Market segmentation lies ‘at the heart of successful marketing’ (McDonald 2010), yet market segmentation solutions are not trivial to interpret, especially if consumers are segmented using post hoc or a posteriori or data-driven segmentation, where several consumer characteristics are analysed simultaneously to identify or construct market segments. In fact, 65% of marketing managers admit to having difficulties with the interpretation of data-driven market segmentation solutions. In this study we develop novel ways of visualising segmentation solutions using graphical statistics methodology. The proposed plots help academics and practitioners to interpret complex market segmentation solutions, thus improving the practical usability of market segmentation, reducing the risk of misinterpretation and contributing to closing the much-lamented ‘theory–practice divide’ in market segmentation.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
AilawadiK. L., NeslinS. A., & GedenkK. (2001) Pursuing the value-conscious consumer: store brands versus national brand promotionsJournal of Marketing, 65, 1, pp 71–89.
2.
AndriotisK., & VaughanR. D. (2003) Urban residents' attitudes toward tourism development: the case of CreteJournal of Travel Research, 42, 2, pp 172–185.
3.
BeckenS., SimmonsD., & FramptonC. (2003) Segmenting tourists by their travel pattern for insights into achieving energy efficiencyJournal of Travel Research, 42, 1, pp 48–53.
4.
BehA., & BruyereB. L. (2007) Segmentation by visitor motivation in three Kenyan national reservesTourism Management, 28, 6, pp 1464–1471.
5.
BennionMLJr (1986) Segmentation and positioning in a basic industryIndustrial Marketing Management, 16, 9, pp 9–18.
6.
BockT. (2010) Improving the display of correspondence analysis using moon plotsInternational Journal of Market Research, 53, 3, pp 307–326.
7.
BodapatiA. V., & GuptaS. (2004) The recoverability of segmentation structure from store-level aggregate dataJournal of Marketing Research, 41, 3, pp 351–364.
8.
BottomleyP., & NairnA. (2004) Blinded by science: the managerial consequences of inadequately validated cluster analysis solutionsInternational Journal of Market Research, 46, 2, pp 171–187.
9.
CastroC. B., ArmarioE. M., & RuizD. M. (2007) The influence of market heterogeneity on the relationship between a destination's image and tourists' future behaviorTourism Management, 28, 1, pp 175–187.
10.
ChambersJ. M., ClevelandW. S., KleinerB., & TukeyP. A. (1993) Graphical Methods for Data Analysis.Belmont, CA: Wadsworth International
11.
ChenC -H, HärdleW. K., & UnwinA. (eds), (2008) Handbook of Data Visualization Springer Handbooks of Computational StatisticsBerlin: Springer Verlag
12.
ChoffreyJ -M, & LilienG. L. (1980) Industrial market segmentation, in Choffrey, J -M & Lilien, G. L. (eds) Marketing Planning for New Industrial ProductsNew York: John Wiley and Sons, pp 74–91
13.
ChungK. Y., OhS. Y., KimS. S., & HanS. Y. (2004) Three representative market segmentation methodologies for hotel guest room customersTourism Management, 25, 4, pp 429–441.
14.
ClevelandW. S. (1993) Visualizing DataSummit, NJ: Hobart Press
DibbS., & SimkinL. (1997) A program for implementing market segmentationJournal of Business and Industrial Marketing, 12, 1, pp 51–65.
17.
DolnicarS. (2004) Beyond ‘commonsense segmentation’: a systematics of segmentation approaches in tourismJournal of Travel Research, 42, 3, pp 244–250.
18.
DolnicarS., & LazarevskiK. (2009) Methodological reasons for the theory/practice divide in market segmentationJournal of Marketing Management, 25, 3-4, pp 357–373.
19.
DolnicarS., & LeischF. (2003) Winter tourist segments in Austria: identifying stable vacation styles using bagged clustering techniquesJournal of Travel Research, 41, pp 281–292.
20.
DolnicarS., & LeischF. (2008) An investigation of tourists' patterns of obligation to protect the environmentJournal of Travel Research, 46, 4, pp 381–391.
21.
DolnicarS., & LeischF. (2010) Evaluation of structure and reproducibility of cluster solutions using the bootstrapMarketing Letters, 21, 1, pp 83–101.
22.
DoyleP., SaundersJ., & WongV. (1985) Japanese marketing strategies in the UK: a comparative studyJournal of International Business Studies, 17, 1, pp 27–46.
23.
EhrenbergAS C (1977) Rudiments of numeracyJournal of the Royal Statistical Society, A., 140, 3, pp 277–297.
24.
EhrenbergAS C (1978) Graphs or tablesThe Statistician, 27, 2, pp 87–96.
25.
FullerJ., & MatzlerK. (2008) Customer delight and market segmentation: an application of the three-factor theory of customer satisfaction on life style groupsTourism Management, 29, 1, pp 116–126.
26.
GreenbergM., & McDonaldS. (1989) Successful needs/benefits segmentation: a user's guideJournal of Consumer Marketing, 6, 3, pp 29–37.
27.
HaleyR. I. (1968) Benefit segmentation: a decision oriented research toolJournal of Marketing, 32, 30, pp 30–35.
28.
HennigC. (2004) Asymmetric linear dimension reduction for classificationJournal of Computational and Graphical Statistics, 13, 4, pp 1–17.
29.
HornemanL., CarterR. W., WeiS., & RuysH. (2002) Profiling the senior traveler: an Australian perspectiveJournal of Travel Research, 41, 1, pp 23–37.
30.
HsuCHC, & LeeE -J (2002) Segmentation of senior motorcoach travelersJournal of Travel Research, 40, 4, pp 363–373.
31.
LeischF. (2006) A toolbox for k-centroids cluster analysisComputational Statistics and Data Analysis, 51, 2, pp 526–544.
32.
LeischF. (2008) Visualization of cluster analysis and finite mixture models, in ChenC -H, HärdleW., & UnwinA. (eds) Handbook of Data Visualization Springer Handbooks of Computational StatisticsBerlin: Springer Verlag
33.
LeischF. (2010) Neighborhood graphs, stripes and shadow plots for cluster visualizationStatistics and Computing, 20, 4, pp 457–469.
MartinetzT. M., BerkovichS. G., & SchultenK. J. (1993) ‘Neural-gas’ network for vector quantization and its application to time-series predictionIEEE Transactions on Neural Networks, 4, 4, pp 558–569.
36.
MazanecJ. A. (1997) Segmenting city tourists into vacation styles, in Grabler, K., Maier, G., Mazanec, J. A. & Wöber, K. (eds) International City Tourism: Analysis and Strategy. The Cutting Edge of TourismNew York: Continuum International Publishing, pp 114-128
37.
MazanecJ. A. (2000) Market segmentation, in JafariJ. (ed) Encyclopedia of TourismLondon: Routledge
38.
MazumdarT., & PapatlaP. (2000) An investigation of reference price segmentsJournal of Marketing Research, 37, 2, pp 246–258.
39.
McDonaldM. (2010) Existentialism - a school of thought based on a conception of the absurdity of the universeInternational Journal of Market Research, 52, 4, pp 427–430.
40.
MurrellP. (2006) R GraphicsLondon: Chapman & Hall/CRC
41.
MyersJ. H., & TauberE. M. (1977) Market Structure AnalysisChicago: American Marketing Association
42.
NairnA., & BottomleyP. (2003) Something approaching science?Cluster analysis procedures in the CRM era International Journal of Market Research, 45, 2, pp 241–261.
43.
PalmerR. A., & MillierP. (2004) Segmentation: identification, intuition, and implementationIndustrial Marketing Management, 33, 8, pp 779–785.
44.
R Development Core Team (2012) R: A Language and Environment for Statistical ComputingVienna: R Foundation for Statistical Computing
45.
ReinartzW. J., & KumarV. (2000) On the profitability of long-life customers in a noncontractual setting: an empirical investigation and implications for marketingJournal of Marketing, 64, 4, pp 17–35.
46.
SmithW. R. (1956) Product differentiation and market segmentation as alternative marketing strategiesJournal of Marketing, 21, 1, pp 3–9.
47.
TufteE. R. (1983) The Visual Display of Quantitative Information Cheshire, Connecticut: Graphics Press
48.
TufteE. R. (1997) Visual Explanations Cheshire, Connecticut: Graphics Press
49.
TukeyJ. W. (1977) Exploratory Data AnalysisReading, MA: Addison-Wesley
50.
VarkiS., & ChintaguntaP. K. (2004) The augmented latent class model: incorporating additional heterogeneity in the latent class model for panel dataJournal of Marketing Research, 41, 2, pp 226–233.
51.
WedelM., & KamakuraW. A. (1998) Market Segmentation: Conceptual and Methodological FoundationsBoston: Kluwer Academic Publishers
52.
WilkinsonL. (2005) The Grammar of GraphicsNew York: Springer Verlag
53.
WindY. (1978) Issues and advances in segmentation researchJournal of Marketing Research, 15, 3, pp 317–338.
54.
ZinsA. (2008) Market segmentation in tourism: a critical review of 20 years' research efforts, in KronenbergSMC, PetersM., PikkemaatB., & WeiermairK. (eds) From the ‘OLD’ to the ‘NEW’ Tourism: Managing Change in the Tourism IndustryBerlin: Erich Schmidt Verlag, pp 289–301
