Refocusing Graduate Public Affairs Education: A Need for Diversity Competencies in Human Resource Management

Abstract

It is generally agreed that diversity is a critical challenge for managers and that advancing organizational diversity is both an ethical and a pragmatic requirement for effective public administration. However, it may be argued that graduate public affairs education relating to human resource management (HRM) has not sufficiently attended to diversity topics and that public affairs graduate curricula in general have not evidenced sufficient inclusion of diversity themes. This essay indicates a need for curricular revision that includes diversity competencies. The research and corresponding analysis is presented in two parts, corresponding to two phases of research. The first addresses findings from graduate student surveys conducted over three years at the University of Vermont. The second concerns data collected from 41 NASPAA-accredited and 17 unaccredited NASPAA-member programs in public affairs. The results from the first phase suggest that graduate public affairs students need greater exposure to diversity themes and issues. The second phase results suggest that NASPAA-accredited programs are not much different from unaccredited member programs in incorporating diversity topics into curricular offerings or otherwise exhibiting a commitment to diversity. The essay ends with several recommendations for programs intending to develop or revise their public policy and administration curricula in order to better attend to diversity concerns.

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Anderson

M. L.

Collins

H. P.

. 2004. Race Class and Gender. Boston: Thomson/Wadsworth.

Argyle

2005. “Are We Preparing our Students for Diversity? Diversity Management in MPA Programs.” Paper presented at the National Conference for Teaching Public Administration, Fort Walton Beach, Florida, Feb . 12-13 .

Baugher

Varanelli

Weisbord

. 2000. “Gender and Culture Diversity Occurring in Self-Formed Work Groups.” Journal of Management Issues, 12(4):391–407.

Burnier

2003. “Giving Voice to Gender in the MPA Classroom: Teaching Organization Theory with a Gender Emphasis.” Journal of Public Affairs Education, 9(4):277–286.

Bagshaw

2004. “Is Diversity Divisive? A Positive Training Approach.” Industrial and Commercial Training, 36(4):153–157.

Dede

2002. “Building a Public Personnel System for the City of Freedonia: A New Approach to Teaching Human Resources Management in an MPA Program.” Journal of Public Affairs Education, 8(4):275–286.

Earnest

Shawnta

. 2003. “Managing Diversity Using a Strategic Planned Change Approach.” The Journal of Management Development, 22(10):863–881.

Ferris

G. R.

et al. 1999. “Human Resources Management: Some New Directions.” Journal of Management, 25(3):385–388.

Frederickson

1980. New Public Administration. Tuscaloosa: University of Alabama Press.

10.

Golembiewski

1995. Managing Diversity in Organizations. Tuscaloosa: The University of Alabama Press.

11.

Hudson

2003. “Perspective: Workplace Diversity—A Competitive Advantage.” Business Insurance, 37(11):14.

12.

Jansen

D. J.

2005. “Black Dean: Race, Reconciliation, and the Emotions of Deanship.” Harvard Educational Review, 75(3):306–325.

13.

Oldfield

Candler

Johnson

. 2006. “Social Class, Sexual Orientation, and Toward Proactive Social Equity Scholarship.” American Review of Public Administration, 36(2):156–172.

14.

Pitts

D. W.

Jarry

E. M.

. 2005. “Ethnic Diversity and Organizational Performance: Assessing Diversity Effects at the Managerial and Street Levels.” Paper presented at the 8th Public Management Research Conference, Los Angeles, CA, Sept . 29 –Oct. 1 . Available at http://pmranet.org/conferences/USC2005/USC2005papers/pmra.pitts.jarry.2005.doc

15.

Riccucci

2003. Managing Diversity in Public Sector Workforces. Boulder: Westview Press.

16.

Rice

Mitchell

. 2006. “Promoting Cultural Competency in Public Administration and Public Service Delivery: Utilizing Self-Assessment Tools and Performance Measures.” Available at http://www.naspaa.org/principals/conference/2006/papers/.

17.

Seyed-Mahmoud

2004. “Managing Workforce Diversity as an Essential Resource for Improving Organizational Performance.” Work Study, 53(6):521–532.

18.

Smith

R. E.

2001. Human Resources Administration: A School-Based Perspective. Larchmont, New York: Eye on Education.

19.

Tilford Group . 2004. “Multicultural Competency Development: Preparing Students to Live and Work in a Diverse World.” Manhattan, Kansas: Kansas State University.

20.

Tillman

L. C.

2002. “Culturally Sensitive Research Approaches: An African American Perspective.” Educational Researcher, 31(9):3–12.

21.

Trower

C. A.

Chait

R. P.

. 2002. “Faculty Diversity: Too Little for Too Long.” Harvard Magazine, (March/April):1–12.

22.

Tshikwatamba

N. E.

2003. “The Challenge of Managing Diversity in South Africa: A Long-time Observer and Researcher Shares His Views on New Opportunities the Human Resources Community Has to Transform Itself and Shift to More Inclusive Personnel Policies and Approaches.” The Public Manager, 32(3):36–39.