Abstract
The aim of this article is to examine the successfulness of death metaphors in the contemporary debate over the Secularisation Theory. Through doing so, the article will propose criteria by which the success of a metaphor – in the sociology of religion and in social science more broadly – can be assessed. It will examine metaphors employed by Stark, Bruce and Callum Brown. It will firstly discuss the nature of the Secularisation debate, metaphor and metaphor in sociology and science more broadly. Then, drawing upon previous research in this area, it will discuss the use of metaphor and analogy in academic discourse and examine criteria by which the success of scientific metaphors might be assessed. Thereafter, it will look at the successfulness of the main recent metaphors employed by proponents and critics of secularisation in terms of these criteria.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
Armstrong
Karen
, (2001 ). The Battle for God: Fundamentalism in Judaism, Christianity and Islam , London : HarperCollins
2.
Bauman
Gerd
, (1996 ). ‘Secularisation Theory: A Derivative, Circular Prophecy’ in Etnofoor , 9 : 1 .
3.
Beck
Ulrich
, and
Sznaider
N.
, (2006 ). ‘Unpacking Cosmopolitanism for the Social Sciences: A Research Agenda’ in British Journal of Sociology , 57 : 1 .
4.
Berger
Peter
, and
Luckmann
Thomas
, (1966 ). ‘Secularization and Pluralism’ in International Yearbook of the Sociology of Religion , 4
5.
Bradie
Michael
, (1984 ). ‘The Metaphorical Character of Science’ in Philosophica Naturalis , 21 .
6.
Brown
Callum
, (2001 ). The Death of Christian Britain , London : Routledge.
7.
Brown
Theodore
, (2003 ). Making Truth: Metaphor in the Sciences , London : Barnes and Noble . (Accessed online at www.press.uillonois.edu)
8.
Bruce
Steve
, (2002 ). God is Dead: Secularization in the West , London : Routledge.
9.
Bruce
Steve
, (1999 ). ‘Christianity in Britain: RIP’ in Sociology of Religion , 62 : 2 .
10.
Bruce
Steve
, (1992 ). ‘The Twilight of the Gods: Religion in Modern Britain,’ Sociology Review , 2 : 2 .
11.
Casanova
J
, (1994 ). Public Religions in the Modern World , Chicago University Press .
12.
Chermiss
H.
(1980 ). The Riddle of the Early Academy , London .
13.
Davie
Grace
, (2000 ). Religion in Modern Europe: A Memory Mutates , Oxford University Press .
14.
Davies
Douglas
, (1997 ). Death, Ritual and Belief , London : Cassells.
15.
Derrida
Jacques
, (1998 ). ‘The Originary Metaphor’ in
Wolffreys
Julian
(ed.), The Derrida Reader , Edinburgh : Edinburgh University Press .
16.
Dobbelaere
Karel
, (1981 ). ‘Secularisation: A Multidimensional Concept’ in Current Sociology , 29 : 2 .
17.
Drane
John
, (2000 ). The McDonaldization of the Church , London : Darton, Longmann and Todd.
18.
Gentner
Dedre
, (1982 ). ‘Are Scientific Analogies Metaphors?’ in
Miall
Davi
, (ed.), Metaphor: Problems and Perspectives , Brighton : Harvester Press .
19.
Gray
John
, (2007 ). Black Mass: Apocalyptic Religion and the Death of Utopia , New York : Farrar, Strauss and Giroux.
20.
Hawkes
Terence
, (1972 ). Metaphor , London : Methuen.
21.
Hayman
Ronald
, (1997 ). Nietzsche , London : Phoenix.
22.
Hervieu-Leger
Daniele
, (2000 ). Religion as a Chain of Memory , Cambridge : Polity Press.
23.
Horkenheimer
M.
, (1974 ). Critique of Instrumental Reason , New York : Seabury Press.
24.
Iannaccone
Lawrence
, (1991 ). ‘The Consequences of Religious Market Structure’ in Rationality and Society , 3 .
25.
Jaspers
Karl
, (1960 ). The Idea of the University , London : Peter Owen.
26.
Kerrnohan
R. D.
, (April 2002 ). ‘Britain's Christian Identity, ‘ in The Contemporary Review.
27.
Kubler-Ross
Elisabeth
, (1969 ). On Death and Dying , Touchstone : New York.
28.
Lakoff
George
, and
Johnson
Mark
, (1980 ). Metaphors We Live By , Chicago : Chicago University Press.
29.
Macdonald
Kevin
, (2006 ). ‘The Frankfurt School of Social Research and the Origins of the Therapeutic State’ in The Occidental Quarterly , 6 : 1 .
30.
Martin
David
, (1969 ). The Religious and the Secular , London : Routledge.
31.
Mcconkey
Dale
, (Summer 2001 ). ‘Whither Hunter's Culture War?’ in Sociology of Religion.
32.
Mithen
Steven
, (1996 ). The Prehistory of the Mind: A Search for the Origins of Art, Religion and Science , London : Thames and Hudson.
33.
Norris
Pippa
, and
Inglehart
Ronald
, (2004 ). Sacred and Secular , Cambridge University Press .
34.
Possomai
Adam
, (2007 ). ‘“Secularisation” and “Religion” as Zombie Categories?’ in Australian Religious Studies Review , 20 : 2 .
35.
Ritzer
George
, (1994 ). The McDonaldization of Society , London : Pine Forge Press.
36.
Sandall
Roger
, (2001 ). The Culture Cult , Oxford : Westview Press.
37.
Slingerland
Edward
, (2004 ). ‘Conceptual Metaphor Theory as Methodology for Comparative Religion’ in Journal of the American Academy of Religion , 72 .
38.
Stark
Rodney
, (1999 ). ‘Secularization: RIP’ in Sociology of Religion , 60 : 3 .
39.
Stark
Rodney
, and
Finke
Robert
, (2000 ). Acts of Faith , Berkeley : University of California Press.
40.
Tschannen
Olivier
, (1991 ). ‘The Secularization Paradigm: A Systematization, ‘ in Journal for the Scientific Study of Religion , 30 : 4 .
41.
Weber
Max
, (1958 ). The Protestant Work Ethic and the Spirit of Capitalism , New York : Scribner.
42.
Wilson
Bryan
, (1982 ). Religion in Sociological Perspective , Oxford : Oxford University Press.