Britain was one of the first countries to introduce competition to retail energy markets in 1998; after a decade of choice, around half of its residential consumers have switched supplier. This paper presents evidence on consumer and supplier behaviour over the decade since the markets were opened to assess the success of the ‘experience’ to date. The early debate about the value of extending choice to householders, in which David Newbery was amongst those who expressed doubts, remains to be resolved in an era of rising costs and increasing politicisation. “While Britain has coped very well with wholesale market power, ending the domestic franchise and removing regulation from the retail supply margin has exposed households to considerable increases in those margins, as switching costs appear significant, and vertically integrated companies have been effective in exploiting their power.” David Newbery, Market Design, EPRG working paper 0515 p.9, 2005
AkmanP.HarkerM.Waddams PriceC., (2007). “Pros and Cons of Prepayment Meters”, mimeo, Centre for Competition Policy, University of East Anglia.
2.
AsherA., (2008). “Regulating the Energy Sector”, speech at Kings seminar, http://www.energywatch.org.uk/uploads/Kings_College_Seminar_on_Regulations_29_February_2008.pdf, accessed 2nd April 2008.
3.
BBC, (2008). “Big Energy Price Rises Likely”, accessed 15 July 2008, http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/low/business/7469848.stm.
4.
BERR, (2007). Digest of United Kingdom Energy Statistics 2007, London.
5.
BERR, (2008). Quarterly Energy Prices, June 2008, London.
6.
BorensteinS., (2008). “Cost, Conflict and Climate: U.S. Challenges in the World Oil Market”, UCEI working paper 177.
7.
BradleyI.PriceC., (1988). “Economic Regulation of Private Monopolies through Price Constraints”, Journal of Industrial Economics, XXXVII(1): 99-106.
8.
BradleyI.PriceC., (1991). “Average Revenue Regulation and Regional Price Structure”, Regional Science and Urban Economics, 21(1): 89-108.
CornwallN., (2008). “Gas and electricity costs to consumers”, National Right to Fuel campaign and Unison.
11.
DarlingA., (2008). Financial statement, House of Commons, March 12th.
12.
DaviesS.W.Waddams PriceC., (2007a). “Competitive non-linear pricing: retail electricity in Great Britain”, mimeo presented at Competition Law and Economics European Network meeting, Bonn, December 2007.
13.
DaviesS.W.Waddams PriceC., (2007b). “Does ownership unbundling matter? Evidence from UK energy markets”, Intereconomics.
14.
Energywatch, (2008a). accessed April 2nd 2008 http://www.energywatch.org.uk/about_us/aims_and_values/index.asp.
15.
Energywatch, (2008b). “Energywatch responds to Budget announcement”, accessed 15th July 2008, http://www.energywatch.org.uk/media/news/show_release.asp?article_id=1090&display_type=archive.
16.
European Commission, (2007). “Energising Europe: A real market with secure supply”. Available at http://ec.europa.eu/energy/electricity/package_2007/index_en.htm.
17.
FarrellJ.KlempererP., (2007). “Coordination and Lock-In: Competition with Switching Costs and Network Effects”, Handbook of Industrial Organization, Elsevier.
GarrodL.HviidM.LoomesG.Waddams PriceC., (2008). Activating Consumers, Office of Fair Trading (forthcoming).
20.
GiuliettiM.OteroJ.WatersonM., (2007). “Pricing behaviour under competition in the UK electricity supply industry”, Warwick Economic Research Paper no. 790.
21.
GiuliettiM.Waddams Priceand C., (2005). “Incentive regulation, competition and relative prices”, Annals of Public and Co-operative Economics, 76(1), 121-149.
22.
GiuliettiM.Waddams PriceC.WatersonM., (2005). “Consumer choice and competition policy: a study of UK energy markets” Economic Journal, 115(October): 49-969.
23.
GreenR.J., (2005a). “Dual Fuel Competition in the British Retail Energy Markets”, IDEI conference on The Economics of Energy Markets,, Toulouse, June.
24.
GreenR.J., (2005b). “Electricity and Markets” Oxford Review of Economic Policy, 21(1): 67-87.
25.
GreenR.McDanielT., (1998). “Competition in Electricity Supply: will ‘1998’ be worth it?” Fiscal Studies, 19(3): 273-293.
26.
HarkerM.Waddams PriceC., (2004). “Consumers and antitrust in British deregulated energy markets” in The Pros and Cons of Antitrust in Deregulated Markets, Konkurrensverket, Stockholm.
27.
HarkerM.AkmanP.MehtaJ.Lovdahl GormsenL.Waddams PriceC., (2008). Benchmarking the performance of the UK framework supporting consumer empowerment through comparison against relevant international comparator countries, Department of Business, Enterprise and Regulatory Reform, London.
28.
HowellD., (1980). Statement to the House of Commons, 16th January, recorded in Hansard.
29.
JoskowP., (2000). “Why do we need electricity retailers? Or can we get it cheaper wholesale?” Center for Energy and Environmental Policy Research, Massachusetts Institute of Technology, revised discussion draft, 13 January 2000.
30.
JoskowP., (2008). “Lessons learned from electricity market liberalization”, The Energy Journal, this issue.
31.
LittlechildS.C. (2003). “Wholesale-Spot Pass Through” Journal of Regulatory Economics23(1): 61-91.
32.
LittlechildS. (2006). “Competition and contracts in the Nordic residential electricity markets.” Utilities Policy, 14(3): 135-147.
33.
MMC (1988). Gas, Cm 500, Monopolies and Mergers Commission, London, HMSO.
34.
MMC (1993). Gas and British Gasplc, CM 2314-17, Monopolies and Mergers Commission, London, HMSO.
35.
NewberyD.M., (1999). Privatization, Restructuring, and Regulation of Network Industries, MIT press.
36.
NewberyD.M., (2002). “Issues and Options for Restructuring Electricity Supply Industries”, DAE working paper 0210.
37.
NewberyD.M. (2005a). “Electricity liberalisation in Britain: The quest for a satisfactory wholesale market design” The Energy Journal European Electricity LiberalisationSpecial Issue, 43-70.
38.
NewberyD.M. (2005b). “Market Design”, EPRG working paper 0515, Cambridge.
39.
OECD (2003). Economic Survey of Switzerland, Paris.
40.
Offer and Ofgas, (1998). “Dual fuel Offers in the Gas and Electricity Markets”, January.
41.
Ofgem (2000). A Review of the Development of Competition in Domestic Gas and Electricity Supply, December.
42.
Ofgem, (2002). Future regulation of domestic gas and electricity supply markets - final proposals, February.
Ofgem, (2008a). “Ofgem Launches Probe into Energy Supply Markets”, http://www.ofgem.gov.uk/Media/PressRel/Documents1/ProbeFINAL.pdf (accessed 1st April 2008).
47.
Ofgem, (2008b). “Switching rate hits 5.1 million in 2007” - R/11, press release 2nd April, accessed 15th July, http://www.ofgem.gov.uk/Media/PressRel/Documents1/Switching%20figures%202007.pdf.
48.
Ofgem, (2008c). Letter from Maxine Frerk, 30th May 2008 http://www.ofgem.gov.uk/Sustainability/SocAction/Publications/Documents1/Open%20letter%20PPM%20Customer%20Switching.pdf
49.
Ofgem, (2008d). Fuel Poverty Action Programme, May 30th.
50.
OlsenO.J.JohnsenT.A.LewisP., (2006). “A Mixed Nordic Experience: Implementing Competitive Retail Electricity Markets for Household Customers”, The Electricity Journal, 19(9): 37-44.
51.
PollittM., (2008). “The Future of Electricity (and Gas) Regulation in a Low Carbon Policy World” The Energy Journal, this issue.
52.
SaliesEWaddamsC. Price, (2004). “Charges, Costs and Market Power in the Deregulated UK Electricity Retail Market”, The Energy Journal, 25(3): 19-35.
