Sage Journals: Discover world-class research

Abstract

In the search for methodologies that yield meaningful interspecies performance differences over the greatest taxonomic range, serial discrimination reversal has demonstrated the greatest promise. However, interpretation of the obtained differences in performance is complicated by a possible mismatching of procedural variables, such as motivational or incentive levels, across species. In short, differences in performance across species may merely reflect unequal motivation, incentive, and the like, and not some more basic organismic, phyletic or taxonomic variable. Two alternative solutions to this methodological dilemma, systematic variation and control by equation, are discussed in view of recent research. Evidence supporting control by equation is presented. The necessity for taxonomic calibration of procedural variables is illustrated.

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Birnbaum

Inter-species serial discrimination reversal (SDR) performance as a function of motivational and incentive level under conditions of successive stimulus presentation. Unpublished doctoral dissertation, Hofstra Univer. Library, 1974.

Bitterman

M. E.

Toward a comparative psychology of learning. American Psychologist, 1960, 15, 704–712.

Bitterman

M. E.

The evolution of intelligence. Scientific American, 1965, 212, 92–100.

Brookshire

Comparative psychology of learning. In Marx

M. H.

(Ed.), Learning: Interactions. New York: Macmillan, 1970. pp. 291–298.

Gossette

Comparisons of successive discrimination reversal (SDR) performances across fourteen different avian and mammalian species. American Zoologist, 1966, 6, 157.

Gossette

Note on the calibration of inter-species (SDR) performance differences: Qualitative vs quantitative variation. Perceptual and Motor Skills, 1970, 31, 301–303. (a)

Gossette

Variation in magnitude of negative transfer on successive discrimination reversal (SDR) tasks across species. Perceptual and Motor Skills, 1970, 31, 95–104. (b)

Gossette

The comparative analysis of discrimination learning: The taxonomic distance hypothesis. Paper read at the 7th Annual Conference of the Australian Psychological Society, in Canberra, Australia, 1972.

Hodos

Evolutionary interpretation of neural and behavioral studies of living vertebrates. In Schmit

F. O.

(Ed.), The neurosciences. New York: Rockefeller Univer. Press, 1970. pp. 26–39.

10.

Kimble

G. A.

Hilgard and Marquis' ‘Conditioning and learning.’ New York: Appleton-Century-Crofts, 1969.

11.

Levine

B. A.

The calibration of the control ranges of drive and incentive variables in the serial discrimination reversal learning of two avian species. Unpublished doctoral dissertation, Hofstra Univer. Library, 1972.

12.

Rensch

The relation between the evolution of central nervous functions and the body size of animals. In Huxley

Hardy

A. C.

, & Ford

(Eds.), Evolution as a process. New York: Collier Books, 1963. pp. 214–236.

13.

Setterington

, & Bishop

Habit reversal in the fish. Psychonomic Science, 1967, 7, 41–42.

14.

Squier

Reversal learning improvement in the fish. Astronotus ocellatus (Oscar). Psychonomic Science, 1969, 14, 143–144.

15.

Thompson

Successive reversal of a position habit in an invertebrate. Science, 1957, 126, 163–164.

16.

Warren

J. M.

The comparative psychology of learning. Annual Review of Psychology, 1965, 16, 95–118.

17.

Warren

J. M.

Learning in vertebrates. In Dewsbury

& Rethlingshafer

(Eds.), Comparative psychology. New York: McGraw-Hill, 1973. pp. 471–509.

18.

Wilcock

Comparative psychology lives on under an assumed name—psychogenetics. American Psychologist, 1972, 27, 531–538.

19.

Woodward

Schoel

, & Bitterman

Reversal learning with singly presented stimuli in pigeons and goldfish. Journal of Comparative and Physiological Psychology, 1971, 76, 460–467.

Note on Methodology in Comparative Behavioral Analysis: Systematic Variation vs Control by Equation

Abstract

Get full access to this article

References