Abstract
Although both the most popular form of synthetic biology (SB) and chemical synthetic biology (CSB) share the biotechnologically useful aim of making new forms of life, SB does so by using genetic manipulation of extant microorganism, while CSB utilises classic chemical procedures in order to obtain biological structures which are non-existent in nature. The main query concerning CSB is the philosophical question: why did nature do this, and not that? The idea then is to synthesise alternative structures in order to understand why nature operated in such a particular way. We briefly present here some various examples of CSB, including those cases of nucleic acids synthesised with pyranose instead of ribose, and proteins with a reduced alphabet of amino acids; also we report the developing research on the “never born proteins” (NBP) and “never born RNA” (NBRNA), up to the minimal cell project, where the issue is the preparation of semi-synthetic cells that can perform the basic functions of biological cells.
Keywords
References
1.
Kitney R.
, and
Freemont P.
(2012 ) FEBS Lett. , 586 , 2029 –2036 .
2.
Peccoud J.
, and
Isalan M.
(2012 ) PLoS One , 7 , e43231 .
3.
Luisi P.L.
, and
Chiarabelli C.
(2011 ) Chemical synthetic biology. John Wiley and Sons Ltd , Chichester .
4.
Chiarabelli C.
,
Stano P.
,
Anella F.
,
Carrara P.
, and
Luisi P.L.
(2012 ) FEBS Lett. , 586 , 2138 –2145 .
5.
Chiarabelli C.
,
Stano P.
, and
Luisi P.L.
(2009 ) Curr. Opin. Biotechnol. , 20 , 492 –497 .
6.
Luisi P.L.
(2007 ) Chem. Biodivers. , 4 , 603 –621 .
7.
Luisi P.L.
,
Chiarabelli C.
, and
Stano P.
(2006 ) Orig. Life Evol. Biosph. , 36 , 605 –616 .
8.
Eschenmoser A.
(2005 ) Chimia , 59 , 836 –850 .
9.
Nielsen P.E.
,
Egholm M.
,
Berg R.H.
, and
Buchardt O.
(1991 ) Science , 254 , 1497 –1500 .
10.
Egholm M.
,
Buchardt O.
,
Christensen L.
,
Behrens C.
,
Freier S.M.
,
Driver D.A.
,
Berg R.H.
,
Kim S.K.
,
Nordén B.
, and
Nielsen P.E.
(1993 ) Nature , 365 , 566 –568 .
11.
Nielsen P.E.
(1999 ) Acc. Chem. Res. , 32 , 624 –630 .
12.
Miller S.L.
,
Dworkin J.P.
, and
Lazcano A.
(2003 ) J. Theor. Biol. , 222 , 127 –134 .
13.
Nelson E.K.
,
Levy M.
, and
Miller S.L.
(2000 ) PNAS , 97 , 3868 –3871 .
14.
Benner S.A.
,
Yang Z.
, and
Chen F.
(2010 ) C. R. Chim. , 14 , 372 –387 .
15.
Yang Z.
,
Chen F.
,
Alvarado J.B.
, and
Benner S.A.
(2011 ) J. Am. Chem. Soc. , 133 , 15105 –15112 .
16.
Winnacker M.
, and
Kool E.T.
(2013 ) Angew. Chem. Int. Ed. Engl. , 52 , 12498 –12508 .
17.
Liu H.
,
Gao J.
, and
Kool E.T.
(2005 ) J. Org. Chem. , 70 , 639 –647 .
18.
Liu H.
,
Gao J.
,
Maynard L.
,
Saito Y.D.
, and
Kool E.T.
(2004 ) J. Am. Chem. Soc. , 126 , 1102 –1109 .
19.
Liu H.
,
Gao J.
,
Lynch S.R.
,
Saito Y.D.
,
Maynard L.
, and
Kool E.T.
(2003 ) Science , 302 , 868 –871 .
20.
Wachtershauser G.
(1988 ) Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA , 85 , 1134 –1135 .
21.
Minakawa N.
,
Kojima N.
,
Hikishima S.
,
Sasaki T.
,
Kiyosue A.
,
Atsumi N.
,
Ueno Y.
, and
Matsuda A.
(2003 ) J. Am. Chem. Soc. , 125 , 9970 –9982 .
22.
Hikishima S.
,
Minakawa N.
,
Kuramoto K.
,
Fujisawa Y.
,
Ogawa M.
, and
Matsuda A.
(2005 ) Angew. Chem. , 117 , 602 –604 .
23.
Doi Y.
,
Chiba J.
,
Morikawa T.
, and
Inouye M.
(2008 ) J. Am. Chem. Soc. , 130 , 8762 –8768 .
24.
Zimmermann N.
,
Meggers E.
, and
Schultz P.G.
(2002 ) J. Am. Chem. Soc. , 124 , 13684 –13685 .
25.
Zimmermann N.
,
Meggers E.
, and
Schultz P.G.
(2004 ) Bioorg. Chem. , 32 , 13 –25 .
26.
Clever G.H.
,
Kaul C.
, and
Carell T.
(2007 ) Angew. Chem. Int. Ed. , 46 , 6226 –6236 .
27.
Clever G.H.
, and
Shionoya M.
(2010 ) Coord. Chem. Rev. , 254 , 2391 –2402 .
28.
Kool E.T.
(2002 ) Acc. Chem. Res. , 35 , 936 –943 .
29.
Leconte A.M.
,
Matsuda S.
, and
Romesberg F.E.
(2006 ) J. Am. Chem. Soc. , 128 , 6780 –6781 .
30.
Hirao I.
,
Kimoto M.
,
Mitsui T.
,
Fujiwara T.
,
Kawai R.
,
Sato A.
,
Harada Y.
, and
Yokoyama S.
(2006 ) Nat. Methods , 3 , 729 –735 .
31.
Hirao I.
,
Mitsui T.
,
Kimoto M.
, and
Yokoyama S.
(2007 ) J. Am. Chem. Soc. , 129 , 15549 –15555 .
32.
Malyshev D.A.
,
Seo Y.J.
,
Ordoukhanian P.
, and
Romesberg F.E.
(2009 ) J. Am. Chem. Soc. , 131 , 14620 –14621 .
33.
Kim T.W.
,
Delaney J.C.
,
Essigmann J.M.
, and
Kool E.T.
(2005 ) Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA , 102 , 15803 –15808 .
34.
Anella F.
,
De Lucrezia D.
,
Chiarabelli C.
, and
Luisi P.L.
(2011 ) Chem. Biodivers. , 8 , 1422 –1432 .
35.
Neveu M.
,
Kim H.J.
, and
Benner S.A.
(2013 ) Astrobiology , 13 , 391 –403 .
36.
Lazcano A.
(2012 ) Hist. Philos. Life Sci. , 34 , 407 –423 .
37.
De Lucrezia D.
,
Anella F.
, and
Chiarabelli C.
(2007 ) Orig. Life Evol. Biosph. , 37 , 379 –385 .
38.
Orgel LE
. (2003 ) Orig. Life Evol. Biosph. , 33 , 211 –218 .
39.
Orgel L.E.
(2004 ) Crit. Rev. Biochem. Mol. Biol. , 39 , 99 –123 .
40.
De Lucrezia D.
,
Franchi M.
,
Chiarabelli C.
,
Gallori E.
, and
Luisi P.L.
(2006 ) Chem. Biodivers. , 3 , 860 –868 .
41.
Chiarabelli C.
,
Vrijbloed J.W.
,
De Lucrezia D.
,
Thomas R.M.
,
Stano P.
,
Polticelli F.
,
Ottone T.
,
Papa E.
, and
Luisi P.L.
(2006 ) Chem. Biodivers. , 3 , 840 –859 .
42.
Luisi P.L.
,
Chiarabelli C.
, and
Stano P.
(2006 ) Orig. Life Evol. Biosph. , 36 , 605 –616 .
43.
Thomas R.M.
,
Vrijbloed J.W.
, and
Luisi P.L.
(2001 ) Chimia , 55 , 114 –118 .
44.
Eichler J.
(2004 ) Protein Pept. Lett. , 11 , 281 –290 .
45.
Scott J.K.
, and
Craig L.
(1994 ) Curr. Opin. Biotechnol. , 5 , 40 –48 .
46.
Jäckel C.
,
Kast P.
, and
Hilvert D.
(2008 ) Annu. Rev. Biophys. , 37 , 153 –173 .
47.
Leisola M.
, and
Turunen O.
(2007 ) Appl. Microbiol. Biotechnol. , 75 , 1225 –1232 .
48.
Voigt C.A.
,
Kauffman S.
, and
Wang Z.G.
(2000 ) Adv. Protein Chem. , 55 , 79 –160 .
49.
Chessari S.
,
Thomas R.
,
Polticelli F.
, and
Luisi P.L.
(2006 ) Chem. Biodivers. , 3 , 1202 –1210 .
50.
Doi N.
, and
Yanagawa H.
(1998 ) Cell. Mol. Life Sci. , 54 , 394 –404 .
51.
Kauffman S.
, and
Ellington A.D.
(1999 ) Curr. Opin. Chem. Biol. , 3 , 256 –259 .
52.
Saven J.G.
(2002 ) Curr. Opin. Struct. Biol. , 12 , 453 –458 .
53.
Watters A.L.
, and
Baker D.
(2004 ) Eur. J. Biochem. , 271 , 1615 –1622 .
54.
Crick F.H.C.
(1968 ) J. Mol. Biol. , 38 , 367 –379 .
55.
Wong J.T.
(1975 ) Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA , 72 , 1909 –1912 .
56.
Brooks D.J.
,
Fresco J.R.
,
Lesk A.M.
, and
Singh M.
(2002 ) Mol. Biol. Evolut. , 19 , 1645 –1655 .
57.
Davidson A.R.
, and
Sauer R.T.
(1994 ) Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA , 91 , 2146 –2150 .
58.
Davidson A.R.
,
Lumb K.J.
, and
Sauer R.T.
(1995 ) Nat. Struct. Biol. , 2 , 856 –864 .
59.
Doi N.
,
Kakukawa K.
,
Oishi Y.
, and
Yanagawa H.
(2005 ) Protein Eng. Des. Sel. , 18 , 279 –284 .
60.
Babajide A.
,
Hofacker I.L.
,
Sippl M.J.
, and
Stadler P.F.
(1997 ) Fold. Des. , 2 , 261 –269 .
61.
Prijambada I.D.
,
Yomo T.
,
Tanaka F.
,
Kawama T.
,
Yamamoto K.
,
Hasegawa A.
,
Shima Y.
,
Negoro S.
, and
Urabe I.
(1996 ) FEBS Lett. , 382 , 21 –25 .
62.
Yamauchi A.
,
Nakashima T.
,
Tokuriki N.
,
Hosokawa M.
,
Nogami H.
,
Arioka S.
,
Urabe I.
, and
Yomo T.
(2002 ) Protein Eng. , 15 , 619 –626 .
63.
Hayashi Y.
,
Sakata H.
,
Makino Y.
,
Urabe I.
, and
Yomo T.
(2003 ) J. Mol. Evol. , 56 , 162 –168 .
64.
Toyota H.
,
Hosokawa M.
,
Urabe I.
, and
Yomo T.
(2008 ) Mol. Biol. Evol. , 25 , 1113 –1119 .
65.
Deamer D.
(2005 ) Trends Biotechnol. , 23 , 336 –338 .
66.
Luisi P.L.
,
Ferri F.
, and
Stano P.
(2006 ) Naturwissenschaften , 93 , 1 –13 .
67.
Forster A.C.
, and
Church G.M.
(2006 ) Mol. Syst. Biol. , 2 , 45 .
68.
Liu C.C.
, and
Schultz P.G.
(2010 ) Annu. Rev. Biochem. , 79 , 413 –44 .
69.
Xie J.
, and
Schultz P.G.
(2005 ) Curr. Opin. Chem. Biol. , 9 , 548 –554 .
70.
Kawakami T.
, and
Murakami H.
(2012 ) J. Nucleic Acids , 2012 : 713510 .
71.
Dabbs E.R.
(1978 ) Mol. Gen. Genet. , 165 , 73 –78 .
72.
O'Brien T.W.
,
Denslow N.D.
,
Anders J.C.
, and
Courtney B.C.
(1990 ) Biochim. Biophys. Acta , 1050 , 174 –178 .
73.
Hampl H.
,
Schulze H.
, and
Nierhaus K.H.
(1981 ) J. Biol. Chem. , 256 , 2284 –2288 .
74.
Schulze H.
, and
Nierhaus K.H.
(1982 ) EMBO J. , 1 , 609 –613 .
75.
Herdewijn P.
,
Marlière P.
(2009 ) Chem. Biodivers. , 6 , 791 –808 .
76.
Rao S.N.
, and
Kollman P.A.
(1986 ) Biopolymers , 25 , 267 –280 .
77.
Horlacher J.
,
Hottiger M.
,
Podust V.N.
,
Hubscher U.
, and
Benner S.A.
(1995 ) Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA , 92 , 6329 –6333 .
78.
Luisi P.L.
(2002 ) Anat. Rec. , 268 , 208 –214 .
79.
Oberholzer T.
, and
Luisi P.L.
(2002 ) J. Biol. Phys. , 28 , 733 –744 .
80.
Pohorille A.
, and
Deamer D.
(2002 ) Trends Biotechnol. , 20 , 123 –128 .
81.
Szathmáry E.
,
Santos M.
, and
Fernando C.
(2005 ) Top Curr. Chem. , 259 , 167 –211 .
82.
Forster A.C.
, and
Church G.M.
(2006 ) Mol. Syst. Biol. , 2 , 45 .
83.
Zhang Y.
,
Ruder W.C.
, and
LeDuc P.R.
(2008 ) Trends Biotechnol. , 26 , 14 –20 .
84.
Glass J.I.
,
Assad-Garcia N.
,
Alperovich N.
,
Yooseph S.
,
Lewis M.R.
,
Maruf M.
,
Hutchison C.A.
3rd
,
Smith H.O.
, and
Venter J.C.
(2006 ) Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA , 103 , 425 –430 .
85.
Gibson D.G.
,
Benders G.A.
,
Andrews-Pfannkoch C.
,
Denisova E.A.
,
Baden-Tillson H.
,
Zaveri J.
,
Stockwell T.B.
,
Brownley A.
,
Thomas D.W.
,
Algire M.A.
,
Merryman C.
,
Young L.
,
Noskov V.N.
,
Glass J.I.
,
Venter J.C.
,
Hutchison C.A.
3rd
, and
Smith H.O.
(2008 ) Science , 319 , 1215 –1220 .
86.
Gibson D.G.
,
Benders G.A.
,
Axelrod K.C.
,
Zaveri J.
,
Algire M.A.
,
Moodie M.
,
Montague M.G.
,
Venter J.C.
,
Smith H.O.
, and
Hutchison C.A.
3rd
(2006 ) Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA , 105 , 20404 –20409 .
87.
Luisi P.L.
(2006 ) The emergence of life: from chemical origin to synthetic biology. Cambridge University Press .