Sage Journals: Discover world-class research

Abstract

Given that a national superintendent dataset has never existed, claims about superintendent turnover and gender gaps have traditionally been based on conjecture or data from a single year and small sample of superintendents. Utilizing a new dataset of all K–12 public school district superintendents in the United States across four school years, this study explores how the superintendent gender gap and turnover have changed over time and across states and district types. Analyses reveal that superintendent turnover has increased, particularly among men, and the superintendent gender gap has marginally narrowed. Although men are increasingly turning over, women are seldom filling those positions—a necessity if the superintendent gender gap is to narrow. State and district analyses are presented, as well as discussion of the implications of the findings and the power of a longitudinal superintendent dataset.

Keywords

administration correlational analysis descriptive analysis diversity gender leadership superintendent turnover women’s issues

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Adukia

Eble

Harrison

Runesha

H. B.

Szasz

(2022). What we teach about race and gender: Representation in images and text of children’s books. [NBER Working Paper 29123]. National Bureau of Economic Research.

Aldeman

(2022). There is no “big quit” in K-12 education. But schools have specific labor challenges that need targeted solutions. The 74 Million.

Alsbrooks

(2022). Spotsylvania school board fires superintendent without cause as new, outspoken chair takes over. WTOP Virginia. https://wtop.com/virginia/2022/01/spotsylvania-school-board-chair-who-called-for-book-burning-ousts-superintendent/

Alston

(1996). Black female school superintendents and success: A study of perceptions regarding constraints and facilitators encountered en route to the superintendency. [Unpublished doctoral dissertation, Pennsylvania State University].

Alston

(1999). Climbing hills and mountains: Black females making it to the superintendency. In Brunner

C. C.

(Ed.), Sacred dreams: Women and the superintendency (pp. 79–90). State University of New York Press.

Alston

(2000). Missing from action: Where are the black female school superintendents? Urban Education, 35(5), 525–531.

Anderson

(2021). Harvard EdCast: The superintendency and culture wars. Harvard Graduate School of Education. https://www.gse.harvard.edu/news/22/10/harvard-edcast-superintendency-and-culture-wars

Bartanen

Grissom

J. A.

(2021). School principal race, teacher racial diversity, and student achievement. Journal of Human Resources, 46(1), 26–52.

Beekley

(1999). “Dancing in red shoes”: Why women leave the superintendency. In Brunner

C. C.

(Ed.). Sacred Dreams: Women and the superintendency (pp. 161–175). State University of New York Press.

10.

Bell

(1998). Organizational influences on women’s experience in the superintendency. Peabody Journal of Education, 65(4), 31–59.

11.

Bell

(2005). Women-led firms and the gender gap in top executive jobs. IZA Discussion Paper, 1689. https://www.iza.org/publications/dp/1689/women-led-firms-and-the-gender-gap-in-top-executive-jobs

12.

Björk

L. G.

(2000). Introduction: Women in the superintendency—Advancements in research and theory. Educational Administration Quarterly, 36(1), 5–17.

13.

Blau

F. D.

Kahn

L. M.

(2017). The gender wage gap: Extent, trends, and explanations. Journal of Economic Literature, 55(3), 789–865.

14.

Bleiberg

Kraft

M. A.

(2022). What happened to the K-12 education labor market during COVID? The acute need for better data systems. Brown University Ed Working Paper No. 22-544.

15.

Blount

(1998). Destined to rule schools: Women and the superintendency. 1873-1995. State University of New York Press.

16.

Bos

A. L.

Greenlee

J. S.

Holman

M. R.

Oxley

Z. M.

Lay

J. C.

(2022). This one’s for the boys: How gendered political socialization limits girls’ political ambition and interest. American Political Science Review, 116(2), 484–501.

17.

Brunner

C. C.

(1997). Working through the “riddle of the heart”: Perspectives of women superintendents. Journal of School Leadership, 7(2), 138–164.

18.

Brunner

C. C.

Grogan

(2007). Women leading school systems: Uncommon roads to fulfillment. Rowman & Littlefield Education.

19.

Carver-Thomas

(2018). Diversifying the teaching profession. Learning Policy Institute.

20.

Castro

Germain

Gooden

(2018). Increasing diversity in K-12 school leadership (Policy Brief 2018-3). University Council for Educational Administration.

21.

Chase

S. E.

Bell

C. S.

(1990). Ideology, discourse, and gender: How gatekeepers talk about women school superintendents. Social Problems, 37(2), 163–177.

22.

Council of Great City Schools. (2003). Superintendents: Characteristics, tenure, and salary. Urban Indicator, 7(1).

23.

DeMatthews

D. E.

Aylward

Knight

Reyes

(2023). The Texas superintendent report: A ten-year analysis of district leadership. Holdsworth Center.

24.

Dillard

C. B.

(1995). Leading with her life: An African American feminist (re)interpretation of leadership for an urban high school principal. Educational Administration Quarterly, 31(4), 539–563.

25.

Duncan

(2022). Addressing teacher shortages in the short- and long-term. The Education Trust.

26.

Eagly

A. H.

Karau

S. J.

(2002). Role congruity theory of prejudice toward female leaders. Psychological Review, 109(3), 573–598.

27.

Egalite

A. J.

Kisida

Winters

M. A.

(2015). Representation in the classroom: The effect of own-race teachers on student achievement. Economics of Education Review, 45, 44–52.

28.

Frankel

(2021). Rural Oregon school superintendent fired after enforcing state mask mandate. The Oregonian. https://www.oregonlive.com/education/2021/08/rural-oregon-school-superintendent-fired-after-enforcing-state-mask-mandate.html

29.

Fung

(2021). The great exodus: Superintendents resigned in droves as culture wars hit schools in 2021. Newsweek.

30.

García

Weiss

(2020). A policy agenda to address the teacher shortage in U.S. public schools. Economic Policy Institute.

31.

Gardiner

M. E.

Enomoto

Grogan

(2000). Coloring outside the lines: Mentoring women in school leadership. State University of New York Press.

32.

Gershenson

Hart

C. M. D.

Lindsay

C. A.

Papageorge

N. W.

(2017). The long run effects of same-race teachers (IZA Discussion Paper No. 10630). http://ftp.iza.org/dp10630.pdf

33.

Gilreath

(2021, November 3). Do fraught school board meetings offer a view of the future? The Hechinger Report. https://hechingerreport.org/do-fraught-school-board-meetings-offer-a-view-of-the-future/

34.

Glass

T. E.

(2020). Where are all the women superintendents? AASA. https://aasa.org/schooladministratorarticle.aspx?id=14492

35.

Glass

T. E.

Björk

Brunner

C. C.

(2000). The study of the American school superintendency, 2000: A look at the superintendent of education in the new millennium. AASA.

36.

Goff

Rodriguez-Escutia

Yang

(2018). Through the labor market looking glass: An inquiry into principal-teacher race congruence. (Working Paper No. 2018-13). WCER.

37.

Goldhaber

Theobald

(2022). Teacher attrition and mobility over time. Educational Researcher, 51(5), 235–237.

38.

Goldin

(2014). A grand gender convergence: Its last chapter. American Economic Review, 104(4), 1091–1119.

39.

Green

(2021). Black Lives Matter, she wrote, and then “everything just imploded.” The New York Times. https://www.nytimes.com/2021/10/10/us/politics/maryland-superintendent-racism-black-lives-matter.html

40.

Grissom

J. A.

Andersen

(2012). Why superintendents turn over. American Educational Research Journal, 49(6), 1146–1180.

41.

Grissom

J. A.

Mitani

(2016). Salary, performance, and superintendent turnover. Educational Administration Quarterly, 52(3), 351–391.

42.

Grissom

Rodriguez

Kern

(2017). Teacher and principal diversity and the representation of students of color in gifted programs. The Elementary School Journal, 117(3), 396–422.

43.

Grogan

(1996). Voices of women aspiring to the superintendency. State University of New York Press.

44.

Grogan

(1999). Equity/equality issues of gender, race, and class. Educational Administration Quarterly, 35(4), 518–536.

45.

Grogan

(2000). Laying the groundwork for a reconception of the superintendency from feminist postmodern perspectives. Educational Administration Quarterly, 36(1), 117–142.

46.

Grogan

Brunner

C. C.

(2005). Women leading systems: Latest facts and figures on women and the superintendency. The School Administrator, 62(2), 46–50.

47.

Grogan

Henry

(1995). Women candidates for the superintendency: Board perspectives. In Irby

B. J.

Brown

(Eds.), Women as school executives: Voices and visions (pp. 164–174). Texas Association of School Administrators and Texas Council of Women School Executives.

48.

Grogan

Smith

(1998). A feminist perspective of women superintendents’ approaches to moral dilemmas. Just and Caring Education, 4(2), 176–192.

49.

Gupton

S. L.

Slick

G. A.

(1995). Women leaders: Who are they are how do they compare? In Irby

B. J.

Brown

(Eds.), Women as school executives: Voices and visions (pp. 6–14). Texas Association of School Administrators and Texas Council of Women School Executives.

50.

Guvenen

Kaplan

Song

(2020). The glass ceiling and the paper floor: Gender differences among top earners, 1981-2012. NBER Macroeconomics Annual 2020, Volume 35. University of Chicago Press.

51.

Hudson

Wesson

Marcano

(1998). What women of color bring to school leadership. In Irby

Brown

(Eds.), Women leaders: Structuring success (pp. 43–49). Kendall/Hunt.

52.

ILO Group. (2022). The superintendent research project. https://www.ilogroup.com/wp-content/uploads/2022/12/The-Superintendent-Research-Project_Dec-2022-Update.pdf

53.

Irby

B. J.

Brown

(Eds). (1995). Women as school executives: Voices and visions. Texas Association of School Administrators & Texas Council of Women School Executives.

54.

Jackson

(1999). Against all odds: African-American women school superintendents. In Brunner

C. C.

(Ed.), Sacred dreams: Women and the superintendency (pp. 141–160). State University of New York Press.

55.

Joshi

Doan

Springer

M. G.

(2018). Student-teacher race congruence: New evidence and insight from Tennessee. AERA Open, 4(4).

56.

Kamler

Shakeshaft

(1999). The role of the search consultant in the career paths of women. In Brunner

(Ed.), Sacred dreams: Women and the superintendency (pp. 51–62). State University of New York Press.

57.

Keller

Molina

Olney

W. W.

(2020). The gender gap among top business executives. NBER Working Paper 28216.

58.

Kim

Brunner

(2009). School administrators’ career mobility to the superintendency: Gender differences in career development. Journal of Educational Administration, 47(1), 75–107.

59.

Kingkade

(2021). Critical race theory battles are driving frustrated, exhausted educators out of their jobs. NBC News. https://www.nbcnews.com/news/us-news/critical-race-theory-battles-are-driving-frustrated-exhausted-educators-out-n1273595

60.

Klasik

Zahran

(2022). The art of sophisticated quantitative description in higher education research. In Perna

L. W.

(Ed.), Higher education: Handbook of theory and research: Vol 37 (pp. 649–743). Springer.

61.

Kowalski

T. J.

McCord

R. S.

Peterson

G. J.

Young

I. P.

Ellerson

N. M.

(2000). American School Superintendent: 2010 Decennial Study. AASA.

62.

Krivkovich

Liu

W. W.

Nguyen

Rambachan

Robinson

Williams

Yee

(2022). Women in the workplace 2022. McKinsey & Company.

63.

Lindsay

Monarrez

Luetmer

(2021). The effects of teacher diversity on Hispanic student achievement in Texas. Urban Institute.

64.

Loeb

Dynarski

McFarland

Morris

Reardon

Reber

(2017, March). Descriptive analysis in education: A guide for researchers. (NCEE 2017-4023). U.S. Department of Education, Institute of Education Sciences, National Center for Education Evaluation and Regional Assistance.

65.

Mahitivanichcha

Rorrer

A. K.

(2006). Women’s choices within market constraints: Re-visioning access to participation in the superintendency. Educational Administration Quarterly, 42(4), 483–517.

66.

Marietti

Stout

(1994). School boards that hire women superintendents. Urban Education, 28(4), 373–385.

67.

Marshall

Patterson

J. A.

Rogers

D. L.

Steel

J. R.

(1996). Caring as career: An alternative perspective for educational administration. Educational Administration Quarterly, 32(2), 271–294.

68.

McDole

Francies

(2022). State policy levers to address teacher shortages. Education Commission of the States.

69.

McMurdock

(2022). Fears of a school superintendent exodus: With data revealing massive pandemic turnover, new survey shows another 1 in 4 leaders expect to “leave soon.” The 74 Million.

70.

Miskel

Cosgrove

(1985). Leader succession in school settings. Review of Educational Research, 55(1), 87–105.

71.

National Academies of Sciences. (2017). Communities in action: Pathways to health equity. National Academies Press. https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/books/NBK425845/

72.

National School Boards Association Council of Urban Boards of Education [CUBE]. (2002). Survey Report: Superintendent Tenure. https://files.eric.ed.gov/fulltext/ED460201.pdf

73.

National Center for Education Statistics [NCES]. (1998). State comparisons of education statistics: 1969-70 to 1996-97. https://nces.ed.gov/pubs98/98018.pdf

74.

National Center for Education Statistics [NCES]. (2018). Common Core of Data: Local education agency (school district) universe survey data (v.1a). https://nces.ed.gov/ccd/files.asp

75.

National Center for Education Statistics [NCES]. (2022a). National teacher and principal survey. https://nces.ed.gov/surveys/ntps/

76.

National Center for Education Statistics [NCES]. (2022b). Schools and staffing survey. https://nces.ed.gov/surveys/sass/

77.

Natkin

G. L.

Cooper

B. S.

Alborano

J. A.

Padilla

Ghosh

S. K.

(2002). Predicting and modeling superintendent turnover. Journal of School Leadership, 13(3), 328–346.

78.

New Schools Venture Fund. (n.d.). Diverse leaders overview. https://www.newschools.org/what-we-fund/diverse-leaders/

79.

Ng Ellerson

Rogers

Starr

Tienken

C. H

. (2020). American Superintendent 2020 Decennial Study. AASA.

80.

Noddings

(1984). Caring: A feminine approach to ethics and moral education. University of California Press.

81.

O’Dea

(2019). Lawmakers seek diversity among NJ’s public school teachers. NY Spotlight News.

82.

Paradies

(2006). A systematic review of empirical research on self-reported racism and health. International Journal of Epidemiology, 35(4), 888–901.

83.

Power

(2020). The COVID-19 pandemic has increased the care burden of women and families. Sustainability: Science, Practice and Policy, 16(1), 67–63.

84.

Revere

A. B.

(1987). Black women superintendents in the United States: 1984-85. The Journal of Negro Education, 56(4), 510–520.

85.

Richards

Wong

(2022). Students walk out, superintendents stress and parents rage: What’s happening as some school boards become more political? USA Today. https://www.usatoday.com/story/news/education/2022/02/19/school-board-politics-fuels-conflict-douglas-county-colorado/6831758001/?gnt-cfr=1

86.

Robinson

K. K.

(2016). What have we learned from departures of female superintendents? Journal of Women in Educational Leadership, 72. https://digitalcommons.unl.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=1075&context=jwel

87.

Robinson

K. K.

Shakeshaft

(2015). Women superintendents who leave: Stress and health factors. Planning and Changing, 46(3–4), 440–458.

88.

Robinson

Shakeshaft

Grogan

Newcomb

W. S.

(2017). Necessary but not sufficient: The continuing inequality between men and women in educational leadership. Findings from the American Association of School Administrators mid-decade survey. Frontiers in Education, 2(12). https://doi.org/10.3389/feduc.2017.00012

89.

Rudman

L. A.

Moss-Racusin

C. A.

Phelan

J. E.

Nauts

(2012). Status incongruity and backlash effects: Defending the gender hierarchy motivates prejudice against female leaders. Journal of Experimental Social Psychology, 48, 165–179.

90.

Sawchuk

(2021a, May 6). Has COVID-19 led to a mass exodus of superintendents? Education Week. https://www.edweek.org/leadership/has-covid-19-led-to-a-mass-exodus-of-superintendents/2021/05

91.

Sawchuk

(2021b, May 7). Wanted: Superintendents to lead districts through the end of the pandemic. Education Week. https://www.edweek.org/leadership/wanted-superintendents-to-lead-districts-through-a-pandemic/2021/05

92.

Sawchuk

(2022a, February 28). Superintendent turnover is a real thing. How bad it is? Education Week. https://www.edweek.org/leadership/superintendent-turnover-is-a-real-thing-how-bad-is-it/2022/02

93.

Sawchuk

(2022b, March 10). Why aren’t there more women superintendents? Education Week. https://www.edweek.org/leadership/why-arent-there-more-women-superintendents/2022/03

94.

Schwartz

H. L.

Diliberti

M. K.

(2022a). Flux in the educator labor market: Acute staff shortages and projected superintendent departures. RAND Corporation.

95.

Schwartz

H. L.

Diliberti

M. K.

(2022b). State of the superintendent. RAND Corporation.

96.

Schwartz

S. A.

(2020). Police brutality and racism in America. Explore, 16(5), 280–282.

97.

Scott

H. J.

(1990). Views of Black school superintendents on Black consciousness and professionalism. The Journal of Negro Education, 59(2), 165–172.

98.

Selsky

(2021). After banning teachers from displaying diversity symbols, Oregon school board fires superintendent. PBS NewsHour. https://www.pbs.org/newshour/education/after-banning-teachers-from-displaying-diversity-symbols-oregon-school-board-fires-superintendent

99.

Shakeshaft

(1989). The gender gap in research in educational administration. Educational Administration Quarterly, 25(4), 324–337.

100.

Shakeshaft

Brown

Irby

Grogan

Ballanger

(2014). Handbook for achieving gender equity through education. Routledge.

101.

Sherman

W. H.

Muñoz

A. J.

Pankake

(2008). The great divide: Women’s experiences with mentoring. Journal of Women in Educational Leadership, 25.

102.

Skrla

Reyes

Scheurich

J. J.

(2000). Sexism, silence, and solutions: Women superintendents speak up and speak out. Educational Administration Quarterly, 36(1), 44–75.

103.

Smith

Porter

Harrison

B. J.

Wohlstetter

(2022). Barriers to increasing teacher diversity: The need to move beyond aspirational legislation. Education and Urban Society. https://doi.org/10.1177/00131245221076086

104.

Sonnenberg

(2003). Programs and plans of the National Center for Education Statistics. National Center for Education Statistics.

105.

Steiner

E. D.

Woo

(2021). Job-related stress threatens the teacher supply: Key findings from the 2021 State of the U.S. Teacher Survey. RAND Corporation.

106.

Superville

D. R.

(2016). Few women run the nation’s school districts. Why? Education Week. https://www.edweek.org/leadership/few-women-run-the-nations-school-districts-why/2016/11

107.

Tallerico

(2000). Gaining access to the superintendency: Headhunting, gender, and color. Educational Administration Quarterly, 36(1), 18–43.

108.

Tallerico

Blount

(2004). Women and the superintendency: Insights from theory and history. Educational Administration Quarterly, 40(5), 633–662.

109.

Tallerico

Burstyn

J. M.

(1996). Retaining women in the superintendency: The location matters. Educational Administration Quarterly, 32(Supplemental/December), 642–664.

110.

Tallerico

Burstyn

Poole

(1993). Gender and politics at work: Why women exist the superintendency. National Policy Board for Educational Administration.

111.

Thomas

Tienken

C. H.

Kang

Patersen

G. J.

(2022). 2021-22 AASA Superintendent Salary and Benefits Study. AASA.

112.

Toppo

(2022). School superintendents head for the exits. Education Next. www.educationnext.org/school-superintendents-head-for-the-exits-big-districts-new-leaders-fill-vacancies/

113.

Ujifusa

(2019). Groups tell Washington to make teacher diversity a priority. Education Week. www.edweek.org/education/groups-tell-washington-to-make-teacher-diversity-a-priority-but-how-exactly/2019/05

114.

United States Department of Education [USED]. (2021). National Center for Education Statistics, National Teacher and Principal Survey (NTPS). https://nces.ed.gov/pubsearch/pubsinfo.asp?pubid=2022112

115.

United States Social Security Administration [SSA]. (2020). Beyond the Top 1000 Names, National data, 2020. https://www.ssa.gov/oact/babynames/limits.html

116.

Vail

(1999). Women at the top. American School Board Journal, 186, 20–24.

117.

Valian

(1999). Why so slow? The advancement of women. MIT Press.

118.

Villareal

(2021). Death threats and fights over critical race theory have driven at least six educators to resign. Newsweek. https://www.newsweek.com/death-threats-fights-over-critical-race-theory-have-driven-least-six-educators-resign-1609461

119.

Wallace Foundation. (2022). New research points to looming principal shortage. https://www.wallacefoundation.org/news-and-media/blog/pages/new-research-points-to-a-looming-principal-shortage.aspx

120.

Walton Family Foundation. (2019). Walton Family Foundation announces $3.5 million in funding to diversify the Prek-12 teaching profession. https://www.waltonfamilyfoundation.org/about-us/newsroom/3-5-million-to-diversify-prek-12-teaching-profession

121.

WestEd. (2022). New federal grant will support increasing the number of principals of color and women principals in Illinois. Author.

122.

White

R.S.

(2021). What’s in a first name? America’s K-12 public school district superintendent gender gap. Leadership and Policy in Schools. DOI: 10.1080/15700763.2021.1965169

123.

White

R. S.

Evans

Malin

(2023). The unique (and not-so-unique) political battles of suburban superintendents. Phi Delta Kappan, 104(5), 6–10. https://doi.org/10.1177/00317217231156223.

124.

Wolfers

(2015, March 2). Fewer women run big companies than men named John. The UpShot, The New York Times. https://www.nytimes.com/2015/03/03/upshot/fewer-women-run-big-companies-than-men-named-john.html

125.

World Economic Forum. (2020). Fewer women CEOs have been appointed since the start of the COVID-19 crisis. https://www.weforum.org/agenda/2020/12/fewer-women-ceos-covid-gender-gap/

126.

Yee

Cuban

(1996). When is tenure long enough? A historical analysis of superintendent turnover and tenure in urban school districts. Educational Administration Quarterly, 32(1_suppl), 615–641.

127.

Zamarro

Prado

M. J.

(2021). Gender differences in couples’ division of childcare, work and mental health during COVID-19. Review of Economics of the Household, 19, 11–40.

Supplementary Material

Please find the following supplemental material available below.

For Open Access articles published under a Creative Commons License, all supplemental material carries the same license as the article it is associated with.

For non-Open Access articles published, all supplemental material carries a non-exclusive license, and permission requests for re-use of supplemental material or any part of supplemental material shall be sent directly to the copyright owner as specified in the copyright notice associated with the article.

0.00 MB

0.24 MB

Ceilings Made of Glass and Leaving En Masse? Examining Superintendent Gender Gaps and Turnover Over Time Across the United States

Abstract

Keywords

Get full access to this article

References

Supplementary Material