Restricted accessResearch articleFirst published online 2007-12
A Further Test of the Finno-Ugrian Suicide Hypothesis: Correspondence of County Suicide Rates in Romania and Population Proportion of Ethnic Hungarians
Across the 42 counties of Romania, the total suicide rate and the population percentage of ethnic Hungarians were strongly positively interrelated (79% attributable variance). Counties with the strongest Hungarian minority had suicide rates converging to (or exceeding) the suicide rate for Hungary, which rate is high. Of a set of about 20 vital statistics and socioeconomic indicators, only life expectancy predicted a significant increment of further variance in the suicide rates. However, this effect was small, adding merely 3% further variance explained to 79% already accounted for. Overall, the findings are supportive of the Finno-Ugrian Suicide Hypothesis, i.e., the notion that geographic patterns of suicide prevalence may be partially due to genetic differences between populations. Supplemental analyses of a questionnaire item which specifically queried this study's main finding indicated widespread disbelief of this fact of suicide prevalence across a variety of samples, including two samples from Romania.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
BaldessariniR. J.HennenJ. (2004) Genetics of suicide: An overview. Harvard Review of Psychiatry, 12,1–13.
2.
BondyB.BuettnerA.ZillP. (2006) Genetics of suicide. Molecular Psychiatry, 11,336–351.
3.
BrentD. A.MannJ. J. (2005) Family genetic studies, suicide, and suicidal behavior. American Journal of Medical Genetics C: Seminars in Medical Genetics, 133C,13–24.
4.
CajvaneanuD. (2004) Does tolerance kill? The Hungarian minority in Romania: A case study. Romanian Journal of Political Sciences, 4,111–118.
5.
Cavalli-SforzaL. L.Cavalli-SforzaF. (1995) The great human diasporas: The history of diversity and evolution. Cambridge, MA: Perseus Books.
6.
Ferrada-NoliM. (1997) A cross-cultural breakdown of Swedish suicide. Acta Psychiatrica Scandinavica, 96,108–116.
7.
FrostP. (2006) European hair and eye color: A case of frequency-dependent sexual selection?Evolution and Human Behavior, 27,85–103.
8.
HjernA.AllebeckP. (2002) Suicide in first- and second-generation immigrants in Sweden: A comparative study. Social Psychiatry and Psychiatric Epidemiology, 37,423–429.
9.
KandrychynS. (2004) Geographic variation in suicide rates: Relationships to social factors, migration, and ethnic history. Archives of Suicide Research, 8,303–314.
10.
KõlvesK.TranU. S.VoracekM. (2007) Knowledge about suicide and local suicide prevalence: Comparison of Estonia and Austria. Perceptual and Motor Skills, 105,3–7.
11.
KondrichinS. V. (1995) Suicide among Finno-Ugrians. Lancet, 346,1632–1633. [Letter].
12.
KondrichinS. V.LesterD. (1997) Finno-Ugrians and suicide. Perceptual and Motor Skills, 85, 514.
13.
KondrichinS. V.LesterD. (1998) Suicide in Belarus. Crisis, 19,167–171.
14.
KondrichinS. V.LesterD. (2002) Suicide in the Ukraine. Crisis, 23,32–33.
15.
KünnapA. (2005) The Western contact field of the Uralic languages. Mankind Quarterly, 45,329–344.
16.
LesterD.KondrichinS. V. (2002) Genetic risk factors and variation in European suicide rates. British Journal of Psychiatry, 180,277–278. [Letter].
17.
LiD.HeL. (2006) Further clarification of the contribution of the tryptophan hydroxylase (TPH) gene to suicidal behavior using systematic allelic and genotypic meta-analyses. Human Genetics, 119,233–240.
18.
MaruğičA. (2005) History and geography of suicide: Could genetic risk factors account for the variation in suicide rates?American Journal of Medical Genetics C: Seminars in Medical Genetics, 133C,43–47. [Editorial].
19.
MaruğičA.FarmerA. (2001) Genetic risk factors as possible causes of the variation in European suicide rates. British Journal of Psychiatry, 179,194–196. [Editorial].
20.
MaruğičA.PermanM.ZorkoM.KravanjaM. (2006) Investigating surnames of males who committed suicide in a patrilineal society. Psychiatria Danubina, 18(Suppl 1), 140. [Abstract].
21.
PusztayJ. (2004) Thoughts on the chain-like homeland of the Uralic people. Mankind Quarterly, 44,313–328.
22.
RitterK.StompeT.VoracekM.EtzersdorferE. (2002) Suicide risk-related knowledge and attitudes of general practitioners. Wiener Klinische Wochenschrift, 114,685–690.
23.
RujescuD.ThalmaierA.MöllerH-J.BronischT.GieglingI. (2007) Molecular genetic findings in suicidal behavior: What is beyond the serotonergic system?Archives of Suicide Research, 11,17–40.
24.
SatoR.KawanishiC.YamadaT.HasegawaH.IkedaH.KatoD.FurunoT.KishidaI.HirayasuY. (2006) Knowledge and attitude towards suicide among medical students in Japan: Preliminary study. Psychiatry and Clinical Neurosciences, 60,558–562.
25.
SokalR. R.OdenN. L.RosenbergM. S.ThomsonB. A. (2000) Cancer incidences in Europe related to mortalities, and ethnohistoric, genetic and geographic distances. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the USA, 97,6067–6072.
26.
SokalR. R.OdenN. L.WalkerJ.Di GiovanniD.ThomsonB. A. (1996) Historical population movements in Europe influence genetic relationships in modern samples. Human Biology, 68,873–898.
27.
TureckiG. (2001) Suicidal behavior: Is there a genetic predisposition?Bipolar Disorders, 3,335–349.
28.
VoracekM. (2004) Suicide rate and blood groups: An ecological study of 39 nations. Perceptual and Motor Skills, 99,896–898.
29.
VoracekM. (2006a) Ancestry, genes, and suicide: A test of the Finno-Ugrian Suicide Hypothesis in the United States. Perceptual and Motor Skills, 103,543–550.
30.
VoracekM. (2006b) Population genetical musings on suicidal behavior as a common, harmful, heritable mental disorder. Behavioral and Brain Sciences, 29,423–424. [Commentary].
31.
VoracekM. (2006c) Suicide rate and skin color. Perceptual and Motor Skills, 102,836–838.
32.
VoracekM. (2007) Genetic factors in suicide: Reassessment of adoption studies and individuals' beliefs about adoption study findings. Psychiatria Danubina, 19,139–153.
33.
VoracekM.EgleJ.SchleicherS.LoiblL. M.SonneckG. (2007) The Beliefs in the Inheritance of Risk Factors for Suicide Scale (BIRFSS): Further results on demographic correlates, dimensionality, reliability, and validity. Omega: Journal of Death and Dying, 55,279–296.
34.
VoracekM.FisherM. L.LoiblL. M.TanH.SonneckG. (2007) Beliefs about the genetics of suicide in Canadian students: Cross-language validation of the Beliefs in the Inheritance of Risk Factors for Suicide Scale (BIRFSS). Unpublished manuscript, Univer. of Virginia.
35.
VoracekM.FisherM. L.MaruğičA. (2003) The Finno-Ugrian suicide hypothesis: Variation in European suicide rates by latitude and longitude. Perceptual and Motor Skills, 97,401–406.
36.
VoracekM.FormannA. K. (2004) Variation in European suicide rates is better accounted for by latitude and longitude than by national percentage of Finno-Ugrians and Type O blood: A rebuttal of Lester and Kondrichin (2004). Perceptual and Motor Skills, 99,1243–1250.
37.
VoracekM.LoiblL. M. (2007) Genetics of suicide: A systematic review of twin studies. Wiener Klinische Wochenschrift, 119,463–475.
38.
VoracekM.LoiblL. M.EgleJ.SchleicherS.SonneckG. (2007) Correlates, item-sequence invariance, and test-retest reliability of the Beliefs in the Inheritance of Risk Factors for Suicide Scale. Psychological Reports, 101,1107–1117.
39.
VoracekM.LoiblL. M.KandrychynS. (2007) Testing the Finno-Ugrian Suicide Hypothesis: Replication and refinement with regional suicide data from Eastern Europe. Perceptual and Motor Skills, 104,985–994.
40.
VoracekM.LoiblL. M.SonneckG. (2007a) Beliefs in the Inheritance of Risk Factors for Suicide Scale: Development, reliability, stability, and convergent and discriminant validity. Psychological Reports, 101,107–116.
41.
VoracekM.LoiblL. M.SonneckG. (2007b) The malleability of beliefs in the genetics of suicide: Intervention study with the Beliefs in the Inheritance of Risk Factors for Suicide Scale (BIRFSS). Unpublished manuscript, Univer. of Virginia.
42.
VoracekM.LoiblL. M.SwamiV.VintilãM.SinniahD.PillaiS. K.SubramaniamP.SonneckG.FurnhamA.LesterD. (2007) The Beliefs in the Inheritance of Risk Factors for Suicide Scale (BIRFSS): Cross-cultural validation in Malaysia, Romania, the UK, and the USA. Unpublished manuscript, Univer. of Virginia.
43.
VoracekM.MaruğičA. (in press) Testing the Finno-Ugrian Suicide Hypothesis: Geographic variation of elderly suicide rates across Europe. Nordic Journal of Psychiatry.
44.
VoracekM.SonneckG. (2006) Medical and psychology students' disbelief in the inheritance of risk factors for suicide. Psychological Reports, 99,599–602.
45.
VoracekM.SonneckG. (2007) Surname study of suicide in Austria: Differences in regional suicide rates correspond to the genetic structure of the population. Wiener Klinische Wochenschrift, 199,355–360.
46.
VoracekM.VintilăM.FisherM. L.YipP. S. F. (2002) Evidence for lack of change in seasonality of suicide from Timiş county, Romania. Perceptual and Motor Skills, 94,1071–1078.
