Charges,Costs and Market Power: the Deregulated UK Electricity Retail Market

Abstract

The residential UK electricity market was opened for the first time in 1999, introducing choice of supplier, and about 40 percent of households changed supplier in the first four years. After three years price caps were removed. We review this process and assess the competitiveness of the market by examining how the charges levied by suppliers depend on cost and demand factors for three different payment methods and consumption levels. We also identify signs of additional market power of incumbency and the effect of levying a tariff with no fixed charge. We find that both cost and demand factors affect charges, and the relationship varies for different payment methods and consumption levels; and that tariffs with no fixed element have different effects for different payment methods. We also conclude that considerable market power seems to remain with potentially adverse distributional effects.

Keywords

Residential electricity Market power electricity prices UK deregulation

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Competition Act (1998). The Stationery Office. London: HMSO.

Cooke

Ferrari

Giulietti

Sharratt

Waddams Price

(2001). “Affording Gas and Electricity: Self Disconnection and Rationing by Prepayment and Low Income Credit Consumers and Company Attitudes to Social Action.” March. Electricity Association, London, UK.

Electricity Association (2002). “Electricity Industry Review 5.” http://www.electricity.org.uk

Electricity Association (2003). “Who Owns Whom in the UK Electricity Industry.” June.

Energywatch (2003). “Energywatch Briefing Paper.” July. http://www.energywatch.org.uk

Fudenberg

Tirole

(1984). “The fact-cat effect, the puppy dog ploy, and the lean and hungry look.” American Economic Review 74: 362-66.

Giulietti

M. C.

Price

Waddams

Waterson

(2003). “Consumer Choice and Industrial Policy: A Study of UK Energy Markets.” Working paper No. 112, Centre for the Study of Electricity Markets (revised version of CCR Working Paper 01-5).

National Grid Transco web site (2002). http://www.nationalgrid.com/uk/.

Ofgem (2002). “Electricity supply competition: an Ofgem occasional paper.” Office of Gas and Electricity Markets, London, UK.

10.

Ofgem (2003a). “Domestic gas and electricity supply competition Recent developments.” June. Ofgem (2003b). http://www.ofgem.gov.uk/ofgem/index.jsp. November 1.

11.

Otero

Waddams Price

(2001). “Price discrimination, regulation and entry in the U.K.residential market.” Bulletin of Economic Research 53(3): 161-175.

12.

Utilities Act (2000). The Stationery Office. London: HMSO.

13.

Waddams Price

Hancock

(1998). “Distributional effects of liberalising UK residential electricity markets.” Fiscal Studies 19(3): 295-320.

14.

White

(1980). “A heteroskedasticity-consistent covariance matrix estimator and a direct test for heteroskedasticity.” Econometrica 48(4): 817-838.