headache disorders: a neurophysiological approach. In:NappiG edsHeadache and depression: pathways as a common clue.New York:Raven Press,1991:67–78
56.
GenazzaniARNappiGFacchinettiFMicieliGPetragliaFBonoGMonittolaGSavoldiFProgressive impairment of CSF beta-EP levels in migraine sufferers.Pain1984;18:127–33
57.
NappiGSandriniGEffects of serotonergic drug administration on nociceptive flexion reflex in daily chronic headache. In:OlesenJSaxenaP eds5-hydroxytryptamine mechanisms in primary headaches.New York:Raven Press,1992:226–30
58.
NappiGSandriniGGranellaFRuizLCeruttiGFacchinettiFBlandiniFManzoniGCA new 5-HT2 antagonist (ritanserin) in the treatment of chronic headache with depression. A double blind study vs amitriptyline.Headache1990;30:439–44
59.
HardeboJEThe involvement of trigeminal substance P neurons in cluster headache: an hypothesis.Headache1984;24:294–304
60.
SandriniGAlfonsiERuizLPavesiGMicieliGManzoniGCManciaDNappiGImpairment of corneal pain perception in cluster headache.Pain1991;47:299–304
61.
SandriniGAntonaciFDanilovACapararoMMicieliGNappiGNociceptive flexion reflex in cluster headache. In:EkbomKGerberWDHenryPNappiGPfaffenrathVTfelt-HansenP edsEuropean Headache Federation (EHF). First International Conference.Bremen:Arcis Verlag,1992:76
