The purpose of this feasibility study was to assess whether combined intermittent theta burst suppression (iTBS) applied to the ipsilesional hemisphere and modified constraint-induced aphasia therapy (mCIAT) are safe and logistically feasible within the time interval associated with iTBS induced long-term potentiation in patients with post-stroke aphasia. We also wanted to determine whether combining priming with iTBS and CIAT improves language functions after treatment.
Methods:
Twelve participants received fMRI (semantic decision/tone decision task) and neuropsychological testing of language skills at three time points – before starting the iTBS/mCIAT intervention (T1), immediately after completing 2-week long course of intervention (T2), and at 3-months follow-up (T3). ITBS was applied to the individually determined fMRI language “hot spot” located in the left fronto-temporal regions.
Results:
There were no serious adverse events, and all mCIAT group therapy sessions (3–4 subjects each) were initiated within 30 minutes of the first group subject receiving iTBS. Neuropsychological assessments of language showed a significant effect of session on Western Aphasia Battery aphasia quotient (WAB-AQ; p = 0.04) and spontaneously correct responses on Boston Naming Test (BNT; p = 0.002), with improvement noted at T2 (p = 0.002) and T3 (p = 0.05) versus T1. FMRI showed significant changes between all timepoints. Post-hoc correlations showed associations between improvements in WAB-AQ from T2 to T3 and decreased BOLD signal in left inferior parietal lobe, and improvements in BNT from T1 to T3 with decreased signal in right inferior frontal gyrus.
Conclusion:
This study shows feasibility and safety for combining behavioral and neurostimulation interventions for chronic post-stroke aphasia. Observed changes in linguistic measures were relatively small. However, they were statistically significant and associated with parallel changes observed in the neuroimaging. Our findings support further development and testing of the combined mCIAT and iTBS protocol and comparisons to either CIAT/mCIAT or iTBS applied alone for the treatment of post-stroke aphasia.
AlbertiA, PaciaroniM, CasoV, VentiM, PalmeriniF, & AgnelliG. (2008). Early seizures in patients with acute stroke: Frequency, predictive factors, and effect on clinical outcome. Vascular Health Risk Management, 4(3), 715–720.
2.
AllendorferJ.B, StorrsJ.M, & SzaflarskiJ.P. (2012). Changes in white matter integrity follow excitatory rTMS treatment of post-stroke aphasia. Restorative Neuroleurology and Neuroscience, 30(2), 103–113.
3.
AndersonV, Spencer-SmithM, & WoodA. (2011). Do children really recover better? Neuro behavioural plasticity after early brain insult. Brain, 134(Pt 8), 2197–2221.
4.
AndrewsR.J. (1991). Transhemispheric diaschisis. A review and comment. Stroke, 22(7), 943–949.
5.
BaeE.H, SchraderL.M, MachiiK, Alonso-AlonsoM, RivielloJ.J.Jr, Pascual-LeoneA, & RotenbergA. (2007). Safety and tolerability of repetitive transcranial magnetic stimulation in patients with epilepsy: A review of the literature. Epilepsy & Behavior, 10(4), 521–528.
6.
BakerJ.M, RordenC, & FridrikssonJ. (2010). Using transcranial direct-current stimulation to treat stroke patients with aphasia. Stroke, 41(6), 1229–1236.
7.
BarkerA.T. (1999). The history and basic principles of magnetic nerve stimulation. Electroencephalography and Clininical Neurophysiology Suppl, 51, 3–21.
8.
BinderJ, & PriceC. (2001). Functional neuroimaging of language. Handbook of functional neuroimaging of cognition. CabezaR. and KingstoneA., Cambridge, MA, The MIT Press: 187–253.
9.
BoehmeA.K, Martin-SchildS, MarshallR.S, & LazarR.M. (2016). Effect of aphasia on acute stroke outcomes. Neurology, 87(22), 2348–2354.
10.
Buchkremer-RatzmannI, AugustM, HagemannG, & WitteO.W. (1996). Electrophysiological transcortical diaschisis after cortical photothrombosis in rat brain. Stroke, 27(6), 1105–1109; discussion 1109-1111
11.
CappaS.F, SandriniM, RossiniP.M, SostaK, & MiniussiC. (2002). The role of the left frontal lobe in action naming: rTMS evidence. Neurology, 59(5), 720–723.
12.
CharidimouA, KasselimisD, VarkanitsaM, SelaiC, PotagasC, & EvdokimidisI. (2014). Why is it difficult to predictlanguage impairment and outcome in patients with aphasia afterstroke?. Journal of Clinical Neurology, 10(2), 75–83.
13.
CotelliM, ManentiR, CappaS.F, GeroldiC, ZanettiO, RossiniP.M, & MiniussiC. (2006). Effect of transcranial magnetic stimulation on action naming in patients with Alzheimer disease. Archives of Neurology, 63(11), 1602–1604.
14.
De RenziE, & VignoloL.A. (1962). The token test: A sensitive test to detect receptive disturbances in aphasics. Brain, 85, 665–678.
15.
DuncanE.S, SchmahT, & SmallS.L. (2016). Performance Variability as a Predictor of Response to Aphasia Treatment. Neurorehabiliation and Neural Repair, 30(9), 876–882.
16.
EatonK.P, SzaflarskiJ.P, AltayeM, BallA.L, KisselaB.M, BanksC, & HollandS.K. (2008). Reliability of fMRI for studies of language in post-stroke aphasia subjects. Neuroimage, 41(2), 311–322.
17.
EpsteinC.M, LahJ.J, MeadorK, WeissmanJ.D, GaitanL.E, & DiheniaB. (1996). Optimum stimulus parameters for lateralized suppression of speech with magnetic brain stimulation. Neurology, 47(6), 1590–1593.
18.
FinocchiaroC, MaimoneM, BrighinaF, PiccoliT, GigliaG, & FierroB. (2006). A case study of Primary Progressive Aphasia: Improvement on verbs after rTMS treatment. Neurocase, 12(6), 317–321.
19.
FridrikssonJ, RichardsonJ.D, FillmoreP, & CaiB. (2012). Left hemisphere plasticity and aphasia recovery. Neuroimage, 60(2), 854–863.
GriffisJ.C, NenertR, AllendorferJ.B, & SzaflarskiJ.P. (2017). Damage to white matter bottlenecks contributes to language impairments after left hemispheric stroke. Neuroimage Clinical, 14, 552–565.
25.
GriffisJ.C, NenertR, AllendorferJ.B, & SzaflarskiJ.P. (2017). Linking left hemispheric tissue preservation to fMRI language task activation in chronic stroke patients. Cortex, 96, 1–18.
26.
GriffisJ.C, NenertR, AllendorferJ.B, VannestJ, HollandS, DietzA, & SzaflarskiJ.P. (2017). The canonical semantic network supports residual language function in chronic post-stroke aphasia. Human Brain Mapping, 38(3), 1636–1658.
27.
HamiltonR.H, ChrysikouE.G, & CoslettB. (2011). Mechanisms of aphasia recovery after stroke and the role of noninvasive brain stimulation. Brain and Language, 118(1-2), 40–50.
28.
HeissW.D, & ThielA. (2006). A proposed regional hierarchy in recovery of post-stroke aphasia. Brain and Language, 98(1), 118–123.
29.
HombergV, & NetzJ. (1989). Generalised seizures induced by transcranial magnetic stimulation of motorcortex. Lancet, 2(8673), 1223.
30.
HuangY.Z, EdwardsM.J, RounisE, BhatiaK.P, & RothwellJ.C. (2005). Theta burst stimulation of the human motor cortex. Neuron, 45(2), 201–206.
31.
HummelF, CelnikP, Pascual-LeoneA, FregniJ, ByblowW, BuetefischC, RothwellJ, CohenL, & GerloffC. (2008). Controversy: Noninvasive and invasive cortical stimulation show efficacy in treating stroke patients. Brain Stimulation, 1(4), 370–382.
KarunanayakaP, SchmithorstV.J, VannestJ, SzaflarskiJ.P, PlanteE, & HollandS.K. (2011). A linear structural equation model for covert verb generation based on independent component analysis of FMRI data from children and adolescents. Frontiers of Systems Neuroscience, 5, 29.
34.
KerteszA. (2006). Western Aphasia Battery-Revised. San Antonio, TX, Psychological Corporation.
35.
KimK.K, KarunanayakaP, PriviteraM.D, HollandS.K, & SzaflarskiJ.P. (2011). Semantic association investigated with functional MRI and independent component analysis. Epilepsy & Behavior, 20(4), 613–622.
36.
KozoraE, & CullumC. (1995). Generative naming in normal aging: Total output and qualitative changes using phonemic and semantic constraints. Clinical Neuropsychologist, 9(4), 313–320.
37.
LazarR.M, & BoehmeA.K. (2017). Aphasia As a Predictor of Stroke Outcome. Current Neurology and Neurosciences Reports, 17(11), 83.
38.
LazarR.M, SpeizerA.E, FestaJ.R, KrakauerJ.W, & MarshallR.S. (2008). Variability in language recovery after first-time stroke. Journal of Neurology Neurosurgery and Psychiatry, 79(5), 530–534.
39.
LezakM. (1995). Neuropsychological assessment,New York, Oxford University Press.
40.
LopesT.M, YasudaC.L, de CamposB.M, BalthazarM.L, BinderJ.R, & CendesF. (2016). Effects of task complexity on activation of language areas in a semantic decision fMRI protocol. Neuropsychologia, 81, 140–148.
41.
MazaikaP, WhitfieldS, & CooperJ. (2005). Detection and repair of transient artifacts in fMRI data. Neuroimage, 26, S36.
42.
MeinzerM, DjundjaD, BarthelG, ElbertT, & RockstrohB. (2005). Long-term stability of improved language functions in chronic aphasia after constraint-induced aphasia therapy. Stroke, 36(7), 1462–1466.
43.
MichelucciR, ValzaniaF, PassarelliD, SantangeloM, RizziR, BuzziA.M, TempestiniA, & TassinariC.A. (1994). Rapid-rate transcranial magnetic stimulation and hemispheric language dominance: Usefulness and safety in epilepsy. Neurology, 44(9), 1697–1700.
44.
MottaghyF.M, HungsM, BrugmannM, SparingR, BoroojerdiB, FoltysH, HuberW, & TopperR. (1999). Facilitation of picture naming after repetitive transcranial magnetic stimulation. Neurology, 53(8), 1806–1812.
45.
NenertR, AllendorferJ.B, MartinA.M, BanksC, BallA, VannestJ, DietzA.R, & SzaflarskiJ.P. (2017). Neuroimaging Correlates of Post-Stroke Aphasia Rehabilitation in a Pilot Randomized Trial of Constraint-Induced Aphasia Therapy. Medical Science Monitor, 23, 3489–3507.
46.
NenertR, AllendorferJB, VannestSK, HollandSK, MartinAN, BanksC, HartKW, LindsellCJ, & SzaflarskiJP (2018). Longitudinal fMRI study of language recovery after a left hemispheric ischemic stroke. Restorative Neurology and Neuroscence, 36, 359–385.
47.
PedersenP.M, JorgensenH.S, NakayamaH, RaaschouH.O, & OlsenT.S. (1995). Aphasia in acute stroke: Incidence, determinants, and recovery. Annals of Neurology, 38(4), 659–666.
48.
PrioriA, BertolasiL, DresslerD, RothwellJ.C, DayB.L, ThompsonP.D, & MarsdenC.D. (1993). Transcranial electric and magnetic stimulation of the leg area of the human motor cortex: Single motor unit and surface EMG responses in the tibialis anterior muscle. Electroencephalography and Clinical Neurophysiology, 89(2), 131–137.
49.
PulvermullerF, & BerthierM.L. (2008). Aphasia therapy on a neuroscience basis. Aphasiology, 22(6), 563–599.
50.
PulvermullerF, NeiningerB, ElbertT, MohrB, RockstrohB, KoebbelP, & TaubE. (2001). Constraint-induced therapy of chronic aphasia after stroke. Stroke, 32(7), 1621–1626.
51.
Raja BeharelleA, DickA.S, JosseG, SolodkinA, HuttenlocherP.R, LevineS.C, & SmallS.L. (2010). Left hemisphere regions are critical for language in the face of early left focal brain injury. Brain, 133(Pt 6), 1707–1716.
52.
RichardsonJ.D, BakerJ.M, MorganP.S, RordenC, BonilhaL, & FridrikssonJ. (2011). Cerebral perfusion in chronic stroke: Implications for lesion-symptom mapping and functional MRI. Behavioral Neurology, 24(2), 117–122.
53.
RipollesP, Marco-PallaresJ, de Diego-BalaguerR, MiroJ, FalipM, JuncadellaM, RubioF, & Rodriguez-FornellsA. (2012). Analysis of automated methods for spatial normalization of lesioned brains. Neuroimage, 60(2), 1296–1306.
54.
RobeyR.R. (1998). A meta-analysis of clinical outcomes in the treatment of aphasia. Journal of Speech Language and Hearing Research, 41(1), 172–187.
55.
RosenH.J, PetersenS.E, LinenweberM.R, SnyderA.Z, WhiteD.A, ChapmanL, DromerickA.W, FiezJ.A, & CorbettaM.D. (2000). Neural correlates of recovery from aphasia after damage to left inferior frontal cortex. Neurology, 55(12), 1883–1894.
56.
RossiS, HallettM, RossiniP.M, & Pascual-LeoneA. (2009). Safety, ethical considerations, and application guidelines for the use of transcranial magnetic stimulation in clinical practice and research. Clinical Neurophysiology, 120(12), 2008–2039.
57.
SatzP, StraussE, HunterM, & WadaJ. (1994). Re-examination of the crowding hypothesis: Effects of age of onset. Neuropsychology, 8(2), 255–262.
58.
SaurD, LangeR, BaumgaertnerA, SchraknepperV, WillmesK, RijntjesM, & WeillerC. (2006). Dynamics of language reorganization after stroke. Brain, 129(Pt 6), 1371–1384.
59.
SeghierM.L, RamlackhansinghA, CrinionJ, LeffA.P, & PriceC.J. (2008). Lesion identification using unified segmentation-normalisation models and fuzzy clustering. Neuroimage, 41(4), 1253–1266.
60.
ShahP, SzaflarskiJ, AllendorferJ, & HamiltonR. (2013). Induction of neuroplasticity and recovery inpost-stroke aphasia by non-invasive brain stimulation. Frontiers of Human Neuroscience, 7.
61.
SlotnickS.D, MooL.R, SegalJ.B, HartJ.Jr. (2003). Distinct prefrontal cortex activity associated with item memory and source memory for visual shapes. Brain Research Cognitive Brain Research, 17(1), 75–82.
62.
SzaflarskiJ, VannestJ, WuS, DifrancescoM, BanksC, & GilbertD. (2011). Excitatory repetitive transcranial magnetic stimulation induces improvements in chronic post-stroke aphasia. Medical Scicience Monitor, 17(3), CR132–139.
63.
SzaflarskiJ.P, AllendorferJ.B, BanksC, VannestJ, & HollandS.K. (2013). Recovered vs. not-recovered from post-stroke aphasia: The contributions from the dominant and non-dominant hemispheres. Restorative Neurology and Neuroscience, 31(4), 347–360.
64.
SzaflarskiJ.P, AllendorferJ.B, ByarsA.W, VannestJ, DietzA, HernandoK.A, & HollandS.K. (2014). Age at stroke determines post-stroke language lateralization. Restorative Neurology and Neuroscience, 32(6), 733–742.
65.
SzaflarskiJ.P, BallA, GretherS, Al-FwaressF, GriffithN.M, Neils-StrunjasJ, NewmeyerA, & ReichhardtR. (2008). Constraint-induced aphasia therapy stimulates language recovery in patients with chronic aphasia after ischemic stroke. Medical Science Monitor, 14(5), CR243–250.
66.
SzaflarskiJ.P, BallA.L, VannestJ, DietzA.R, AllendorferJ.B, MartinA.N, HartK, & LindsellC.J. (2015). Constraint-Induced Aphasia Therapy for Treatment of Chronic Post-Stroke Aphasia: A Randomized, Blinded, Controlled Pilot Trial. Medical Science Monitor, 21, 2861–2869.
67.
SzaflarskiJ.P, BinderJ.R, PossingE.T, McKiernanK.A, WardB.D, & HammekeT.A. (2002). Language lateralization in left-handed and ambidextrous people: fMRI data. Neurology, 59(2), 238–244.
68.
SzaflarskiJ.P, GlossD, BinderJ.R, GaillardW.D, GolbyA.J, HollandS.K, OjemannJ, SpencerD.C, SwansonS.J, FrenchJ.A, & TheodoreW.H. (2017). Practice guideline summary: Use of fMRI in the presurgical evaluation of patients with epilepsy: Report of the Guideline Development, Dissemination, and Implementation Subcommittee of the American Academy of Neurology. Neurology, 88(4), 395–402.
69.
SzaflarskiJ.P, HollandS.K, JacolaL.M, LindsellC, PriviteraM.D, & SzaflarskiM. (2008). Comprehensive presurgical functional MRI language evaluation in adult patients with epilepsy. Epilepsy & Behavior, 12(1), 74–83.
70.
SzaflarskiJ.P, RackleyA.Y, KleindorferD.O, KhouryJ, WooD, MillerR, AlwellK, BroderickJ.P, & KisselaB.M. (2008). Incidence of seizures in the acute phase of stroke: A population-based study. Epilepsia, 49(6), 974–981.
71.
SzaflarskiJ.P, VannestJ, WuS.W, DifrancescoM.W, BanksC, & GilbertD.L. (2011). Excitatory repetitive transcranial magnetic stimulation induces improvements in chronic post-stroke aphasia. Medical Science Monitor, 17(3), CR132–139.
72.
TalelliP, GreenwoodR.J, & RothwellJ.C. (2007). Exploring Theta Burst Stimulation as an intervention to improve motor recovery in chronic stroke. Clinical Neurophysiology, 118(2), 333–342.
73.
TillemaJ.M, ByarsA.W, JacolaL.M, SchapiroM.B, SchmithorstV.J, SzaflarskiJ.P, & HollandS.K. (2008). Cortical reorganization of language functioning following perinatalleft MCA stroke. Brain and Language, 105(2), 99–111.
74.
TippettD.C, & HillisA.E. (2017). Where are aphasia theory and management headed?F1000Res6
75.
VannestJ, SzaflarskiJ.P, EatonK.P, HenkelD.M, MoritaD, GlauserT.A, ByarsA.W, PatelK, & HollandS.K. (2013). Functional magnetic resonance imaging reveals changes in language localization in children with benign childhood epilepsy with centrotemporal spikes. Journal of Child Neurology, 28(4), 435–445.
76.
WassermannE.M. (1998). Risk and safety of repetitive transcranial magnetic stimulation: Report and suggested guidelines from the International Workshop on the Safety of Repetitive Transcranial Magnetic Stimulation, June 5-7, 1996. Electroencephalography and Clinical Neurophysiology, 108(1), 1–16.
77.
WiseR.J. (2003). Language systems in normal and aphasic human subjects: Functional imaging studies and inferences from animal studies. British Medical Bulletin, 65, 95–119.
78.
YarnellP, MonroeP, & SobelL. (1976). Aphasia outcome in stroke: A clinical neuroradiological correlation. Stroke, 7(5), 516–522.
79.
ZiemannU, CorwellB, & CohenL.G. (1998). Modulation of plasticity in human motor cortex after forearm ischemic nerve block. Journal of Neuroscience, 18(3), 1115–1123.
80.
ZiemannU, HallettM, & CohenL.G. (1998). Mechanisms of deafferentation-induced plasticity in human motor cortex. Journal of Neuroscience, 18(17), 7000–7007.
