In her article ‘Rethinking the subject, reimagining worlds,’ Susan M. Ruddick
adds to a growing body of geographical literature that adopts a neo-vitalist
approach to the understanding of nature and the human subject. In this brief
article we suggest that whilst Ruddick’s argument raises many interesting points
it is nonetheless hampered by a limited engagement with the historiography of
scientific metaphors and the wider ethical and political tensions engendered by
a contemporary recourse to vitalist ontologies.
AngererM-L (2007) Vom Begehren nach dem
Affekt. Zürich:
Diaphanes.
2.
CooleDFrostS (eds) (2010) New Materialisms: Ontology,
Agency, and Politics. Durham:
Duke University Press.
3.
CrenshawK (1991) Mapping the margins:
intersectionality, identity politics, and violence against women of
color. Stanford Law Review43: 1241–1299.
4.
Deuber-MankowskyAHolzheyCFE (2013) Situiertes Wissen und Regionale
Epistemologie: Zur Aktualität Georges Canguilhems und Donna J.
Haraways. Wien:
Turia & Kant.
5.
DolphijnRvan der TuinI (2012) New Materialism: Interviews and
Cartographies. Ann Arbor:
Open Humanities Press.
6.
FarrellJ (2015) The Battle for Yellowstone: Morality
and the Sacred Roots of Environmental Conflict.
Princeton, NJ: Princeton
University Press.
7.
HarawayD (1976) Crystals, Fabrics, and Fields:
Metaphors of Organicism in Twentieth-Century Developmental Biology.
New Haven, CT: Yale
University Press.
8.
HarawayD (1988) Situated knowledges: the
science question in feminism and the privilege of partial
perspective. Feminist Studies14 (3):
575–599.
9.
HarawayD (2008) When Species Meet.
Minneapolis: University of
Minnesota Press.
HardingS (1991) Subjectivity, experience and
knowledge: an epistemology from/for rainbow coalition
politics. In: HardingSScheichEOsietzkyM (eds) “Multiple subject”—Feminist Perspectives on
Postmodernism, Epistemology and Science.
Hamburg:
Argument-Verlag, pp.
7–26.
12.
HartsockNCM (1983) The feminist standpoint:
developing the ground for a specifically feminist historical
materialism. In: HardingSHintikkaMB (eds) Discovering Reality. Feminist Perspectives on
Epistemology, Metaphysics, Methodology, and Philosophy of Science.
Dordrecht:
Reidel, pp.
283–310.
13.
JohnsonEMorehouseHDalbyS. (2014) After the Anthropocene:
politics and geographic inquiry for a new epoch.
Progress in Human Geography38
(3):439–456.
14.
LettowS (2003) ‘Der Mensch’ in der
philosophischen Anthropologie: Männlichkeit und kulturelle Hegemonie
zwischen Weimarer Republik and National sozialismus. In:
LenzC (ed) Männlichkeiten, Gemeinschaften, Nationen:
historische Studien zur Geschlechterordnung des Nationalen.
Opladen: Leske &
Budrich, pp.
23–43.
15.
MassumiB (1995) The autonomy of
affect. Cultural Critique31: 83–109.
16.
MohantyCT (1984) Under western eyes: feminist
scholarship and colonial discourse. Boundary
2.3 (12/13):
333–358.
17.
OsietzkiM (2003) Das ‘Unbestimmte’ des
Lebendigen als Ressource wissenschaftlich-technischer
Innovationen. In: WeberJBathC (eds) Turbulente Körper, soziale Maschinen.
Feministische Studien zur Technowissenschaftskultur.
Opladen: Leske &
Budrich, pp.
137–150.
18.
RuddickS (2017forthcoming) Rethinking the subject,
reimagining worlds. Dialogues in Human
Geography (this issue).
19.
SharpH (2011) Spinoza and the Politics of
Renaturalization. Chicago:
Chicago University Press.
20.
Teherani-KrönnerP (1992) Eine Kulturökologie im
biologischen Gewand: Die Uexküllsche Umweltlehre. In:
GlaeserBTeherani-KrönnerP (eds) Humanökologie und Kulturökologie: Grundlagen,
Ansätze, Praxis. Opladen:
WestdeutscherVerlag, pp.
153–172.
21.
TreplLVoigtA (2011) The classical
holism-reductionism debate in ecology. In: JaxKSchwarzAEEcology Revisited. Reflecting on Concepts, Advancing Science.
Dordrecht, Heidelberg, London, New York:
Springer, pp.
45–83.
22.
TreplL (1988) Natur als konservatives Ideal
und die Rolle der ökologischen Wissenschaft.
Fachschaft Biologie Tübingen (ed) Ökologie und
Politik, pp. 67–75.
23.
WeberJ (2003) Umkämpfte Bedeutungen: Naturkonzepte
im Zeitalter der Technoscience. New York and
Frankfurt a.M.:
Campus.
