Forecasting Inbound Canadian Tourism: An Evaluation of Error Corrections Model Forecasts

Abstract

This paper computes and evaluates a variety of quantitative forecasts for inbound Canadian tourists, including the Error Corrections Model (ECM) and the traditional regression model forecasts. A number of forecasting methods are employed: naive to sophisticated, univariate to multivariate, time series and econometric. Forecasts for the number of inbound Canadian tourists are derived using data from four major markets: the USA, the UK, Germany and Japan. The evaluation of the forecasts is based on the Generalized Forecast Error Second Moment (GFESM) criterion developed by Clements and Hendry (1993) and the Adjusted Mean Absolute Percentage Error (AMAPE) criterion. The ECM forecasts performed best, while the traditional regression model forecasts performed poorly. In this study, using Canadian data, the development of an ECM (which entails careful analysis of the integration and co-integration properties of the variables) provides an improvement in forecast accuracy. Previous tourism studies have found less promising results concerning the performance of the ECM forecasts.

Keywords

tourism forecasting error corrections forecasts evaluating forecasts

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Archer

B.H.

(1987), ‘Demand forecasting and estimation’, in Ritchie

J.R.B.

Goeldner

C.R.

, eds, Travel, Tourism and Hospitality Research, J. Wiley, New York.

Box

George E.P.

Jenkins

Gwilym M.

(1970), Time Series Analysis, Forecasting, and Control, Holden Day, San Francisco, CA.

Calantone

Roger J.

DiBenedetto

C. Anthony

Bojanic

David

(1987), ‘A comprehensive review of the tourism forecasting literature’, Journal of Travel Research, Vol 26, No 2, pp 28–39.

Clements

Michael P.

Hendry

David F.

(1993), ‘On the limitations of comparing mean square forecast errors’, Journal of Forecasting, Vol 12, pp 617–637.

Engle

R.E.

Granger

C.W.J.

(1987), ‘Co-integration and error correction: Representation, estimation, and testing’, Econometrica, Vol 55, pp 251–276.

Engle

R.E.

Granger

C.W.J.

(1991), ‘Long-run economic relationships’, in Readings in Co-Integration, Oxford University Press, Oxford.

Franses

Philip H.

Kliebergen

Frank

(1996), ‘Unit roots in the Nelson–Plosser data: Do they matter for forecasting?’, International Journal of Forecasting, Vol 12, pp 283–288.

Gonzalez

Pilar

Moral

Paz

(1995), ‘Analysis of the international tourism demand in Spain’, International Journal of Forecasting, Vol 11, pp 233–252.

Gustavsson

Patrik

Nordström

Jonas

(2000), ‘The impact of seasonal unit roots and vector ARMA modelling on forecasting monthly tourism flows’, unpublished manuscript, Trade Union Institute for Economic Research and Stockholm School of Economics, pp 1–24.

10.

Holden

(1995), ‘Vector Auto Regression modeling and forecasting’, Journal of Forecasting, Vol 14, pp 159–166.

11.

Holt

C.C.

(1957), ‘Forecasting seasonal trends by exponentially weighted moving averages’, Office of Naval Research (Memorandum No 52), Carnegie Institute of Technology.

12.

Hylleberg

Engle

R.F.

Granger

C.W.J.

Yoo

B.S.

(1990), ‘Seasonal integration and cointegration’, Journal of Econometrics, Vol 44, pp 215–238.

13.

Johansen

(1988), ‘Statistical analysis of co-integration vectors’, Journal of Economic Dynamics and Control, Vol 12, pp 231–254.

14.

Kim

Seokchool

Song

Haiyan

(1998), ‘Analysis of inbound tourism demand in South Korea: A co-integration and error correction approach’, Tourism Analysis, Vol 3, pp 25–41.

15.

Kulendran

Nada

(1996), ‘Modelling quarterly tourist flows to Australia using co-integration analysis’, Tourism Economics, Vol 2, No 3, pp 203–222.

16.

Kulendran

Nada

King

Maxwell

(1997), ‘Forecasting international quarterly tourist flows using error correction and time series models’, International Journal of Forecasting, Vol 13, pp 319–327.

17.

Kulendran

Nada

Witt

Stephen F.

(2001), ‘Co-integration versus least squares regression’, Annals of Tourism Research, Vol 28, No 2, pp 291–311.

18.

Lathiras

Petros

Siriopoulas

Costas

(1998), ‘The demand for tourism to Greece: A co-integration approach’, Tourism Economics, Vol 4, No 2, pp 171–185.

19.

LeSage

J.P.

(1990), ‘A comparison of the forecasting ability of ECM and VAR models’, Review of Economics and Statistics, Vol 72, pp 664–671.

20.

Makridakis

Hibon

(2000), ‘The M-3 competition: Results, conclusions and implications’, International Journal of Forecasting, Vol 16, pp 451–476.

21.

Nelson

C.R.

Plosser

C.I.

(1982), ‘Trends and random walks in macroeconomic time series’, Journal of Monetary Economics, Vol 10, pp 139–162.

22.

Sims

C.A.

(1980), ‘Macroeconomics and reality’, Econometrica, Vol 48, pp 1–49.

23.

Uysal

Crompton

J.L.

(1985), ‘An overview of approaches used to forecast tourism demand’, Journal of Travel Research, Vol 23, No 3, pp 7–15.

24.

Witt

Stephen F.

Martin

C.A.

(1987), ‘Econometric models for forecasting international tourism demand’, Journal of Travel Research, Vol 25, No 3, pp 23–30.

25.

Witt

Stephen F.

Witt

Christine A.

(1995), ‘Forecasting tourism demand: A review of empirical research’, International Journal of Forecasting, Vol 11, pp 447–475.