Transcranial direct current stimulation (tDCS) may provide a potential therapy for cognitive deficits caused by traumatic brain injury (TBI), yet its efficacy and mechanisms of action are still uncertain.
OBJECTIVE:
We hypothesized that anodal tDCS over the left dorsolateral prefrontal cortex (DLPFC) would boost the influence of a cognitive training regimen in a mild-to-moderate TBI (mmTBI) sample. Cognitive enhancement was measured by examining event-related potentials (ERPs) during cognitive control tasks from pre- to post-treatment.
METHODS:
Thirty-four participants with mmTBI underwent ten sessions of cognitive training with active (n = 17) or sham (n = 17) anodal tDCS to the left DLPFC. ERPs were assessed during performance of an auditory oddball (3AOB), N-back, and dot pattern expectancy (DPX) task before and after treatment.
RESULTS:
P3b amplitudes significantly decreased from baseline to post-treatment testing, regardless of tDCS condition, in the N-back task. The active tDCS group demonstrated a significantly increased P3a amplitude in the DPX task. No statistically significant stimulation effects were seen during the 3AOB and N-back tasks.
CONCLUSION:
Active anodal tDCS paired with cognitive training led to increases in P3a amplitudes in the DPX, inferring increased cognitive control. P3b decreased in the N-back task demonstrating the effects of cognitive training. These dissociated P3 findings suggest separate mechanisms invoked by different neuroplasticity-inducing paradigms (stimulation versus training) in brain networks that support executive functioning.
Baguley,I. J., Felmingham,K. L., Lahz,S., Gordon,E., Lazzaro,I., & Schotte,D. E. (1997) Alcohol abuse and traumatic brain injury: Effect on event-related potentials, Archives of Physical Medicine and Rehabilitation78(11), 1248–1253.
2.
Blennow,K., Brody,D. L., Kochanek,P. M., Levin,H., McKee,A., Ribbers,G. M., …Zetterberg,H. (2016) Traumatic brain injuries, Nature Reviews Disease Primers2(1), 1–19.
3.
Boudewyn,M., Roberts,B. M., Mizrak,E., Ranganath,C., & Carter,C. S. (2019) Prefrontal transcranial direct current stimulation (tDCS) enhances behavioral and EEG markers of proactive control, Cognitive Neuroscience10(2), 57–65.
4.
Brainard,D. H. (1997) The psychophysics toolbox, Spatial Vision10, 433–436.
5.
Chase,H. W., Boudewyn,M. A., Carter,C. S., & Phillips,M. L. (2019) Transcranial direct current stimulation: A roadmap for research, from mechanism of action to clinical implementation, Molecular Psychiatry1–11.
6.
Cavanagh,J. F. (2019) Electrophysiology as a theoretical and methodological hub for the neural sciences, Psychophysiology56, 1–13.
7.
Cavanagh,J. F., Rieger,R. E., Wilson,J. K., Gill,D., Fullerton,L., Brandt,E., & Mayer,A. R. (2019) Joint analysis of frontal theta synchrony and white matter following mild traumatic brain injury, Brain Imaging and Behavior.
8.
Cavanagh,J. F., & Frank,M. J. (2014) Frontal theta as a mechanism for cognitive control, Trends in Cognitive Sciences18(8), 414–421.
9.
Chan,M. M. Y., & Han,Y. M. Y. (2020) Effects of Transcranial Direct Current Stimulation (tDCS) in the normalization of brain activation in patients with neuropsychiatric disorders: A systematic review of neurophysiological and neuroimaging studies. Neural Plasticity2020, e8854412.
10.
Cicerone,K. D., Langenbahn,D. M., Braden,C., Malec,J. F., Kalmar,K., Fraas,M., Felicetti,T., Laatsch,L., Harley,J. P., Bergquist,T., Azulay,J., Cantor,J., & Ashman,T. (2011) Evidence-based cognitive rehabilitation: Updated review of the literature from 2003 through 2008, Archives of Physical Medicine and Rehabilitation92(4), 519–530.
11.
Cole,M. W. (2017) Control and Connectivity: Dynamic Networks in the Human Brain. In Egner, T. (Ed.), The Wiley Handbook of Cognitive Control, pp. 314–333.
12.
Daffner,Kirk R., Hyemi,C., Xue,S., Elise,C. T., Jenna,L. R., Scott,M. M., & Phillip,J. H. (2011) Mechanisms underlying age- and performance-related differences in working memory, Journal of Cognitive Neuroscience23(6), 1298–1314.
13.
Dedoncker,J., Brunoni,A. R., Baeken,C., & Vanderhasselt,M. -A. (2016) A systematic review and meta-analysis of the effects of Transcranial Direct Current Stimulation (tDCS) over the dorsolateral prefrontal cortex in healthy and neuropsychiatric samples: Influence of stimulation parameters, Brain Stimulation9(4), 501–517.
14.
Delorme,A., & Makeig,S. (2004) EEGLAB: An open source toolbox for analysis of single-trial EEG dynamics including independent component analysis, Journal of Neuroscience Methods134(1), 9–21.
15.
Dockree,P. M., & Robertson,I. H. (2011) Electrophysiological markers of cognitive deficits in traumatic brain injury: A review, International Journal of Psychophysiology82(1), 53–60.
16.
Duncan,C. C., Summers,A. C., Perla,E. J., Coburn,K. L., & Mirsky,A. F. (2011) Evaluation of traumatic brain injury: Brain potentials in diagnosis, function, and prognosis, International Journal of Psychophysiology82(1), 24–40.
17.
Faul,F., Erdfelder,E., Buchner,A., & Lang,A. -G. (2009) Statistical power analyses using G*Power 3.1: Tests for correlation and regression analyses, Behavior Research Methods41, 1149–1160.
18.
Filmer,H. L., Lyons,M., Mattingley,J. B., & Dux,P. E. (2017) Anodal tDCS applied during multitasking training leads to transferable performance gains, Scientific Reports7(1).
19.
Filmer,H. L., Varghese,E., Hawkins,G. E., Mattingley,J. B., & Dux,P. E. (2016) Improvements in attention and decision-making following combined behavioral training and brain stimulation, Cerebral Cortex.
20.
Gbadeyan,O., McMahon,K., Steinhauser,M., & Meinzer,M. (2016) Stimulation of dorsolateral prefrontal cortex enhances adaptive cognitive control: A high-definition transcranial direct current stimulation study, Journal of Neuroscience36(50), 12530–12536.
21.
Gill,J., Shah-Basak,P. P., & Hamilton,R. (2015) It’s the thought that counts: Examining the task-dependent effects of transcranial direct current stimulation on executive function, Brain Stimulation8(2), 253–259.
22.
Gu,S., Pasqualetti,F., Cieslak,M., Telesford,Q. K., Yu,A. B., Kahn,A. E., …Bassett,D. S. (2015) Controllability of structural brain networks, Nature Communications6(1), 1–10.
23.
Hogeveen,J., Grafman,J., Aboseria,M., David,A., Bikson,M., & Hauner,K. K. (2016) Effects of high-definition and conventional tDCS on response inhibition, Brain Stimulation9(5), 720–729.
Imburgio,M. J., & Orr,J. M. (2018) Effects of prefrontal tDCS on executive function: Methodological considerations revealed by meta-analysis, Neuropsychologia117, 156–166.
26.
Karbach,J., & Kray,J. (2009) How useful is executive control training? Age differences in near and far transfer of task-switching training, Developmental Science12(6), 978–990.
27.
Kim,H., Chey,J., & Lee,S. (2017) Effects of multicomponent training of cognitive control on cognitive function and brain activation in older adults, Neuroscience Research124, 8–15.
28.
Kinnunen,K. M., Greenwood,R., Powell,J. H., Leech,R., Hawkins,P. C., Bonnelle,V., …Sharp,D. J. (2011) White matter damage and cognitive impairment after traumatic brain injury, Brain134(2), 449–463.
29.
Kleiner,M., Brainard,D., & Pelli,D. (2007) What’s new in Psychtoolbox-?Perception ECVP Abstract Supplement36.
30.
Kraus,M. F., Susmaras,T., Caughlin,B. P., Walker,C. J., Sweeney,J. A., & Little,D. M. (2007) White matter integrity and cognition in chronic traumatic brain injury: A diffusion tensor imaging study, Brain130(10), 2508–2519.
31.
Langlois,J. A., Rutland-Brown,W., & Wald,M. M. (2006) The epidemiology and impact of traumatic brain injury: A brief overview, Journal of Head Trauma Rehabilitation21(5), 375–378.
32.
Li,S., Zaninotto,A. L., Neville,I. S., Paiva,W. S., Nunn,D., & Fregni,F. (2015) Clinical utility of brain stimulation modalities following traumatic brain injury: Current evidence, Neuropsychiatric Disease and Treatment11, 1573–1586.
33.
Lingsma,H. F., Roozenbeek,B., Steyerberg,E. W., Murray,G. D., & Maas,A. I. (2010) Early prognosis in traumatic brain injury: From prophecies to predictions, The Lancet Neurology9(5), 543–554.
34.
Lubitz,A. F., Niedeggen,M., & Feser,M. (2017) Aging and working memory performance: Electrophysiological correlates of high and low performing elderly, Neuropsychologia106, 42–51.
35.
MATLAB. (2018) MATLAB (R2018b) [Computer Software]. Natwik, MA: The MathWorks Inc. Retrieved from, http://www.mathworks.com
36.
McDonald,B. C., Laura,A. F., & Andrew,J. S. (2002) Executive dysfunction following traumatic brain injury: Neural substrates and treatment strategies ed. Thomas W. McAllister, NeuroRehabilitation17(4), 333–344.
37.
Neurobehavioral Systems, Inc. (2015) Presentation (Version 14.0) [Computer Software]. Berkeley, CA. Retrieved from http://www.neurobs.com
38.
Nolan,H., Whelan,R., & Reilly,R. B. (2010) FASTER: Fully automated statistical thresholding for EEG artifact rejection, Journal of Neuroscience Methods192(1), 152–162.
39.
O’Neil-Pirozzi,T. M., Doruk,D., Thomson,J. M., & Fregni,F. (2017) Immediate memory and electrophysiologic effects of prefrontal cortex transcranial direct current stimulation on neurotypical individuals and individuals with chronic traumatic brain injury: A pilot study, International Journal of Neuroscience127(7), 592–600.
40.
Pandit,A. S., Expert,P., Lambiotte,R., Bonnelle,V., Leech,R., Turkheimer,F. E., & Sharp,D. J. (2013) Traumatic brain injury impairs small-world topology, Neurology80(20), 1826–1833.
41.
Pelli,D. G. (1997) The VideoToolbox software for visual psychophysics: Transforming numbers into movies, Spatial Vision10, 437–442.
42.
Pergher,V., Wittevrongel,B., Tournoy,J., Schoenmakers,B., & Hulle,M. M. V. (2018) N-back training and transfer effects revealed by behavioral responses and EEG. Brain and Behavior8(11), e01136.
43.
Quinn,D. K., Upston,J., Jones,T., Brandt,E., Story-Remer,J., Fratzke,V., Wilson,J. K., Rieger,R., Hunter,M. A., Gill,D., Richardson,J. D., Campbell,R., Clark,V. P., Yeo,R. A., Shuttleworth,C. W., & Mayer,A. R. (2020) Cerebral perfusion effects of cognitive training and transcranial direct current stimulation in mild-moderate TBI, Frontiers in Neurology11, 545174.
44.
Quinn,D. K., Story-Remer,J., Brandt,E., Fratzke,V., Rieger,R., Wilson,J. K., Gill,D., Mertens,N., Hunter,M. A., Upston,J., Jones,T., Richardson,J. D., Myers,O., Arciniegas, D.B., Campbell,R., Clark,V. P., Yeo,R. A., Shuttleworth,C. W., & Mayer,A. R. (2022) Transcranial direct current stimulation modulates working memory and prefrontal-insula connectivity after mild-moderate traumatic brain injury. Frontiers in Human Neuroscience13. https://doi.org/10.3389/fnhum.2022.1026639
45.
R Core Team. (2019) R: A language and environment for statistical computing. R Foundation for Statistical Computing, Vienna, Austria. Retrieved from http://www.R-project.org/
46.
Rabinowitz,A. R., & Levin,H. S. (2014) Cognitive sequelae of traumatic brain injury, The Psychiatric Clinics of North America37(1), 1–11.
47.
Rahman,A., Reato,D., Arlotti,M., Gasca,F., Datta,A., Parra,L. C., & Bikson,M. (2013) Cellular effects of acute direct current stimulation: Somatic and synaptic terminal effects, The Journal of Physiology591(10), 2563–2578.
48.
Rietdijk,W. J. R., Franken,I. H. A., & Thurik,A. R. (2014) Internal consistency of event-related potentials associated with cognitive control: N2/P3 and ERN/Pe, PLoS ONE9(7), 1–7.
49.
Ruf,S. P., Fallgatter,A. J., & Plewnia,C. (2017) Augmentation of working memory training by transcranial direct current stimulation (tDCS), Scientific Reports, 7(1), 1–11.
Stagg,C. J., Lin,R. L., Mezue,M., Segerdahl,A., Kong,Y., Xie,J., & Tracey,I. (2013) Widespread modulation of cerebral perfusion induced during and after transcranial direct current stimulation applied to the left dorsolateral prefrontal cortex, Journal of Neuroscience33(28), 11425–11431.
52.
Stephens,J. A., & Berryhill,M. E. (2016) Older adults improve on everyday tasks after working memory training and neurostimulation, Brain Stimulation9(4), 553–559.
53.
Sur,S., & Sinha,V. K. (2009) Event-related potential: An overview, Industrial Psychiatry Journal18(1), 70–73.
54.
The jamovi project. (2020) jamovi (Version 1.1.9.0) [Computer Software]. Retrieved from https://www.jamovi.org
55.
Trumbo,M. C., Matzen,L. E., Coffman,B. A., Hunter,M. A., Jones,A. P., Robinson,C. S. H., & Clark,V. P. (2016) Enhanced working memory performance via transcranial direct current stimulation: The possibility of near and far transfer, Neuropsychologia93, 85–96.
56.
Turner,G. R., McIntosh,A. R., & Levine,B. (2011) Prefrontal compensatory engagement in TBI is due to altered functional engagement of existing networks and not functional reorganization, Frontiers in Systems Neuroscience5.
57.
VA/DoDClinical Practice Guideline for the Management of Concussion-Mild Traumatic Brain Injury. 2016, pp. 1–133.
58.
Wiegand,A., Sommer,A., Nieratschker,V., & Plewnia,C. (2019) Improvement of cognitive control and stabilization of affect by prefrontal transcranial direct current stimulation (tDCS, Scientific Reports9(1), 1–8.
59.
Xin,Z., Lai,Z. -R., Li,F., & Maes,J. H. R. (2014) Near- and far-transfer effects of working memory updating training in elderly adults, Applied Cognitive Psychology28(3), 403–408.
60.
Zaloshinja,E., Miller,T., Langlois,J., & Selassie,A. (2008) Prevalence of long-term disability from traumatic brain injury in the civilian population of the United States, 2005, Journal of Head Trauma Rehabilitation23(6), 394–400.
61.
Zelazo,P. D., & Anderson,J. E. (2013) What is Cognitive Control? In
Zelazo,P. D., &
Sera,M. D. (Eds.), Minnesota Symposia on Child Psychology, pp. 1–20.
