This study examines competing justice claims that stakeholders policymakers, district leaders, families, and educators evoked during the 2020 COVID-19 New York City school reopening debates. Drawing on thematic analysis of 300 news and opinion articles, we examine stakeholders’ overlapping and contested understandings of justice in public education, including claims related to how school resources are distributed, whom district policies recognize, and who is represented in policymaking. In addition to deepening our understanding of the educational politics of the COVID-19 pandemic—an event with field-changing consequences—our analysis offers researchers and policymakers a more robust basis for advancing equity and conceptualizing just educational policy for multiple stakeholders.
AllbrightT. N.MarshJ. A.HallM.TobenL.PicusL. O.LavadezM. (2019). Conceptualizing equity in the implementation of California education finance reform. American Journal of Education, 125, 173–200.
5.
American Public Media Research Lab. (2021, March). The color of coronavirus: Covid-19 deaths by race and ethnicity in the U.S. website. American Public Media. https://www.apmresearchlab.org/covid/deaths-by-race
AsburyK.FoxL.DenizE.CodeA.ToseebU. (2021). How is COVID-19 affecting the mental health of children with special educational needs and disabilities and their families?Journal of Autism and Developmental Disorders, 51(5), 1772–1780. https://doi.org/10.1007/s10803-020-04577-2
12.
BaileyD. H.DuncanG. J.MurnaneR. J.Au YeungN. (2021). Achievement gaps in the wake of COVID-19. Educational Researcher, 50(5), 266–275. https://doi.org/10.3102/0013189x211011237
BertrandM.PerezW. Y.RogersJ. (2015). The covert mechanisms of education policy discourse: Unmasking policy insiders’ discourses and discursive strategies in upholding or challenging racism and classism in education. Education Policy Analysis Archives, 23, 93.
15.
BulkleyK. E. (2013). Conceptions of equity: How influential actors view a contested concept. Peabody Journal of Education, 88(1), 10–21. https://doi.org/10.1080/0161956X.2013.752309
16.
Calabrese BartonA.TanE. (2020). Beyond equity as inclusion: A framework of “rightful presence” for guiding justice-oriented studies in teaching and learning. Educational Researcher, 49(6), 433–440. https://doi.org/10.3102/0013189X20927363
17.
CalarcoJ. M.MeanwellE.AndersonE. M.KnopfA. S. (2021). By default: How mothers in different-sex dual-earner couples account for inequalities in pandemic parenting. Socius, 7, 23780231211038784. https://doi.org/10.1177/23780231211038783
18.
CampA. M.ZamarroG. (2022). Determinants of ethnic differences in school modality choices during the COVID-19 crisis. Educational Researcher, 51, 6–16.
19.
CareyR. L. (2014). A cultural analysis of the achievement gap discourse: Challenging the language and labels used in the work of school reform. Urban Education, 49(4), 440–468.
Centers for Disease Control and Prevention. (2022). COVID-19–associated hospitalizations among adults during SARS-CoV-2 delta and omicron variant predominance, by race/ethnicity and vaccination status—COVID-NET, 14 states, July 2021–January 2022. Morbidity and Mortality Weekly Report, 71, 466–473. https://www.cdc.gov/mmwr/volumes/71/wr/mm7112e2.htm
23.
ChuY. (2019). What are they talking about when they talk about equity? A content analysis of equity principles and provisions in state Every Student Succeeds Act plans. Education Policy Analysis Archives, 27(158), 1–30. https://doi.org/10.14507/epaa.27.4558
24.
ColemanJ. (1968). The concept of equality of educational opportunity. Harvard Educational Review, 38(1), 7–22.
25.
CollinsJ. E. (2021). Who wants to reopen schools in a pandemic? Explaining public preferences reopening schools and public compliance with reopening orders during the COVID-19 pandemic (EdWorkingPaper: 21-448). Annenberg Institute at Brown University. https://doi.org/10.26300/xkjk-4350
26.
CottoR.Jr.WoulfinS. (2021). Choice with (out) equity? Family decisions of child return to urban schools in pandemic. Journal of Family Diversity in Education, 4(1), 42–63.
27.
Darling-AduanaJ.WoodyardH. T.SassT. R.BarryS. S. (2022). Learning-mode choice, student engagement, and achievement growth during the COVID-19 pandemic (EdWorkingPaper: 22-536). Annenberg Institute at Brown University. https://doi.org/10.26300/jxcj-gs73
28.
DavisC. R.GroomsJ.OrtegaA.RubalcabaJ. A.-A.VargasE. (2021). Distance learning and parental mental health during COVID-19. Educational Researcher, 50(1), 61–64. https://doi.org/10.3102/0013189X20978806
29.
DeAngelisC. A.MakridisC. (2021). Are school reopening decisions related to union influence?Social Science Quarterly, 102(5), 2266–2284.
30.
DeterdingN. M.WatersM. C. (2021). Flexible coding of in-depth interviews: A twenty-first-century approach. Sociological Methods and Research, 50, 708–739. https://doi.org/10.1177/0049124118799377
31.
DiemS.YoungM. D.SampsonC. (2019). Where critical policy meets the politics of education: An introduction. Educational Policy, 33(1), 3–15. https://doi.org/10.1177/0895904818807317
32.
DiemS.YoungM. D.WeltonA. D.MansfieldK. C.LeeP. L. (2014). The intellectual landscape of critical policy analysis. International Journal of Qualitative Studies in Education, 27(9), 1068–1090. https://doi.org/10.1080/09518398.2014.916007
33.
DumasM. J. (2009). Theorizing redistribution and recognition in urban education research: How do we get dictionaries at Cleveland? In AnyonJ. (Ed.), Theory and educational research: Toward critical social explanation (pp. 82–107). Routledge.
FraserN. (1997). Justice interruptus: Critical reflections on the “postsocialist” condition. Psychology Press.
42.
FraserN. (2000). Rethinking recognition. New Left Review, 3, 107–120.
43.
FraserN. (2005). Reframing justice in a globalizing world. New Left Review, 36, 69–88.
44.
FreidusA. (2019). “A great school benefits us all”: Advantaged parents and the gentrification of an urban public school. Urban Education, 54(8), 1–28. https://doi.org/10.1177/0042085916636656
45.
FreidusA. (2020). Modes of belonging: Debating school demographics in gentrifying New York. American Educational Research Journal, 57(2), 808–839. https://doi.org/10.3102/0002831219863372
46.
FreidusA. (2022). Segregation, diversity, and pathology: School quality and student demographics in gentrifying New York. Educational Policy, 36(4), 822–848.
47.
FreidusA.EwingE. L. (2022). Good schools, bad schools: Race, school quality, and neoliberal educational policy. Educational Policy, 36(4), 763–768. https://doi.org/10.1177/08959048221087208
GrossmannM.ReckhowS.StrunkK. O.TurnerM. (2021). All states close but red districts reopen: The politics of in-person schooling during the COVID-19 pandemic. Educational Researcher, 50(9), 637–648.
52.
GuitonG.OakesJ. (1995). Opportunity to learn and conceptions of educational equality. Educational Evaluation and Policy Analysis, 17(3), 323–336.
HartneyM. T.FingerL. K. (2022). Politics, markets, and pandemics: Public education’s response to COVID-19. Perspectives on Politics, 20(2), 457–473.
56.
Herbel-EisenmannB.KeazerL.TraynorA. (2018). District decision-makers’ considerations of equity and equality related to students’ opportunities to learn algebra. Teachers College Record, 120(9), 1–38.
HodgeE. M. (2021). Conceptions of equity in common core policy messages in a metropolitan district. The Educational Forum, 85(1), 89–106. https://doi.org/10.1080/00131725.2020.1772427
59.
HorowitzJ. M. (2021). More Americans now say academic concerns should be a top factor in deciding to reopen K-12 schools. Pew Research Center. https://pewrsr.ch/2NrJlIB
60.
HorsfordS. D. (2016). Social justice for the advantaged: Freedom from racial equality post-Milliken. Teachers College Record, 118(3), 1–18.
61.
HoustonD. M.SteinbergM. P. (2022). Public support for educators and in-person instruction during the covid-19 pandemic (EdWorkingPaper: 22-575). Annenberg Institute at Brown University. https://doi.org/10.26300/ek3z-x247
62.
JencksC. (1988). Whom must we treat equally for educational opportunity to be equal?Ethics, 98(3), 518–533.
KretchmarK.BrewerT. J. (2022). Neoliberalism, COVID, anti-science, and the politics of school reopening. Education Policy Analysis Archives, 30, 42–42.
65.
Ladson-BillingsG. (2006). From the achievement gap to the education debt: Understanding achievement in US schools. Educational Researcher, 35(7), 3–12.
66.
LandivarL. C.RuppannerL.RouseL.ScarboroughW. J.CollinsC. (2022). Research note: School reopenings during the COVID-19 pandemic and implications for gender and racial equity. Demography, 59(1), 1–12.
67.
Lewis-DurhamT. C. (2020). “All lives matter”: How districts co-opt equity language and maintain the status quo. Education Policy Analysis Archives, 28, 141. https://doi.org/10.14507/epaa.28.5248
MariannoB. D.HemphillA. A.Loures-EliasA. P. S.GarciaL.CooperD.CoombesE. (2022). Power in a pandemic: Teachers’ unions and their responses to school reopening. AERA Open, 8, 1–16. https://doi.org/10.1177/23328584221074337
NygreenK. (2016). Competing paradigms of educational justice: Parent organizing for educational equity in a neoliberal reform context. Equity & Excellence in Education, 49(2), 202–214. https://doi.org/10.1080/10665684.2016.1144832
80.
OlneckM. R. (1993). Terms of inclusion: Has multiculturalism redefined equality in American education?American Journal of Education, 101(3), 234–260.
81.
OmiM.WinantH. (2015). Racial formation in the United States. Routledge.
PerrilloJ. (2012). Uncivil rights: Teachers, unions, and race in the battle for school equity. University of Chicago Press.
84.
RauscherE.BurnsA. (2021). Unequal opportunity spreaders: Higher COVID-19 deaths with later school closure in the United States. Sociological Perspectives, 64(5), 831–856. https://doi.org/10.1177/07311214211005486
85.
ReichJ.MehtaJ. (2021, July21). Healing, community, and humanity: How students and teachers want to reinvent schools post-COVID. https://doi.org/10.35542/osf.io/nd52b
SampsonC.BertrandM. (2022). “This is civil disobedience. I’ll continue”: The racialization of school board meeting rules. Journal of Education Policy, 37, 226–246.
88.
Sattin-BajajC.RodaA. (2020). Opportunity hoarding in school choice contexts: The role of policy design in promoting middle-class parents’ exclusionary behaviors. Educational Policy, 34(7), 1–44. https://doi.org/10.1177/0895904818802106
89.
ScottJ. T. (2013a). A Rosa Parks moment? School choice and the marketization of civil rights. Critical Studies in Education, 54(1), 5–18.
90.
ScottJ. T. (2013b). School choice and the empowerment imperative. Peabody Journal of Education, 88(1), 60–73.
91.
ShahV. (2018). Different numbers, different stories: Problematizing “gaps” in Ontario and the TDSB. Canadian Journal of Educational Administration and Policy, 187, 31–47.
SingerJ.MarshJ. A.Menefee-LibeyD.AlonsoJ.BradleyDTracyH. (2022). The politics of School reopening during COVID-19: A multiple case study of five Urban Districts in the 2020-21 School Year. (EdWorkingPaper No. 22-605). Annenberg Institute at Brown University. https://doi.org/10.26300/0bke-pz42
97.
StoneD. A. (1997). Policy paradox: The art of political decision making. W.W. Norton.
98.
StoutR. T.TallericoM.ScribnerK. P. (1994). Values: The “what?” of the politics of education. Journal of Education Policy, 9(5), 5–20.
TavoryI.TimmermansS. (2014). Abductive analysis: Theorizing qualitative research. University of Chicago Press.
101.
ThompsonC. N.BaumgartnerJ.PichardoC.ToroB.LiL.ArciuoloR.. . . FineA. (2020). COVID-19 outbreak—New York City, February 29–June 1, 2020. Morbidity and Mortality Weekly Report, 69, 1725–1729. http://doi.org/10.15585/mmwr.mm6946a2
102.
TrujilloT.MollerJ.JensenR.KissellR. E.LarsenE. (2021). Images of educational leadership: How principals make sense of democracy and social justice in two distinct policy contexts. Educational Administration Quarterly, 57(4), 536–569.
103.
TurnerE. O. (2015). Districts’ responses to demographic change: Making sense of race, class and immigration in political and organizational context. American Educational Research Journal, 52(1), 4–39.
104.
TurnerE. O. (2020a). Equity in pandemic schooling: An action guide for families, educators, and communities. Lapham-Marquette Equity in Action Committee. https://tinyurl.com/EquityGuidePandemicSchooling
105.
TurnerE. O. (2020b). Suddenly diverse: How school districts manage race and inequality. University of Chicago Press.
106.
TurnerE. O.BenekeA. J. (2020). “Softening” school resource officers: The extension of police presence in schools in an era of black lives matter, school shootings, and rising inequality. Race, Ethnicity, and Education, 23(2), 221–240.
107.
TurnerE. O.SpainA. K. (2020). The multiple meanings of (in)equity: Remaking school district tracking policy in an era of budget cuts and accountability. Urban Education, 55(5), 783–812.
VargasN.MoraG. C.GleesonS. (2021). Race and ideology in a pandemic: White privilege and patterns of risk perception during COVID-19. Social Problems. Advance online publication. https://doi.org/10.1093/socpro/spab037
WelnerK. G.CarterP. L. (2013). Achievement gaps arise from opportunity gaps. In CarterP. L.WelnerK. G. (Eds.), Closing the opportunity gap: What America must do to give every child an even chance (pp. 1–10). Oxford University Press.
