Abstract
Psychoanalysis is in decline. Its methods disbar it from serious consideration as a natural science and its claims to therapeutic efficacy are in tatters. The role it performed earlier in the century as part of the narrative knowledge of western culture is in eclipse. Trainees in psychiatry are still, however, on occasion seduced by its faded charms, to their detriment. The time has come to relegate psychoanalysis to its proper place as a moment in the historical development of psychiatry and a ripple in 20th century western culture.
References
1.
Smith
GC
. Psychoanalysis today . Australian and New Zealand Journal of Psychiatry 1988 ; 22 :12 –15
2.
Freud
S
. Psycho-analysis . Trans.
Strachey
J.
Standard Edition Vol XVII . London : Hogarth Press 1955 , orig. 1923., 235 –254
3.
Jaspers
K
. General psychopathology . Trans:
Hoening
J
Hamilton
MW
7th ed. Manchester : University Press , 1963
4.
Freud
S
. The psychopathology of everyday life . Trans:
Strachey
J.
Standard Edition , Vol VI . London : Hogarth Press , 1957 , orig. 1910
5.
Freud
S
. Leonardo da Vinci and a memory of his childhood . Trans:
Strachey
J.
Standard Edition Vol XI . London : Hogarth Press , 1957 , orig. 1910
6.
Timpanaro
S
. The Freudian slip: psychoanalysis and textural criticism . Trans:
Soper
K.
London : New Left Books , 1976
7.
Grunbaum
A
. The foundations of psychoanalysis: a philosophical critique . Berkeley : University of California Press , 1984
8.
Grunbaum
A
. Precis of the foundations of psychoanalysis . Behavioural and Brain Sciences 1986 ; 9 :217 –284
9.
Kraupl
Taylor F.
. Psychoanalysis: a philosophical critique . Psychological Medicine 1986 ; 17 :557 –560
10.
Parker
P
. Psychoanalysis and scientific methods: no need for despondency . Australian and New Zealand Journal of Psychiatry 1988 ; 22 :17 –18
11.
Lyotard
JF
. The postmodern condition: a report on knowledge . Trans:
Bennington
G
Massumu
B.
Minneapolis : University of Minnesota Press , 1984
12.
Ricoeur
P
. Freud and philosophy . Trans:
Savage
D.
New Haven : Yale University Press , 1970
13.
Churchland
PS
. Mind brain reduction: new light from the philosophy of science . Neuroseience 1982 ; 7/5 :1041 –1047
14.
Churchland
PS
. Neurophilosophy . Cambridge Mass : MIT Press , 1986
15.
Freud
S
. Project for a scientific psychology . Standard Edition , Vol 1 , London : Hogarth Press 1950 , orig. 1895
16.
Gibbon
E
. The history of the decline and fall of the Roman Empire . Melbourne : Ward Lock & Co. 1910 , orig. 1794