Hallux rigidus (HR) is one of the most common causes of forefoot pain. A number of classification systems have been developed to evaluate HR. These systems are based on either radiological parameters alone or a combination of radiological and clinical features. The purpose of this paper is to critically evaluate HR classification systems by undertaking a detailed review using English language medical and paramedical databases.
Materials and Methods
The authors identified 18 formal HR classification systems described in the literature, some of which are variations on a theme.
Results
No clear consensus on the construction of HR classification systems appears to exist. Different criteria and methods are used which make comparison difficult. Furthermore, it appears that, no serious consideration has been given to their reliability and validity. Criteria used to justify inclusion of these parameters have been based mainly on clinical experience rather than formal research.
Conclusion
For such a common condition, there is a need for a properly constructed, prospective study to develop a suitable classification system. It should include scientifically validated parameters to help stratify different stages of the disease and aid clinical and scientific communication.
AsterAS; ForsterM.C.; RajanR.A.: Radiographic pre-operative assessment in hallux valgus: is it reliable?The Foot.14: 129–132, 2004. http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.foot.2004.02.002
2.
BarcaF.: Tendon arthroplasty of the first metatarsophalangeal joint in hallux rigidus: preliminary communication.Foot & Ankle Int.18: 222–228, 1997.
3.
BecherC; KilgerR.; ThermannH.: Results of cheilectomy and additional microfracture technique for the treatment of hallux rigidus.Foot & Ankle Surg.11: 155–160, 2005. http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.fas.2005.06.001
BingoldA.C.; CollinsD.H.: Hallux rigidus.J Bone Joint Surg.32B: 214–222, 1950.
6.
BonneyG.; MacNabI.: Hallux valgus and hallux rigidus. A critical survey of operative results.J Bone Joint Surg.34B: 366–385, 1952.
7.
BuchbinderR; GoelV; BombardierC.; Hogg-JohnsonS.: Classification systems of soft tissue disorders of the neck and upper limb: Do they satisfy methodological guidelines?J Clin Epidemiol49: 141–149, 1996. http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/0895-4356(95)00519-6
8.
CohenI.; KanatI.: Functional limitation of motion of the first metatarsophalangeal joint.J Foot Surg.23: 477–487, 1984.
9.
CoughlinM.J.: Arthritides. In: CoughlinMJ.MannR.A.: Surgery of the Foot & Ankle7th Ed.St Louis.: Mosby. 1999, 605–650.
CoughlinM.J.; ShurnasP.S.: Hallux rigidus: Grading and long-term results of operative treatment.J Bone Joint Surg.85A: 2072–2088, 2003b.
12.
CoxD; FitzpatrickR.; FletcherAE: Quality-of-life assessment: can we keep it simple?J Rol Stat Soc Series A.155: 353–393, 1992. http://dx.doi.org/10.2307/2982889
13.
DragoJJ; OloffL.; JacobsA.M.: A comprehensive review of hallux limitus.J Foot & Ankle Surg23: 213–220, 1984.
14.
EasleyME; DavisW.H.; AndersonR.B.: Intermediate to long-term followup of medial-approach dorsal cheilectomy for hallux rigidus.Foot & Ankle Int.20: 173–180, 1999.
15.
FelsonD.T.; AndersonJ.J.: Methodological and statistical approaches to criteria development in rheumatic diseases.Balliere's Clinical Rheumatology.9: 253–266, 1995.
16.
FelthamGT; HanksS.E.; MarcusR.E.: Age-based outcomes of cheilectomy for the treatment of hallux rigidus.Foot & Ankle Int.22: 192–197, 2001.
17.
GeldwertJJ; RockGD; McGrathM.P.; MancusoJ.E.: Cheilectomy: still a useful technique for grade 1 and grade 2 hallux limitus/ rigidus.J Foot Surg.31: 154–159, 1992.
18.
GiannestrasN.J.: Hallux Rigidus. In GiannestrasN.J. Ed. Foot disorders: medical and surgical management.Philadephia: Lea & Febiger. 1973, 400–402.
19.
GianniniS; CeccarelliF.; FaldiniC: What's new in surgical options for hallux rigidus.J Bone Joint Surg.86A:72–83, 2004.
20.
GoodfellowJ.: Aetiology of hallux rigidus.Proc R Soc Med.59: 821–824, 1966.
21.
GonzalezJV; GarrettPP; JordanM.J.; ReillyC.H.: The modified Homann osteotomy: An alternative joint salvage procedure for hallux rigidus.J Foot & Ankle Surg.43: 380–388, 2005.
22.
HanftJR; MasonE.T.; LandsmanA.S.: A new radiographic classification for hallux limitus.J Foot Ankle Surg.32: 397–404, 1993.
23.
HattrupS.J.; JohnsonK.A.: Subjective results of hallux rigidus following treatment with Cheilectomy.Clin Orthop.226: 182–191, 1988.
KellgrenJ.H.; LawrenceJ.S.: Radiological assessment of osteoarthrosis.Ann Rheum Dis.16: 494–502, 1957.
28.
KelikianH.: Hallux Rigidus. In KelikianH. ed. Arthroplastic resections. In hallux valgus, allied deformities of the forefoot and metatarsalgia.Philadelphia: WB Saunders. 1965, 262–281.
29.
KeoghP; NagariaJ.; StephensM.: Cheilectomy for hallux rigidus.Irish J Med Sci.161: 681–683, 1992.
30.
KessellL.; BonneyG.: Hallux rigidus in the adolescent.J Bone Joint Surg.40B: 668–673, 1958.
31.
KravitzSR; LaPortaG.A.; LawsonJ.H.: KLL Progressive staging classification of hallux limitus and hallux rigidus.The Lower Extremity1: 55–66, 1994.
32.
LambrinudiC.: Metatarsus primus elevatus.Proc R Soc Med.31: 1273–1275, 1938.
33.
LapidusP.: Dorsal bunion: Its mechanics and operative correction.J Bone Joint Surg.22B: 627–637, 1940.
34.
LombardiCM; SilhanekAD; ConnollyFG; DennisL.N.; KeslonskyA.J.: First metatarsophalangeal joint arthrodesis for treatment of hallux rigidus: a retrospective study.J Foot Ankle Surg.40: 137–143, 2001.
35.
LauT.C.; DanielsT.R.: Outcomes following Cheilectomy and interposition arthroplasty in hallux rigidus.Foot & Ankle Int.22: 462–470, 2001.
36.
MackayDC; BlythM.; RymaszewskiL.A.: The role of cheilectomy in the treatment of hallux rigidus.J Foot & Ankle Surg.36: 337–340, 1997.
37.
MannR.A.; ClantonT.O.: Hallux rigidus: treatment by cheilectomy.J Bone Joint Surg.70A: 400–406, 1988.
38.
MannRA; CoughlinM.J.; DuVriesH.L.: Hallux rigidus: a review of the literature and a method of treatment.Clin Orthop.142: 57–63, 1979.
39.
McMasterM.J.: The pathogenesis of hallux rigidus.J Bone Joint Surg.60B: 82–87, 1978.
40.
MulierT; SteenwerckxA.; ThienpontE.: Results after cheilectomy in athletes with hallux rigidus.Foot & Ankle Int.20: 232–237, 1999.
41.
NilsonneH.: Hallux rigidus and its treatment.Acta Orthop Scand.1: 295–303, 1930.
42.
PontellD.P.; GudasC.J.: Retrospective analysis of surgical treatment of hallux rigidus/limitus: Clinical and radiographic followup of hinged, silastic implant arthroplasty and cheilectomy.J Foot Surg.27: 503–510, 1988.
43.
RegnauldB.: Disorders of the great toe. In ElsonR.The Foot: pathology, aetiology, seminology, clinical investigation and treatment.New York: Springer-Verlag. 1986, 269–281, 344–349.
44.
ReijmanM; HazesJ.M.W.; KoesB.W.: Validity, reliability and applicability of seven definitions of hip OA used in epidemiological studies: a systematic appraisal.Ann Rheum Dis.63: 226–232, 2004. http://dx.doi.org/10.1136/ard.2003.010348
45.
RonconiP; MonachinoP.; BaleanuM.: Distal oblique osteotomy of the 1st metatarsal for correction of hallux limitus and hallux rigidus deformity.J Foot Ankle Surg.39: 154–160, 2000.
46.
RoukisTS; JacobsPM; DawsonDM; ErdmannB.B.; RingstromJ.B.: A prospective comparison of clinical, radiographic, intraoperative features of hallux rigidus.J Foot & Ankle Surg.41: 76–95, 2002.
47.
RzoncaE; LevitzS.; LueB.: Hallux equinus: The stages of hallux limitus and hallux rigidus.JAPA.74: 390–393, 1984.
48.
SaxenaA.: The Valenti procedure for hallux limitus/ rigidus.J Foot Ankle Surg.34: 485–488, 1995.
SelnerAJ; BogdanR.; SelnerMD: Tri-correctional osteotomy for the correction of late-stage hallux limitus/ rigidus.JAPMA.87: 414–424, 1997.
51.
SukM; HansonBP; NorvellD.C.; HelfetD.L.: Muskuloskeletal outcomes measures and instruments. AO Handbook.New York. Thieme. 2005, 7–19.
52.
VanoreJV; ChristensenJ.C.; KravitzSR: Clinical practice guideline first metatarsophalangeal joint disorders Panel of the American College of Foot & Ankle Surgeons.Diagnosis and treatment of first metatarsophalangeal joint disorders. Section 2: Hallux rigidus. J. Foot Ankle Surg.42: 124–136, 2003. http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/S1067-2516(03)70015-5
53.
ViegusG.V.: Reconstruction of hallux limitus deformity using a first metatarsal sagittal-Z osteotomy.J Foot & Ankle Surg.37: 204–211, 1998.
54.
ZygonisT; JollyG.P.; GarbalosaJ.C.: The value of radiographic parameters in the surgical treatment of hallux rigidus.J Foot & Ankle Surg.44: 185–189, 2005.
