Motor learning textbooks provide specific recommendations for the use of whole and part practice during motor skill acquisition. Magill recommended basing decisions on Naylor and Briggs' hypothesis of task complexity and organization, while Schmidt and Wrisberg recommended basing decisions on skill classification. To evaluate the accuracy of these recommendations, a meta-analysis was conducted. Through a literature search, 44 articles were located, and 20 provided sufficient information to calculate effect sizes. Effect sizes were calculated using means for whole and part practice for acquisition and retention. Although several analyses were compromised by insufficient studies investigating whole and part practice, mean effect sizes generally supported motor learning textbooks. To better verify the empirical validity of recommendations for the use of whole and part practice, more studies are necessary.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
AshD. W.HoldingD. H. (1990) Backward versus forward chaining in the acquisition of a keyboard skill. Human Factors, 32, 139–146.
2.
BarryG.ValerieS. (1996) Analysis of part-task training using the backward-transfer technique. Journal of Experimental Psychology: Applied, 2, 227–249.
3.
BlakeK. A.WilliamsC. L. (1969) Retarded, normal, and superior subjects' learning of paired associates by whole and parts methods. Psychological Reports, 25, 319–324.
4.
BriggsG. E.NaylorJ. C. (1962) The relative efficiency of several training methods as a function of transfer task complexity. Journal of Experimental Psychology, 64, 505–512.
5.
Articles were retrieved but not used in the meta-analysis.
6.
FabianiM.BuckleyJ.GrattonG.ColesM.DonchinE. (1989) The training of complex task performance. Acta Psychologica, 71, 259–299.
7.
FezzaniK.ThonB.LagardeJ. (2000) Can different levels of S-R practice influence sequence learning? An investigation into the context of a perceptual-motor sequence learning task. Perceptual and Motor Skills, 91, 463–475.
8.
FrederiksenJ. R.WhiteB. Y. (1989) An approach to training based upon principled task decomposition. Acta Psychologica, 71, 89–146.
9.
GoettlB. P.ShuteV. J. (1996) Analysis of part-task training using the backward transfer technique. Journal of Experimental Psychology, 2, 227–249.
10.
HedgesL. V. (1981) Distribution theory for Glass's estimator of effect size and related estimators. Journal of Educational Statistics, 6, 107–128.
11.
HedgesL. V.OlkinI. (1985) Statistical methods for meta-analysis.New York: Academic Press.
12.
JohnsL. (1989) Hemispheric preference and progressive-part or whole practice in beginning typewriting. Perceptual and Motor Skills, 68, 359–364.
13.
KeeleS. W.JenningsP.JonesS.CaultonD.CohenA. (1995) On the modularity of sequence representation. Journal of Motor Behavior, 27, 17–30.
14.
KnappC. G.DixonW. R. (1952) Learning to juggle: II. A study of whole and part methods. The Research Quarterly, 23, 398–401.
15.
LerstenK. C. (1968) Transfer of movement components in a motor learning task. The Research Quarterly, 39, 575–581.
16.
MaH.TromblyC. A. (2001) The comparison of motor performance between part and whole tasks in elderly persons. The American Journal of Occupational Therapy, 55, 62–67.
17.
MagillR. (2007) Motor learning: Concepts and applications. (8th ed.) Boston, MA: McGraw-Hill.
18.
ManeA. M.AdamsJ. A.DonchinE. (1989) Adaptive and part-whole training in the acquisition of a complex perceptual-motor skill. Acta Psychologica, 71, 179–196.
19.
McGuiganF. J. (1960) Variation of whole-part methods of learning. Journal of Educational Psychology, 51, 213–216.
20.
McGuiganF. J.MacCaslinE. F. (1955) Whole and part methods in learning a perceptual motor skill. The American Journal of Psychology, 68, 658–661.
21.
MurrayJ. F. (1981) Effects of whole vs part method of training on transfer of learning. Perceptual and Motor Skills, 53, 883–889.
22.
NaylorG.BriggsJ. (1963) Effects of task complexity and task organization on the relative efficiency of part and whole training methods. Journal of Experimental Psychology, 65, 217–224.
23.
NettelbeckT.KirbyN. H. (1976) A comparison of part and whole training methods with mildly mentally retarded workers. Journal of Occupational Psychology, 49, 115–120.
24.
NewellK. M.CarltonM. J.FisherA. T.RutterB. G. (1989) Whole-part training strategies for learning the response dynamics of microprocessor driven simulators. Acta Psychologica, 71, 197–216.
25.
ParkJ. H.WildeH.SheaC. H. (2004) Part-whole practice of movement sequences. Journal of Motor Behavior, 36, 51–61.
26.
PeckA.DetweilerM. C. (2000) Training concurrent multistep procedural tasks. Human Factors, 42, 379–389.
27.
PisacretaR. (1982) A comparison of forward and backward procedures for the acquisition of response chains in pigeons. Bulletin of the Psychonomic Society, 20, 233–236.
Rubin-RabsonG. (1940) Studies in the psychology of memorizing piano music: III. A comparison of the whole and the part approach. The Journal of Educational Psychology, 31, 460–476.
30.
SchmidtR. A.WrisbergC. A. (2008) Motor learning and performance: A problem-based learning approach. (4th ed.) Champaign, IL: Human Kinetics.
31.
SmithG. J. (1999) Teaching a long sequence of behavior using whole task training, forward chaining, and backward chaining. Perceptual and Motor Skills, 89, 951–965.
32.
SpoonerF. (1984) Comparisons of backward chaining and total task presentation in training severely handicapped persons. Education and Training of the Mentally Retarded, 19, 15–22.
33.
SpoonerF.WeberL. H.SpoonerD. (1983) The effects of backward chaining and total task presentation on the acquisition of complex tasks by severely retarded adolescents and adults. Education and Treatment of Children, 6, 401–420.
34.
StammersR. B. (1980) Part and whole practice for a tracking task: Effects of task variables and amount of practice. Perceptual and Motor Skills, 50, 203–210.
35.
StammersR. B. (1982) Part and whole practice in training for procedural tasks. Human Learning, 1, 185–207.
36.
SummerJ.KennedyT. (1992) Strategies in the production of a 5:3 polyrhythm. Human Movement Science, 11, 101–112.
37.
VerweyW. B. (2001) Concatenating familiar movement sequences: The versatile cognitive processor. Acta Psychologica, 106, 69–95.
38.
VerweyW. B.DronkertY. (1996) Practicing a structured continuous key-pressing task: Motor chunking or rhythm consolidation. Journal of Motor Behavior, 28, 71–79.
39.
WallsR. T.DowlerD. L.HauchtP. A.ZawlockiR. (1984) Progressive delay and unlimited delay of prompts in forward chaining and whole task training strategies. Education and Training of the Mentally Retarded, 19, 276–284.
40.
WallsR. T.ZaneT.EllisW. D. (1981) Forward and backward chaining, and whole task methods: Training assembly tasks in vocational rehabilitation. Behavior Modification, 5, 61–74.
41.
WallsR. T.ZaneT.JohnT. E. (1980) Trainers' personal methods compared to two structured training strategies. American Journal of Mental Deficiency, 84, 495–507.
42.
WattersR. G. (1989) Human sequenced behavior: A comparison of forward chaining, backward chaining, and whole task training procedures. Journal of Human Movement Studies, 16, 183–190.
43.
WattersR. G. (1990) Human sequenced behavior: A comparison of forward chaining, backward chaining, and whole task training at different sequence lengths. Journal of Human Movement Studies, 18, 25–35.
44.
WattersR. G. (1992) Retention of human sequenced behavior following forward chaining, backward chaining, and whole task training procedures. Journal of Human Movement Studies, 22, 117–129.
45.
WattersR. G.ScottJ. M. (1992) Teaching human sequenced behavior with and without prompts: A comparison of forward chaining, backward chaining, and whole task procedures. Journal of Human Movement Studies, 22, 239–249.
46.
WeberN. J. (1978) Chaining strategies for teaching sequenced motor tasks to mentally retarded adults. The American Journal of Occupational Therapy, 32, 385–389.
47.
WeisK. M. (1978) A comparison of forward and backward procedures for the acquisition of response chains in humans. Journal of the Experimental Analysis of Behavior, 29, 255–259.
48.
WightmanD. C.SistrunkF. (1987) Part-task training strategies in simulated carrier landing final-appro ach training. Human Factors, 29, 245–254.
49.
WilcoxB. (1974) The teaching of serial tasks using chaining strategies. British Journal of Psychology, 44, 175–183.
50.
ZaneT.WallsR. T.ThvedtJ. E. (1981) Prompting and fading guidance procedures: Their effect on chaining and whole task teaching strategies. Education and Training of the Mentally Retarded, 16, 125–135.
