Abstract
BACKGROUND:
Kinesio Tape (KT) is one of the most common taping methods used to prevent injuries, rehabilitate injured athletes, and improve muscle performance. But there are no studies investigating the acute effect of reverse taping on the isokinetic muscle strength.
OBJECTIVE:
To investigate the effects of KT applied to quadriceps (Q) and hamstring (H) muscles on knee extension (Ex) and flexion (Flx) strength, H/Q ratio, and fatigue index (FI).
METHODS:
In total, 17 healthy male subjects with a history of regular physical activity for at least 3 years participated in the study voluntarily. The muscle facilitation and muscle inhibition techniques of KT were applied in reverse direction to the Q and H muscles, and concentric/concentric isokinetic Ex and Flx strengths of the knee were measured at 60, 180, and 240
RESULTS:
As for the strength, T2 showed higher scores compared to T1 and T3 at all angular velocities (
CONCLUSIONS:
Simultaneous facilitation and inhibition, applied to Q and H, respectively, had a positive effect on both the Ex and Flx strengths and also on H/Q ratio at high angular velocities (180
Introduction
Kinesio Tape (KT), developed by Kase in 1973, is one of the most common taping methods used to prevent sports injuries, rehabilitate injured athletes, and improve muscle performance [37, 43]. Currently, KT is being intensively used by athletes, physiotherapists, and researchers, and researchers have shown that KT affects the inflammation by increasing blood and lymph circulation, and thereby, stimulates movement through intense contraction in the muscle, reduces pain via decreasing the pressure on subcutaneous nociceptors, and facilitates movement in joint and muscle functions by muscle alignment and activation methods [14, 28, 42, 48]. KT has a structure that can have a high degree of tension (up to 50%–75% of its original length) based on the contraction and direction of movement of the muscle group to which it is applied, and two types of applications of KT techniques have been reported for its effect on muscle strength [22, 39]. One of these is the “muscle facilitation” technique, which is applied to the insertion of the muscle from its origin with a KT tension of 50%–75%, increasing the contraction of the muscle. Second is the “muscle inhibition” technique, which is applied to the origin of the muscle from its insertion with a KT tension of 15–25%, decreasing the contraction of the muscle. Although researchers have studied the effects of KT on muscle strength and endurance with different muscle and experimental groups [3, 19, 30, 31, 32, 39, 41, 46, 48], there is still no consensus on whether KT has positive effects in terms of performance [48]. This has led to a lack of clear scientific consensus.
Recently, different applications of KT to Q and H muscle groups have been reported [10, 14, 28, 30, 31, 37, 43, 46]. It emerges that in spite of a large number of studies dealing with the acute and chronic effects of KT on Q and H using different taping methods [14, 36, 43, 48], there are no studies investigating the acute effect of reverse taping on the isokinetic strength of these muscles.
Thus the aim of our study was to investigate the effects of KT facilitation and inhibition techniques applied to the vastus medialis (VM) and biceps femoris (BF) and semimembranosus (SM) on the isokinetic knee strength, H/Q ratio, and fatigue index (FI). It was hypothesized that the facilitation method applied to Q and H muscles would positively affect isokinetic knee strength, and the inhibition technique applied to the antagonist of the muscle to which facilitation was applied would increase the strength of these muscle groups.
Method
Subjects
In total, 17 healthy male subjects (mean age, 20.47 years; mean height, 1.77 m; and mean weight, 75.35 kg) with a history of regular physical activity for at least 3 years participated in the study voluntarily. Inclusion criteria were regular physical activity for at least 3 years and no previous knee injuries.
Descriptive parameters of subjects (
17)
Descriptive parameters of subjects (
This study was designed as a randomized controlled cross-experimental trial. With this design, the effect of KT on isokinetic knee extension (Ex) and flexion (Flx) strength was investigated by muscle facilitation and muscle inhibition techniques via reverse taping. The effect of KT on H/Q ratios was also investigated through the peak moments obtained. Subjects visited the laboratory four times at 24-hour intervals.
During the first visit, the aim of the study was explained to all subjects, subjects were informed about the test protocols to be applied, and the written informed consent was obtained from all subjects. Height, weight, and body mass index (BMI) measurements were obtained, and then pilot trial was performed on all subjects to measure knee Ex and Flx strength at concentric/concentric contraction at specific angular velocities (60
Warm-up procedure
Before the tests, the subjects undertook 5 minutes of low intensity aerobic run and 10 minutes of dynamic and static stretching of lower extremity muscles for general warm-up [2].
Determination of descriptive information
A Gaia 359 Plus Body Pass analyzer was used to record the height, weight, and BMI parameters of the subjects. Before the measurements, the device was introduced to all the subjects and they were asked to stay as quiet and as immobile as possible during the test. An individual demonstrated the test with the analyzer to help the subjects understand it. The subjects stood on the analyzer with bare feet, wearing a t-shirt and shorts, and their height (cm), weight (kg), and BMI (kg/m
Determination of isokinetic knee strength
Isokinetic knee strength was determined via peak moment parameter [26, 35]. Before isokinetic knee strength, isokinetic dynamometer was calibrated as advised by CSMI (2003). Subject’s moments for knee extension and flexion were determined as 60
Subjects were asked to exert five maximum efforts and the highest values displayed per angular speed were accepted as peak moment values. To protect them from injuries, three practice repetitions of all angular speeds were made before the test, and the test was started after 30 seconds of rest. Each subject was informed about basic push/pull and the number of remaining repetitions, and received loud verbal encouragement were given continuously to help the peak moment (PM) values of the subjects to be the highest level during testing [9]. At all angular speeds, PM values were recorded in Newton meter (Nm).
Application of KT
In order to investigate the effects of the muscle facilitation and muscle inhibition techniques of KT on isokinetic knee Ex and Flx strengths, two different taping methods were applied and isokinetic knee strengths were measured immediately after each taping. In the first application method, muscle facilitation of KT was applied on the VM from its origin to its insertion at high tension (50%–75%), muscle inhibition of KT was applied on the BF and SM from their insertion to their origin at low tension (25%), and isokinetic knee-strength measurements were performed. In the second application method, muscle facilitation of KT was applied on the BF and SM from their origin to their insertion at high tension (50%–75%), muscle inhibition of KT was applied on the VM from its insertion to its origin at low tension (25%), and isokinetic knee-strength measurements were performed. Prior to the application of KT, the Q and H regions of the subjects were shaven and cleaned, and the application was performed in the most appropriate way [22, 39].
Statistical analysis
The SPSS 22.0 version was used for statistical analyses. The data were presented as minimum, maximum, mean, standard deviation, standard error, 95% confidence interval and partial eta (effect size). Shapiro-Wilk test was used to check normality of the data. Repeated measures one-way ANOVA and LSD test were used to analyze the differences between trials. For statistical results, a
Analysis of isokinetic knee strength parameters of subjects between trials
Analysis of isokinetic knee strength parameters of subjects between trials
Analysis of H/Q ratios of subjects between trials
Analysis of fatigue index of subjects between trials
SD standard deviation; SE standard error; CI confidence of interval; LB lower bound; UB upper bound.
When the isokinetic knee strengths between trials were examined statistically, it was found that T2 showed higher results compared to T1 and T3 at all angular velocities (
When the H/Q ratios between the trials were examined statistically, T2 was found to have higher ratios compared to T1 at 180
Mean FI values obtained during the isokinetic knee Ex and Flx strength measurements at 60, 180, and 240
Discussion
Two major findings emerge from this study: (1) the application of KT in T2 increased isokinetic knee strength both in the Ex and Flx phases at all angular velocities; (2) the application of KT in T2 increased H/Q ratio at 180 and 240
However, the muscle inhibition of KT on VM and muscle facilitation on BF and SM in T3 did not have any effect on the isokinetic knee Ex and Flx strengths (
We believe that the isokinetic strength increases observed in both the Ex and Flx phases in T2 measurements were due to muscle facilitation technique applied to the VM to increase muscle strength in the Ex phase and also due to the muscle inhibition technique applied to BF and SM muscles in H to increase muscle strength in the Flx phase. In our study, the effect of KT reverse taping on the increase of strength was thought to be due to increased stimulation of motor unit with the stimulation of both central and peripheral nervous system by cutaneous afferent applications and increased stimulation of motor cortex resulting in increased muscle activation, as stated by Ridding et al. [34]. In addition, researchers demonstrated that motor units were stimulated more quickly and easily by reducing the neural threshold with cutaneous applications [21]. Hsu et al. [17] reported that the increase in muscle activation could increase the tension in the taped muscle and increase muscle reflex, and thereby, muscle activation. However, some researchers argued that cutaneous application of KT may increase muscle activity by altering motor neuron stimulation, but was not a potent stimulant to affect strength [43]. In the current study it was thought that the resulting strength increase by the reverse application of KT affected muscle strength by creating different tensions in Q and H muscle groups.
Asymmetric strength ratio and strength balance may play some role in predisposition to injuries [25]. The asymmetric force for the lower extremity can be defined as the inability of Q and H muscles in both the right and left sides to produce a self-balancing, mutual moment in similar contraction types [23]. In our study, H/Q ratio differences between the application of KT in T2 and T1 were statistically significant (
In our study, it was found that the FI levels of the isokinetic knee Ex and Flx strength tests performed at 3 all velocities did not show any difference between the trials (
Conclusion
The current results showed that muscle facilitation applied to the VM simultaneously with inhibition applied to BF and SM may have a positive effect on both the Ex and Flx strengths and the H/Q ratio in healthy individuals at high angular velocities (180
Footnotes
Conflict of interest
None to report.
