Abstract
Eutopic and ectopic endometria of women with adenomyosis show a series of metabolic and molecular abnormalities that increase angiogenesis and proliferation, decrease apoptosis, allow local production of estrogens, create progesterone resistance, and impair cytokine expression. These changes enhance the ability of the endometrium to infiltrate the junctional zone myometrium and the growth of ectopic tissue. In addition, in these subjects several immunological abnormalities have been observed, together with an increased production of ‘free radicals’ leading to excessive growth of endometrial stromal cells that may facilitate the establishment of adenomyosis. A limiting factor is that these studies have been performed on hysterectomy specimens representing final stages of the disease. This increased knowledge has created new therapeutic options, including the block of local aromatase production through the use of selective estrogen receptor modulators, estrogen-progestin combinations and gonadotropin-releasing hormone super agonists. Also promising are investigations into the mechanism of dysmenorrhea and abnormal uterine bleeding.
Keywords
Over the last 20 years, the scientific community devoted increasing attention to structural, as well as functional, changes occurring in endometrial differentiation, metabolism, apoptosis, neo-angiogenesis and innervation in women with endometriosis, suggesting a primary role for a higher than physiological invasiveness of eutopic endometrium in the genesis of the disease [1–4].
Although to a lesser extent, a number of investigations have also addressed the issue of the existence of changes occurring in eutopic endometrium in women with adenomyosis. In this case, however, attention has also been drawn to alterations observed in the inner myometrium, specifically an increase in its thickness [5]. This increased knowledge has important consequences as it is leading to new therapeutic options, both in terms of pain relief, including dysmenorrhea and abnormal uterine bleeding as well as providing the basis for treatment with adenomyosis-associated infertility.
A number of hypotheses have been proposed to explain the genesis of adenomyosis. At the same time, discussing the etiology of the condition is outside the scope of this review, as in this article the focus will be on experimental data, not hypotheses. Therefore, the specific aim of this review is to describe how a modified endometrium with an increased ‘aggressiveness’ may represent one of the mechanisms through which adenomyosis may be produced. In addition, although it is true that a hypothesis may be formulated on the fact that depending on the ‘aggressiveness’ of the modified endometrium, the disease may progress to a different extent, but there is insufficient information available to elaborate on this point.
Here, we wish to summarize information gathered over the last two decades on changes in the endometrium and inner myometrium in women with adenomyosis. In doing so it is important to stress that – contrary to what happens in women with endometriosis – even after noninvasive diagnosis became possible, studies of the endometrium in adenomyosis patients have been invariably carried out on hysterectomy samples. This means that, as yet, no information exists on the endometrium in initial or subclinical forms of the disease; a further consequence is that no epidemiological data on the incidence of adenomyosis are available, although, back in 1995, de Souza
Methodology
For this review, we searched the database SCOPUS (from 1990 to the middle of 2011) for all full texts and/or abstract articles published in English. Search terms included ‘uterine adenomyosis’ and ‘eutopic endometrium’ and with or without ‘ectopic endometrium’. In fact, the search of ‘adenomyosis’ and ‘endometrium’ revealed over 900 papers. The search of ‘adenomyosis’ and ‘eutopic endometrium’ resulted in 104 papers; of these articles we selected those showing changes that may facilitate the establishment of the disease. In addition, upon screening the results for applicable titles and/or abstracts – with one exception – only the articles with original data in the international English literature were utilized
Clinical data on studies of the eutopic endometrium in adenomyosis.
Only the abstract was available.
A: Adenomyosis; C: Control group; E: Endometriosis; F: Fibroid; US: Ultrasound.
What follows is a detailed review of the literature on the subject, divided into sections covering all major aspects of the problem.
Endometrial anomalies
A number of anomalies have been found both in women with adenomyosis and in those with endometriosis. This should not be surprising given recent data indicating that up to 35% of women with frank endometriosis, the presence of adenomyosis can also be determined [7]. In 2005, Kunz
Innervation
In 2002, Quinn and Kirk studied patterns of uterine innervation in normal as well as abnormal uteri removed at hysterectomy for a variety of clinical conditions [10]. Histologically normal uteri from nulliparous or parous women showed similar patterns of innervation, namely the presence of nerve bundles at the endometrial—myometrial interface and in the subserosal layers. In contradistinction to this, uteri with adenomyosis showed large areas of myometrium without nerves and absence of nerves in the neurovascular bundles supplying these areas. Then, in 2007, Quinn described in greater detail the innervation of the uterus in women with adenomyosis [11]. He used a standard immunohistochemical staining utilizing the antiprotein gene product 9.5 (PGP9.5) and again compared two groups of uteri: one to be considered normal and the other with a histopathological diagnosis of adenomyosis. Normal innervation of the uterus included concentrations of nerves in the subserosal layers and at the endometrial—myometrial interface with sparse, neurovascular bundles distributed throughout the myometrial stroma. In contradistinction to this, in cases with adenomyosis, he found no nerves in areas with adenomyotic foci and an absence of nerves at the endometrial—myometrial nerve plexus. Quinn concluded that adenomyosis is associated with loss of nerve fibers at the endometrial—myometrial interface and absence of nerve fibers in the adenomyotic foci.
In relation to the endometrium, its innervation has also been reported in women with endometriosis [12,13]. Zhang
Subsequently, the same group carried out a study of contiguous endometrial and myometrial tissues in 37 women with uterine fibroids and 29 women with adenomyosis [15] and, while confirming the detection of PGP9.5-immunoactive nerve fibers in the functional layer of the endometrium in women with pain, but not in those without pain, found no statistical differences between women with adenomyosis and uterine fibroids. These investigations suggest that PGP9.5-immunoactive nerve fibers appear in the endometrium and myometrium of women with painful adenomyosis and uterine fibroids may play a role in pain generation in these two disorders.
Angiogenesis
In order to survive and grow, endometrial cells and stroma must acquire a blood supply; indeed, during a menstrual cycle there are waves of active angiogenesis within the endometrium, with the development of arterioles and a capillary network, an event involving a spatially regulated process of vascular smooth cell differentiation, which is under the influence of a number of factors [16]. The activity of some of these factors in women with adenomyosis has now been investigated with interesting results.
Of special interest are enzymes called matrix metalloproteinases (MMPs). They are expressed in the human endometrium as a consequence of cellular events during the menstrual cycle that require extracellular matrix remodeling [17]. In 1997, Bruner
Proliferation & apoptosis
Jones
With the aim of determining whether adenomyotic lesions originate in the basal layer of the eutopic endometrium, Matsumoto
Steroid & cytokine production & responsiveness
In 1993 Yamamoto and coworkers detected aromatase and estrone sulfatase activity in glandular cells of eutopic and ectopic endometrial tissues in women with adenomyosis and concluded that newly synthesized estrogens may enhance the growth of ectopic tissue [26]. In the same year, Lei
In contradistinction to this, compared with a normal endometrium, progesterone receptor isoform B (PR-B) and IκBα – a member of a family of cellular proteins that function to inhibit the NF-κB, a protein complex that controls the transcription of DNA – were statistically significantly reduced in ectopic as well as eutopic endometrium from women with adenomyosis [28].
Sotnikova
Immune components
As early as 1993, immunological abnormalities were identified in women with adenomyosis [30]; in affected subjects expression of the HLA-DR antigen in the glandular cells of both eutopic and ectopic endomettia was significantly lower than in samples from normal controls. Ota and his group have further evaluated T cell subsets, including γδT cells, HLA antigens and adhesion molecules expressed in endometria of patients with adenomyosis. Compared with samples from normal subjects, in both eutopic and ectopic endometria they found a significantly increased expression of these antigens, particularly in the number of γδT cells in the stroma and adhesion molecules and HLA antigens on the glandular cells [31]. Subsequently, Chiang and Hill described key immune response elements in eutopic and ectopic endometria obtained at hysterectomy and observed that activated T cells, IFN-γ and up regulation of antigen presentation may play a role in normal endometrial physiology [32]. T cells, IFN-γ and HLA-DR-positive stromal cells were more abundant in the secretory endometrium than in proliferative samples. CD3, IFN-γ and HLA-DR-positive cells were scattered throughout the myometrium and, interestingly, were concentrated around vessels. They concluded that the increased number of T cells, the higher expression of IFN-γ, and an enhanced antigen presentation in ectopic, compared with eutopic, endometrium supports the concept that cellular immune activation is clearly involved in adenomyosis.
Ota and Tanaka have also investigated the expression of very late activation antigens (VLA-2, 3, 4, 5, 6 and E-cadherin) and found that the expression of VLA-2, VLA-3 and E-cadherin was significantly increased throughout the menstrual cycle in samples from subjects with adenomyosis [33]. By contrast, the expression of VLA-4 in the adenomyosis group was significantly reduced in the secretory phase. In their view, results suggest the presence of a defective microenvironment in the eutopic endometrium of adenomyosis patients. A similar increase in expression of heat shock protein 27 was noted in the eutopic endometrium from patients with adenomyosis compared with controls, regardless of the menstrual phase [34].
A number of leukocyte anomalies have also been observed in the endometrium of patients suffering from adenomyosis. Propst
Altered production of reactive oxygen species
An important area of investigation of endometria from women with adenomyosis is that related to the production of free radicals. These are intimately involved in the physiology of reproduction and enzymes that produce and eliminate various free radicals and are distributed throughout the body. These enzymes are believed to modulate concentrations of free radicals at an optimal level and maintain the body's homeostasis. Reactive oxygen species may modulate growth of endometrial stroma and, under pathologic conditions such as adenomyosis and endometriosis, increased oxidative stress, and the depletion of antioxidants may contribute to excessive growth of endometrial stromal cells. For this reason, it is useful to study this class of enzymes in pathologies involving the endometrium.
The first enzymic activity investigated in women with adenomyosis is glutathione peroxidase. Its expression on the surface of glandular epithelia during the menstrual cycle in fertile controls is weak in the early proliferative phase and gradually increases to become most marked in the early secretory phase, decreasing thereafter. In contradistinction to this, glutathione peroxidase expression in the eutopic endometrium in adenomyosis and endometriosis is persistently higher than in controls throughout the menstrual cycle, suggesting a pathological role in both disorders [37].
A second enzyme investigated is xanthine oxidase. Its expression in the glandular epithelium of normal subjects varies according to the menstrual phase, but in patients with adenomyosis this variation differs completely from that of controls; xanthine oxidase expression seems to be present in ectopic endometrial tissue in all cases. Mean nomogram levels in the glandular epithelium in adenomyosis tissue have been found to be as high as those in the early secretory phase in the eutopic endometrium. The authors concluded that aberrant expression of xanthine oxidase in eutopic and ectopic endometria appears to play a pathological role in endometriosis and adenomyosis [38].
COX-2 is a third enzyme examined in connection with adenomyosis. Recent experiments suggest that COX-2 antagonizes cell apoptosis, increases invasiveness and promotes angiogenesis. Ota
Ota
Finally, Ota
Pathogenesis
The advent of noninvasive techniques for the study of adenomyosis has helped our knowledge of the pathophysiology of this disease, documenting that it can be already present in women in their 30s. This increased knowledge has now produced new therapeutic options, both pharmacological and surgical [42,43].
Given that adenomyosis is an estrogen-dependent disease, a first-line investigation dealt with counteracting their response to estrogen suppression. Maia
Clinical significance
Recently, Hatok
Several studies exist on the multifactorial effects of gonadotropin releasing hormone superagonists (GnRHa) on adenomyotic tissues. Khan
Progestins have been utilized in patients with endometriosis for decades, although the absence of diagnostic tools prevented their use in those with adenomyosis. It seems that this treatment may produce a series of complex changes and more information is required before a final conclusion can be reached. On the one hand, there is a certain degree of progesterone resistance in patients with adenomyosis; Yang
In addition, in a recent study Mehasseb
Potential markers
On the other hand, Nie
Nie
A second option for a marker is based on the work of Shen
Finally, Huang and colleagues have just published that tyrosine kinase receptor B (TrkB) is expressed in the eutopic endometrium of women with adenomyosis and that the average level of TrkB protein and of TrkB mRNA in secretory endometrial samples of women with adenomyosis was significantly higher than that in controls (p < 0.01) [58]. The expression level of the TrkB protein was positively correlated with the serum CA125 (p = 0.016) and with the intensity of dysmenorrhea (p = 0.002). The authors concluded that measurement of TrkB in the eutopic endometrium may represent a marker of the progression of adenomyosis.
The fact that new imaging techniques allow an early detection of adenomyosis means that the previously described new knowledge can also be applied to infertility associated with the disease. Indeed, today a number of medical and surgical techniques are available to improve the chances of conception in younger women with adenomyosis [59]. Having said this, the fact remains that substantially more information is necessary on the situation existing in the eutopic endometrium at the early stages of the disease to formulate a meaningful hypothesis on its role in causing adenomyosis.
An interesting approach for a comparative diagnosis of adenomyosis versus fibroids has been suggested by Hever
In conclusion, evidence is also accumulating that endometrial anomalies in adenomyosis and endometriosis indicate that both are phenotypes of a single disorder rather than two distinct disease entities [61] and a report comparing the eutopic endometrium in both conditions is in preparation. In addition, the high correlation between the presence of endometriosis and that of adenomyosis in first degree relatives is suggestive of a common origin [62].
Future perspective
Within the next 5 years we should witness a progressive switch in the diagnosis of adenomyosis from a posthysterectomy finding to an early, noninvasive procedure (3D transvaginal ultrasound and MRI) capable of identifying early stages of the disease.
Executive summary
Adenomyosis is associated with loss of nerve fibers at the endometrial—myometrial interface and absence of nerve fibers in the adenomyotic foci.
The elevation of matrix metalloproteinase-2 and −9 expression may contribute to invasion of endometrial tissues into the myometrium and increased angiogenesis in adenomyotic implants.
Altered apoptosis and proliferation of the eutopic endometrium can possibly play a role in the pathophysiology of adenomyosis.
Aromatase and estrone sulfatase activity in glandular cells of eutopic and ectopic endometrial tissues in women with adenomyosis may enhance the growth of ectopic tissue.
Numerous immunological abnormalities have been identified in women with adenomyosis.
Reactive oxygen species modulate growth of endometrial stroma and under pathologic conditions, such as adenomyosis and endometriosis, increased oxidative stress and depletion of antioxidants may contribute to excessive growth of endometrial stromal cells.
Glutathione peroxidase expression in the eutopic endometrium in adenomyosis and endometriosis is persistently higher than in controls throughout the menstrual cycle.
The exaggerated expression of these enzymes suggests a crucial role for superoxide in subfertility and/or miscarriage in adenomyosis and endometriosis.
A retrospective study of endometrial tissues obtained from patients with adenomyosis showed that aromatase was expressed in 80% of the eutopic endometrial slices, mainly in the stromal cells, whereas it was mostly absent in adenomyotic tissue.
Estrogens may endow epithelial—mesenchymal transition cells with migratory and invasive properties.
The effect of estrogen is suppressed by the selective estrogen receptor modulator raloxifene suggesting that this compound may represent a potential therapeutic agent for adenomyosis patients.
The measurement of endometrial aromatase cytochrome P450 (CYP19) in adenomyosis patients could be of discriminative value in the prediction of the degree of estrogen dependency of the disease.
Gonadotropin-releasing hormone superagonist treatment for periods of 3–6 months is able to markedly reduce the inflammatory reaction and angiogenesis and to significantly induce apoptosis in tissues derived from women with adenomyosis.
In addition to a hypoestrogenic effect, a direct antiproliferative effect of gonadotropin releasing hormone superagonist may be involved in the regression of adenomyotic foci with consequent remission of clinical symptoms.
Progestins have been utilized in patients with endometriosis for decades, although the absence of diagnostic tools prevented their use in those with adenomyosis. However, there is a degree of progesterone resistance in patients with adenomyosis and progestins' effect may be diminished.
A recent study concluded that estrogen-B expression and the lack of progesterone expression are probably related to the development and/or progression of the disease.
It seems that adenomyosis is an epigenetic disease amenable to rectification by pharmacological agents.
Nuclear p65 may be developed into a marker for adenomyosis in women with heavier menstrual bleeding and women with dysmenorrheal.
Tyrosine kinase receptor B is expressed in eutopic endometrium of women with adenomyosis and its measurement in eutopic endometrium may represent a marker of the progression of adenomyosis.
An improved and earlier diagnosis will have a major impact on three fronts:
First, in the presence of infertility it will be easier to diagnose the existence of adenomyosis as a cause or contributing factor;
Second, the new techniques will allow large screenings and therefore make it possible to collect data on the epidemiology of the disease and its true impact on fertility;
Third, availability of transvaginal ultrasound and MRI will dramatically improve the possibilities for treatment, whether pharmacological, surgical or combined. A number of procedures are already available and over the next 5–10 years these techniques will be applied more and more widely. Comparative studies will follow and the superiority of one method over another will be determined.
Within 5 years endometrial markers of adenomyosis will have been identified and tested and within 10 years they will be widely applied.
New treatment modalities will be developed based on the increased knowledge of the pathophysiology of the disease; it is anticipated that within 10 years these will be able to block the progression of adenomyosis, possibly avoiding surgery altogether.
The concomitant presence of adenomyosis and endometriosis will be evaluated in statistically valid ways; this will permit the collection of ‘clean’ epidemiological data in younger women and the study of homogeneous groups of women with endometriosis, adenomyosis or both conditions, versus nonaffected controls. These data are needed in order to find out whether or when adenomyosis becomes a progressive disease and design conservative treatment at an early stage.
In the final analysis these studies will be able to provide a definitive response to the hypothesis that adenomyosis and endometriosis are phenotypes of the same metabolic and molecular disorder.
