The notion of sufficiency has recently gained some momentum in separate discourses on distributive justice (‘sufficientarianism') and the environment (‘eco-sufficiency'). An investigation of their relationship is warranted, as their scope overlaps in areas such as environmental justice and socio-economic policy. This paper argues that the two understandings of sufficiency are incompatible, because eco-sufficiency has adopted an extremely perfectionist view of the good life while sufficientarianism is committed to pluralism. A plausible explanation for this incompatibility relates to the two different meanings of the term sufficiency as a limit (eco-sufficiency) and as a minimum requirement (sufficientarianism).
AlexanderS.2013. ‘Voluntary simplicity and the social reconstruction of law: de-growth from the grassroots up’. Environmental Values22(2): 287–308. Crossref.
3.
ArnesonR.J.2000. ‘Perfectionism and politics’. Ethics111(1): 37–63. Crossref.
4.
AxelsenD.V. and NielsenL.. 2014. ‘Sufficiency as freedom from duress’. Journal of Political Philosophy23(4): 406–426. Crossref.
5.
BenbajiY.2005. ‘The doctrine of sufficiency: a defence’. Utilitas17(3): 310–332. Crossref.
6.
CasalP.2007. ‘Why sufficiency is not enough’. Ethics117: 296–326. Crossref.
7.
ChanJ.2000. ‘Legitimacy, unanimity, and perfectionism’. Philosophy & Public Affairs29(1): 5–42. Crossref.
DalyH.E.1996. Beyond Growth: The Economics of Sustainable Development. Boston, MA: Beacon Press.
12.
DienerE. and SuhE.M.. 2000. Culture and Subjective Well-Being. Cambridge, MA: MIT Press.
13.
DorseyD.2012. The Basic Minimum: A Welfarist Approach. Cambridge/New York, NY: Cambridge University Press.
14.
FiggeF., YoungW. and BarkemeyerR.. 2014. ‘Sufficiency or efficiency to achieve lower resource consumption and emissions? The role of the rebound effect’. Journal of Cleaner Production69: 216–224. Crossref.
15.
FischerC. and GrieshammerR.. 2013. ‘When less is more: sufficiency: terminology, rationale and potentials’. Oeko-Institute Working Papers2. Online at http://www.oeko.de/oekodoc/1879/2013-007-en.pdf (accessed 9 June 2016).
16.
FrankfurtH.1987. ‘Equality as a moral ideal’. Ethics98: 21–43. Crossref.
17.
FrankfurtH.1988. The Importance of What We Care About: Philosophical Essays. Cambridge/New York, NY: Cambridge University Press. Crossref.
18.
FreyB.S. and StutzerA.. 2002. Happiness and Economics: How the Economy and Institutions Affect Well-Being. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.
19.
GambrelJ.C., and CafaroP.. 2010. ‘The virtue of simplicity’. Journal of Agricultural and Environmental Ethics23(1–2): 85–108. Crossref.
GrassoM.2012. ‘Sharing the emission budget’. Political Studies60(3): 668–686. Crossref.
22.
HurkaT.1993. Perfectionism. Oxford/New York, NY: Oxford University Press.
23.
HusebyR.2010. ‘Sufficiency: restated and defended’. Journal of Political Philosophy18(2): 178–197. Crossref.
24.
KerschnerC.2010. ‘Economic de-growth vs. steady-state economy’. Journal of Cleaner Production18(6): 544–551. Crossref.
25.
KhoslaA.2013. ‘Beyond Rio: from green economy to green society’. In SchneidewindU., SantariusT. and HumburgA., (eds.) Economy of Sufficiency: Essays on Wealth in Diversity, Enjoyable Limits and Creating Commons, pp. 14–24. Wuppertal: Wuppertal Institut für Klima, Umwelt, Energie.
26.
KymlickaW.1989. ‘Liberal individualism and liberal neutrality’. Ethics99(4): 883–905. Crossref.
27.
LambertonG.2005. ‘Sustainable sufficiency – an internally consistent version of sustainability’. Sustainable Development13(1): 53–68. Crossref.
LayardP.R.G.2005. Happiness: Lessons from a New Science. New York, NY: Penguin Press.
30.
MenzelS. and GreenT.L.. 2013. ‘Sovereign citizens and constrained consumers: why sustainability requires limits on choice’. Environmental Values22(1): 59–79. Crossref.
31.
MeyerL.H. and RoserD.. 2006. ‘Distributive justice and climate change: the allocation of emission rights’. Analyse & Kritik28: 223–249. Crossref.
32.
MilbrathL.W.1993. ‘Redefining the good life in a sustainable society’. Environmental Values2(3): 261–269. Crossref.
33.
PageE.A.2007. ‘Justice between generations: investigating a sufficientarian approach’. Journal of Global Ethics3(1): 3–20. Crossref.
34.
PageE.A.2013. ‘Climate change justice’. In FalknerR., (ed.) The Handbook of Global Climate and Environment Policy, pp. 231–248. Chichester: Wiley-Blackwell. Crossref.
35.
ParfitD.1984. Reasons and Persons. Oxford: Clarendon Press.
36.
PrincenT.2005. The Logic of Sufficiency. Cambridge, MA: MIT Press.
37.
RendallM.2011. ‘Non-identity, sufficiency and exploitation’. Journal of Political Philosophy19(2): 229–247. Crossref.
38.
SachsW.2009. ‘Fair wealth: pathways into post-development’. In PalosuoE., (ed.) Rethinking Development in a Carbon-Constrained World: Development Cooperation and Climate Change, pp. 196–206. Finland: Ministry for Foreign Affairs.
39.
SallehA.2009. Eco-sufficiency and Global Justice: Women Write Political Ecology. London: Pluto Press.
40.
SallehA.2011. ‘Climate strategy: making the choice between ecological modernisation or living well’. Journal of Australian Political Economy66: 124–149.
SchneidewindU., SantariusT. and HumburgA. (eds). 2013. Economy of Sufficiency: Essays on Wealth in Diversity, Enjoyable Limits and Creating Commons. Wuppertal: Wuppertal Institut für Klima, Umwelt, Energie.
43.
ShieldsL.2012. ‘The prospects for sufficientarianism’. Utilitas24(1): 101–117. Crossref.
44.
ShueH.1993. ‘Subsistence emissions and luxury emissions’. Law & Policy15(1): 39–59. Crossref.
