The Australian health insurance industry has been critical of psychiatry. The data on patterns of claims which have been the focus for some of their concerns are reviewed. The evidence on the efficacy of psychotherapy is also reviewed. Psychotherapy has been shown to be an effective treatment for persons with incapacitating neurotic and personality disorders, a treatment too important to be endangered by dissent over health insurance payments. Proposals for a peer review process for long term psychotherapy are mooted in the expectation that agreement between the health insurance industry and psychiatry would benefit those patients in need of psychotherapy.
References
1.
AndrewsG.HarveyR. (1981) Does psychotherapy benefit neurotic patients?Archives of General Psychiatry, 38, 1203–1208.
2.
AndrewsG.TennantC.BrodatyH. (1981) The need for psychiatric care. The Medical Journal of Australia, 1, 593–594.
3.
A.P.A. Commission On Psychiatric Therapies (1982) Methodology and Efficacy Issues in Research on Psychotherapy. Unpublished manuscript. Department of Psychiatry, Albert Einstein College of Medicine, New York.
4.
von DuhrssenA.JorswieckE. (1965) Eine empirisch-statistiche Untersuchung zur Leistungsfahigkeit psychoanalytischer Behandlung. Der Nervenarzt, 36, 166–169.
5.
GarfieldS. L.BerginA. E. (1978) Handbook of Psychotherapy and Behaviour Change. John Wiley and Sons, New York.
6.
HallC. P. (1974) Financing mental health services through insurance. American Journal of Psychiatry, 131, 1079–1088.
7.
HallW.WeekesP.HarveyR.AndrewsG. (1982) A survey of psychiatrists’ views on the treatment of agoraphobia. Australian and New Zealand Journal of Psychiatry, 16, 225–233.
8.
OpitL. J. (1981) Geographic and Imputed Social Status Factors In Relation to the Use of Private Health Care Services in a Health Insured Population (1977–1978). Department of Social and Preventive Medicine, Monash Medical School, Prahan, Victoria.
9.
OpitL. J.GadielD. L. (1982) The demand for private psychiatric services in a health insured population. Community Health Studies, 6, 93–98.
10.
SchlesingerH. J.MumfordE.GlassG. V. (1980) Mental health services and medical utilization. In Psychotherapy: Practice, Research and Policy. (Ed. VandenbosG. R.). Sage, Beverly Hills, CA.
11.
SharfsteinS. S.MagnasH. L. (1975) Insuring intensive psychotherapy. American Journal of Psychiatry, 132, 1252–1256.
12.
SpielmanR. (1982) Psychiatric ‘scapegoats'. Letter to the Editor. Sydney Morning Herald, 11 August.
13.
Voluntary Health Insurance Association Of Australia (1982) Submission to Joint Committee of Parliament, Public Accounts Enquiry, Canberra, July 1982. Paragraphs 33–35.
14.
WilliamsA. (1982) An evaluation of the ‘Triumph of the Therapeutic’ argument in Melbourne, Unpublished Ph.D. thesis, School of Behavioural Sciences, La Trobe University.
