In the Deese-Roediger-McDermott-Read-Solso (DRMRS) procedure, which has recently enjoyed widespread use, participants try to remember lists of items constructed around critical themes that are not presented. The purpose of this quantitative review was to estimate the extent to which these themes are falsely recalled (Critical Intrusions) and to compare this error rate with Correct Recall and with false recall of other words that were not presented (Noncritical Intrusions). Based on 111 estimates, the mean rate of Critical Intrusions was .374 (95% confidence interval of .344 to .403), which was a very large effect (d = 2.40). Critical Intrusions were less frequent than Correct Recall (.572) but more frequent than Noncritical Intrusions (.078). Critical Intrusions were lower (.318) for people told to be confident (not to guess) than for people not so cautioned (.428), a medium to large effect size (d = 0.69). Effects of other variables are summarized, and the theoretical and applied implications of these results are discussed.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
BowlerD. M.GardinerJ. M.GriceS., & SaavalainenP. (2000) Memory illusions: False recall and recognition in adults with Asperger's syndrome. Journal of Abnormal Psychology, 109, 663–672.
2.
BrainerdC. J., & ReynaV. F. (1998) When things that were never experienced are easier to “remember” than things that were. Psychological Science, 9, 484–489.
3.
BrédartS. (2000) When false memories do not occur: Not thinking of the lure or remembering that it was not heard?Memory, 8, 123–128.
4.
BremnerJ. D.ShobeK. K., & KihlstromJ. F. (2000) False memories in women with self-reported childhood sexual abuse. Psychological Science, 11, 333–337.
5.
BruceD., & WinogradE. (1998) Remembering Deese's 1959 articles: The Zeitgeist, the sociology of science, and false memories. Psychonomic Bulletin & Review, 5, 615–624.
6.
ClancyS. A.McNallyR. J.PitmanR. K.SchachterD. L., & LenzenwegerM. F. (2002) Memory distortion in people reporting abduction by aliens. Journal of Abnormal Psychology, 111, 455–461.
7.
ClancyS. A.SchachterD. L.McNallyR. J., & PitmanR. K. (2000) False recognition in women reporting recovered memories of sexual abuse. Psychological Science, 11, 26–31.
8.
CohenJ. (1977) Statistical power analyses for the behavioral sciences. (Rev. ed.) New York: Academic Press.
9.
DeeseJ. (1959) On the prediction of occurrence of particular verbal intrusions in immediate recall. Journal of Experimental Psychology, 58, 17–22.*
10.
FreydJ. J., & GleavesD. H. (1996) “Remembering” words not presented in lists: Relevance to the current recovered/false memory controversy. Journal of Experimental Psychology: Learning, Memory, and Cognition, 22, 811–813.
11.
GalloD. A.McDermottK. B.PercerJ. M., & RoedigerH. L.III. (2001) Modality effects in false recall and false recognition. Journal of Experimental Psychology: Learning, Memory, and Cognition, 27, 339–353.
12.
GalloD. A., & RoedigerH. L.III. (2002) Variability among word lists in eliciting memory illusions: Evidence for associative activation and monitoring. Journal of Memory and Language, 47, 469–497.
13.
GoodwinK. A.MeissnerC. A., & EricssonK. A. (2001) Toward a model of false recall: Experimental manipulation of encoding context and the collection of verbal reports. Memory & Cognition, 29, 806–819.
14.
HicksJ. L., & MarshH. W. (1999) Attempts to reduce the incidence of false recall with source monitoring. Journal of Experimental Psychology: Learning, Memory, and Cognition, 25, 1195–1209.
15.
Intons-PetersonM. J.RocchiP.WestT.McLellanK., & HackneyA. (1999) Age, testing at preferred or nonpreferred times (testing optimality), and false memory. Journal of Experimental Psychology: Learning, Memory, and Cognition, 25, 23–40.*
16.
KelloggR. T. (2001) Presentation modality and mode of recall in verbal false memory. Journal of Experimental Psychology, 27, 913–929.
17.
KensingerE. A., & SchachterD. L. (1999) When true memories suppress false memories: Effects of aging. Cognitive Neuropsychology, 16, 399–415.
18.
KimballD. R., & BjorkR. A. (2003) The influence of intentional and unintentional forgetting on false memories. Journal of Experimental Psychology: General, 131, 116–130.
19.
KoriatA.GoldsmithM., & PanskyA. (2000) Toward a psychology of memory accuracy. Annual Review of Psychology, 51, 481–537.
20.
LampinenJ. M.NeuschatzJ. S., & PayneD. G. (1999) Source attributions and false memories: A test of the demand characteristics account. Psychonomic Bulletin & Review, 6, 130–135.*
21.
LampinenJ. M., & SchwartzR. M. (2000) The impersistence of false memory persistence. Memory, 8, 393–400.
22.
LibbyL. K., & NeisserU. (2001) Structure and strategy in the associative false memory paradigm. Memory, 9, 145–163.
23.
MarmurekH. H. C., & HamiltonM. E. (2000) Imagery effects in false recall and false recognition. Journal of Mental Imagery, 24, 83–96.
24.
McDermottK. B. (1996) The persistence of false memories in list recall. Journal of Memory and Language, 35, 212–230.*
25.
McDermottK. B. (1997) Priming on perceptual implicit memory tests can be achieved through presentation of associates. Psychonomic Bulletin & Review, 4, 212–230.*
26.
McDermottK. B., & WatsonJ. M. (2001) The rise and fall of false recall: The impact of presentation duration. Journal of Memory and Language, 45, 160–176.
27.
McKelvieS. J. (1999) Effect of retrieval instructions on false recall. Perceptual and Motor Skills, 88, 876–878.*
28.
McKelvieS. J. (2001) Effect of free and forced retrieval instructions on false recall and recognition. The Journal of General Psychology, 128, 261–278.*
29.
McNallyR. J. (2003) Recovering memories of trauma: A view from the laboratory. Current Directions in Psychological Science, 12, 32–35.
30.
MillerM. B., & WolfordG. L. (1999) Theoretical commentary: The role of criterion shift in false memory. Psychological Review, 106, 398–405.*
31.
MookD. (1983) In defense of external invalidity. American Psychologist, 38, 379–387.
32.
NewsteadN. A., & NewsteadS. E. (1998) False recall and false memory: The effect of instructions on memory errors. Applied Cognitive Psychology, 12, 67–79.*
33.
NormanK. A., & SchachterD. L. (1997) False recognition in younger and older adults: Exploring the characteristics of illusory memories. Memory & Cognition, 25, 838–848.*
34.
PayneD. G.ElieC. J.BlackwellJ. M., & NeuschatzJ. S. (1996) Memory illusions: Recalling, recognizing, and recollecting events that never occurred. Journal of Memory and Language, 35, 251–285.*
35.
Pérez-MataM. N.ReadJ. D., & DigesM. (2002) Effects of divided attention and word concreteness on correct recall and false memory reports. Memory, 10, 161–177.
36.
PlattR. D.LaceyS. C.IobstA. D., & FinkelmanD. (1998) Absorption, dissociation, and fantasy-proneness as predictors of memory distortion in autobiographical and laboratory-generated memories. Applied Cognitive Psychology, 12, S77–S89.*
37.
ReadJ. D. (1996) From a passing thought to a false memory in 2 minutes: Confusing real and illusory events. Psychonomic Bulletin & Review, 3, 105–111.*
38.
RhodesM. G., & AnastasiJ. S. (2000) The effects of a levels-of-processing manipulation on false recall. Psychonomic Bulletin & Review, 7, 158–162.
39.
RobinsonK. J., & RoedigerH. L.III. (1997) Associative processes in false recall and recognition. Psychological Science, 8, 231–237.*
40.
RoedigerH. L.IIIBalotaD. A., & WatsonJ. M. (2001) Spreading activation and arousal of false memories. In RoedigerH. L.IIINairneJ. S.NeathI., & SurprenantA. M. (Eds.), The nature of remembering: Essays in honor of Robert Crowder.Washington, DC: American Psychological Association. Pp. 95–115.
41.
RoedigerH. L.III, & McDermottK. B. (1995) Creating false memories: Remembering words not presented on lists. Journal of Experimental Psychology: Learning, Memory, and Cognition, 21, 803–814.*
42.
RoedigerH. L.III, & McDermottK. B. (1996) False perception of false memories. Journal of Experimental Psychology: Learning, Memory, and Cognition, 22, 814–816.
43.
RoedigerH. L.III, & McDermottK. B. (1999) False alarms about false memories. Psychological Review, 106, 406–410.
44.
RoedigerH. L.IIIWatsonJ. M.McDermottK. B., & GalloD. A. (2001) Factors that determine false recall: A multiple regression analysis. Psychonomic Bulletin & Review, 8, 385–407.
45.
SchachterD. L.VerfaellieM., & PradreD. (1996) The neuropsychology of memory illusions: False recall and recognition in amnesic patients. Journal of Memory and Language, 35, 319–334.*
46.
SeamonJ. G.GuerryJ. D.MarshG. P., & TracyM. C. (2002) Accurate and false recall in the Deese/Roediger and McDermott procedure: A methodological note on sex of participant. Psychological Reports, 91, 423–427.
47.
SeamonJ. G.LeeI. A.TonerS. K.WheelerR. H.GoodkindM. S., & BirchA. D. (2002) Thinking of critical words during study is unnecessary for false memory in the Deese, Roediger, and McDermott procedure. Psychological Science, 13, 526–531.
48.
SeamonJ. G.LuoC. R.KopeckyJ. J.PriceC. A.RothschildL.FungN. S., & SchwartzM. A. (2002) Are false memories more difficult to forget than accurate memories? The effect of retention interval on recall and recognition. Memory & Cognition, 30, 1054–1064.
49.
SeamonJ. G.LuoR.ShulmanE. P.TonerS. K., & CaglarS. (2002) False memories are hard to inhibit: Differential effects of directed forgetting on accurate and false recall in the DRM procedure. Memory, 10, 225–237.
50.
StadlerM. A.RoedigerH. L.III, & McDermottK. B. (1999) Norms for word lists that create false memories. Memory & Cognition, 27, 494–500.*
51.
ThaparA., & McDermottK. B. (2001) False recall and false recognition induced by presentation of associated words: Effects of retention interval and level of processing. Memory & Cognition, 29, 424–432.
52.
TogliaM. P.NeuschatzJ. S., & GoodwinK. A. (1999) Recall accuracy and illusory memories: When more is less. Memory, 7, 233–256.*
53.
TunP. A.WingfieldA.RosenM. J., & BlanchardL. (1998) Response latencies for false memories: Gist-based processes in normal aging. Psychology and Aging, 13, 230–241.*
54.
WinogradE.PelusoJ. P., & GloverT. A. (1998) Individual differences in susceptibility to memory illusions. Applied Cognitive Psychology, 12, S5–S27.*
