Petroleum Prospect Valuation: The Option to Drill Again

Abstract

We examine the value of an exploration prospect that is to be exploited via a series of possibly dependent trials. Failure on any particular trial is assumed to convey bad news, but also provides an option to try again. The pattern and strength of dependence among trials determines the value of this option, and therefore also influences the value of the underlying prospect. We describe the solution to this valuation problem, examine the behavior of the option premium, and characterize potential errors that are inherent in two ad hoc procedures that are often used to estimate prospect value. We demonstrate that the impact of dependence among trials is monotonic: each increase in the degree of dependence results in a further reduction in expected value of the prospect. We also characterize the particular pattern of dependence that is implied by a plausible model of exploratory risk.

Keywords

Oil exploration valuation risk uncertainty drilling oil fields

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Goodwin

Lawrence

(1996). Texas Oil, American Dreams. Austin, TX: Texas State Historical Society.

Jackson

Grayson C.

(1960). Decisions Under Uncertainty: Drilling Decisions by Oil and Gas Operators. Cambridge, MA:: Harvard University Press.

Harris

DeVerle P.

(1990). Mineral Exploration Decisions: A Guide to Economic Analysis and Modeling. New York: Wiley.

Hendricks

Kovenock

Dan

(1989). “Asymmetric Information, Information Externalities, and Efficiency: The Case of Oil Exploration.” The Rand Journal of Economics, 20(2): 164-182.

Kemp

Alexander G.

Rose

David

(1984). “Investment in Oil Exploration and Production: The Comparative Influence of Taxation.” In Pearce

David W.

eds., Risk and the Political Economy of Resource Development. New York: St. Martin’s Press.

Laughton

David

(1998). “The Management of Flexibility in the Upstream Petroleum Industry.” The Energy Journal, 19(1): 83-114.

Lerche

MacKay

James A.

(1999). Economic Risk in Hydrocarbon Exploration. San Diego, CA: Academic Press.

Megill

Robert E.

(1988). An Introduction to Exploration Economics, third edition. Tulsa, OK: PennWell Publishing Co.

Newendorp

Paul D.

(1975). Decision Analysis for Petroleum Exploration. Tulsa, OK: The Petroleum Publishing Co.

10.

Paddock

James L.

Siegel

Daniel R.

Smith

James L.

(1988). “Option Valuation of Claims on Real Assets: The Case of Offshore Petroleum Leases.” Quarterly Journal of Economics, 103(3): 479-508.

11.

Pickles

Smith

James L.

, (1993). “Petroleum Property Valuation: A Binomial Lattice Implementation of Option Pricing Theory.” The Energy Journal, 14(2): 1-26.

12.

Railroad Commission of Texas , (2004). “East Texas Oilfield.” Document available online at: http://rra.dst.tx.us/c_t/History1/EAST%20TEXAS%20OILFIELD.cfm .

13.

Smith

James L.

Thompson

Rex

, (2003). “Diversification and the Value of Exploration Portfolios.” Center for Energy and Environmental Policy Research, Working Paper No. WP-2005- 007. April 2005. Massachusetts Institute of Technology, Cambridge, MA.

14.

Wang

Kokolis

G. P.

Rapp

W. J.

Litvak

B. L.

(2000). “Dependent Risk Calculations in Multiple-Prospect Exploration Evaluations” Paper #SPE 63198. Dallas, TX: Society of Petroleum Engineers.