Information-processing research into the natural process of clinical reasoning is reviewed and the University of Vermont diagnostic reasoning research project is described. Experienced psychiatric diagnosticians use a hypothetico-deductive logic. The development of a profile of diagnostic competencies is outlined and a course in diagnostic reasoning for medical students, which specifically objectified the tactics and strategy of reasoning and resulted in a significant improvement in the profile of competencies, is described. Finally, the organisation of a diagnostic formulation is discussed.
References
1.
BarrowsH. S. (1979), An Overview of Medical Problem Solving, paper presented at a conference on the Role of Problem Solving in Medicine, sponsored by the University of Vermont, Smugglers Notch, Vermont, October 1979
2.
BloisM. S. (1980), Clinical judgment and computers, New England Journal of Medicine303, 192–7
3.
de OowinE. L.de OowinR. L. (1976), Bedside Diagnostic Examination, 3rd edn.MacMillan, New York
4.
DegrootA. D. (1965), Thought and Choke in Chess, Mouton, The Hague
5.
ElsteinA. S. (1976), Clinical judgment: Psychological research and medical practice, Science194, 696–700
6.
ElsteinA. S.BordageG. (1979), Psychology of clinical reasoning, inStoneG.CohenF.AdlerN. (eds), Health Psychology — A Handbook, Jossey-BassSan Francisco
7.
ElsteinA. S.ShulmanL. S.SprafkaS. A. (1978), Medical Problem Solving: An Analysis of Clinical Reasoning, Harvard, Cambridge, Mass
8.
FeightnerJ. W.NormanG. R.BarrowsH. S.NeufeldV. R. (1975), A Comparison of the Clinical Methods of Primary and Secondary Care Physicians, paper presented at symposium sponsored by the Association of American Medical Colleges, Washington, November 1975
9.
Fitzhenry-CoorI. (1986), Appendix I: Process tracing of the diagnostic reasoning of an experienced clinician, in NurcombeB.GallagherR. M., The Clinical Process in Psychiatry, Cambridge University Press, New York
10.
Fitzhenry-CoorI.NurcombeB. (1982), Manual for the Vermont Diagnostic Reasoning Project, Department of Psychiatry, University of Vermont, Burlington, Vermont
11.
Fitzhenry-CoorI.NurcombeB. (1983), Assessing clinical reasoning: The development of a new test in psychiatric education, Journal of Psychiatric Education7, 183–96
12.
GauronE. F.DickinsonJ. F. (1965), Diagnostic decision making in psychiatry: I. Information Usage. II. Diagnostic styles, Archives of General Psychiatry14, 225–32, 233–77
13.
HoltR. R. (1958), Clinical and statistical prediction: A reformulation and some new data, Journal of Abnormal and Social Psychology56, 1–12
14.
DellKen R. E. (1973), Psychiatric diagnoses: A study of how they are done, British Journal of Psychiatry122, 437–45
15.
KleinmuntzB. (1969), Clinical Information Processing by Computer. Holt, New York
16.
LarkinJ.McDermottJ.SimonD. P.SimonH. (1980), Expert and novice performance in solving physics problems, Science208, 1335–42
17.
MeehlP. E. (1954). Clinical versus Statistical Prediction, University of Minnesota, Minneapolis
18.
MeehlP. E. (1974), Psychodiagnosis: Selected Papers, University of Minnesota, Minneapolis
19.
NurcombeB.Fitzhenry-CoorI. (1982), How do psychiatrists think? Clinical reasoning in the psychiatric interview: A research and education project, Australian and New Zealand Journal of Psychiatry16, 13–24
20.
NurcombeB.GallagherR. M. (1986), The Clinical Process in Psychiatry: Diagnosis and Management Planning, Cambridge University Press, New York
21.
SandiferM. G.HordernA.GreenI. M. (1970), The psychiatric interview: The input of the first three minutes, American Journal of Psychiatry126, 968–73
22.
ShiffrinR. M.AtkinsonR. C. (1969), Storage and retrieval processes in long-term memory, Psychological Review76, 179–93
