This paper analyzes the impact of changes in average fuel efficiency on traffic-related fatalities while controlling for other confounding effects. These other effects include population, per capita income, per capita alcohol consumption, existence of safety-belt laws (and safety-belt usage), and age cohorts in the population. State-level time-series data over 24 years is used with a fixed effect negative binomial regression model that accounts for both the distributional properties of accident count data and heterogeneity. Other studies of this issue have not used either panel data in this way nor have they used appropriate statistical methods for count data. Results vary with the selection of the time series used. Overall results suggest that while there may have been an association between fleet fuel efficiency improvements and traffic fatalities in the 1970s, this has largely disappeared. There are suggestions that variance in the composition of the vehicle fleet may have adverse safety impacts.
AschPeterLevyDavid T.SheaDennisBodenhornHoward (1991). “Risk Compensation and the Effectiveness of Safety Belt Use Laws: A Case Study of New Jersey,” Policy Sciences24: 181-197.
2.
BuzemanDagmar G.VianoDavid C.LovsundPer (1998). “Car Occupant Safety in Frontal Crashes: A Parameter Study of Vehicle Mass, Impact Speed, and Inherent Vehicle Protection,” Accident Analysis and Prevention30(6): 713-722.
3.
CrandallRobert W.GrahamJohn D. (1989). “The Effect of Fuel Economy Standards on Automobile Safety,” Journal of Law and Economics32: 97-118.
4.
CrandallRobert W.GruenspechtHoward K.KeelerTheodore E.LaveLester B. (1986). Regulating the Automobile, The Brookings Institution: Washington, DC.
5.
EvansLeonard (1984). “Driver Fatalities Versus Car Mass Using A New Exposure Approach,” Accident Analysis and Prevention16(1): 19-36.
6.
EvansLeonard (1994). “Driver Injury and Fatality Risk in Two-car Crashes Versus Mass Ratio Inferred Using Newtonian Mechanics,” Accident Analysis and Prevention26(5): 609-616.
7.
EvansLeonard (2001). “Causal Influence of Car Mass and Size on Driver Fatality Risk,” American Journal of Public Health91(7): 1076-1081.
8.
EvansLeonardFrickMichael C. (1992). “Cars Size or Car Mass: Which Has Greater Influence on Fatality Risk?” American Journal of Public Health82(8): 1105-1112.
9.
EvansLeonardFrickMichael C. (1993). “Mass Ratio and Relative Driver Fatality Risk in Two-Vehicle Crashes,” Accident Analysis and Prevention25(2): 213-224.
10.
EvansLeonardFrickMichael C. (1994). “Car Mass and Fatality Risk: Has the Relationship Changes?” American Journal of Public Health, 84(1): 33-36.
11.
EvansLeonardWasielewskiPaul (1987). “Serious or Fatal Driver Injury Rate Versus Car Mass in Head-on Crashes Between Cars of Similar Mass,” Accident Analysis and Prevention19(2): 119-131.
12.
EvansLeonardWasielewskiPaulVon BuseckCalvin R. (1982). “Compulsory Seat Belt Usage and Driver Risk-Taking Behavior,” Human Factors24(1): 41-48.
13.
EvansWilliam N.GrahamJohn D. (1991). “Risk Reduction or Risk Compensation? The Case of Mandatory Safety-Belt Use Laws,” Journal of Risk and Uncertainty4: 61-73.
14.
GreeneDavidKellerMaryann (2002). APPENDIX A - Dissent on Safety Issues, in Effectiveness and Impact of Corporate Average Fuel Economy (CAFE) Standards, National Research Council, National Academy Press: Washington, DC.
15.
GrimeG.HutchinsonT.P. (1979). “Vehicle Mass and Driver Injury,” Ergonomics22(1): 93194.
16.
HakimSimonSheferDanielHakkertA.S.HochermanIrit (1991). “A Critical Review of Macro Models for Road Accidents,” Accident Analysis and Prevention23(5): 379-400.
17.
HausmanJerryHallBronwyn H.GrilichesZvi (1984). “Econometric Models for Count Data with an Application to the Patents-R &D Relationship,” Econometrica52: 909-938.
18.
JovanisP.ChangH. (1986). “Modeling the relationship of accident to mile travelled,” Transportation Research Record1068: 42-51.
19.
KahaneCharles (1997). “Relationships between Vehicle Size and Fatality Risk in Model Year 1985-93 Passenger Cars and Light Trucks,” DOT HS 808 570, NHTSA Technical Report.
20.
KarlaftisMatthew G. TarkoAndrzej P. (1998). “Heterogeneity Considerations in Accident Modeling,” Accident Analysis and Prevention30: 425-433.
21.
KhazzoomDaniel J. (1994). “Fuel Efficiency and Automobile Safety: Single-vehicle Highway Fatalities for Passenger Cars,” The Energy Journal15(4): 49-101.
22.
LeflerDevon E.GablerHampton C. (2004). “The fatality and injury risk of light truck impacts with pedestrians in the United States,” Accident Analysis and Prevention36: 295-304.
23.
LoebPeter D. (1987). “The Determinants of Automobile Fatalities: with Special Consideration to Policy Variables,” Journal of Transport Economics and Policy21: 279-287.
24.
MajumdarArnabNolandRobert B.OchiengWashington Y. (2004). “A Spatial Analysis of Safety-belt Usage and Safety-belt Laws,” Accident Analysis and Prevention.36(4): 551-560.
25.
McCarthyP. S. (1999). “Public Policy and Highway Safety: A City-wide Perspective,” Regional Science and Urban Economics29: 231-244.
26.
MiaouS.-P.LumH. (1993a). “Modeling vehicle accidents and highway geometric design relationships.” Accident Analysis and Prevention25(6), 689-709.
27.
National Research Council (NRC), (2002). Effectiveness and Impact of Corporate Average Fuel Economy (CAFE) Standards, National Academy Press: Washington, DC.
28.
NolandRobert B. (2003). “Traffic Fatalities and Injuries: The Effect of Changes in Infrastructure and Other Trends,” Accident Analysis and Prevention35: 599-611.
29.
NolandRobert B.KarlaftisMatthew G. (2004). “Policy Recommendations from Accident Models: Are the Results Specification-Sensitive?” Paper no. 043296 presented at the Annual Meeting of the Transportation Research Board, Washington, DC.
30.
PeltzmanS. (1975). “The Effects of Automobile Safety Regulation,” Journal of Political Economy83: 677-725.
31.
RivaraFrederick P.ThompsonDiane C.CummingsPeter (1999). “Effectiveness of Primary and Secondary Enforced Seat Belt Laws,” American Journal of Preventive Medicine16(1S): 3039.
32.
RossMarcWenzelTom (2003). “An Analysis of Traffic Deaths by Vehicle Type and Model,” report number T021, American Council for an Energy-Efficient Economy, Washington, DC, presented at the 82nd Annual Meeting of the Transportation Research Board.
33.
SchipperLeeFigueroaMaria JosefinaPriceLynnEspeyMolly (1993). “Mind the gap: the vicious circle of measuring automobile fuel use,” Energy Policy21(12): 1173-1190.
34.
ToyEdmond L.HammittJames K. (2003). “Safety Impacts of SUVs, Vans, and Pickup Trucks in Two-Vehicle Crashes,” Risk Analysis, 23(4): 641-650.
35.
WoodDenis P. (1997). “Safety and the Cars Size Effect: A Fundamental Explanation,” Accident Analysis and Prevention29(2): 139-151.
