Emissions grandfathering holds that a history of emissions strengthens an agent's claim for future emission entitlements. Though grandfathering appears to have been influential in actual emission control frameworks, it is rarely taken seriously by philosophers. This article presents an argument for thinking this an oversight. The core of the argument is that members of countries with higher historical emissions are typically burdened with higher costs when tran-sitioning to a given lower level of emissions. According to several appealing views in political philosophy (utilitarianism, egalitarianism, prioritarianism and sufficientarianism) they are therefore entitled to greater resources, including emission entitlements, than those in similar positions but with lower emissions. This grandfathering may play an especially important role in allocating emission entitlements among rich countries.
AgarwalA., and NarainS.. 1991. Global Warming in an Unequal World: A Case of Environmental Colonialism.New Delhi: Centre for Science and Environment.
2.
ArnesonR.J.1989. ‘Equality and equal opportunity for welfare’. Philosophical Studies56: 77–93. CrossRef.
3.
ArnesonR.J.2000. ‘Luck egalitarianism and prioritarianism’. Ethics110: 339–49. CrossRef.
4.
BaerP., AthanasiouT., KarthaS., and Kemp-BenedictE.. 2008. The Greenhouse Development Rights Framework.Second edition. Berlin: Heinrich Böll Foundation.
5.
BöhmS., JonesC., LandC., and PatersonM. (eds). 2006. Against Automobility.Oxford: Blackwell.
6.
BoothC.2012. ‘Bystanding and climate change’. Environmental Values21: 397–416. CrossRef.
7.
CallendarG.S.1938. ‘The artificial production of carbon dioxide and its influence on temperature’. Quarterly Journal of the Royal Meteorological Society64: 223–40. CrossRef.
8.
CaneyS.2005a. ‘Cosmopolitan justice, responsibility, and global climate change’. Leiden Journal of International Law18: 747–77. CrossRef.
9.
CaneyS.2005b. Justice Beyond Borders.Oxford: Oxford University Press. CrossRef.
10.
CaneyS.2009. ‘Justice and the distribution of greenhouse gas emissions’. Journal of Global Ethics5: 125–46. CrossRef.
11.
CaneyS.2010. ‘Climate change and the duties of the advantaged’. Critical Review of International Social and Political Philosophy13: 203–28. CrossRef.
12.
CaneyS.2011. ‘Climate change, energy rights, and equality’. In ArnoldD. (ed.), The Ethics of Global Climate Change. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. CrossRef.
13.
CasalP.2007. ‘Why sufficiency is not enough’. Ethics117: 296–326. CrossRef.
14.
CohenG.A.1989. ‘On the currency of egalitarian justice’. Ethics99: 906–44. CrossRef.
15.
CohenG.A.2004. ‘Expensive taste rides again’. In BurleyJ. (ed.), Dworkin and His Critics.Oxford: Blackwell. CrossRef.
16.
CrispR.2003. ‘Equality, priority, and compassion’. Ethics113: 745–63. CrossRef.
17.
DworkinR.1981a. ‘What is equality? Part one: Equality of welfare’. Philosophy and Public Affairs10: 185–246.
18.
DworkinR.1981b. ‘What is equality? Part two: Equality of resources’. Philosophy and Public Affairs10: 283–345.
19.
DworkinR.2000. Sovereign Virtue: The Theory and Practice of Equality. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.
20.
FrankfurtH.1987. ‘Equality as a moral ideal’, Ethics98: 21–43. CrossRef.
21.
GardinerS.M.2011. A Perfect Moral Storm. Oxford: Oxford University Press. CrossRef.
22.
GoodinR.2008. ‘What is so special about our fellow countrymen?’. In BrooksT. (ed.), The Global Justice Reader.Oxford: Blackwell.
23.
GosseriesA.2004. ‘Historical emissions and free-riding’. In MeyerL.H. (ed.), Justice in Time.Baden-Baden: Nomos.
24.
GosseriesA.2005. ‘Cosmopolitan luck egalitarianism and the greenhouse effect’. In WeinstockD. (ed.), Global Justice, Global Institutions.Calgary: University of Calgary Press.
25.
GosseriesA., and HungerbühlerM.. 2006. ‘Rule change and intergenerational justice. In TremmelJ.C. (ed.), Handbook of Intergenerational Justice.Cheltenham: Edward Elgar.
26.
GrubbM.1989. ‘The greenhouse effect: negotiating targets’. International Affairs66: 67–89. CrossRef.
27.
HareR.M.1981. Moral Thinking. Oxford: Oxford University Press. CrossRef.
28.
HarsanyiJ.C.1982. ‘Morality and the theory of rational behaviour’. In SenA.K. and WilliamsB. (eds), Utilitarianism and Beyond.Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
29.
HaywardT.2007. ‘Human rights versus emissions rights: Climate justice and the equitable distribution of ecological space’. Ethics and International Affairs21: 431–50. CrossRef.
HusebyR.2010. ‘Sufficiency: restated and defended’. Journal of Political Philosophy18: 178–97. CrossRef.
32.
JamiesonD.2010a. ‘Adaptation, mitigation, and justice’. In GardinerS.M., CaneyS., JamiesonD., and ShueH. (eds), Climate Ethics: Essential Readings.Oxford: Oxford University Press.
33.
JamiesonD.2010b. ‘Ethics, public policy, and global warming’. In GardinerS.M., CaneyS., JamiesonD., and ShueH. (eds), Climate Ethics: Essential Readings.As above.
34.
KnightC.2009. Luck Egalitarianism: Equality, Responsibility, and Justice.Edinburgh: Edinburgh University Press.
35.
KnightC.2011. ‘Climate change and the duties of the disadvantaged: reply to Caney’. Critical Review of International Social and Political Philosophy14: 531–42. CrossRef.
36.
KnightC.2013. ‘What is grandfathering?’. Environmental Politics22 (3): 410–27. CrossRef.
37.
MillerD.2007. National Responsibility and Global Justice. Oxford: Oxford University Press. CrossRef.
38.
MillerD.2009. ‘Global justice and climate change’. In PetersonG.B. (ed.), The Tanner Lectures on Human Values, vol. 28. Salt Lake City: University of Utah Press.
39.
MoellendorfD.2009. Global Inequality Matters. Basingstoke: Palgrave Macmillan. CrossRef.
40.
NussbaumM.2011. Creating Capabilities. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press. CrossRef.
41.
PageE.A.2006. Climate Change, Justice, and Future Generations. Cheltenham: Edward Elgar. CrossRef.
42.
PageE.A.2008. ‘Distributing the burdens of climate change’. Environmental Politics17: 556–75. CrossRef.
43.
PageE.A.2011. ‘Climatic justice and the fair distribution of atmospheric burdens: A conjunctive account’. The Monist94: 412–32. CrossRef.
44.
ParfitD.1984. Reasons and Persons. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
45.
ParfitD.1996. ‘Equality and priority’. In MasonA. (ed.), Ideals of Equality.Oxford: Blackwell.
46.
PatersonM.2007. Automobile Politics.Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
47.
RatermanT.2012. ‘Bearing the weight of the world: On the extent of an individual's environmental responsibility’. Environmental Values21: 417–36. CrossRef.
48.
RawlsJ.1999a. A Theory of Justice, revised edition. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
49.
RawlsJ.1999b. The Law of Peoples. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.
50.
RazJ.1986. The Morality of Freedom.Oxford: Oxford University Press.
51.
ScanlonT.1998. What We Owe to Each Other. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.
52.
Schwartz CowanR.1997. ‘Automobiles and Automobility’. In A Social History of American Technology.Oxford: Oxford University Press.
53.
SenA.1999. Development as Freedom. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
54.
ShavellS.2008. ‘On optimal legal change, past behavior, and grandfathering’. Journal of Legal Studies37: 37–85. CrossRef.
55.
ShueH.1992. ‘The unavoidability of justice’. In HurrellA. and KingsburyB. (eds), The International Politics of the Environment.Oxford: Oxford University Press.
56.
ShueH.2010a. ‘Subsistence emissions and luxury emissions’. In GardinerS.M., CaneyS., JamiesonD., and ShueH. (eds), Climate Ethics: Essential Readings.As above.
57.
ShueH.2010b. ‘Global environment and international inequality’. In GardinerS.M., CaneyS., JamiesonD., and ShueH. (eds), Climate Ethics: Essential Readings.As above.
58.
SingerP.2006. ‘Ethics and climate change: A commentary on MacCracken, Toman and Gardiner’. Environmental Values15: 415–22. CrossRef.
59.
Sinnott-ArmstrongW.2010. ‘It's not my fault: Global warming and individual moral obligations’. In GardinerS.M., CaneyS., JamiesonD., and ShueH. (eds), Climate Ethics: Essential Readings.As above.
60.
SoltauF.2009. Fairness in International Climate Change Law and Policy. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. CrossRef.
61.
WesleyE., and PetersonF.. 1999. ‘The ethics of sharing in the global greenhouse’. Journal of Agricultural and Environmental Ethics11: 167–96. CrossRef.
