This study investigates how students’ national identity affects their historical understanding by mediating their use of affective historical empathy. The research focuses on the case of “comfort women” (women forced into sexual slavery for Japanese soldiers during WWII) in South Korea—a topic in which a strong nationalist narrative dominates social and educational discourses. I conducted semi-structured, task-based group interviews with 16 high school students in South Korea. In interviews, students’ national identity mediated how they utilized four types of affective historical empathy: Students as ethnic Koreans cared more about “our” Korean comfort women over others; cared that Korean comfort women and others suffered from what “we” and “they” did as nations; cared for those women's voices from a humanitarian perspective beyond their ethnic and national boundaries; and cared to make social changes for those women and themselves as future citizens of their democratic nation. These findings help us understand how students’ emotional attachment to “our” nation and its members can mediate their historical understanding through affective historical empathy as well as how affective historical empathy can motivate students to move beyond purely nationalistic concerns. This case study also stimulates reflection on historical empathy's implications for students’ democratic civic participation.
AndersonB.Imagined communities: Reflections of the origin and spread of nationalismRevised ed.2006VersoNew York, NY
2.
BartonK.C.‘You'd be wanting to know about the past’: Social contexts of children's historical understanding in Northern Ireland and the USAComparative Education371200189–106
3.
BartonK.C.School history as resource for constructing identities: Implications of research from the United States, Northern Ireland, and New ZealandCarreteroM.AsensioM.Rodriguez-MoneoM.History education and the construction of national identities2012Information Age PublishingCharlotte, NC93–107
4.
BartonK.C.Elicitation techniques: Getting people to talk about ideas that they don't usually talk aboutTheory & Research in Social Education4322015179–205
5.
BartonK.C.AveryP.G.Research on social studies education: Diverse students, settings, and methodsGitomerD.H.BellC.A.Handbook of research on teaching2015American Educational Research AssociationWashington, DC985–1038
6.
BartonK.C.LevstikL.S.Teaching history for the common good2004RoutledgeNew York, NY
7.
BartonK.C.LevstikL.S.“It wasn't a good part of history”: National identity and students’ explanations of historical significanceLevstikL.S.BartonK.C.Researching history education: Theory, method, and context2008RoutledgeNew York, NY240–272
8.
BartonK.C.McCullyA.W.History, identity, and the school curriculum in Northern Ireland: An empirical study of secondary students’ ideas and perspectivesJournal of Curriculum Studies371200585–116
9.
BartonK.C.McCullyA.W.Trying to “see things differently”: Northern Ireland students’ struggle to understand alternative historical perspectivesTheory & Research in Social Education402012371–408
10.
BraunV.ClarkeV.Using thematic analysis in psychologyQualitative Research in Psychology32200677–101
11.
BrooksS.Historical empathy in the social studies classroom: A review of the literatureJournal of Social Studies Research3322009213–234
12.
BrooksS.Historical empathy as perspective taking and care in one secondary social studies classroomTheory & Research in Social Education3922011166–202
13.
BrooksS.Connecting the past to the present in the middle-level classroom: A comparative case studyTheory & Research in Social Education421201465–95
14.
CarreteroM.AsensioM.Rodríguez-MoneoM.History education and the construction of national identities2012Information Age PublishingCharlotte, NC
ConnorW.Beyond reason: The nature of the ethnonational bondEthnic and Racial Studies1631993373–389
17.
CornblethC.Images of America: What youth do know about the United StatesAmerican Educational Research Journal3922002519–552
18.
CunninghamD.L.Understanding pedagogical reasoning in historical teaching through the case of cultivating historical empathyTheory & Research in Social Education3542007592–630
19.
CunninghamD.L.An empirical framework for understanding how teachers conceptualize and cultivate historical empathy in studentsJournal of Curriculum Studies4152009679–709
20.
EderD.FingersonL.Interview children and adolescentsGubriumJ.F.HolsteinJ.A.Handbook of interview research: Context and method2002Sage PublicationsThousand Oaks, CA181–202
21.
EndacottJ.Reconsidering affective engagement in historical empathyTheory & Research in Social Education38120106–49
22.
EndacottJ.BrooksS.An updated theoretical and practical model for promoting historical empathySocial Studies Research and Practice81201341–58
23.
EpsteinT.Deconstructing differences in African-American and European-American adolescents’ perspectives on U.S. historyCurriculum Inquiry2841998397–423
24.
EpsteinT.Racial identity and young people's perspectives on social studies educationTheory into Practice401200142–47
25.
EpsteinT.Interpreting national history: Race, identity, and pedagogy in classroom and communities2009RoutledgeNew York, NY
KimS.LeeN.Shared history and the responsibility for justice: The Korean council for the women drafted for military sexual slavery by JapanMolonyB.NelsonJ.Women's activism and “second wave” feminism: Transnational histories2017BloomsburyLondon, England193–214
38.
KohlmeierJ.“Couldn't she just leave?”: The relationship between consistently using class discussion and the development of historical empathy in a 9th grade world history courseTheory & Research in Social Education341200634–57
39.
LevstikL.S.GrothJ.“Ruled by our own people”: Ghanaian adolescents’ conceptions of citizenshipTeachers College Records1072005563–586
40.
LevyS.A.Heritage, history, and identityTeachers College Record11620141–34
41.
LevyS.A.How students navigate the construction of heritage narrativesTheory & Research in Social Education452017157–188
42.
Ministry of EducationKuksa [National history]1996The National Institute of Korean HistorySeoul, Korea
43.
Ministry of EducationKuksa [National history]2002The National Institute of Korean HistorySeoul, Korea
44.
Morris-SuzukiT.Introduction: Confronting the ghosts of war in East AsiaMorris-SuzukiT.LowM.PetrovL.TsuT.Y.East Asia beyond the history wars: Confronting the ghosts of violence2013RoutledgeNew York, NY1–26
45.
O'BrienS.Translator's introductionYoshimiY.Comfort women: Sexual slavery in the Japanese military during world war II (S. O'Brien, Trans.)2000Columbia UniversityNew York, NY1–21Original work published 1995
46.
ParkY.Comforting the nation: ‘Comfort women,’ the politics of apology and the workings of genderInterventions222000199–211
The United Nations Commission on Human Rights (UNHRC)Report on the mission to the Democratic People's Republic of Korea, the Republic of Korea and Japan on the issue of military sexual slavery in wartime1996, January 4 Retrieved fromhttps://digitallibrary.un.org/record/228137/files/E_CN-4_1996_53_Add-1-EN.pdf
55.
The United States House of RepresentativesH.Res.121: A resolution expressing the sense of the house of representatives that the government of Japan should formally acknowledge, apologize, and accept historical responsibility in a clear and unequivocal manner for its imperial armed forces’ coercion of young women into sexual slavery, known to the world as “comfort women”, during its colonial and wartime occupation of Asia and the Pacific Islands from the 1930s through the duration of world war II2007Retrieved fromhttps://www.congress.gov/bill/110th-congress/house-resolution/121
YangH.Revisiting the issue of Koran “military comfort women”: The question of truth and positionalityPositions51199751–72
58.
YangH.Re-membering the Korean military comfort womenKimE.H.ChoiC.Dangerous women: Gender and Korean nationalism1998RoutledgeNew York123–139
59.
YoshimiY.Comfort women: Sexual slavery in the Japanese military during world war II. (S. O'Brien, Trans.)2000Columbia UniversityNew York, NYOriginal work published 1995
