A variety of market mechanisms have been proposed and implemented around the world in order to create competitive electricity pools and exchanges. However, it is an open question whether pool-based daily auctions or continuous bilateral trading deliver different prices under conditions of market power. In this paper we present a computationally intensive simulation model of the wholesale electricity market in England and Wales to isolate and systematically test the potential impact of alternative trading arrangements on electricity prices. After eight years of trading under a pool-based system, proposals were initiated in 1998 to change the market in England and Wales to bilateral trading. This paper uses an agent-based simulation to evaluate two important aspects of that proposal. The results show that daily bidding with Pay SMP settlement, as in the original Pool day-ahead market, produces the lowest prices while hourly bidding with Pay Bid settlement, as proposed for the bilateral model, produces the highest prices.
BrennanT.J.PalmerL.L.KoppR.J.KrupnickA.J.StalianoV.BurtrawD. (1996). A Shock to the System: Restructuring America's Electricity Industry. Resources for the Future. Washington, DC.
2.
BunnD.W.DayC.VlahosK. (1998). “Understanding Latent Market Power in the Electricity Pool of England and Wales,” in Pricing Energy in a Competitive Market, Electric Power Research Institute, 3412 Hillview Ave, Palo Alto, CA 94304 USA.
3.
Department of Trade and Industry (1997). Review of Energy Sources for Power Stations: Terms of Reference, HMSO, London SW8 5DT.
4.
Department of Trade and Industry (1998a). Review of Energy Sources for Power Stations Interim Conclusions, HMSO, London SW8 5DT.
5.
Department of Trade and Industry (1998b). A Fair Deal for Consumers: Modernising the Framework for Utility Regulation, CM 3898, HMSO, London SW8 5DT.
6.
Electricity Pool of England and Wales (1997). Minister's Speech to the PoolAGM, The England and Wales Electricity Pool 338 Euston Road, 10th Floor, Regent's Place, London, NW1 3BP.
7.
von der FehrN-H.M.HarbordD.(1993). “Spot Market Competition in the UK Electricity Market,” The Economic Journal103: 531-546.
8.
Financial Times (1999a). “Production 'disrupted due to big electricity price rises'.” NATIONAL NEWS, 13 August, 1999. The Financial Times Ltd. London, http://www.ft.com
9.
Financial Times (1999b). “ELECTRICITY COMPETITION: Wholesale price fall predicted.” NEWS DIGEST, 4 August, 1999. The Financial Times Ltd. London, http://www.ft.com
10.
GreenR. (1996). “Increasing Competition in the British Electricity Spot Market.” Journal of Industrial Economics XLIV(2): 205-216.
11.
GreenR. (1999). “The Electricity Contract Market.” Journal of Industrial Economics XLVII(l): 107-124.
12.
GreenR.NewberyD.M. (1992). “Competition in the British Electricity SpotMarket,” Journal of Political Economy100(5): 929-953.
13.
HelmD.PowellA. (1992). “Pool Prices, Contracts and Regulation in the British Electricity Supply Industry.” Fiscal Studies13(1) February: 89-105.
14.
HuntS.ShuttleworthG. (1996). Competition and Choice in Electricity. National Economic Research Associates. England: John Wiley &Sons Ltd.
15.
IsaacR.M.WalkerJ.M. (1985). “Information and Conspiracy in Sealed Bid Auctions,” Journal of Economic Behaviour and Organization6: 139-159.
16.
KlempererP.D.MeyerM.A. (1989). “Supply Function Equilibria in Oligopoly Under Uncertainty.” Econometrica57(November): 1243-1277.
17.
Monopolies and Mergers Commission (1996a). National Power and Southern Electric A report on the proposed merger, CM 3230, HMSO London SW8 5DT.
18.
Monopolies and Mergers Commission(1996b). PowerGen and Midlands Electricity pic: A report on the proposed merger, CM 3231, HMSO London SW8 5DT.
19.
National Grid Company Pic (1998). 1998 Seven Year Statement for the years 1998/9 to 2004/5, The National Grid Company Pic, National Grid House, Kirby Corner Road, Coventry, CV4 3JY.
20.
NewberyD.(1997). “Lectures on Regulation Series VII: Pool Reform and Competition in Electricity,” The Institute of Economic Affairs, 2 Lord North Street, London, SW1P 3LB.
21.
NyborgK.G.SundaresanS. (1996). “Discriminatory versus uniform Treasury auctions: Evidence from when-issued transactions,” Journal of Financial Economics42: 63-104.
22.
Office of Electricity Regulation(1994a). Report on Trading Outside the Pool, Office of Gas and Electricity Markets, Stockley House, 130 Wilton Road, London SW1V 1LQ. http://www.open.gov.uk/offer/pubsmain.htm.
23.
Office of Electricity Regulation(1994b). Decision on Monopolies and Mergers Reference. Office of Gas and Electricity Markets, Stockley House, 130 Wilton Road, London SW1V 1LQ. http://www.open.gov.uk/offer/pubsmain.htm
24.
Office of Electricity Regulation (1997). Review of Electricity Trading Arrangements A Consultation Paper. December1997. Office of Gas and Electricity Markets, Stockley House, 130 Wilton Road, London SW1V 1LQ. http://www.open.gov.uk/offer/pubsmain.htm.
25.
Office of Electricity Regulation(1998a). Review of Electricity Trading Arrangements: Advice on Terms of Reference. January1998. Office of Gas and Electricity Markets, Stockley House, 130 Wilton Road, London SW1V 1LQ. http://www.open.gov.uk/offer/pubsmain.htm.
26.
Office of Electricity Regulation(1998b). Review of Electricity Trading Arrangements: Background Paper 1 - Electricity Trading Arrangements in England and Wales. February1998. Office of Gas and Electricity Markets, Stockley House, 130 Wilton Road, London SW1V 1LQ. http://www.open.gov.uk/offer/pubsmain.htm.
27.
Office of Electricity Regulation (1998c). Review of Electricity Trading Arrangements: Background Paper 2 - Electricity Trading Arrangements in Other Countries. February1998. Office of Gas and Electricity Markets, Stockley House, 130 Wilton Road, London SW1V 1LQ. http://www.open.gov.uk/offer/pubsmain.htm.
28.
Office of Electricity Regulation (1998d). Review of Electricity Trading Arrangements: Report on Consultation on Terms of Reference. March1998. Office of Gas and Electricity Markets, Stockley House, 130 Wilton Road, London SW1V 1LQ. http://www.open.gov.uk/offer/pubsmain.htm
29.
Office of Electricity Regulation(1998e). Review of Electricity Trading Arrangements: Working Paper on Trading Inside and Outside the Pool. March1998. Office of Gas and Electricity Markets, Stockley House, 130 Wilton Road, London SW1V 1LQ. http://www.open.gov.uk/offer/pubsmain.htm.
30.
Office of Electricity Regulation(1998f). Review of Electricity Trading Arrangements: Third Party Papers. April1998. Office of Gas and Electricity Markets, Stockley House, 130 Wilton Road, London SW1V 1LQ. http://www.open.gov.uk/offer/pubsmain.htm.
31.
Office of Electricity Regulation (1998g). Review of Electricity Trading Arrangements: Third Party Papers -Further Submissions. April1998. Office of Gas and Electricity Markets, Stockley House, 130 Wilton Road, London SW1V 1LQ. http://www.open.gov.uk/offer/pubsmain.htm.
32.
Office of Electricity Regulation(1998h). A possible Common Model for trading arrangements: a discussion note by Offer. May1998. Office of Gas and Electricity Markets, Stockley House, 130 Wilton Road, London SW1V 1LQ. http://www.open.gov.uk/offer/pubsmain.htm.
33.
Office of Electricity Regulation (1998i). Review of Electricity Trading Arrangements: Interim Conclusions. June1998. Office of Gas and Electricity Markets, Stockley House, 130 Wilton Road, London SW1V 1LQ. http://www.open.gov.uk/offer/pubsmain.htm.
34.
Office of Electricity Regulation(1998j). Review of Electricity Trading Arrangements: Proposals. August1998. Office of Gas and Electricity Markets, Stockley House, 130 Wilton Road, London SW1V 1LQ. http://www.open.gov.uk/offer/pubsmain.htm.
35.
Office of Electricity Regulation(1998k). Review of Electricity Trading Arrangements: Framework Document. November1998. Office of Gas and Electricity Markets, Stockley House, 130 Wilton Road, London SW1V 1LQ. http://www.open.gov.uk/offer/pubsmain.htm
36.
Office of Electricity Regulation (1981). Report on Pool Price Increases in Winter 1997/98, Office of Gas and Electricity Markets, Stockley House, 130 Wilton Road, London SW1V 1LQ. http://www.open.gov.uk/offer/pubsmain.htm.
37.
Office of Electricity Regulation(1999a). Press Notice: Pool Prices Must Come Down, Office of Gas and Electricity Markets, Stockley House, 130 Wilton Road, London SW1V 1LQ. http://www.open.gov.uk/offer/pubsmain.htm.
38.
Office of Electricity Regulation (1999b). Pool Price: A Consultation Paper, Office of Gas and Electricity Markets, Stockley House, 130 Wilton Road, London SW1V 1LQ. http://www.open.gov.uk/offer/pubsmain.htm.
39.
Office of Electricity Regulation (1999h). The New Electricity trading arrangements: Volume 1. July1999. Office of Gas and Electricity Markets, Stockley House, 130 Wilton Road, London SW1V 1LQ. http://www.open.gov.uk/offer/pubsmain.htm.
40.
Office of Electricity Regulation (1999i). The New Electricity trading arrangements: Volume 2. July1999. Office of Gas and Electricity Markets, Stockley House, 130 Wilton Road, London SW1V 1LQ. http://www.open.gov.uk/offer/pubsmain.htm.
41.
Office of Electricity Regulation(1999j). The New Electricity trading arrangements: a draft specification for the balancing mechanism and imbalance settlement. Version 1.2. July1999. Office of Gas and Electricity Markets, Stockley House, 130 Wilton Road, London SW1V 1LQ. http://www.open.gov.uk/offer/pubsmain.htm.
42.
Office of Electricity Regulation (1999k). The New Electricity trading arrangements: Ofgem/DTI conclusions. October1999. Office of Gas and Electricity Markets, Stockley House, 130 Wilton Road, London SW1V 1LQ. http://www.open.gov.uk/offer/pubsmain.htm.
43.
Office of Electricity Regulation (1991). Rises in pool prices in July: a decision document. October1999. Office of Gas and Electricity Markets, Stockley House, 130 Wilton Road, London SW1V 1LQ. http://www.open.gov.uk/offer/pubsmain.htm.
44.
Office of Electricity Regulation (1999m). Social Action Plan: A framework document. October1999. Office of Gas and Electricity Markets, Stockley House, 130 Wilton Road, London SW1V 1LQ. http://www.open.gov.uk/offer/pubsmain.htm.
45.
Patrick R.HWolakF.A. (1997). “Estimating the Customer-Level Demand for Electricity Under Real-Time Market Prices” (Preliminary Draft), available from http://www.stanford.edu/—;wolak/
46.
PowellA. (1993). “Trading Forward in an Imperfect Market the Case of Electricity in Britain,” The Economic Journal (March):444-453.
RothkopfM.H. (1999). “Daily Repetition: A Neglected Factor in the Analysis of Electricity Auctions.” The Electricity Journal (April): 61-70.
49.
SimonD.P. (1994). “The Treasury's experiment with Single-Price Auctions in the Mid-1970s: Winner's or Taxpayer's Curse?” Review of Economics and Statistics76 (November): 754-760.
50.
SuttonR.S.BartoA.G. (1998). An Introduction to Reinforcement Learning. MIT Press.
51.
WolframC.D. (1998). “Strategic Bidding in a Multi-unit Auction: An Empirical Analysis of Bids to Supply Electricity in England and Wales,” Rand Journal of Economics29: 703-725.
