This paper addresses the need for a tool that makes use of expert opinion to determine whether individual public administration services should be outsourced. It begins by analyzing the specific characteristics of the public sector in relation to outsourcing and continues with a description of the main services, both mandatory and otherwise, provided by a local corporation, classifying them according to whether they are aimed at people, the territory or infrastructure. Fuzzy math tools are then used, by means of an endecadarian scale, to allow diverse experts to state the degree to which they agree on the possible outsourcing of a public service. In order to facilitate their decision-making, experts can offer a confidence interval of that degree. From the different intervals obtained through this process, a decision method is presented that uses the fuzzy logic tool “experton” as a basis. Several examples clarify and exemplify the method.
Alfaro-GarciaV.G., Gil-LafuenteA.M. and Alfaro CalderonG.G., A fuzzy methodology for innovation management measurement, Kybernetes46(1) (2017), 50–66.
2.
Barcellos de PaulaL. and Gil-LafuenteA.M., Algorithm applied in corporate sustainability, Kybernetes (2018), DOI: 10.1108/K-02-2018-0077
3.
ChavezR., González-SantoyoF., FloresB. and FloresJ.J., Second-order changes on personal assignment under uncertainty. Scientific Methods for the Treatment of Uncertainty in Social Sciences, Advances in Intelligent Systems and Computing377 (2015), 115–128.
4.
ChristensenT., Smart Policy?, The Oxford handbook of public policy. Oxford University Press, 2006, 77-102.
5.
Corominas-CollD., Ferrer-ComalatJ.C., Linares-MustarósS. and BertranX., A study of the strong Allee effect with fuzzy parameters for its application in economics, Kybernetes46(1) (2017), 191–206.
6.
CouturierA. and FioleauB., Expertons and management decision-making criteria interdependence and implications valuation, Fuzzy Economic Review1(1) (1996), 31–46.
7.
EspinoT.F. and PadrónV., ¿Qué actividades deberían externalizar las empresas? Una aproximación bajo la perspectiva de recursos y capacidades,n y Economía de la Empresa, Revista Investigaciones Europeas de Dirección10(1) (2004), 209–230.
8.
HirotaK., Concepts of probabilistic sets, Fuzzy Sets and Systems5 (1981), 31–46.
9.
HirotaK. and PedryczW., Analysis and synthesis of fuzzy systems by the use of probabilistic sets, Fuzzy Sets and Systems10 (1983), 1–13.
10.
HoferC. and SchendelD., Strategy Formulation: Analytical Concepts, Ed. West Group, 2005.
11.
JohanssonT. and SiverboS., Supplier Competition and Supplier Control In Public Sector Outsourcing: Complements, Substitutes or Neither? 9th International Conference on Accounting, Auditing and Management in Public Sector Reforms, 2016.
12.
JohnstonJ.M. and GirthA.M., Government contracts and “managing the market” exploring the costs of strategic management responses to weak vendor competition, Administration & Society44 (2012), 3–29.
13.
KaufmannA., Les expertons, Ed. Hermes, 1987.
14.
KaufmannA., Theory of expertons and fuzzy-logic, Fuzzy Sets and Systems28(3) (1988), 295–304.
15.
KaufmannA. and Gil-AlujaJ., Introducción de la teoría de los subconjuntos borrosos a la gestión de las empresas, Milladoiro, 1986.
16.
KaufmannA. and Gil-AlujaJ., Técnicas operativas de gestión para el tratamiento de la incertidumbre. Hispano Europea, 1987.
17.
KaufmannA. and Gil-AlujaJ., Técnicas especiales para la gestión de expertos, Milladoiro, 1993.
18.
Ferrer-ComalatJ.C., Linares-MustarósS. and Corominas-CollD., A formalization of the theory of expertons. Theoretical foundations, properties and development of software for its calculation, Fuzzy Economic Review21(1) (2016), 23–39.
19.
Ferrer-ComalatJ.C., Linares-MustarósS. and Corominas-CollD., A model for optimal investment project using fuzzy probability, Economic Computation and Economic Cybernetics Studies and Research50(4) (2016), 187–203.
20.
Ferrer-ComalatJ.C., Linares-MustarósS. and Corominas-CollD., A generalization of the theory of expertons, International Journal of Uncertainty, Fuzziness and Knowledge-Based Systems26(Supplement 1) (2018), 121–13.
21.
HeilpernS., The expected value of a fuzzy number, Fuzzy Sets and Systems47 (1992), 81–86.
22.
HeilpernS., Using fuzzy data analysis in economy, Proceedings II Meeting SIGEFI (1995), 315–326.
23.
JaileJ.M., Ferrer-ComalatJ.C and Linares-MustarósS., Determining the influence variables in the pork price, based on expert systems, Scientific Methods for the Treatment of Uncertainty in Social Sciences, Advances in Intelligent Systems and Computing377 (2015), 81–92.
24.
Linares-MustarósS., Ferrer-ComalatJ.C. and CassúE., The assessment of cash flow forecasting, Kybernetes42(5) (2013), 720–735.
25.
Linares-MustarósS., MerigóJ.M. and Ferrer-ComalatJ.C., Processing extreme values in sales forecasting, Cybernetics and Systems46(3-4) (2015), 207–229.
26.
Linares-MustarósS., Ferrer-ComalatJ.C., Corominas-CollD. and MerigóJ.M., The ordered weighted average in the theory of expertons, International Journal of Intelligent Systems34(3) (2019), 345–365.
27.
LopezE. and MendañaC., The aggregation linguistic information for decision making based on expertons and 2-tuples, Fuzzy Economic Review8(2) (2003), 39–53.
28.
MasJ., Gestión privada de servicios públicos: La externalización (outsourcing) en la administración pública. V Congreso Internacional del CLAD, 2000.
29.
MerigóJ.M., Gil-LafuenteA.M. and BarcellosL., Uncertain induced generalized aggregation operators and its application in the theory of expertons, Fuzzy Economic Review15(2) (2010), 25–42.
30.
MerigóJ.M., CasanovasM. and YangJ.B., Group decision making with expertons and uncertain generalized probabilistic weighted aggregation operators, European Journal of Operational Research235(1) (2014), 215–224.
31.
Mulet-FortezaC., HorrachP., SociasA. and MerigoJ.M., The forgotten effects: An appliction in the social economy of companies of the Balearic Islands, Economic Computation & Economic Cybernetics Studies and Research52(3) (2018), 147–160.
32.
RussellB., Vagueness, The Australasian Journal of Psychology and Philosophy1(2) (1923), 84–92.
33.
SirbiladzeG., KhutsishviliI. and GhvaberidzeB., Multistage decision-making fuzzy methodology for optimal investments based on experts’ evaluations, European Journal of Operational Research232(1) (2014), 169–177.
34.
ViñasJ., Causas para externalizar servicios en la Administración pública, Revista Presupuesto y Gasto Público66 (2012), 167–182.
35.
WhiteR. and JamesB., Manual del outsourcing. Ediciones Gestión 2000, 2000.
36.
Yepes-BaldoM., Boria-ReverterS., RomeoM. and TorresA., Expertons and uncertain averaging operators versus correlational approaches: A case study on corporate social responsibility and effectiveness, Kybernetes46(1) (2017), 38–49.
37.
ZadehL.A., Fuzzy sets, Information and Control8(3) (1965), 338–335.
