Citizenship education appears in the curricula of many nations. The aims of citizenship education are often based on the aspirations of society and supported by research and theory that describes what citizenship education is or should be. Seldom do we find links between these aspirational visions and actual societal outcomes. Citizenship education, in different guises, has been a goal of the New Zealand education system since formal schooling was established in 1877. This article sets out to ask whether this focus has had the intended outcome. The citizenship education goals of the current curriculum are matched against national and international studies that give an insight into what kind of society and what kind of citizens New Zealand has produced. The results show that overall New Zealand is a stable, democratic, safe and fair society but with areas of injustice and inequity still to be addressed.
References
1.
AitkenG.SinnemaC. (2008) Effective Pedagogy in Social Sciences/Tikanga $ Iwi: Best evidence synthesis iteration. Wellington: Ministry of Education.
2.
Alton-LeeA. (2003) Quality Teaching for Diverse Learners in Schooling: Best evidence synthesis. Wellington: Ministry of Education.
3.
ArcherE.OpenshawR. (1992) Citizenship as ‘Official’ Goals in Social Studies in New Zealand, in OpenshawR. (Ed.) New Zealand Social Studies: Past, present and future, pp. 19–33. Palmerston North: Dunmore Press.
4.
BarrH. (1998) Citizenship Education without a Textbook, Children's Social and Economics Education, 4(1), 28–35.
5.
Carroll-LindJ. (2009) School Safety: An inquiry into the safety of students at school. Wellington: Office of the Children's Commissioner.
6.
CaygillR.KirkhamS. (2008) Trends in Year 5 Mathematics Achievement 1994–2006. New Zealand results from three cycles of the Trends in Mathematics and Science study (TIMSS). Wellington: New Zealand: Research Division, Ministry of Education.
7.
CaygillR.SokS. (2008) PISA 2006: School context of science achievement. How Ready Are 15 Year-Olds for Tomorrow's World? Wellington: Comparative Education Research Unit, Ministry of Education.
8.
CoganJ. (1997) Multi-dimensional Citizenship: Education policy for the twenty-first century. Tokyo: Sasakawa Peace Foundation.
9.
CubittS. (2006) The Draft New Zealand Curriculum, Curriculum Matters, 2, 195–212.
10.
Education Review Office (ERO) (2006) The Quality of Teaching in Years 4 and 8: Social studies. Wellington: ERO.
11.
Education Review Office (ERO) (2007) The Teaching of Social Studies: Good practice. Wellington: ERO.
GilbertR. (1996) Studying Society and Environment: A handbook for teachers. Melbourne: Macmillan Education.
14.
GrossmanD.LeeW.O.KennedyK., (Eds) (2008) Citizenship Curriculum in Asia and the Pacific. Dordrecht: Springer & Comparative Education Research Centre.
15.
HébertY.SearsA. (2001) Citizenship Education in Canada: Invited theme, Canadian Education Research and Information Service (CERIS). http://projektiqytetar.org/Citizenship_Education.pdf (accessed 9 March 2012).
KennedyK.FairbrotherG. (2004) Asian Perspectives on Citizenship Education in Review: Postcolonial construction or pre-colonial values, in LeeW.O.GrossmanD.KennedyK.FairbrotherG. (Eds) Citizenship in Asia and the Pacific: Concepts and issues, pp. 289–302. Dordrecht: Springer & Comparative Education Research Centre.
18.
KerrD. (2000) Citizenship Education: An international comparison across 16 countries. Paper presented at American Educational Research Association, New Orleans, 24–28 April.
19.
McGeeJ. (1998) Curriculum in Conflict: Historical development of citizenship in social studies, in BensonP.OpenshawR. (Eds) New Horizons for New Zealand Social Studies, pp. 43–52. Palmerston North: ERDC Press.
20.
Ministry of Education (2007) The New Zealand Curriculum. Wellington: Learning Media.
21.
Ministry of Education (2008) State of Education in New Zealand: 2008. Wellington: Strategy and System Performance, Ministry of Education.
22.
Ministry of Social Development (2008) Children and Young People: Indicators of wellbeing in New Zealand. Wellington: Ministry of Social Development.
23.
MutchC. (2003) Citizenship Education in New Zealand: Inside or outside the curriculum?Citizenship, Social and Economics Education, 5(3), 164–179.
24.
MutchC. (2004) Educational Policy and Notions of Citizenship in Four Asia-Pacific Societies, Asia Pacific Education Review, 5(2), 178–187. http://dx.doi.org/10.1007/BF03024955.
25.
MutchC. (2005) Developing Global Citizens: The rhetoric and the reality in New Zealand, in WhiteC.OpenshawR. (Eds) Democracy at the Crossroads: International perspectives on global citizenship education, pp. 187–210. Lanham, MD: Lexington Books.
26.
MutchC. (2008) ‘Creative and Innovative Citizenry’: Exploring the past, present and future of citizenship education in New Zealand, in GrossmanD.LeeW.O.KennedyK. (Eds) Citizenship Curriculum in Asia and the Pacific. Dordrecht: Springer & Comparative Education Research Centre. http://dx.doi.org/10.1007/978–1 −4020–8745 −5_12.
27.
MutchC. (2009) Curriculum: What, how and for whom?Curriculum Matters, 5, 1–3.
28.
MutchC. (2010) Embedding Education for Citizenship into Pedagogical Practices: The case of New Zealand, in KennedyK.LeeW.O.GrossmanD., Citizenship Pedagogies in Asia and the Pacific. Dordrecht: Springer & Comparative Education Research Centre.
29.
MutchC.HunterP.MilliganA.OpenshawR.SiteneA. (2008) Understanding the Social Sciences as a Learning Area: A position paper prepared for the Ministry of Education. Wellington: Ministry of Education.
30.
Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development (OECD) (2009) Education at a Glance. Paris: OECD.
31.
PedersonP.CoganJ. (2002) Civics Education Pedagogy and Assessment in the Pacific Rim: Six cases, International Journal of Social Education, 17(1), 16–30.
32.
PerryB. (2009). Non-income Measures of Material Well-Being and Hardship. First results from the 2008 New Zealand Living Standards Survey with international comparisons. Working paper. 01/09. Wellington: New Zealand: Ministry of Social Development.
33.
ReedG. (2004) Multi-dimensional Citizenship, Confucianism, Humanism and the Imagined Community, in LeeW.O.GrossmanD.KennedyK.FairbrotherG. (Eds) Citizenship in Asia and the Pacific: Concepts and issues, pp. 239–256. Dordrecht: Springer & Comparative Education Research Centre.
34.
RiversJ. (2008) Growing Independence: A summary of key findings from the Competent Learners @ 14 project. Wellington: Ministry of Education.
35.
Torney-PurtaJ.LehmannR.OswaldH.SchulzH. (2001) Citizenship and Education in Twenty-eight Countries: Civic knowledge and engagement at age fourteen. Amsterdam: International Association for the Evaluation of Educational Achievement.
36.
WylieC.HodgenE. (2007) Competent Learners @ 16: Competency levels and development over time. Wellington: Ministry of Education.
37.
WylieC.HodgenE.HipkinsR.VaughanK. (2009) Competent Learners on the Edge of Adulthood: A summary of key findings from the Competent Learners @ 16 project. Wellington: New Zealand Council for Educational Research.
