Teachers’ sensemaking of student behavior determines whether students get in trouble and are formally disciplined. Status categories, such as race, can influence perceptions of student culpability, but the degree to which teachers’ initial identification of student misbehavior exacerbates racial disproportionality in discipline receipt is unknown. This study provides the first systematic documentation of teachers’ use of office discipline referrals (ODRs) in a large, diverse urban school district in California that specifies the identity of both the referred and referring individuals in all ODRs. We identify teachers exhibiting extensive referring behavior, or the top 5% referrers, based on the number of ODRs they make in a given year and evaluate their contributions to disciplinary disparities. We find that “top referrers” effectively double the racial gaps in ODRs for both Black-White and Hispanic-White comparisons. These gaps are mainly driven by higher numbers of ODRs issued for Black and Hispanic students due to interpersonal offences and defiance and also partially convert to racial gaps in suspensions. Both the level and racial compositions of the school sites where top referrers serve and their personal traits seem to explain some of their frequent referring behavior. Targeting supports and interventions to top referrers might afford an important opportunity to reduce racial disciplinary gaps.
AllenQ. (2017). “They write me off and don’t give me a chance to learn anything”: Positioning, discipline, and Black masculinities in school. Anthropology & Education Quarterly, 48(3), 269–283. https://doi.org/10.1111/aeq.12199
2.
American Psychological Association. (2008). Are zero tolerance policies effective in the schools?: An evidentiary review and recommendations. American Psychologist, 63(9), 852–862. https://doi.org/10.1037/0003-066X.63.9.852
3.
AndersonK.RitterG. (2016). Disparate use of exclusionary discipline: Evidence on inequities in school discipline from a U.S. state (SSRN Scholarly Paper No. 2838464). https://papers.ssrn.com/abstract=2838464
4.
AtilesJ. T.GreshamT. M.WashburnI. (2017). Values and beliefs regarding discipline practices: How school culture impacts teacher responses to student misbehavior. Educational Research Quarterly, 40(3), 3–24.
5.
Bacher-HicksA.BillingsS. B.DemingD. J. (2019). The school to prison pipeline: Long-run impacts of school suspensions on adult crime. National Bureau of Economic Research.
6.
BarrettN.McEachinA.MillsJ. N.ValantJ. (2021). Disparities and discrimination in student discipline by race and family income. Journal of Human Resources, 56(3), 711–748.
7.
BellC.PuckettT. (2020). I want to learn but they won’t let me: Exploring the impact of school discipline on academic achievement. Urban Education. Advance online publisher. https://doi.org/10.1177/0042085920968629
8.
BlakeJ. J.ButlerB. R.LewisC. W.DarensbourgA. (2011). Unmasking the inequitable discipline experiences of urban Black girls: Implications for urban educational stakeholders. The Urban Review, 43(1), 90–106. https://doi.org/10.1007/s11256-009-0148-8
9.
BradshawC. P.MitchellM. M.O’BrennanL. M.LeafP. J. (2010). Multilevel exploration of factors contributing to the overrepresentation of Black students in office disciplinary referrals. Journal of Educational Psychology, 102(2), 508–520. https://doi.org/10.1037/a0018450
10.
Children’s Defense Fund. (1975). School suspensions: Are they helping children. Washington Research Project.
11.
ChoV.MansfieldK. C.ClaughtonJ. (2020). The past and future technology in classroom management and school discipline: A systematic review. Teaching and Teacher Education, 90, Article 103037. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.tate.2020.103037
12.
ChuE. M.ReadyD. D. (2018). Exclusion and urban public high schools: Short- and long-term consequences of school suspensions. American Journal of Education, 124(4), 479–509.
13.
CookC. R.DuongM. T.McIntoshK.FiatA. E.LarsonM.PullmannM. D.McGinnisJ. (2018). Addressing discipline disparities for Black male students: Linking malleable root causes to feasible and effective practices. School Psychology Review, 47(2), 135–152.
14.
CruzR. A.KulkarniS. S.FirestoneA. R. (2021). A quantcrit analysis of context, discipline, special education, and disproportionality. AERA Open, 7. https://doi.org/10.1177/23328584211041354
15.
CurranF. C. (2020). A matter of measurement: How different ways of measuring racial gaps in school discipline can yield drastically different conclusions about racial disparities in discipline. Educational Researcher, 49(5), 382–387.
16.
Darling-HammondS.FroniusT. (2022). Restorative practices in schools. In SabornieE. J.EspelageD. L. (Eds.), Handbook of classroom management (pp. 54–73). Routledge.
17.
DavisonM.PennerA. M.PennerE. K. (2022). Restorative for all? Racial disproportionality and school discipline under restorative justice. American Educational Research Journal, 59(4), 687–718.
18.
DavisonM.PennerA. M.PennerE. K.Pharris-CiurejN.PorterS. R.RoseE. K.Shem-TovY.YooP. (2021). School discipline and racial disparities in early adulthood. Educational Researcher, 51(3), 231–234. https://doi.org/10.3102/0013189x211061732
GansenH. M. (2021). Disciplining difference(s): Reproducing inequalities through disciplinary interactions in preschool. Social Problems, 68(3), 740–760.
21.
GershensonS.HartC. M.HymanJ.LindsayC. A.PapageorgeN. W. (2022). The long-run impacts of same-race teachers. American Economic Journal: Economic Policy, 14(4), 300–342.
22.
GilliamW. S.MaupinA. N.ReyesC. R.AccavittiM.ShicF. (2016). Do early educators’ implicit biases regarding sex and race relate to behavior expectations and recommendations of preschool expulsions and suspensions. Yale University Child Study Center, 9(28), 1–16.
23.
GionC.McIntoshK.FalconS. (2022). Effects of a multifaceted classroom intervention on racial disproportionality. School Psychology Review, 51(1), 67–83.
24.
GionC.McIntoshK.SmolkowskiK. (2018). Examination of American Indian/Alaska Native school discipline disproportionality using the vulnerable decision points approach. Behavioral Disorders, 44(1), 40–52.
25.
GirvanE. J.GionC.McIntoshK.SmolkowskiK. (2017). The relative contribution of subjective office referrals to racial disproportionality in school discipline. School Psychology Quarterly, 32(3), 392–404. https://doi.org/10.1037/spq0000178
26.
GirvanE. J.McIntoshK.Santiago-RosarioM. R. (2021). Associations between community-level racial biases, office discipline referrals, and out-of-school suspensions. School Psychology Review, 50(2–3), 288–302. https://doi.org/10.1080/2372966X.2020.1838232
27.
GirvanE. J.McIntoshK.SmolkowskiK. (2019). Tail, tusk, and trunk: What different metrics reveal about racial disproportionality in school discipline. Educational Psychologist, 54(1), 40–59.
GottfredsonG. D.GottfredsonD. C.PayneA. A.GottfredsonN. C. (2005). School climate predictors of school disorder: Results from a national study of delinquency prevention in schools. Journal of Research in Crime and Delinquency, 42(4), 412–444. https://doi.org/10.1177/0022427804271931
30.
GregoryA.HuangF. L.AnyonY.GreerE.DowningB. (2018). An examination of restorative interventions and racial equity in out-of-school suspensions. School Psychology Review, 47(2), 167–182.
31.
GregoryA.MoselyP. M. (2004). The discipline gap: Teachers’ views on the over-representation of African American students in the discipline system. Equity & Excellence in Education, 37(1), 18–30.
32.
GregoryA.RobertsG. (2017). Teacher beliefs and the overrepresentation of Black students in classroom discipline. Theory Into Practice, 56(3), 187–194. https://doi.org/10.1080/00405841.2017.1336035
33.
GregoryA.SkibaR. J.NogueraP. A. (2010). The achievement gap and the discipline gap: Two sides of the same coin?Educational Researcher, 39(1), 59–68. https://doi.org/10.3102/0013189X09357621
34.
GregoryA.WeinsteinR. S. (2008). The discipline gap and African Americans: Defiance or cooperation in the high school classroom. Journal of School Psychology, 46(4), 455–475.
35.
GriffithD.TynerA. (2019). Discipline reform through the eyes of teachers. Thomas B. Fordham Institute.
36.
HashimA. K.StrunkK. O.DhaliwalT. K. (2018). Justice for all? Suspension bans and restorative justice programs in the Los Angeles Unified School District. Peabody Journal of Education, 93(2), 174–189.
37.
HayesM. S.LiuJ.GershensonS. (2023). Who refers whom? The effects of teacher characteristics on disciplinary office referrals. Economics of Education Review, 93, Article 102376. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.econedurev.2023.102376
38.
HeilbrunA.CornellD.KonoldT. (2018). Authoritative school climate and suspension rates in middle schools: Implications for reducing the racial disparity in school discipline. Journal of School Violence, 17(3), 324–338. https://doi.org/10.1080/15388220.2017.1368395
39.
HoltS.GershensonS. (2019). The impact of demographic representation on absences and suspensions. Policy Studies Journal, 47(4), 1069–1099.
40.
HoltS.VinopalK.ChoiH.SorensenL. (2022). Strictly speaking: Examining teacher use of punishment and student outcomes [SSRN Scholarly Paper]. http://dx.doi.org/10.2139/ssrn.4093118
41.
HwangN. (2018). Suspensions and achievement: Varying links by type, frequency, and subgroup. Educational Researcher, 47(6), 363–374. https://doi.org/10.3102/0013189X18779579
42.
HwangN.PennerEmily K.DavisonMilesSanabriaTanyaHanselmanPaulDominaThurstonPennerAndrew M. (2022). Reining in punitive discipline: Recent trends in exclusionary school discipline disparities. Socious, 8. https://doi.org/10.1177/23780231221103044
43.
JarvisS. N.OkonofuaJ. A. (2020). School deferred: When bias affects school leaders. Social Psychological and Personality Science, 11(4), 492–498.
44.
KimC. Y. (2011). Policing school discipline. Brooklyn Law Review, 77(3), 861–904.
LacoeJ.SteinbergM. P. (2019). Do suspensions affect student outcomes?Educational Evaluation and Policy Analysis, 41(1), 34–62.
47.
LewisA. E.DiamondJ. B. (2015). Despite the best intentions: How racial inequality thrives in good schools. Oxford University Press.
48.
LindsayC. A.HartC. M. D. (2017). Exposure to same-race teachers and student disciplinary outcomes for Black students in North Carolina. Educational Evaluation and Policy Analysis, 39(3), 485–510. https://doi.org/10.3102/0162373717693109
49.
LiuJ.HayesM. S.GershensonS. (2022). JUE insight: From referrals to suspensions: New evidence on racial disparities in exclusionary discipline. Journal of Urban Economics. Advance online publication. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jue.2022.103453
50.
LosenD. J.HodsonC. L.KeithI. I.MAM. (2015). Are we closing the school discipline gap. UCLA: The Civil Rights Project/Proyecto Derechos Civiles.
51.
McCarthyJ. D.HogeD. R. (1987). The social construction of school punishment: Racial disadvantage out of universalistic process. Social Forces, 65 (4), 1101–1120.
52.
McIntoshK.GirvanE. J.HornerR.SmolkowskiK. (2014). Education not incarceration: A conceptual model for reducing racial and ethnic disproportionality in school discipline. Journal of Applied Research on Children: Informing Policy for Children at Risk, 5(2), Article 4. http://digitalcommons.library.tmc.edu/childrenatrisk/vol5/iss2/4
53.
MendezL. M. R.KnoffH. M.FerronJ. M. (2002). School demographic variables and out-of-school suspension rates: A quantitative and qualitative analysis of a large, ethnically diverse school district. Psychology in the Schools, 39 (3), 259–277. https://doi.org/10.1002/pits.10020
MittlemanJ. (2018). A downward spiral? Childhood suspension and the path to juvenile arrest. Sociology of Education, 91(3), 183–204.
56.
NealL. V. I.McCrayA. D.Webb-JohnsonG.BridgestS. T. (2003). The effects of African American movement styles on teachers’ perceptions and reactions. Journal of Special Education, 37(1), 49–57. https://doi.org/10.1177/00224669030370010501
57.
NishiokaV.MerrillB.HansonH. (2021). Changes in exclusionary and nonexclusionary discipline in grades k-5 following state policy reform in Oregon. U.S. Department of Education, Institute of Education Sciences, National Center for Education Evaluation and Regional Assistance, and Regional Educational Laboratory Northwest. https://ies.ed.gov/ncee/rel/Products/Region/northwest/Publication/4044
58.
NishiokaV.ShigeokaS.LolichE. (2017). School discipline data indicators: A guide for districts and schools. U.S. Department of Education, Institute of Education Sciences, National Center for Education Evaluation and Regional Assistance, and Regional Educational Laboratory Northwest. https://ies.ed.gov/ncee/edlabs/regions/northwest/pdf/REL_2017240.pdf
59.
NoltemeyerA. L.McloughlinC. S. (2010). Patterns of exclusionary discipline by school typology, ethnicity, and their interaction. Penn GSE Perspectives on Urban Education, 7(1), 27–40.
60.
NoltemeyerA. L.WardR. M.McloughlinC. (2015). Relationship between school suspension and student outcomes: A meta-analysis. School Psychology Review, 44(2), 224–240.
61.
OkonofuaJ. A.EberhardtJ. L. (2015). Two strikes race and the disciplining of young students. Psychological Science, 26(5), 617–624.
62.
OkonofuaJ. A.PauneskuD.WaltonG. M. (2016). Brief intervention to encourage empathic discipline cuts suspension rates in half among adolescents. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, 113(19), 5221–5226.
63.
OkonofuaJ. A.WaltonG. M.EberhardtJ. L. (2016). A vicious cycle: A social-psychological account of extreme racial disparities in school discipline. Perspectives on Psychological Science, 11(3), 381–398.
64.
OwensJ. (2022). Double jeopardy: Teacher biases, racialized organizations, and the production of racial/ethnic disparities in school discipline. American Sociological Review, 87(6), 1007–1048.
65.
OwensJ.McLanahanS. S. (2020). Unpacking the drivers of racial disparities in school suspension and expulsion. Social Forces, 98(4), 1548–1577. https://doi.org/10.1093/sf/soz095
66.
PearmanF. A.CurranF. C.FisherB.GardellaJ. (2019). Are achievement gaps related to discipline gaps? Evidence from national data. Aera Open, 5(4). https://doi.org/10.1177/2332858419875440
67.
PiqueroA. R. (2008). Disproportionate minority contact. The Future of Children, 18(2), 59–79.
68.
RiosV. M. (2011). Punished: Policing the lives of Black and Latino boys. NYU Press.
69.
RodriguezL. A.WelshR. O. (2022). The dimensions of school discipline: Toward a comprehensive framework for measuring discipline patterns and outcomes in schools. AERA Open, 8. https://doi.org/10.1177/23328584221083669
70.
Santiago-RosarioM. R.WhitcombS. A.PearlmanJ.McIntoshK. (2021). Associations between teacher expectations and racial disproportionality in discipline referrals. Journal of School Psychology, 85, 80–93. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jsp.2021.02.004
71.
SheddC. (2015). Unequal city: Race, schools, and perceptions of injustice. Russell Sage Foundation.
72.
ShirrellM.BristolT. J.BrittonT. A. (2021). The effects of student-teacher ethno-racial matching on exclusionary discipline for Asian American, Black, and Latinx students: Evidence from New York City (Working Paper no. 21-475). Annenberg Institute for School Reform at Brown University.
73.
SkibaR. J.ChungC.-G.TrachokM.BakerT. L.SheyaA.HughesR. L. (2014). Parsing disciplinary disproportionality: Contributions of infraction, student, and school characteristics to out-of-school suspension and expulsion. American Educational Research Journal, 51(4), 640–670.
74.
SkibaR. J.HornerR. H.ChungC.-G.RauschM. K.MayS. L.TobinT. (2011). Race is not neutral: A national investigation of African American and Latino disproportionality in school discipline. School Psychology Review, 40(1), 85–107.
75.
SkibaR. J.MichaelR. S.NardoA. C.PetersonR. L. (2002). The color of discipline: Sources of racial and gender disproportionality in school punishment. The Urban Review, 34(4), 317–342.
76.
SmolkowskiK.GirvanE. J.McintoshK.NeseR. N. T.HornerR. H. (2016). Vulnerable decision points for disproportionate office discipline referrals: Comparisons of discipline for African American and White elementary school students. Behavioral Disorders, 41(4), 178–195. https://doi.org/10.17988/bedi-41-04-178-195.1
77.
SorensenL. C.BushwayS. D.GiffordE. J. (2022). Getting tough? The effects of discretionary principal discipline on student outcomes. Education Finance and Policy, 17(2), 255–284. https://doi.org/10.1162/edfpa00341
78.
StoiberK. C.GettingerM. (2016). Multi-tiered systems of support and evidence-based practices. In JimersonS. R.BurnsM. K.VanDerHeydenA. M. (Eds.), Handbook of response to intervention (pp. 121–141). Springer.
WelshR. O. (2023). Navigating tensions in school discipline: Examining school leaders, teachers, and the conversion of referrals into suspensions. American Journal of Education, 129(2). https://doi.org/10.1086/723064
85.
WelshR. O.SwainW. A. (2020). (Re)defining urban education: A conceptual review and empirical exploration of the definition of urban education. Educational Researcher, 49(2), 90–100.
86.
WileyK. E. (2021). A tale of two logics: School discipline and racial disparities in a “mostly White” middle school. American Journal of Education, 127(2), 163–192.
87.
WuS.-C.PinkW.CrainR.MolesO. (1982). Student suspension: A critical reappraisal. The Urban Review, 14(4), 245–303. https://doi.org/10.1007/BF02171974
88.
ZakszeskiB.RutherfordL.HeidelburgK.ThomasL. (2021). In pursuit of equity: Discipline disproportionality and SWPBIS implementation in urban schools. School Psychology, 36(2), 122–130. https://doi.org/10.1037/spq0000428
89.
ZimmermannC. R. (2018). The penalty of being a young Black girl: Kindergarten teachers’ perceptions of children’s problem behaviors and student–teacher conflict by the intersection of race and gender. The Journal of Negro Education, 87(2), 154–168.
90.
ZimmermanR. S.KhouryE. L.VegaW. A.GilA. G.WarheitG. J. (1995). Teacher and parent perceptions of behavior problems among a sample of African American, Hispanic, and non-Hispanic White students. American Journal of Community Psychology, 23(2), 181–197. https://doi.org/10.1007/BF02506935
Supplementary Material
Please find the following supplemental material available below.
For Open Access articles published under a Creative Commons License, all supplemental material carries the same license as the article it is associated with.
For non-Open Access articles published, all supplemental material carries a non-exclusive license, and permission requests for re-use of supplemental material or any part of supplemental material shall be sent directly to the copyright owner as specified in the copyright notice associated with the article.
