Abstract
A 5-year trial of acupuncture therapy in the Finnish NHS is surveyed. The material of 348 pain patients has been described in Part I. Acupuncture was less effective in the elderly, in patients with a psychiatric history, on high doses of analgesics, and in those with longstanding pain. Twenty six per cent of the patients were relieved of pain for more than two years. The response to treatment was not influenced by the patients social status or his expectations of benefit.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
junnila
SYT
: Long-term treatment of chronic pain with acupuncture. Part I .
Acupuncture & Electro-Therapeut. Res. Inf.J.
Vol. 12 , No. 1 , 23 -36 , 1987
2.
Linton
SJ
Melin
L
: The accuracy of remembering chronic pain .
Pain
, Vol. 13 , 281 -285 , 1982
3.
Dixon
JS
Sitton
N
Bird
HA
Wright
V
: The pseudoscience of visual analogue scale .
Rev.du Rheumatism.Num.Spec.
p.1388 , 1981
4.
Carlsson
AM
: Assessment of chronic pain I. Aspects of the reliability and validity of the visual analogue scale .
Pain
, Vol. 16 , 87 -101 , 1983
5.
Melzack
R
: Acupuncture and musculosceletal pain .
J.Rheumatol
. Vol. 5 , 119 -120 , 1978
6.
Beecher
HK
.: The powerful placebo .
J.A.M.A.
Vol. 159 , 1602 -1606 , 1955
7.
Bischko
J
:
Einführung in die Akupunktur
. Karl Haug Verlag Heidelberg , 1973
8.
Bischko
J
:
Akupunktur für Fortgeschrittene
. Karl Haug Verlag , Heidelberg , 1978
9.The Academy of Traditional Chinese Medicine :
An Outline of Chinese Acupuncture.
Foreign Languages Press , Beijing , 1975
10.
Omura
Y
: Patho-Physiology of acupuncture treatment: Effects of acupuncture on cardiovascular and nervous systems .
Acupuncture & Electro-Therapeut. Res.lnt.J.
Vol. 1 , 51 -141 , 1975
11.
Godfrey
CM
Morgan
P
: A controlled trail of the theory of acupuncture in musculosceletal pain .
J.Rheumatol.
Vol. 5 , 121 -124 , 1978
12.
Melzack
R
Stillwell
DM
Fox
EJ
: Trigger points and acupuncture points for pain: Correlations and implications .
Pain
, Vol. 3 , 3 -23 , 1977
13.
Kim
KC
Yount
RA
: The effect of acupuncture on low back pain .
Am.J.Chin.Med
. Vol. 2 , 421 -428 , 1974
14.
Laitinen
J
: Acupuncture for migraine prophylaxis: a prospective clinical study with six months follow-up .
Amer.J.Chin,Med.
Vol. 3 , 271 -274 , 1975
15.
Chen
GS
Huang
Y-C
.: Two and half years of acupuncture in Alabama .
South Med.J. Vol.
71 , 898 -903 , 1978
16.
Brattberg
G
: Dåsighet efter akupunkturbehandling kan göra patienten olämplig som bilförare .
Läkartidningen
, Vol. 83 , 2301 -2302 , 1986
17.
Boxall
EH
: Acupuncture hepatitis in the west Midlands .
J.Med.Virol
. Vol. 2 , 377 -379 , 1978
18.
Carron
H
Epstein
BS
Grand
B
: Complications of acupuncture J.A.M.A. Vol. 228 , 1552 -1554 , 1974
19.
Corbett
M
Sinclair
M
: Acu- and pleuropuncture .
New Engl.J.Med.
Vol. 290 , 167 -168 , 1974
20.
Drake
DE
: Complication of acupuncture. J.A.M.A. Vol. 229 , 1285 -1286 , 1974
21.
Goldberg
I
: Pneumothorax associated with acupuncture .
Med.J.Aust.
Vol 1 , 941 -942 , 1978
22.
Hussain
KK
: Serum hepatitis assaciated with repeated acupuncture .
Br.Med.j.
Vol. 3 , p.41 , 1974
23.
Izatt
E
Fairman
M
: Staphylococcal septicaemia with disseminated intravascular coagulation associated with acupuncture .
Postgrad. Med. J.
Vol. 53 , 285 -286 , 1977
24.
Lewis-Driver
DJ
: Pneumothorax assosiated with acupuncture .
Med.J.Aust.
Vol. 2 , 296 -297 , 1973
25.
Nieda
S
Abe
T
Kuribayashi
R
et al : Case of cardiac injury resulting from acupunctures .
Jap.J. Thoracic Surg
. Vol. 26 , 881 -883 , 1973
26.
Ritter
HG
Tarala
R
: Pneumothorax after acupuncture .
Br.Med.j.
Vol. 6137 , 602 -603 , 1978
27.
Schiff
AF
: Fatality due to acupuncture .
Med.Times
, Vol. 93 , 630 -631 , 1965
28.
Smith
PF
Rauscher
CR
: Complications of acupuncture. J.A.M.A. Vol. 229 , p.1286 , 1974
29.
Waldman
I
: Pneumothorax from acupuncture .
New Engl.J. Med.
Vol. 290 , p.633 , 1974
30.
Peacher
w
: Adverse reactions, contraindications and complications of acupuncture .
Amer.J.Chin.Med.
Vol.3 , 35 -45 ,1975
31.
Junnila
SYT
.: Acute mental confusion correlated to acupuncture .
Scand.J.Acupuncture & Electrother.
Vol.1 , 69 -73 , 1986
32.
Halsey
JP
Cardoe
N
: Benoxaprofen: side-effect profile in 300 patients .
Br.Med.J.
Vol. 284 , 1365 -1368 , 1982
33.
Pöntinen
PJ
: Acupuncture in the treatment of low back pain and sciatica .
Acupuncture & Electro-Therapeut. Res.Int. J.
: Vol. 4 , 53 -57 , 1979
34.
Jensen
LB
Melsen
B
Jensen
SB
: Effect of acupuncture on headache measured by reduction in number of attacks and use of drugs .
Scand.J.Dent.
Vol. 87 , 373 -380 , 1979
35.
Glennie-Smith
K
.: Acupuncture in the service of Western medicine .
Medical Digest
. Vol. 28 ,2 , 26 -30 , 1983
36.
Toomey
TC
Ghia
JN
Mao
W
Gregg
JM
: Acupuncture and chronic pain mechanisms: the moderating effects of affect, personality and stress on response to treatment .
Pain
, Vol. 3 , 137 -145 , 1977
