BACKGROUND: To establish a Physical Employment Standard for tasks with high physical demands, it is important to determine the physiological requirements. One such task for the UK Coastguard is mud rescue.
OBJECTIVE: To quantify the physiological demand of pulling a rescue sled across estuary mud, and determine whether rescuer experience has an impact on the physiological demand of this task.
METHODS: Forty participants walked 150 m in 3 minutes across estuary mud. Following 3 minute rest, they walked 150 m pulling a rescue sled (61 kg) in pairs (based on experience).
RESULTS: Experienced rescuers had a total oxygen consumption approximately 24% lower than those inexperienced in the task. Relative oxygen consumption (O2) was significantly (p < 0.05) greater in the non-experienced (mean [SD]; 42.90 [6.55] mL.kg–1.min–1) compared to the experienced group (32.85 [5.79] mL.kg–1.min–1) when controlled for pace. Required O2 for various speeds were predicted based on non-experienced participants and assessed for agreement. LoA (95%) mean±difference was 0.0003 ± 3.48 mL.kg–1.min–1, with a CV of 2.30%.
CONCLUSIONS: For tasks that require a high relative O2, such as mud rescue, the minimum level of fitness at entry should be based upon the metabolic demands measured on those who are inexperienced.
RaysonM, HollimanD, BelyavinA. Development of physical selection procedures for the British army. Phase 2. Relationship between physical tests and criterion tasks. Ergonomics2000;43(1):73–105.
2.
ReillyT, WoolerA, TiptonM. Occupational fitness standards for beach lifeguards phase The physiological demands of Beach Lifeguarding. Occup Med2006;56:6–11.
3.
JamnikV, ThomasSG, ShawJ, GledhillN. Identification and characterization of the critical physically demanding tasks encountered by correctional officers. Appl Physiol Nutr Metab2010;35(1):45–58.
4.
BrewerJ, BuckleP, CastleP. “The Use of Work Place Physiological Measurements to Establish the Minimum Fitness Standards Required for Entry into the United Kingdom Police Service. J Athl Enhancement2013;2:4.
ÅstrandP, RodahlK. Text Book of Work Physiology (3rd ed) New York. McGraw-Hill; 1986:491–93.
7.
O’ConnellE, ThomasP, CadyL, KarwaskyR. Energy Cost of simulated stair climbing as a job-related task in fire fighting. J Occup Med1986;28:282–4.
8.
GledhillN, JamnikV. Characterization of the physical demands of firefighting. Can J Sports Sci1992;17(3):207–13.
9.
ShwomC, OttoR, WygandJ. The energy cost of unilateral and bilateral load carry during fixed rate stair climbing. Med Sci Sports Exerc1996;28(suppl. 5):S198.
10.
BilzonJ, ScarpelloE, BilzonJ, AllsoppA. Generic task-related occupational requirements for Royal Naval personnel. Occup Med2002;52(8):503–10.
11.
ReillyT, IggledenC, GennserM, TiptonM. Occupational fitness standards for Beach Lifeguards phase 2: The development of an easily administered fitness test. Occup Med2006;56:12–7.
12.
NevillAM, RamsbottomR, WilliamsC. Scaling physiological measurements for individuals of different body size. Eur J Appl Physiol and Occupational Physiology1992;65(2):110–7.
13.
JuhaniI, PekkaS, TimoA. Strain skiing and hauling a sledge or carrying a backpack. Eur J Appl Physiol1986;55:597–603.
14.
GarcinM, CravicJ, VandewallH, MonodH. Physiological strains while pushing or hauling. Eur J Appl Physiol1996;72:478–82.
15.
JamnikV, GumienakR, GledhillN. Developing legally defensible physiological employment standards for prominent physically demanding public safety occupations: A Canadian perspective. Eur J Appl Physiol2013;113(10):2447–57.
16.
MilliganG. Fitness Standards for the Maritime and Coastguards Agency and the Oil and Gas Industry. PhD Thesis2013)126–40.
17.
TiptonM, ReillyT, ReesA, SprayG, GoldenF. Swimming performance in surf: The influence of experience. Int J Sports Med2008;29(11):895–8.
BlacklockRE, ReillyTJ, SpivockM, NewtonPS, OlinekSM. Standard Establishment Through Scenarios (SETS): A new technique for occupational fitness standards. Work (Reading, Mass.)2015;52(2):375–83.
20.
FieldADiscovering statistics with SPSS (4th Ed) London: Sage;2013:227.
21.
AtkinsonG, NevillA. Statistical methods for assessing measurement error (reliability) in variables relevant to sports medicine. Sports Med1998;26(4):217–38.
22.
BlandJ, AltmanD. Statistical methods for assessing agreement between two methods of clinical measurement. Lancet i1986)307–10.
23.
WilliamsK, CavanaghP. Relationship between distance running mechanics, running economy, and performance. J Appl Physiol1987;63(3);1236–45.
24.
BoydL, RogersT, DochertyD, PetersenS. Variability in performance on a work simulation test of physical fitness for firefighters. Appl Physiol Nutr and Metab2014;40(4):364–70.
25.
JacksonA. Pre-employment physical evaluation. Exerc Sport Sci Rev1994;22:53–90.
