Observing that net prices do not rise as predicted and that resource stocks are not fixed, Adelman questions Hotelling's model of an exhaustible resource. He cites a rule of thumb for valuing oil reserves which is about one-half that given by the Hotelling valuation principle. We apply an optimization model to a stylized characterization of an oil reservoir. Adelman's valuation rule is confirmed. An r-percent rule emerges as well, but it is not Hotelling's rule. We end the paper with our interpretation of Hotelling's rule. We also consider the role of investment in augmenting the quantities of a resource currently extracted.
AdelmanM.A. (1990). “Mineral Depletion, with Special Reference to Petroleum,” Review of Economics and Statistics72(1): 1 10.
2.
AdelmanM.A. (1993a). The Economics of Petroleum Supply: Papers by M.A. Adelman, 1962-1993. Cambridge MA: MIT Press.
3.
AdelmanM.A. (1993b). “Modelling World Oil Supply,” The Energy Journal14(1), reprinted in The Economics of Petroleum Supply (Adelman, 1993): 269-301.
4.
AdelmanM.A.De SilvaHarindarKoehnMichael F. (1991). “User Cost in Oil Production,” Resources and Energy13: 217-40.
5.
AdelmanM.A.WatkinsG.C. (1995). “Reserve Asset Values and the 'Hotelling Valuation Principle',” Southern Economic Journal61(3): 664-73.
6.
BlackGeoffreyLaFranceJeffrey T. (1998). “Is Hotelling's Rule Relevant to Domestic Oil Production?” Journal of Environmental Economics and Management36(2): 149-169.
7.
CairnsRobert D. (2001). “Capacity Choice and the Theory of the Mine,” Environment and Resource Economics18(1): 129-148.
8.
CairnsRobert D.DavisGraham A. (1998). “Economic Theory and the Valuation of Mineral Reserves,” OPEC Review (September): 169-183.
9.
DavisGraham A. (1996). “Option Premiums in Mineral Asset Pricing: Are They Important?” Land Economics (May): 167-186.
10.
DavisGraham A.CairnsRobert D. (1998). “Simple Analytics of Valuing Producing Petroleum Reserves.” The Energy Journal19(4): 133-142.
11.
DavisGraham A.CairnsRobert D. (1999). “Valuing Petroleum Reserves Using Current Net Price,” Economic Inquiry37(2): 295-311.
12.
HotellingHarold (1931). “The Economics of Exhaustible Resources,” Journal of Political Economy39(2): 135-79.
13.
JohnsonTommiPaxsonDean A.RizzutoRonald J. (1995). “Do Investors Follow Accounting or Appraised Petroleum Values?” Oil and Gas Tax Quarterly43(4): 685-711.
14.
LohrenzJohn (1991). “Market Discount Factors for Fully Developed, Declining Production,” Journal of Petroleum Technology (March): 350-355.
15.
LohrenzJohnBaileyA.J. (1995). “Evidence and Results of Present Value Maximization for Oil and Gas Development Projects,” SPE 30050 Proceedings of the 1995 Hydrocarbon Economics and Evaluation Symposium,, Society of Petroleum Engineers, Dallas, Texas, 163-177.
16.
LohrenzJohnBurzlaffBernard H.DoughertyElmer L. (1981). “How Policies Affect the Rates of Recovery from Mineral Resources,” SPE 9553, Transactions of the Society of Petroleum Engineers (December): 645-657.
17.
McDonaldStephen L. (1994). “The Hotelling Principle and In-Ground Values of Oil Reserves: Why the Principle Over-Predicts Actual Values,” The Energy Journal15(3): 1-17.
18.
MaglioloJoseph (1986). “Capital Market Analysis of Reserve Recognition Accounting.” Journal of Accounting Research (supplement): 69-107.
19.
MillerMerton H.UptonCharles W. (1985a). “A Test of the Hotelling Valuation Principle,” Journal of Political Economy93(1): 1-25.
20.
MillerMerton H.UptonCharles W. (1985b). “The Pricing of Oil and Gas: Some Further Results,” Journal of Finance40(3): 1009-1020.
21.
SchwartzEduardo S. (1997). “The Stochastic Behavior of Commodity Prices: Implications for Valuation and Hedging.” Journal of Finance52(3): 923-973.
22.
ThompsonAndrew C. (2001). “The Hotelling Principle, Backwardation of Futures Prices and the Values of Developed Petroleum Reserves - The Production Contraint Hypothesis.” Resource and Energy Economics23(2): 133-156.
23.
UrenLester Charles (1950). Petroleum Production Engineering. New York: McGraw-Hill.
24.
WatkinsG.C. (1992). “The Hotelling Principle: Autobahn or Cul de Sac?” The Energy Journal13(1): 1-24.
