Abstract
Feeding and swallowing problems in infants and children have a great impact on health and wellbeing. The aim of this study was to provide an overview of recognized feeding and swallowing problems in different groups of children with neuromuscular diseases, based on relevant literature and expert opinion, and to propose recommendations for the assessment and treatment of these problems. Almost all pediatric neuromuscular diseases are accompanied by feeding and swallowing problems during the different phases of deglutition, problems that give rise to a wide variety of signs and symptoms, which emphasizes the importance of a comprehensive feeding and swallowing assessment by a speech and language therapist.
INTRODUCTION
Children with neurologic disabilities frequently have problems with feeding and swallowing. In 2007, the American Speech-Language-Hearing Association adopted “feeding and swallowing disorders” as a more inclusive phrase for disorders in the development of eating and drinking skills and dysphagia, disorders that are common in various pediatric populations. Feeding disorders are defined as problems with eating activities, such as sucking during breastfeeding or bottle-feeding, eating with a spoon, chewing, or drinking from a cup. Swallowing disorders, or dysphagia, are defined as abnormalities in one of the four phases of the normal swallowing mechanism, namely, the oral preparatory, oral transport, pharyngeal, and esophageal phases [1]. Feeding and swallowing disorders in children with neurodevelopmental disabilities have a great impact on the health and wellbeing of these children and their families. Feeding disorders, choking, and aspiration have been described in children with neuromuscular diseases (NMDs) and in children with cerebral palsy [2, 3], but the underlying causes and swallowing patterns are different in NMDs and cerebral palsy [4]. In general, children with cerebral palsy are at risk of aspirating thin fluids, whereas children with NMDs lack the muscle strength required to swallow solid food properly [4, 5]. Muscle weakness is a common feature of childhood NMDs, although the factors contributing to, and the pattern of, muscle weakness vary in the different types of NMD.
The aim of this study was to provide an overview of the known feeding and swallowing problems of different groups of children with NMDs and to propose recommendations for the assessment and treatment of these problems.
NEUROMUSCULAR DISEASES IN CHILDREN
NMDs are acquired or inherited (genetic) conditions affecting the neuromuscular system, with hypotonia due to muscle weakness being the predominant characteristic symptom. NMDs are broadly subdivided into muscular dystrophies, myopathies, and neuropathies. Some common NMDs seen in children are listed in Table 1.
NORMAL DEVELOPMENT OF FEEDING SKILLS AND SWALLOWING
Initially, neonates suckle from the breast (or bottle), but after about 3 months brainstem reflexes, such as the sucking reflex, disappear and by about 6 months infants start eating foods of different consistencies. The oral anatomy changes as a result of the growth of the oral cavity and the descent of laryngeal structures. Between 6 and 12 months, infants learn to chew and swallow pureed or solid food [8], which requires greater strength of the oral muscles. The complete swallowing mechanism develops thereafter, with the adult swallowing pattern being reached in puberty, after the pharynx has attained its adult length.
ASSESSMENT OF PEDIATRIC FEEDING AND SWALLOWING DISORDERS
A feeding disorder refers to problems in the development of feeding skills, such as sucking from breast or bottle, eating from a spoon, chewing, or drinking from a cup, while a swallowing disorder, or dysphagia, refers to problems in one or more phases of the swallowing process (Table 2) [9].
In infants and children with feeding and swallowing disorders, a comprehensive swallowing assessment is necessary in order to provide adequate management and recommendations for efficient and safe feeding. In accordance with the International Classification of Functioning, Disability and Health (ICF), the assessment includes information on mealtime environment (participation), activities of the child during mealtimes (activities), and motor skills, neuromotor development, and neuromuscular conditions (body function and structures) [9, 10]. It includes making an inventory of feeding and swallowing problems, observing eating and drinking of different consistencies, and assessing neuromotor development and oral motor skills. If there is concern about safe swallowing, a video fluoroscopic swallow study (VFSS) or a flexible endoscopic evaluation of swallowing (FEES) should be performed [11].
Swallowing in children and adults is different, in the sense that mouth and digestive anatomy is different in children and adults, and so, in general, is the consistency of food eaten and hence the consistency of the bolus swallowed [12]. Feeding skills are developed during infancy and childhood, and the changing oral and pharyngeal anatomy during this time necessitates careful assessment during the consecutive stages of infancy and childhood.
METHODS
Members of the Children’s Swallowing Team (LE and CE) of the Radboud University Medical Centre (the Netherlands) reviewed the literature (Pubmed and Web of Science) using the search terms ‘feeding problems AND infants/children’, ‘swallowing problems AND infants/children’, ‘dysphagia AND infants/children’, all in combination with various neuromuscular diseases (Table 3). Only English-language articles were included, published from 1985 until 2014. The first search identified 75 articles, of which 62 were included (Table 3). Articles were included if they provided information on the oral preparatory, oral transport, pharyngeal, and/or esophageal phases of swallowing.
RESULTS: FEEDING AND SWALLOWING PROBLEMS IN CHILDREN WITH NMD
The various problems associated with the four phases of swallowing seen in children with NMDs are presented in Table 3. In many cases, problems occur in more than one phase. The oral (preparatory) phase is often complicated by structural impairments, such as limited mouth opening, inability to close the mouth due to malocclusions, or structural abnormalities of the tongue.
DISCUSSION
The common element in all NMDs is muscle weakness, which influences motor abilities and oral motor activities, with the pattern of eating or swallowing problems being influenced by the specific muscle groups affected by the NMD. Moreover, a wide variety of signs and symptoms are caused by aspecific (not disease) dependent variables including (a) the onset of signs and symptoms, (b) the phase of dysfunctional swallowing, (c) disease progression, and (d) bulbar muscle involvement.
(a) Onset of signs and symptoms
Fetal dysphagia occurs in relation to polyhydramnios in some NMDs, which is important to observe and relate to possible swallowing problems. Feeding problems may present at birth, with a neonatal onset and are often related to weak sucking. In most NMDs, with the exception of spinal muscular atrophy, the triggering and timing of swallowing in the bulbar region is normal [13], so that dysphagia is mainly related to weakness of the oral muscles rather than to incoordination of sucking, swallowing, and breathing. Coughing during feeding in the neonatal period in infants with an NMD is mainly related to pharyngeal residue after swallowing. This emphasizes the need for a thorough feeding and swallowing assessment, in order to make the right decisions regarding food adaptation. In neonates with weak sucking, thickened liquids require stronger suction and could make problems with pharyngeal residue worse [73]. Tailor-made interventions with a focus on the safety of swallowing and making use of soft nipples, diminished suck–swallow sequences, and limited feeding time may be necessary [53, 74]. If sucking and swallowing are too weak, unsafe, or impossible, a feeding tube is needed to prevent aspiration and to provide adequate nutritional intake. Chewing difficulties can be a later complication, leading to prolonged mealtimes, choking, or asphyxiation, and a low food/calorie intake [52]. In progressive NMDs, although many children may have learned to chew, masticatory problems may arise because of increasing weakness of the masseter and temporal muscles, in combination with weak tongue movements, resulting in prolonged mealtimes and the feeling that food is sticking in the throat.
(b) The phase of dysfunctional swallowing
Problems in the oral preparatory and oral transport phases
Oral muscle weakness influences the oral preparatory phase, resulting in weak sucking, weak mastication, or an inability to suck or chew. Weak sucking in the neonatal period often leads to (supplementary) tube feeding, which hampers the development of oral feeding [58]. Almost all NMDs of childhood are accompanied by mastication problems. The ability to chew depends on orofacial anatomical features, the coordination of these anatomical features, and the strength of the masticatory muscles [75]. In children with an NMD, the oral phase of swallowing is often complicated by structural impairments, such as malocclusions, limited mouth opening, tented upper lip, high arched palate, atrophic or hypertrophic tongue, or sunken cheeks. Together with the reduced force of the masticatory muscles, these abnormalities hamper the ability to chew solid food. Both human and animal studies have shown that food consistency affects orofacial development, suggesting that a diet with harder textures enhances bone and muscle growth [75]. If children with an NMD cannot handle chewable consistencies, then oral structures may not develop normally, which contributes to less efficient chewing.
Drooling of saliva and food is often due to poor lip seal, but it does not occur in all NMDs. Drooling in cerebral palsy has been extensively studied and is considered multifactorial with diminished subconscious swallowing frequency, insufficient oral suction, incomplete oral closure, tongue protrusion, slow tongue movements, and oral dyskinesia [76]. Drooling in NMDs is found mainly in children with severe bulbar weakness, such as congenital myotonic dystrophy, congenital myopathy, and Pompe disease. This suggests that drooling in these children is mainly due to oral weakness, such that there is reduced oral lip seal and limited oral suction of the tongue.
The main problems in the oral transport phase are piecemeal deglutition (the need for multiple swallows to clear the oral cavity), poor bolus formation, and oral residue after swallow. Many of these problems are caused by tongue weakness, so that affected children need more time to finish their meals.
Problems in the pharyngeal phase
Pharyngeal phase problems can range from nasal regurgitation, residue after swallow in the valleculae, piriform sinuses, and pharyngeal wall, to laryngeal penetration of food above the vocal folds and aspiration. Nasal regurgitation of food or liquid is caused by insufficient velopharyngeal closure but occurs in only a few NMDs, which underlines the different involvement of oral muscles in the various NMDs.
During a VFSS, solid food typically gives rise to more problems than does thin liquid [5, 47]. In some cases, there is delayed initiation of swallowing, which suggests central nervous system involvement. Post-swallow residue and aspiration in combination with weak coughing and restrictive pulmonary function can lead to chest infections [52, 77], which is important to consider in children with NMD, presenting with pneumonia.
Reduced pharyngeal pressure during swallowing and insufficient opening of the upper esophageal sphincter, often because of weakness of the submental muscle group, hampers transport through the sphincter. This leads to post-swallow residue, potentially leading to indirect aspiration [77].
Problems in the (upper) esophageal phase
Post-swallow residue above the upper esophageal sphincter (which can be a pharyngeal or esophageal problem), esophageal dysmotility, and gastroesophageal reflux (GER) are common problems. Esophageal motor disorders are caused by weakness of the esophageal musculature [78], which might lead to ineffective peristalsis with retention of material in the esophagus after swallowing. In turn, the presence of residue can lead to regurgitation of material from the esophagus back into the pharynx, with the risk of aspiration of the regurgitated material [79]. As a result of neuromuscular incoordination and weakness, the antireflux function of the lower esophageal sphincter is reduced, which together with esophageal dysmotility leads to GER [78].
(c) Disease progression
Children with a nonprogressive NMD (such as some forms of congenital myopathy) often do not gain experience with feeding in the neonatal period. Oral feeding has to be introduced step by step, taking into account possible pharyngeal dysphagia [80]. Careful introduction of small amounts of liquid and food is important to monitor the safety of swallowing and to observe the development of oral skills. In our clinical experience, these children often receive their nutrition by means of oral and tube feeding [81].
Some NMDs are slowly progressive and, as a consequence, feeding and swallowing problems develop insidiously, which necessitates close professional monitoring from an early stage. Moreover, the involvement of oral muscles in different progressive NMDs is disease specific, resulting in different signs and symptoms of dysphagia. For example, patients with Duchenne muscular dystrophy, spinal muscular atrophy II/III, or childhood-onset myotonic dystrophy will not experience problems in the neonatal period, but may gradually develop chewing problems or choking, even in early stages of their disease.
(d) Bulbar muscle involvement
From Table 3 it is clear that the oral and pharyngeal muscles involved in feeding and swallowing are affected differently in the different NMDs. In some diseases the perioral and masticatory muscles are weak, which may affect facial growth and jaw mobility and may cause malocclusion. Masticatory muscle involvement will lead to chewing problems or, in some NMDs, to reduced mouth opening. Tongue weakness hampers adequate transport of food from the oral cavity to the pharyngeal area. Palatal involvement induces nasal regurgitation during swallowing. Involvement of the submental muscles and pharyngeal muscles leads to weak swallowing and to pharyngeal residue after swallowing. In addition, the oral muscles are not affected equally or at the same time in progressive NMDs [41]. Changes in the fine coordination of the activity of various oral muscles will adversely affect mastication, food transport, and swallowing.
RECOMMENDATIONS
On the basis of current knowledge and our clinical experience (expert opinion), we can formulate recommendations for the evaluation and management of dysphagia in children with NMDs.
Comprehensive swallowing assessment
The wide variety of signs and symptoms of dysphagia in NMD underlines the importance of a comprehensive feeding and swallowing assessment by a speech and language therapist (SLT) in infants and children with NMD presenting with dysphagia. Infants and children with an NMD show a wide range of intellectual abilities, and many children with intellectual impairment have feeding and swallowing problems as a result of the complex interactions between anatomical, medical, physiological, and behavioral factors [74]. These factors have to be taken into account during the assessment.
The underlying mechanisms of dysphagia have to be investigated carefully, focusing on the affected muscles and disturbances of the biomechanical events of swallowing. Oral muscle involvement can be monitored by muscle ultrasound, a promising and non-invasive tool, because muscle abnormalities may explain the biomechanical problems [82, 83]. Investigation with VSSS or FEES is advised if there is concern about safe swallowing. Essential differences between children with central and peripheral neurologic disorders need to be taken into account.
Use of a structured questionnaire
Children with a slowly progressive NMD rarely spontaneously complain about chewing problems or the feeling that food is sticking in their throat, because they may adapt their feeding and swallowing habits to their reduced oral strength without realizing that they are doing so. This phenomenon has also been reported in adults with a progressive neuromuscular disorder [84]. It will lead to compensatory actions (either adequate or inadequate) with possible positive or adverse side effects [85]. Furthermore, patients and their parents are not always aware of the risks of dysphagia and possible solutions for the problem. They should be asked about mealtime duration (participation level) and the problems experienced (activity level). Chen et al. (2012) provided a semi-structured questionnaire including specific questions on feeding and swallowing ability, time needed to complete a meal, current motor function status, and current respiratory status [22]. They also paid attention to changing feeding and swallowing habits. Use of a structured questionnaire may unravel these changes, since sometimes individuals may subconsciously choose food consistencies that are easier to eat, which may mask dysphagia even in the early stages of an NMD [39, 41].
Thickening liquids
The primary aim in the rehabilitation of feeding and swallowing disorders is to achieve safety, i.e., to prevent choking and aspiration pneumonia. In many, but not all (e.g., spinal muscular atrophy I and hereditary sensory and autonomic neuropathy types 1 and II [22, 27]) NMDs, children find it more difficult to cope with thick liquid and solid food than with thin liquids. In contrast to children with cerebral palsy, children with an NMD may experience more problems with post-swallow residue when drinking thickened liquids. The consistency of food/drink can best be determined on the basis of the results of a swallow study. Disease-specific recommendations are important, such as clearing pharyngeal residue by drinking water during and after meals. Furthermore, regular reassessment is necessary to evaluate disease progression or regression and the effects of interventions. Silent, sometimes life-threatening, aspiration can occur as a result of a weak cough and post-swallow residue. We recommend that airstacking or other lung volume recruiting therapies should not be used directly after a meal because of the risk of inhalation of pharyngeal residue. In the case of recurrent (aspiration) pneumonia, prophylactic antibiotic therapy should be considered in combination with non-oral feeding.
Food adaptation
Mastication problems are often reported as a result of weakness of the masticatory muscles and aberrations in masticatory performance, together with compromised dentition. In the case of mastication problems, softer foods and smaller pieces of food are recommended. These dietary changes should be monitored carefully, and patients should be seen by a dietician, to ensure that they have an adequate intake of nutrients, such as iron and fiber [86].
Training
The multifactorial feeding problems call for intensive collaboration between pediatric neurologist, SLT, rehabilitation physician, special dentist, and dietician, preferably in a multidisciplinary team. There is evidence that training is beneficial. For example, adaptation of the head posture of children with spinal muscular atrophy type II improves the efficiency of swallowing [5]. Beside adapting the consistency and portion size of food, task-specific training should be considered. Rehabilitation programs have shown task-related training [87] and swallowing training [88] to be effective in adults. Moreover, studies of motor function in children with neuromuscular disorders, such as Duchenne muscular dystrophy, have shown that ‘no use is disuse’ [89]. For example, confinement to a wheelchair was found to accelerate the loss of arm function of boys with Duchenne muscular dystrophy. Jansen et al. (2013) showed that assisted bicycle training of the legs and arms might slow the deterioration due to disuse [89]. Also a pilot study of boys and young adults with Duchenne muscular dystrophy showed that use of sugar-free chewing gum improved mastication [90]. These promising outcomes have to be studied over a longer period and in other groups of NMD.
Tube feeding
In the case of sucking and swallowing problems in the neonatal period, a nasogastric tube is used for feeding, to supplement the diet if the oral calorie intake is insufficient. If the sucking and swallowing difficulties persist for longer, it is often decided to place a gastrostomy. Gastrostomy placement may improve clinical outcomes and quality of life in children with progressive NMDs, who develop feeding and swallowing disorders later [81]. In a cohort of 36 children with NMD who underwent gastrostomy placement, 26 had a reduced frequency of chest infections [91]. However, no international guidelines are yet available for the indications for, and timing of, gastrostomy placement. DiVito and Meyers recommended that a feeding tube be placed if (a) the child aspirates on the VFSS, (b) mealtimes are always longer than 30 minutes, (c) the child is unable to meet nutritional needs for growth and development, (d) there is weight loss or lack of weight gain for 3 months, or (e) there is a decrease of 2 or more weight or height percentiles [92].
Drooling treatment
Drooling of saliva is reported in some NMDs, but especially in myotonic dystrophy, congenital myopathy, and Pompe disease. While the evaluation and treatment of drooling in children with cerebral palsy have been extensively studied [93], there is relatively little information about drooling in children with NMDs. Lip strengthening training in children with myotonic dystrophy was found to increase lip force and lip force endurance, but did not influence drooling [94]. Results from future studies on saliva control in NMDs have to be awaited.
Malocclusion treatment
Malocclusion in combination with oral muscle weakness, especially of the masseter muscles, may lead to open mouth posture and mastication problems. Various types of malocclusion occur in the various NMDs. For example, myotonic dystrophy is often accompanied by anterior open bite and posterior crossbite, with a large overjet (class II malocclusion), and distal occlusion [95]. In contrast, in Duchenne muscular dystrophy, anterior and posterior open bite and anterior crossbite (class III malocclusion) are reported [95]. There is a lack of clear information about the short- and long-term results of orthodontic treatment for malocclusion in NMD. For the time being, malocclusion problems require intensive collaboration between specialized dentists and specialists in feeding and swallowing problems in NMD. At the current time, we cannot make any recommendations, and studies about this topic are urgently needed.
CONCLUSIONS
The differences in the pathophysiology of feeding and swallowing problems necessitate disease-specific recommendations. In turn, this emphasizes the necessity of studying the neurophysiologic mechanisms of dysphagia in different types of childhood NMD. International guidelines for the treatment of children with NMDs, such as spinal muscular atrophy or congenital myasthenic syndrome, should be adapted in the light of available information. This will lead to tailored recommendations for children with feeding and swallowing disorders as a result of an NMD.
CONFLICT OF INTEREST STATEMENT
The authors have no conflict of interest to report.
