Categorical Inequality in Black and White: Linking Disproportionality Across Multiple Educational Outcomes

Abstract

We characterize the extent to which Black-White gaps for multiple educational outcomes are linked across school districts in the United States. Gaps in disciplinary action, grade-level retention, classification into special education and Gifted and Talented, and Advanced Placement course-taking are large in magnitude and correlated. Racial differences in family income and parent education are strikingly consistent predictors of these gaps, and districts with large gaps in one outcome are likely to have large gaps in another. Socioeconomic and segregation variables explain 1.7 to 3.5 times more variance for achievement relative to nonachievement outcomes. Systemic patterns of racial socioeconomic inequality drive inequalities across multiple educational outcomes; however, discretionary policies at local levels are more influential for nonachievement outcomes.

Keywords

Black-White inequality categorical inequality disproportionality discipline special education Gifted and Talented Advanced Placement

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Ahram

Fergus

Noguera

(2011). Addressing racial/ethnic disproportionality in special education: Case studies of suburban school districts. Teachers College Record, 113(10), 2233–2266.

Baier

(1958). The moral point of view. Cornell University Press.

Balfanz

Byrnes

Fox

(2015). Sent home and put off track: The antecedents, disproportionalities, and consequences of being suspended in the 9th grade. In Losen

D. J.

(Ed.), Closing the school discipline gap: Equitable remedies for excessive exclusion (pp. 17–30). Teachers College Press.

Barnard-Brak

McGaha-Garnett

Burley

(2011). Advanced Placement course enrollment and school-level characteristics. NASSP Bulletin, 93(3), 165–174. https://doi.org/10.1177/0192636511418640

Barrett

McEachin

Mills

Valant

(2017). Technical report: Disparities in student discipline by race and family income. Education Research Alliance for New Orleans.

Beck

A. N.

Muschkin

C. G.

(2012). The enduring impact of race: Understanding disparities in student disciplinary infractions and achievement. Sociological Perspectives, 55(4), 637–662. https://doi.org/10.1525/sop.2012.55.4.637

Berwick

(2015, March 17). Zeroing out zero tolerance. The Atlantic. https://www.theatlantic.com/education/archive/2015/03/zeroing-out-zero-tolerance/388003/

Bradshaw

C. P.

Mitchell

M. M.

O’Brennan

L. M.

Leaf

P. J.

(2010). Multilevel explorations of factors contributing to the overrepresentation of Black students in office discipline referrals. Journal of Educational Psychology, 102(2), 508–520. https://doi.org/10.1037/a0018450

Brophy

(1988). Classroom management as socializing students into clearly articulated roles. Journal of Classroom Interaction, 33(1), 1–4.

10.

Bui

S. A.

Craig

S. G.

Imberman

S. A.

(2014). Is gifted education a bright idea? Assessing the impact of gifted and talented programs on students. American Economic Journal: Economic Policy, 6(3), 30–62. https://doi.org/10.1257/pol.6.3.30

11.

Card

Giuliano

(2014). Does gifted education work? For which students? (NBER Working Paper No. w20453). National Bureau of Economic Research. https://doi.org/10.3386/w20453

12.

Card

Giuliano

(2016). Universal screening increases the representation of low-income and minority students in gifted education. Proceeding of the National Academy of Sciences of the U S A, 113(48), 13678–13683. https://doi.org/10.1073/pnas.1605043113

13.

Calton

M. T.

(2012). Black male perspectives on their educational experiences in high school. Urban Education, 47(6), 1055–1085. https://doi.org/10.1177/0042085912454442

14.

Carter

P. L.

Welner

K. G.

(Eds.). (2013). Closing the opportunity gap: What America must do to give every child an even chance. Oxford University Press. https://doi.org/10.1093/acprof:oso/9780199982981.001.0001

15.

Chajewski

Mattern

K. D.

Shaw

E. J.

(2011). Examining the role of Advanced Placement Exam participation in 4-year college enrollment. Educational Measurement: Issues and Practice, 30(4), 16–27. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1745-3992.2011.00219.x

16.

Child Trends Data Bank. (2015). Children who repeated a grade. Child Trends.

17.

Christle

Nelson

C. M.

Jolivette

(2004). School characteristics related to the use of suspension. Education and Treatment of Children, 27(4), 509–526.

18.

Cisneros

Gomez

L. M.

Powers

J. M.

Halloway-Libell

Corley

K. M.

(2014). The Advanced Placement opportunity gap in Arizona: Access, participation, and success. AASA Journal of Scholarship and Practice, 11(2), 20–32.

19.

Cockx

Picchio

Baert

(2018). Modeling the effects of grade retention in high school. Journal of Applied Econometrics, 34(3), 403–424. https://doi.org/10.1002/jae.2670

20.

Conger

Long

M. C.

Iatarola

(2009). Explaining race, poverty, and gender disparities in advanced course-taking. Journal of Policy Analysis and Management, 28(4), 555–576. https://doi.org/10.1002/pam.20455

21.

Corra

Carter

J. S.

Carter

S. K.

(2011). The interactive impact of race and gender on high school advanced course enrollment. Journal of Negro Education, 80(1), 33–46.

22.

Curran

C. F.

(2016). Estimating the effect of state zero tolerance laws on exclusionary discipline, racial discipline gaps, and student behavior. Educational Evaluation and Policy Analysis 38(4), 647–668. https://doi.org/10.3102/0162373716652728

23.

Dancy

(2000). Practical reality. Oxford University Press.

24.

Dee

T. S.

Penner

E. K.

(2017). The causal effects of cultural relevance: Evidence from an ethnic studies curriculum. American Educational Research Journal, 54(1), 127–166. https://doi.org/10.3102/0002831216677002

25.

Dever

B. V.

Raines

T. C.

Dowdy

Hostutler

. (2016). Addressing disproportionality in special education using a universal screening approach. The Journal of Negro Education, 85(1), 59–71. https://doi.org/10.7709/jnegroeducation.85.1.0059

26.

Domina

Penner

(2017). Categorical inequality: Schools as sorting machines. Annual Review of Sociology, 43, 311–330. https://doi.org/10.1146/annurev-soc-060116-053354

27.

Elhoweris

(2008). Teacher judgment in identifying gifted/talented students. Multicultural Education, 15(3), 35–38.

28.

Eren

Lovenheim

M. F.

Mocan

N. H.

(2018). The effect of grade retention on adult crime: Evidence from a test-based promotion policy (NBER Working Paper No. w25384). National Bureau of Economic Research. https://doi.org/10.3386/w25384

29.

Fabelo

Thompson

M. D.

Plotkin

Carmichael

Marchbanks

M. P.

III Booth

E. A.

(2011). Breaking schools’ rules: A statewide study of how school discipline relates to students’ success and juvenile justice involvement. Council of State Governments Justice Center.

30.

Fields

S. A.

(2004). Assessor effects on the evaluation of the WISC-III [Master’s thesis, University of South Florida]. https://scholarcommons.usf.edu/etd/1033

31.

Fierros

E. G.

Conroy

J. W.

(2002). Double jeopardy: An exploration of restrictiveness and race in special education. In Losen

D. J.

Orfield

(Eds.), Racial inequity in special Education (pp. 39–70). Harvard Education Press.

32.

Finn

J. D.

Servoss

T. J.

(2014). Misbehavior, suspensions, and security measures in high school: Racial/ethnic and gender differences. Journal of Applied Research on Children: Informing Policy for Children at Risk, 5(2), Article 11.

33.

Fish

R. E.

(2017). The racialized construction of exceptionality: Experimental evidence of race/ethnicity effects on teachers’ interventions. Social Science Research, 62, 317–334. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ssresearch.2016.08.007

34.

Fish

R. E.

(2019). Standing out and sorting in: Exploring the role of racial composition in racial disparities in special education. American Educational Research Journal, 56(6), 2573–2608. https://doi.org/10.3102/0002831219847966

35.

Fisher

C. W.

Berliner

D. C.

Filby

N. N.

Marliave

Cahen

L. S.

Dishaw

M. M.

(1981). Teaching behaviors, academic learning time, and student achievement: An overview. Journal of Classroom Interaction, 17(1), 2–15.

36.

Ford

D. Y.

(1998). The underrepresentation of minority students in gifted education: Problems and promises in recruitment and retention. Journal of Special Education, 32(1), 4–14. https://doi.org/10.1177/002246699803200102

37.

Ford

D. Y.

Grantham

T. C.

Whiting

G. W

. (2008). Culturally and linguistically diverse students in gifted education: Recruitment and retention issues. Exceptional Children, 74(3), 289–306. https://doi.org/10.1177/001440290807400302

38.

Fryer

R. G.

Jr. Levitt

S. D.

(2004). Understanding the Black-White test score gap in the first two years of school. Review of Economics and Statistics, 86(2), 447–464. https://doi.org/10.1162/003465304323031049

39.

Godley

Monroe

Castma

(2015). Increasing access to and success in Advanced Placement English in Pittsburgh public schools. English Journal, 105(1), 28–34.

40.

González

(2012). Keeping kids in schools: Restorative justice, punitive discipline, and the School to Prison Pipeline. Journal of Law & Education, 41(2), 281–335.

41.

González

(2015). Socializing schools: Addressing racial disparities in discipline through restorative justice. In Losen

D. J.

(Ed.), Closing the school discipline gap: Equitable remedies for excessive exclusion (pp. 151–165). Teachers College Press.

42.

Gordon

(2018, April 5). Who is in special education and who has access to related services? New evidence from the National Survey of Children’s Health (Brookings Institution Evidence Speaks Reports, Vol. 2, Issue 46). https://www.brookings.edu/wp-content/uploads/2018/04/gordon-report.pdf

43.

Greenwood

C. R.

Horton

B. T.

Utley

C. A.

(2002). Academic engagement: Current perspectives on research and practice. School Psychology Review, 31(3), 328–349.

44.

Gregory

Cornell

Fan

(2011). The relationship of school structure and support to suspension rates for Black and White high school students. American Educational Research Journal, 48(4), 904–934. https://doi.org/10.3102/0002831211398531

45.

Gregory

Skiba

R. J.

Noguera

P. A.

(2010). The achievement gap and the discipline gap: Two sides of the same coin? Educational Researcher, 39(1), 59–68. https://doi.org/10.3102/0013189X09357621

46.

Grissom

J. A.

Redding

(2016). Discretion and disproportionality: Explaining the underrepresentation of high-achieving students of color in gifted programs. AERA Open, 2(1), 1–25. https://doi.org/10.1177%2F2332858415622175

47.

Hallett

R. E.

Venegas

K. M.

(2011). Is increased access enough? Advanced Placement courses, quality, and success in low-income urban schools. Journal for the Education of the Gifted, 34(3), 468–487. https://doi.org/10.1177/016235321103400305

48.

Hanushek

E. A.

Kain

J. F.

Rivkin

S. G.

(2002). Inferring program effects for special populations: Does special education raise achievement for students with disabilities? Review of Economics and Statistics, 84(4), 584–599. https://doi.org/10.1162/003465302760556431

49.

Harry

Klingner

(2014). Why are so many minority students in special education? Understanding race & disability in schools (2nd ed.). Teachers College Press.

50.

Hosp

J. L.

Reschly

D. J.

(2004). Disproportionate representation of minority students in special education: Academic, demographic, and economic predictors. Exceptional Children, 70(2), 185–199. https://doi.org/10.1177/001440290407000204

51.

Jacob

B. A.

Lefgren

(2004). Remedial education and student achievement: A regression-discontinuity analysis. Review of Economics and Statistics, 86(1), 226–244. https://doi.org/10.1162/003465304323023778

52.

Jacob

B. A.

Lefgren

(2009). The effect of grade retention on high school completion. American Economic Journal: Applied Economics, 1(3), 33–58. https://doi.org/10.1257/app.1.3.33

53.

Jimerson

S. R.

Ferguson

(2007). A longitudinal study of grade retention: Academic and behavioral outcomes of retained students through adolescence. School Psychology Quarterly, 22(3), 314–339. https://doi.org/10.1037/1045-3830.22.3.314

54.

Jimerson

S. R.

Kaufman

A. M.

(2003). Reading, writing, and retention: A primer on grade retention research. The Reading Teacher, 56(7), 622–635.

55.

Jimerson

S. R.

Pletcher

S. M. W.

Graydon

Schnurr

B. L

Nickerson

A. B

Kundert

D. K.

(2006). Beyond grade retention and social promotion: Promoting the social and academic competence of students. Psychology in the Schools, 43(1), 85–97. https://doi.org/10.1002/pits.20132

56.

Kinsler

(2011). Understanding the Black-White school discipline gap. Economics of Education Review, 30(6), 1370–1383. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.econedurev.2011.07.004

57.

Klopfenstein

(2004). Advanced Placement: Do minorities have equal opportunity? Economics of Education Review, 23(2), 115–131. https://doi.org/10.1016/S0272-7757(03)00076-1

58.

Ladson-Billings

(2006). From the achievement gap to the education debt: Understanding achievement in US schools. Educational Researcher, 35(7), 3–12. https://doi.org/10.3102/0013189X035007003

59.

LiCalsi

Ozek

Figlio

(2017). The uneven implementation of universal school policies: Maternal education and Florida’s mandatory grade retention policy. Education Finance and Policy, 14(3), 383–413. https://doi.org/10.1162/edfp_a_00252

60.

Losen

Hodson

C. I.

Keith

I. I.

Michael

Morrison

Belway

(2015). Are we closing the school discipline gap? K-12 racial disparities in school discipline. University of California, Los Angeles.

61.

Massey

(2007). Categorically unequal: The American stratification system. Russell Sage Foundation.

62.

McBee

M. T.

(2006). A descriptive analysis of referral sources for gifted identification screening by race and socioeconomic status. Journal of Secondary Gifted Education, 17(2), 103–111. https://doi.org/10.4219/jsge-2006-686

63.

Mendez

L. M. R.

Knoff

H. M.

(2003). Who gets suspended from school and why: A demographic analysis of schools and disciplinary infractions in a large school district. Education and Treatment of Children, 26(1), 30–51.

64.

Mendez

L. M. R.

Knoff

H. M.

Ferron

J. M.

(2002). School demographic variables and out-of-school suspension rates: A quantitative and qualitative analysis of a large, ethnically diverse school district. Psychology in the Schools, 39(3), 259–277. https://doi.org/10.1002/pits.10020

65.

Milner

H. R.

IV . (2012). Rethinking achievement gap talk in urban education. Urban Education, 48(1), 3–8. https://doi.org/10.1177/0042085912470417

66.

Morgan

P. L.

Farkas

Hillemeier

M. M.

Maczuga

(2012). Are minority children disproportionately represented in early intervention and early childhood special education? Educational Researcher, 41(9), 339–351. https://doi.org/10.3102/0013189X12459678

67.

Morgan

P. L.

Farkas

Hillemeier

M. M.

Maczuga

(2017). Replicated evidence of racial and ethnic disparities in disability identification in U.S. schools. Educational Researcher, 46(6), 305–322. https://doi.org/10.3102/0013189X17726282

68.

Morgan

P. L.

Farkas

Hillemeier

M. M.

Mattison

Maczuga

Cook

(2015). Minorities are disproportionately underrepresented in special education: Longitudinal evidence across five disability conditions. Educational Researcher, 44(5), 278–292. https://doi.org/10.3102/0013189X15591157

69.

Morris

J. E.

(2002). African American students and gifted education: The politics of race and culture. Roeper Review, 24(2), 59–62. https://doi.org/10.1080/02783190209554130

70.

Musu-Gillette

de Brey

McFarland

Hussar

Sonnenberg

Wilkinson-Flicker

(2017). Status and trends in the education of racial and ethnic Groups 2017 (NCES 2017-051). U.S. Department of Education, National Center for Education Statistics. http://nces.ed.gov/pubsearch

71.

National Research Council. (2002). Minority students in special and gifted education. National Academies Press. https://doi.org/10.17226/10128

72.

Noltemeyer

Mcloughlin

C. S.

(2010). Patterns of exclusionary discipline by school typology, ethnicity, and their interaction. Penn GSE Perspectives on Urban Education, 7(1), 27–40.

73.

Noordzij

van Diepen

Caskey

F. C.

Jager

K. J.

(2017). Relative risk versus absolute risk: one cannot be interpreted without the other. Nephrology Dialysis Transplantation, 32(Suppl. 2), ii13–ii18. https://doi.org/10.1093/ndt/gfw465

74.

Okonofua

J. A.

Eberhardt

J. L.

(2015). Two strikes: Race and the disciplining of young students. Psychological Science, 26(5), 617–624. https://doi.org/10.1177/0956797615570365

75.

Okonofua

J. A.

Paunesku

Walton

G. M.

(2016). Brief intervention to encourage empathic discipline cuts suspension rates in half among adolescents. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, 113(19), 5221–5226. https://doi.org/10.1073/pnas.1523698113

76.

Quinn

D. M.

(2015). Kindergarten Black–White test score gaps: Re-examining the roles of socioeconomic status and school quality with new data. Sociology of Education, 88(2), 120–139. https://doi.org/10.1177/0038040715573027

77.

Reardon

S. F.

Kalogrides

Shores

(2019). The geography of racial/ethnic test score gaps. American Journal of Sociology, 124(4), 1164–1221. https://doi.org/10.1086/700678

78.

Reardon

S. F.

Shear

B. R.

Castellano

K. E.

A. D.

(2017). Using heteroskedastic ordered probit models to recover moments of continuous test score distributions from coarsened data. Journal of Educational and Behavioral Statistics, 42(1), 3–45. https://doi.org/10.3102/1076998616666279

79.

Robinson

N. M.

(2003). Two wrongs do not make a right: Sacrificing the needs of gifted students does not solve society’s unresolved problems. Journal for the Education of the Gifted, 26(4), 251–273. https://doi.org/10.4219/jeg-2003-307

80.

Rothstein

Wozny

(2013). Permanent income and the Black-White test score gap. Journal of Human Resources, 48(3), 510–544. https://doi.org/10.3368/jhr.48.3.510

81.

Rowe

(2017, April 2). Gifted programs across Washington leave out Black and Latino students—but Federal Way is one model for change. The Seattle Times. https://www.seattletimes.com/education-lab/gifted-programs-across-washington-leave-out-Black-and-latino-students-except-in-federal-way/

82.

Santoli

S. P.

(2002). Is there an Advanced Placement advantage? American Secondary Education, 30(3), 23–35.

83.

Schulz

K. F.

Altman

D. G.

Moher

. (2010). CONSORT 2010 statement: Updated guidelines for reporting parallel group randomised trials. BMJ, 8, 18. https://doi.org/10.1186/1741-7015-8-18

84.

Schwerdt

West

M. R.

(2012). The effects of early grade retention on student outcomes over time: Regression discontinuity evidence from Florida (Program on Education Policy and Governance Working Papers Series PEPG 12-09). https://dash.harvard.edu/bitstream/handle/1/9544244/West%20GradeRetention%20PEPG%20paper_080612.pdf?sequence=1&isAllowed=y

85.

Skiba

R. J.

(2014). The failure of zero tolerance. Reclaiming Children and Youth, 22(4), 27–33.

86.

Skiba

R. J.

Chung

C. G.

Trachok

Baker

T. L.

Sheya

Hughes

R. L.

(2014). Parsing disciplinary disproportionality: Contributions of infraction, student, and school characteristics to out-of-school suspension and expulsion. American Educational Research Journal, 51(4), 640–670. https://doi.org/10.3102/0002831214541670

87.

Skiba

R. J.

Horner

R. H.

Chung

C. G.

Rausch

M. K.

May

S. L.

Tobin

(2011). Race is not neutral: A national investigation of African American and Latino disproportionality in school discipline. School Psychology Review, 40(1), 85–107.

88.

Stearns

Moller

Blau

Potochnick

(2007). Staying back and dropping out: The relationship between grade retention and school dropout. Sociology of Education, 80(3), 210–240. https://doi.org/10.1177/003804070708000302

89.

Sullivan

A. L.

Klingbeil

D. A.

Van Norman

E. R.

(2013). Beyond behavior: Multilevel analysis of the influence of sociodemographics and school characteristics on students’ risk of suspension. School Psychology Review, 42(1), 99–113.

90.

Taliaferro

J. D.

DeCuir-Gunby

J. T.

(2008). African American educators’ perspectives on the Advanced Placement opportunity gap. Urban Review, 40(2), 164–185. https://doi.org/10.1007/s11256-007-0066-6

91.

Tilly

(1998). Durable inequality. University of California Press.

92.

Tilly

(2003). Inequality, democratization, and de-democratization. Sociological Theory, 21(1), 36–43. https://doi.org/10.1111/1467-9558.00174

93.

Tomchin

E. M.

Impara

J. C.

(1992). Unraveling teachers’ beliefs about grade retention. American Educational Research Journal, 29(1), 199–223. https://doi.org/10.3102/00028312029001199

94.

Tyson

(Ed.). (2011). Integration interrupted: Tracking, Black students, and acting White after Brown. Oxford University Press.

95.

Tyson

(2013). Tracking segregation, and the opportunity gap. In Carter

P. L.

Welner

K. G.

(Eds.), Closing the opportunity gap: What America must do to give every child an even chance (pp. 169–180). Oxford Scholarship Online. https://doi.org/10.1093/acprof:oso/9780199982981.003.0012

96.

U.S. Department of Education, National Center for Education Statistics. (2006). The condition of education 2006 (NCES 2006-071). U.S. Government Printing Office. https://nces.ed.gov/pubs2006/2006071.pdf

97.

U.S. Department of Education, Office of Special Education and Rehabilitative Services, Office of Special Education Programs. (2016). 38th Annual Report to Congress on the Implementation of the Individuals with Disabilities Education Act, 2016. https://files.eric.ed.gov/fulltext/ED572027.pdf

98.

Wallace

J. M.

Jr. Goodkind

Wallace

C. M.

Bachman

J. G.

(2008). Racial, ethnic, and gender differences in school discipline among U.S. high school students: 1991–2005. Negro Educational Review, 59(1–2), 47–62.

99.

Welch

Payne

A. A.

(2012). Exclusionary school punishment: The effect of racial threat on expulsion and suspension. Youth Violence and Juvenile Justice, 10(2), 155–171. https://doi.org/10.1177/1541204011423766

100.

Whiting

G. W.

Ford

D. Y.

(2009). Multicultural issues: Black students and Advanced Placement classes: Summary, concerns, and recommendations. Gifted Child Today, 32(1), 23–26. https://doi.org/10.4219/gct-2009-840

101.

Williams

(2006). Generalized ordered logit/partial proportional odds models for ordinal dependent variables. Stata Journal, 6(1), 58–82. https://doi.org/10.1177/1536867X0600600104

102.

Williams

(2009). Using heterogeneous choice models to compare logit and probit coefficients across groups. Sociological Methods & Research, 37(4), 531–559. https://doi.org/10.1177/0049124109335735

103.

Williams

(2010). Fitting heterogeneous choice models with oglm. Stata Journal, 10(4), 540–567. https://doi.org/10.1177/1536867X1101000402

104.

West

S. G.

Hughes

J. N.

(2010). Effect of grade retention in first grade on psychosocial outcomes. Journal of Educational Psychology, 102(1), 135–152. https://doi.org/10.1037/a0016664