We combine an expert elicitation and a bottom-up manufacturing cost model to compare the effects of R&D and demand subsidies. We model their effects on the future costs of a low-carbon energy technology that is not currently commercially available, purely organic photovoltaics (PV). We find that: (1) successful R&D enables PV to achieve a cost target of 4c/kWh, (2) the cost of PV does not reach the target when only subsidies, and not R&D, are implemented, and (3) production-related effects on technological advance—learning-by-doing and economies of scale—are not as critical to the long-term potential for cost reduction in organic PV than is the investment in and success of R&D. These results are insensitive to two levels of policy intensity, the level of a carbon price, the availability of storage technology, and uncertainty in the main parameters used in the model. However, a case can still be made for subsidies: comparisons of stochastic dominance show that subsidies provide a hedge against failure in the R&D program.
ArrowKenneth (1962). “The Economic Implications of Learning by Doing.” The Review of Economic Studies29(3): 155-173.
2.
BakerErinChonHaewonKeislerJeffrey (forthcoming). “Advanced Solar R&D: Applying Expert Elicitations to Inform Climate Policy.” Energy Economics, in press.
3.
BenthemArthur vanGillinghamKennethSweeneyJames (2008). “Learning-by-Doing and the Optimal Solar Policy in California.” The Energy Journal29(3): 131.
4.
BrabecC. J. (2004). “Organic photovoltaics: technology and market.” Solar Energy Materials and Solar Cells83(2-3): 273-292.
5.
BrenkertA.S.SmithS.KimS.PitcherH. (2003). “Model documentation for the MiniCAM.” Technical Report PNNL-14337, Pacific Northwest National Laboratory.
6.
BrutonT. M.WoodockJ. M. (1997). “Multi-megawatt upscaling of silicon and thin film solar cell and module manufacturing (MUSIC FM)”, Report CT94 0008, European Commission Project RENA.
7.
ClarkeLeon E.WeyantJohn P. (2002). “Modeling Induced Technological Change: An Overview.” Technological Change and the Environment. A. Gruebler, N. Nakicenovic and W. Nordhaus. Washington, DC, Resources for the Future: 320-363.
8.
ClarkeLeonWeyantJohnBirkyAlicia (2006). “On the sources of technological change: Assessing the evidence.” Energy Economics28(5-6): 579-595.
9.
ClarkeLeonWeyantJohnEdmondsJae (2008). “On the sources of technological change: What do the models assume.” Energy Economics30(2): 409-424.
10.
ClarkeLeonWiseMarshallPlacetMarylynnCesar IzaurraldeRLurzJoshuaKimSonSmithSteveThomsonAllison (2006). “Climate change mitigation: An analysis of advanced technology scenarios.” Technical Report PNNL-16078, Pacific Northwest National Laboratory.
11.
ClemenR.T.KwitR.C. (2001). “The value of decision analysis at Eastman Kodak Company, 1990-1999.” Interfaces31: 74-92.
12.
ClemenR.T.WinklerR.L. (1999). “Combining probability distributions from experts in risk analysis.” Risk Analysis19: 187-203.
13.
CurtrightA. E.MorganM. G.KeithD. W. (2008). “Expert Assessments of Future Photovoltaic Technologies.” Environmental Science & Technology42(24): 9031-9038.
14.
DeutchJohnMonizErnestAnsolabehereStephen (2003). “The Future of Nuclear Power: An Interdisciplinary MIT Study.” Cambridge, MA, Massachusetts Institute for Technology.
15.
DosiGiovanni (1988). “Sources, Procedures, and Microeconomic Effects of Innovation.” Journal of Economic Literature26(3): 1120-1171.
16.
DukeR.D.KammenD.M. (1999). “The Economics of Energy Market Transformation Initiatives.” The Energy Journal20(4): 15-64.
17.
EdenhoferOttmarLessmannKaiKemfertClaudia (2006). “Induced Technological Change---Exploring its Implications for the Economics of Atmospheric Stabilization: Synthesis Report from the Innovation Modeling Comparison Project.” The Energy Journal27(Special Issue on Endogenous Technological Change and the Economics of Atmospheric Stabilisation): 57-108.
18.
EdmondsJ.ClarkeJ.DooleyJ., (2004). “Stabilization of CO2 in a B2 world: insights on the roles of carbon capture and disposal, hydrogen, and transportation technologies.” Energy Economics26(4): 517-537.
19.
FrantzisL.JonesE.LeeC., (2000). “Opportunities for Cost Reductions in Photovoltaic Modules.” 16th European Photovoltaic Solar Energy Conference, Glasgow.
20.
FreemanChris (1974). The economics of industrial innovation. Cambridge, MA, The MIT Press.
21.
FreemanChrisPerezC. (1988). “Structural crises of adjustment, business cycles, and investment behavior.” Technical change and economic theory. G. Dosi, C. Freeman, R. Nelson, G. Silverberg and L. Soete. London, Pinter.
22.
FthenakisV.AlsemaE. (2006). “Photovoltaics energy payback times, greenhouse gas emissions and external costs: 2004 - early 2005 status.” Progress in Photovoltaics14(3): 275-280.
23.
FthenakisVasilis M.KimHyung ChulAlsemaErik (2008). “Emissions from photovoltaic life cycles.” Environ. Sci. Technol.42(6): 2168-2174.
24.
GhannamM.SivoththamanS.PoortmansJ. (1997). “Trends in industrial silicon solar cell processes.” Solar Energy59(1-3): 101-110.
25.
GillinghamKennethNewellRichardPizerWilliam (2007). “Modeling endogenous technological change for climate policy analysis.” RFF Discussion Paper 07-14. Washington, DC: Resources For the Future.
26.
GinleyDave (2007). “National Solar Technology Roadmap: Organic PV.” NREL/MP-520-41738, National Renewable Energy Laboratory.
27.
GoulderLawrence H.SchneiderStephen H. (1999). “Induced Technological Change and the Attractiveness of CO2 Abatement Policies.” Resource and Energy Economics21: 211-253.
28.
GrubbM. (1997). “Technologies, energy systems and the timing of CO2 emissions abatement - An overview of economic issues.” Energy Policy25(2): 159-172.
29.
GrubbMichaelKoehlerJonathanAndersonDennis (2002). “Induced technical change in energy and environmental modeling: Analytic approaches and policy implications.” Annual Review of Energy and the Environment27: 271-308.
30.
GruberHarald (1996). “Trade policy and learning by doing: the case of semiconductors.” Research Policy25: 723-739.
31.
GrueblerArnulfNakicenovicNebojsaVictorDavid G. (1999). “Modeling technological change: Implications for the global environment.” Annual Review of Energy and the Environment24: 545569.
32.
HegedusS.OkuboN. (2005). “Real BOS and system costs of off-grid PV installations in the US: 1987-2004.” Conference Record of the Thirty-first IEEE Photovoltaic Specialists Conference, 2005.
33.
HoffertM. I.CaldeiraK.BenfordG., (2002). “Advanced technology paths to global climate stability: Energy for a greenhouse planet.” Science298(5595): 981-987.
34.
HorbachJens (2007). “Determinants of environmental innovation--New evidence from German panel data sources.” Research Policy37(1): 163-173.
35.
IEA (2008). Energy Technology Perspectives: Scenarios and Strategies to 2050. Paris, International Energy Agency.
36.
JaffeAdam B.NewellRichard G.StavinsRobert N. (2002). “Environmental Policy and Technological Change.” Environmental and Resource Economics22(1-2): 41-70.
37.
JaffeAdam B.NewellRichard G.StavinsRobert N. (2005). “A tale of two market failures: Technology and environmental policy.” Ecological Economics54(2-3): 164-174.
38.
KalowekamoJosephBakerErin (forthcoming). “Estimating the manufacturing cost of purely organic solar cells.” Solar Energy, in press.
39.
KeithD. W. (1996). “When is it appropriate to combine expert judgments?” Climatic Change33(2): 139-143.
40.
KeshnerM.S.AryaR. (2004). “Study of the Potential Cost Reductions Resulting from Super-Large-Scale Manufacturing of PV Modules.” Report NREL/SR-520-36846, Golden, CO, National Renewable Energy Laboratory.
41.
KlaassenG.MiketaA.LarsenK., (2005). “The impact of R&D on innovation for wind energy in Denmark, Germany and the United Kingdom.” Ecological Economics54(2-3): 227-240.
42.
KouvaritakisNikolaosSoriaAntonioIsoardStephane (2000). “Modelling energy technology dynamics: methodology for adaptive expectations models with learning by doing and learning by searching.” International Journal of Global Energy Issues14(1-4): 104-115.
43.
LevyHaim (1992). “Stochastic dominance and expected utility: Survey and analysis.” Management Science38: 555-593.
44.
LewisNathan S. (2007). “Toward cost-effective solar energy use.” Science315(5813): 798-801.
45.
LoschelAndreas (2004). “Technological change, energy consumption, and the costs of environmental policy in energy-economy-environment modeling.” International Journal of Energy Technology and Policy2(3): 250-261.
46.
ManneA.RichelsR. (2004). “The impact of learning-by-doing on the timing and costs of CO2 abatement.” Energy Economics26(4): 603-619.
47.
MaycockPaul D. (1997). “Cost reduction in PV manufacturing: Impact on grid-connected and building-integrated markets.” Solar Energy Materials and Solar Cells47: 37-45.
48.
MaycockPaul D. (2003). “PV Technology, Performance, Cost 1995-2010.” PV Energy Systems.
49.
MiketaAsamiSchrattenholzerLeo (2004). “Experiments with a methodology to model the role of R&D expenditures in energy technology learning processes; first results.” Energy Policy32: 16791692.
50.
MooreMark A.BoardmanAnthony E.ViningAidan R. (2004). “Just give me a number! Practical values for the social discount rate.” Journal of Policy Analysis and Management23(4): 789-812.
51.
MoweryDavidRosenbergNathan (1979). “The influence of market demand upon innovation: a critical review of some recent empirical studies.” Research Policy8(2): 102-153.
52.
NRC (2007). Prospective Evaluation of Applied Energy Research and Development at DOE (Phase Two). National Research Council (NRC), The National Academies Press, Washington D.C.
53.
NemetGregory F. (2006). “Beyond the learning curve: factors influencing cost reductions in photo-voltaics.” Energy Policy34(17): 3218-3232.
54.
NemetGregory F. (2007). Policy and innovation in low-carbon energy technologies. Energy and Resources Group, PhD Dissertation.
55.
NemetGregory F. (2008). “Demand-pull energy technology policies, diffusion, and improvements in California wind power.” Innovations for a Low Carbon Economy: Economic, Institutional and Management Approaches. T. Foxon, J. Koehler and C. Oughton. Cheltenham, UK, Edward Elgar.
56.
NemetGregory F. (2009). “Interim monitoring of cost dynamics for publicly supported energy technologies.” Energy Policy37(3): 825-835.
57.
NemetGregory F.KammenDaniel M. (2007). “U.S. energy research and development: Declining investment, increasing need, and the feasibility of expansion.” Energy Policy35(1): 746-755.
58.
NeuhoffKarstenNemetGregorySatoMisato, (2007). “The role of the supply chain in innovation: the example of photovoltaic cells.” Working Paper EPRG 07/32. Cambridge, U.K., University of Cambridge - Electricity Policy Research Group.
59.
Norberg-BohmVicki (1999). “Stimulating green technological innovation: An analysis of alternative policy mechanisms.” Policy Sciences32(1): 13-38.
60.
O’NeillBrianGrueblerArnulfNakicenovicNebojsa (2003). “Letters to the Editor: Planning for Future Energy Resources.” Science300: 581.
61.
PacalaSteveSocolowRobert (2004). “Stabilization Wedges: Solving the Climate Problem for the Next 50 Years with Current Technologies.” Science305: 968-972.
62.
PeerenboomJ. P.BuehringW. A.JosephT. W. (1989). “Selecting a Portfolio of Environmental-Programs for a Synthetic Fuels Facility.” Operations Research37(5): 689-699.
63.
PoppD. (2004). “ENTICE: endogenous technological change in the DICE model of global warming.” Journal of Environmental Economics and Management48(1): 742-768.
64.
PoppDavid (2006). “ENTICE-BR: The effects of backstop technology R&D on climate policy models.” Energy Economics28(2): 188-222.
65.
PrinsGwynRaynerSteve (2007). “Time to ditch Kyoto.” Nature449(7165): 973-975.
66.
RemerD. S.ChaiL. H. (1990). “Design Cost Factors for Scaling-up Engineering Equipment.” Chemical Engineering Progress86(8): 77-82.
67.
RequateTill (2005). “Dynamic incentives by environmental policy instruments - a survey.” Ecological Economics54(2-3): 175-195.
68.
RohatgiA. (2003). “Road to cost-effective crystalline silicon photovoltaics.” Proceedings of 3rd World Conference on Photovoltaic Energy Conversion, Osaka, Japan.
69.
RothschildMichaelStiglitzJoseph (1970). “Increasing risk I: A definition.” Journal of Economic Theory2: 225-243.
70.
SchaefferG.J.SeebregtsA.J.BeurskensL.W.M., (2004). “Learning from the Sun; Analysis of the use of experience curves for energy policy purposes: The case of photovoltaic power. Final report of the PHOTEX project.” ECN Renewable Energy in the Built Environment.
71.
SEIA (2004). Our Solar Power Future: The photovoltaics industry roadmap through 2030 and beyond. Washington, DC, Solar Energy Industries Association.
72.
SharpePaulKeelinTom (1998). “How Smithkline Beecham Makes Better Resource-Allocation Decisions.” Harvard Business Review76(2): 45-57.
73.
StavyMichael (2002). “A Financial Worksheet for Computing the Cost of Solar Electricity Generated at Grid Connected Photovaltaic Generating Plants.” Journal of Solar Energy Engineering124: 319-321.
74.
IanSue Wing (2006). “Representing induced technological change in models for climate policy analysis.” Energy Economics28(5-6): 539-562.
75.
TaylorMargaretNemetGregoryColvinMichael (2007). “Government Actions and Innovation in Clean Energy Technologies: The Cases of Photovoltaic Cells, Solar Thermal Electric Power, and Solar Water Heating.” CEC-500-2007-012. Sacramento, California Energy Commission.
76.
ChihiroWatanabeWakabayashiKoujiMiyazawaToshinori (2000). “Industrial Dynamism and the Creation of a Virtuous Cycle Between R&D, Market Growth and Price Reduction - The Case of photovoltaic Power Generation (PV) Development in Japan.” Technovation20: 299-312.
77.
WeneClas-Otto (2000). Experience Curves for Technology Policy. Paris, International Energy Agency.
78.
YangChi-JenOppenheimerMichael (2007). “A Manhattan Project for climate change?” Climatic Change V 80(3): 199-204.
