Engaging in environmental stewardship is critical for sustainability. Understanding individual differences and engagement is an important gap in present scholarship and addressing it is necessary to understand individual factors that relate to the types of activities engaged in, motivations and barriers to environmental stewardship. We surveyed 637 Canadian and American adults via Amazon Mechanical Turk, querying a range of demographic, psychological and environmental perceptions factors as well as motivations and barriers to stewardship activities. Respondents were ultimately grouped into Non-Stewards, Home-Oriented Stewards and Community-Oriented Stewards. Few differences were found among these groups. However, Home-Oriented Stewards and Community-Oriented Stewards exhibited very different initial and ongoing motivations to engage in environmental stewardship. Accordingly, we identify stewardship motivations as a potential leverage point and as one of several promising avenues for future research related to enhancing engagement in environmental stewardship for the sustainability of the planet.
AnderssonE., EnqvistJ. and TengöM.. 2017. ‘Stewardship in urban landscapes’. In BielingC. and PlieningerT. (eds), The Science and Practice of Landscape Stewardship, pp. 222–239. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
2.
AsahS.T. and BlahnaD.J.. 2012. ‘Motivational functionalism and urban conservation stewardship: implications for volunteer involvement’. Conservation Letters5 (6): 470–477. Crossref.
3.
AsahS.T., and BlahnaD.J.D.J.2013. ‘Practical implications of understanding the influence of motivations on commitment to voluntary urban conservation stewardship’. Conservation Biology27 (4): 866–875. Crossref.
4.
AsahS.T., LenentineM.M. and BlahnaD.J.. 2014. ‘Benefits of urban landscape eco-volunteerism: Mixed methods segmentation analysis and implications for volunteer retention’. Landscape and Urban Planning123: 108–113. Crossref.
5.
AttfieldR.1999. The Ethics of the Global Environment. Edinburgh: Edinburgh University Press.
6.
BennettN.J., WhittyT.S., FinkbeinerE., PittmanJ., BassettH., GelcichS. and AllisonE.H.. 2018. ‘Environmental stewardship: a conceptual review and analytical framework’. Environmental Management61: 597–614. Crossref.
7.
BerenguerJ.2007. ‘The effect of empathy in proenvironmental attitudes and behaviours’. Environment and Behavior39 (2): 269–283. Crossref.
8.
BerkesF., DoubledayN.C. and CummingG.S.. 2012. ‘Aldo Leopold's land health from a resilience point of view: self-renewal capacity of social–ecological systems’. EcoHealth9 (3): 278–287. Crossref.
9.
BerryR.J. (ed). 2006. Environmental Stewardship (vol. 56). New York, NY: T&T Clark.
10.
BielingC. and PlieningerT. (eds). 2017. The Science and Practice of Landscape Stewardship. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
11.
BliucA.M., McGartyC., ThomasE.F., LalaG., BerndsenM. and MisajonR.. 2015. ‘Public division about climate change rooted in conflicting socio-political identities’. Nature Climate Change5 (3): 226. Crossref.
12.
BramstonP., PrettyG. and ZammitC.. 2011. ‘Assessing environmental stewardship motivation’. Environment and Behavior43 (6): 776–788. Crossref.
13.
BrownK., AdgerW.N., Devine-WrightP., AnderiesJ.M., BarrS., BousquetF., BulterC., EvansL., MarshallN. and QuinnT.. 2019. ‘Empathy, place and identity interactions for sustainability’. Global Environmental Change56: 11–17. Crossref.
14.
CaliendoM., Cobb-ClarkD. and UhlendorffA.. 2015. ‘Locus of control and job search strategies’. The Review of Economics and Statistics97: 88–103. Crossref.
15.
ChapinF.S., PickettS. T., PowerM.E., CollinsS.L., BaronJ.S., InouyeD.W., and TurnerM.G.. 2015. ‘Earth stewardship: an initiative by the Ecological Society of America to foster engagement to sustain planet Earth’. In RozziR., ChapinF.S.III, CallicottJ.B., PickettS., PowerM.E., ArmestoJ.J. and MayR.H.Jr. (eds), Earth Stewardship, pp. 173–194. Switzerland: Springer International Publishing.
16.
ChapinF.S., PowerM.E., PickettS.T., FreitagA., ReynoldsJ.A., JacksonR.B., LodgeD.M., DukeC., CollinsS.L. and BartuskaA.G.. 2011. ‘Earth stewardship: science for action to sustain the human-earth system’. Ecosphere2 (8): 1–20. Crossref.
17.
ChenG., GullyS.M. and EdenD.. 2001. ‘Validation of a new general self-efficacy scale’. Organizational Research Methods4 (1): 62–83. Crossref.
18.
DonnellanM.B., OswaldF.L., BairdB.M. and LucasR.E.. 2006. ‘The mini-IPIP scales: tiny-yet-effective measures of the Big Five factors of personality’. Psychological Assessment18 (2): 192–203. Crossref.
19.
DresnerM., HandelmanC., BraunS. and Rollwagen-BollensG.. 2015. ‘Environmental identity, pro-environmental behaviors, and civic engagement of volunteer stewards in Portland area parks’. Environmental Education Research21 (7): 991–1010. Crossref.
20.
DunlapR.E. and McCrightA.M.. 2008. ‘A widening gap: Republican and Democratic views on climate change’. Environment: Science and Policy for Sustainable Development50 (5): 26–35. Crossref.
21.
EnqvistJ.P., WestS., MastersonV.A., HaiderL.J., SvedinU. and TengöM.. 2018. ‘Stewardship as a boundary object for sustainability research: linking care, knowledge and agency’. Landscape and Urban Planning179: 17–37. Crossref.
22.
EnqvistJ.P., CampbellL.K., StedmanR.C. and SvendsenE. S.. 2019. ‘Place meanings on the urban waterfront: a typology of stewardships’. Sustainability Science14 (3): 589–605. Crossref.
23.
EnzlerH.B. and DiekmannA.. 2019. ‘All talk and no action? An analysis of environmental concern, income and greenhouse gas emissions in Switzerland’. Energy Research & Social Science51: 12–19. Crossref.
24.
EysenckS.B., EastingG. and PearsonP.R.. 1984. ‘Age norms for impulsiveness, venturesomeness and empathy in children’. Personality and Individual Differences5: 315–321. Crossref.
25.
FeinbergM. and WillerR.. 2012. ‘The moral roots of environmental attitudes’. Psychological Science24: 56–62. Crossref.
26.
FisherD.R., CampbellL.K. and SvendsenE.S.. 2012. ‘The organisational structure of urban environmental stewardship’. Environmental Politics21(1): 26–48. Crossref.
27.
FolkeC., JanssonÅ., RockströmJ., OlssonP., CarpenterS.R., ChapinF.S., Anne-SophieC., DailyG., DanellK. and WestleyF.. 2011. ‘Reconnecting to the biosphere’. Ambio40 (7): 719. Crossref.
28.
FolkeC., BiggsR., NorströmA.V., ReyersB. and RockströmJ.. 2016. ‘Social-ecological resilience and biosphere-based sustainability science’. Ecology and Society21 (3): 41. Crossref.
29.
ForsythD.R., VugtM., SchleinG. and StoryP.A.. 2015. ‘Identity and sustainability: localized sense of community increases environmental engagement’. Analyses of Social Issues and Public Policy15: 233–252. Crossref.
30.
GaterslebenB., StegL. and VlekC.. 2002. ‘Measurement and determinants of environmentally significant consumer behavior’. Environment and Behavior34 (3): 335–362. Crossref.
31.
GiffordR.2011. ‘The dragons of inaction: psychological barriers that limit climate change mitigation and adaptation’. American Psychologist66 (4): 290–302. Crossref.
32.
GiffordR. and NilssonA.. 2014. ‘Personal and social factors that influence pro-environmental concern and behaviour: a review’. International Journal of Psychology49 (3): 141–157. Crossref.
33.
GiffordR., ScannellL., KormosC., SmolovaL., BielA., BoncuS., CorralV., GüntherfH., HanyuK. and KaiserF.G.. 2009. ‘Temporal pessimism and spatial optimism in environmental assessments: an 18-nation study’. Journal of Environmental Psychology29 (1): 1–12. Crossref.
34.
GoltsmanS., KellyL., McKayS., AlgaraP. and WightL.. 2009. ‘Raising “free range kids”: creating neighborhood parks that promote environmental stewardship’. Journal of Green Building4 (2): 90–106. Crossref.
35.
HirshJ.B.2010. ‘Personality and environmental concern’. Journal of Environmental Psychology30 (2): 245–248. Crossref.
36.
HodgeI. and ReaderM.. 2010. ‘The introduction of entry level stewardship in England: extension or dilution in agri-environment policy?’ Land Use Policy27 (2): 270–282. Crossref.
37.
Huddart KennedyE., KrahnH. and KrogmanN.T.. 2015. ‘Are we counting what counts? A closer look at environmental concern, pro-environmental behaviour, and carbon footprint’. Local Environment20 (2): 220–236. Crossref.
38.
KollmussA. and AgyemanJ.. 2002. ‘Mind the gap: Why do people act environmentally and what are the barriers to pro-environmental behavior?’ Environmental Education Research8 (3): 239–260. Crossref.
39.
LaneR. and WatsonM.. 2012. ‘Stewardship of things: the radical potential of product stewardship for re-framing responsibilities and relationships to products and materials’. Geoforum43: 1254–1265. Crossref.
40.
LarsonL.R., StedmanR.C., CooperC.B. and DeckerD.J.. 2015. ‘Understanding the multi-dimensional structure of pro-environmental behavior’. Journal of Environmental Psychology43: 112–124. http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.jenvp.2015.06.004.
41.
LawrenceG., RichardsC.A. and CheshireL.. 2004. ‘The environmental enigma: Why do producers professing stewardship continue to practice poor natural resource management?’ Journal of Environmental Policy & Planning6 (3–4): 251–270. Crossref.
42.
LuH. and SchuldtJ.P.. 2015. ‘Exploring the role of incidental emotions in support for climate change policy’. Climatic Change131 (4): 719–726. Crossref.
43.
MathevetR., BousquetF. and RaymondC.M.. 2018. ‘The concept of stewardship in sustainability science and conservation biology’. Biological Conservation217: 363–370. Crossref.
44.
McCrightA.M. and DunlapR.E.. 2011. ‘Cool dudes: the denial of climate change among conservative white males in the United States’. Global Environmental Change21 (4): 1163–1172. Crossref.
45.
MeadowsD.1999. Leverage Points: Places to Intervene in a System. Ann Arbor, MI: The Sustainability Institute.
46.
MilfontT.L. and SibleyC.G.. 2012. ‘The big five personality traits and environmental engagement: associations at the individual and societal level’. Journal of Environmental Psychology32 (2): 187–195. Crossref.
47.
MorrisonM., DuncanR. and PartonK.. 2015. ‘Religion does matter for climate change attitudes and behavior’. PloS One10 (8): e0134868. Crossref.
48.
MoserS., and KleinhückelkottenS.. 2018. ‘Good intents, but low impacts: diverging importance of motivational and socioeconomic determinants explaining pro-environmental behavior, energy use, and carbon footprint’. Environment and Behavior50 (6): 626–656. Crossref.
49.
MullinixK J., LeeperT.J., DruckmanJ.N. and FreeseJ.. 2016. ‘The generalizability of survey experiments’. Journal of Experimental Political Science2 (2): 109–138. Crossref.
50.
OregS.2003. ‘Resistance to change: developing an individual differences measure’. Journal of Applied Psychology88 (4): 680–693. Crossref.
51.
PalmerC.2006. ‘Stewardship: a case study in environmental ethics’. In BerryR.J. (ed), Environmental Stewardship, pp. 63–75. New York, New York: T&T Clark.
52.
PaolacciG. and ChandlerJ.. 2014. ‘Inside the Turk: understanding Mechanical Turk as a participant pool’. Current Directions in Psychological Science23 (3): 184–188. Crossref.
53.
Pérez-RamírezM., CastrejónM., GutiérrezN.L. and DefeoO.. 2016. ‘The Marine Stewardship Council certification in Latin America and the Caribbean: a review of experiences, potentials and pitfalls’. Fisheries Research182: 50–58. Crossref.
54.
PlummerR., SpiersA., SummerR. and FitzGibbonJ.. 2008. ‘The contributions of stewardship to managing agro-ecosystem environments’. Journal of Sustainable Agriculture31 (3): 55–84. Crossref.
55.
PoortingaW., SpenceA., WhitmarshL., CapstickS. and PidgeonN.F.. 2011. ‘Uncertain climate: an investigation into public skepticism about anthropogenic climate change’. Global Environmental Change21 (3): 1015–1024. Crossref.
56.
Ram-BidesiV.2015. ‘Recognizing the role of women in supporting marine stewardship in the Pacific Islands’. Marine Policy59: 1–8. Crossref.
57.
RaymondC.M., BielingC., FagerholmN., Martin-LopezB. and PlieningerT.. 2016. ‘The farmer as a landscape steward: comparing local understandings of landscape stewardship, landscape values, and land management actions’. Ambio45 (2): 173–184. Crossref.
58.
RyanR.L., KaplanR. and GreseR.E.. 2001. ‘Predicting volunteer commitment in environmental stewardship programmes’. Journal of Environmental Planning and Management44 (5): 629–648. Crossref.
59.
SapiainsR., BeetonR.J.S., and WalkerI.A.. 2016. ‘Individual responses to climate change: framing effects on pro-environmental behaviors’. Journal of Applied Social Psychology46 (8): 483–493. Crossref.
60.
SilvaP. and KrasnyM.E.. 2016. ‘Parsing participation: models of engagement for outcomes monitoring in urban stewardship’. Local Environment21 (2): 157–165. Crossref.
61.
SilvermanC.E.2018. ‘Empowerment to action: youth participation in a community-based stewardship program’ (unpublished Master of Science thesis). San José, California: San José State University.
62.
SongY. and ShiM.. 2017. ‘Associations between empathy and big five personality traits among Chinese undergraduate medical students’. PloS One12 (2): e0171665. Crossref.
63.
SteffenW., PerssonÅ., DeutschL., ZalasiewiczJ., WilliamsM., RichardsonK., CrumleyC., CrutzenP., FolkeC. and MolinaM.. 2011. ‘The Anthropocene: from global change to planetary stewardship’. Ambio40 (7): 739. Crossref.
64.
WangJ. and KimS.. 2018. ‘Analysis of the impact of values and perception on climate change skepticism and its implication for public policy’. Climate6 (4): 99. Crossref.
65.
WestS., HaiderL.J., MastersonV., EnqvistJ.P., SvedinU. and TengöM.. 2018. ‘Stewardship, care and relational values’. Current Opinion in Environmental Sustainability35: 30–38. Crossref.
66.
WorrellE., AllwoodJ. and GutowskiT.. 2016. ‘The role of material efficiency in environmental stewardship’. Annual Review of Environment and Resources41: 575–598. Crossref.
67.
WorrellR. and ApplebyM.C.. 2000. ‘Stewardship of natural resources: definition, ethical and practical aspects’. Journal of Agricultural and Environmental Ethics12 (3): 263–277. Crossref.
68.
ZhouM.2015. ‘Public environmental skepticism: a cross-national and multilevel analysis’. International Sociology30 (1): 61–85. Crossref.
