Published evidence suggest that laboratories allow little delegation of control to the students. We gave first-year undergraduates almost complete control of a laboratory with intensive tutor support. Staff believed the activity to have been welcomed by the students. Evaluation provides far from convincing evidence for this. Explanations are suggested.
EdwardN. S., ‘The role of laboratory work in engineering education: Student & staff perceptions’, Intl. J. Elect. Enging. Educ., 39 (2001), 11.
2.
ClowD., ‘Teaching, learning and computing’, University Chem. Educ., 2 (1998), 58–62.
3.
BatesG. C., ‘The role of the laboratory in secondary school science programs’, in RoweM. B. (ed.), What Research Says to the Science Teacher, Vol 1 (National Science Teachers' Association, Washington DC, 1978).
4.
JohnstoneA. H., ‘Chemical education research: Facts, findings and consequences’, Chemical Society Review, 2 (1980), 365–390.
5.
JohnstoneA. H., ‘Chemistry teaching: Science or alchemy?’, J. Chemistry Educ., 74 (1997), 262–268.
6.
GuyJ. J., Quantitative classroom observation illustrated by a study of chemistry classroom teaching, Chemical Education Research Symposium Report, Birmingham (Royal Society of Chemistry, London, 1982).
7.
EdwardN. S., Engineering laboratory practices in higher education: A survey and the development of an alternative simulation of one experiment, unpublished MEd dissertation, 1995.
8.
JohnstoneA. H.McCallumM., ‘Objectives in practical work’, in Proc. Education Division of the Chemical Society, Nottingham, 1972.
9.
HoweM. J. A., ‘Using cognitive psychology to help students to learn’, in Student Learning (SRHE and OU Press, Milton Keynes, 1987).
FinegoldL.HartleyC. L., ‘An experiment on experiments in a senior laboratory’, Am. J. Physics, 40 (1972), 28–31.
12.
TamirP., An enquiry orientated laboratory examination, Journal of Educational Measurement, 11 (1977), 43–48.
13.
HegartyE. H., ‘Practical curriculum development; scientific inquiry in university classes’, Research and Development in Higher Education, 2 (1979), 133–142.
14.
MeesterM. A. M.MaskillR., ‘The practical side of chemistry’, Educational Chemistry, 31 (1993), 156–159.
15.
HunterC.WardellS.WilkinsH., ‘Introducing first year students to some skills of investigatory laboratory work’, University Chem. Educ., 4 (2000), 12–15.
