To compare the incidence of delirium in postoperative cardiac surgical patients treated with either cimetidine or ranitidine.
Method:
Cardiac surgery patients were randomized to receive either cimetidine or ranitidine postoperatively. Each patient underwent three Mini-Mental Status Examinations (MMSE) and the medical record was reviewed for pertinent past medical history, laboratory data, and evidence of delirium on three occasions: one day preoperatively (before H-2 blocker was given), in the early postoperative period (while receiving the H-2 blocker); usually two days postoperatively on the day of hospital discharge (several days after the H-2 blocker had been discontinued).
Results:
Overall, both groups in the early postoperative period showed a significant decrease in the MMSE score (27.11 ± 4.44 to 25.38 ± 2.87, mean ± SD; t = 5.16, p < .0005), which resolved by the time of hospital discharge. There was no significant difference between cimetidine and ranitidine. Both age and preoperative MMSE score were strongly associated with the development of delirium.
Conclusions:
We found no significant difference between cimetidine's versus ranitidine's effect upon cognitive functioning in the postoperative cardiac surgical patient. This was true even when controlling for age and length of stay.
WaltRPTrotmanIFGoldingPLShepherdTHRawlingsJHuntRHColin-JonesDMilton-ThompsonGJMisiewiczJJ. Comparison of twice-daily ranitidine with standard cimetidine treatment of duodenal ulcer. Gut1981;22:319–322.
2.
AshtonMGHoldsworthCDRyanFPMooreM. Healing of gastric ulcers after one, two, and three months of ranitidine. British Journal of Medicine—Clinical Research1982;284:467–468.
3.
HineKRHolmesGKMelikianVLuceyMFaircloughPD. Ranitidine in reflux oesophagitis: A double-blind placebo-controlled study. Digestion1984;29:119–123.
4.
BurlandWLDuncanWAHesselboTMillsJGSharpePCHaggieSJWyllieJH. Pharmacological evaluation of cimetidine, a new histamine H2-receptor antagonist in healthy men. British Journal of Clinical Pharmacology1975;2:481–486.
5.
ClaymanCB. Evaluation of cimetidine (Tagamet). An antagonist of hydrochloric acid secretion. Journal of the American Medical Association1977;238:1289–1290.
6.
BinderJHCoccoACrossleyRJFinkelsteinWFontRFriedmanGGroarkeJHughesWJohnsonAFMcGuiganJESummersRVlahcevicRWilsonECWinshipDH. Cimetidine in the treatment of duodenal ulcer: A multicenter double blind study. Gastroenterology1978;74:380–388.
7.
WinshipDH. Cimetidine in the treatment of duodenal ulcer: Review and commentary. Gastroenterology1978;74:402–406.
8.
EnglertEJr.FrestonJWGrahamDYFinkelsteinWKrussDMPriestRJRaskinJBRhodesJBRogersAIWengerJWilcoxLLCrossleyRJ. Cimetidine, antacid, and hospitalization in the treatment of benign gastric ulcer: A multicenter double-blind study. Gastroenterology1978;74:416–425.
9.
FrestonJW. Cimetidine in the treatment of gastric ulcer: Review and commentary. Gastroenterology1978;74:426–430.
10.
KrussDMLittmanA. Safety of cimetidine. Gastroenterology1978;74:478–483.
11.
BrimblecombeRWDuncanWA. The relevance to man of pre-clinical data for cimetidine. Proceedings of the second International Symposium on Histamine H2-Receptor Antagonists. BurlandWLSimkinsMA, editors. International congress series no. 416/G. Amsterdam: Excerpta Medica1977:54–66.
12.
SomogyiAGuglerR. Clinical pharmacokinetics of cimetidine. Clinical Pharmacokinetics1983;8:463–495.
13.
Cimetidine—an investigational drug for the treatment of duodenal ulcer. Medical Letter1977;19:29–31.
14.
Cimetidine (Tagamet): Update on adverse effects. Medical Letter1978;20:77–78.
15.
SchentagJJCerraFBCalleriGMDeGlopperERoseJQBernardH. Pharmacokinetic and clinical studies in patients with cimetidine-associated mental confusion. Lancet1979;1(8109):177–181.
16.
SchentagJJCerraFBCalleriGMLeisingMEFrenchMABernardH. Age, disease, and cimetidine disposition in healthy subjects and chronically ill patients. Clinical Pharmacology and Therapeutics1981;29:737–743.
17.
FeldmanMBurtonME. Histamine2-receptor antagonists: Standard therapy for acid-peptic diseases (first of two parts). New England Journal of Medicine1990;323:1672–1680.
18.
Cimetidine and ranitidine [editorial]. Lancet1982;1(8272):601.
19.
Ranitidine (Zantac). Medical Letter1982;24:111–113.
20.
StrumWB. Ranitidine. Journal of the American Medical Association1983;250:1894–1896.
21.
ZeldisJBFriedmanLSIsselbacherKJ. Ranitidine: A new H2-receptor antagonist. New England Journal of Medicine1983;309:1368–1373.
22.
RobinsAHLuckeWMcFadyenMLWrightJP. Effect of the H2-receptor antagonist ranitidine on depression and anxiety in duodenal ulcer patients. Postgraduate Medical Journal1984;60:353–355.
23.
FrestonJW. Cimetidine: II. Adverse reactions and patterns of use. Annals of Internal Medicine1982;97:728–734.
24.
McGuiganJE. A consideration of the adverse effects of cimetidine. Gastroenterology1981;80:181–192.
25.
ThomasJMMisiewiczG. Histamine H2-receptor antagonists in the short- and long-term treatment of duodenal ulcer. Clinics in Gastroenterology1984;13:501–541.
26.
AmbielliMP. Drug stop: A review of histamine 2-receptor antagonists. Journal of Neurosurgical Nursing1983;15:370–373.
27.
ZimmermanTW. Problems associated with medical treatment of peptic ulcer disease. American Journal of Medicine1984;77:51–56.
28.
FlindACRowley-JonesD. H2-receptor blockers and mental confusion [letter]. Lancet1984;2(8394):98.
29.
WeddingtonWWMuellingAEMoosaHHKimballCPRowlettRR. Cimetidine toxic reactions masquerading as delirium tremens. Journal of the American Medical Association1981;245:1058–1059.
30.
SawyerDConnerCSScalleyR. Cimetidine: Adverse reactions and acute toxicity. American Journal of Hospital Pharmacology1981;38:188–197.
31.
GrahnenATyllstromJTyllstromBJamesomSLoofL. Cimetidine accumulation and mental confusion in cirrhosis (letter). New England Journal of Medicine1982;307:187.
32.
PedrazzoliSPetrinPPasqualiCMilitelloCSpertiCFregoneseVSiminiG. Ranitidine reverses cimetidine-induced mental confusion in a patient with Zollinger-Ellison syndrome [letter]. Archives of Surgery1983;118:256.
33.
Drugs for treatment of peptic ulcers. Drugs of Choice. Medical Letter. rev. ed.1993:144–150.
34.
LipsyRJFennertyBFaganT. Clinical review of histamine2-receptor antagonists. Archives of Internal Medicine1990;150:745–751.
35.
WaltRPLaBrooySJAvgerinosAOehrTRileyAMisiewiczJJ. Investigations on the penetration of ranitidine into the cerebrospinal fluid and a comparison of the effects of ranitidine and cimetidine on male sex hormones. Scandinavian Journal of Gastroenterology—Supplement1981;69:19–25.
36.
PorterJBBeardKWalkerALawsonDHJickHKellawayGS. Intensive hospital monitoring study of intravenous cimetidine. Archives of Internal Medicine1986;146:2237–2239.
37.
Mental confusion associated with ranitidine [letters]. Medical Journal of Australia1983;2:477–479.
38.
SilverstonePH. Ranitidine and confusion [letter]. Lancet1984;1(8385):1071.
39.
HughesJDReedWDSerjeantCS. Mental confusion associated with ranitidine [letter]. Medical Journal of Australia1983;2:12–13.
40.
EpsteinCM. Ranitidine and confusion [letter]. Lancet1984;1(8385):1071.
41.
ManiRBSpellunJSFrankJHLaurenoR. H2-receptor blockers and mental confusion [letter]. Lancet1984;2(8394):98.
42.
BillingsRFSteinMB. Depression associated with ranitidine. American Journal of Psychiatry1986;143:915–916.
HirschE. Famotidine and ranitidine, but not cimetidine, causes severe, disabling headache [letter]. Gastroenterology1989;84:202–203.
45.
EpsteinCM. Histamine H2 antagonists and the nervous system. American Family Physician1985;32:109–112.
46.
ZimmermanTWSchenkerS. A comparative evaluation of cimetidine and ranitidine. Rational Drug Therapy1985;19:1–7.
47.
FrestonJW. Safety perspectives on parental H2-receptor antagonists. American Journal of Medicine1987;83:58–67.
48.
McElweeHPSirinekKRLevineBA. Cimetidine affords protection equal to antacids in prevention of stress ulceration following thermal injury. Surgery1979;86:620–626.
49.
StoeltingRK. Gastric fluid pH in patients receiving cimetidine. Anesthesia and Analgesia1978;57:675–677.
50.
Cimetidine and the acid-aspiration syndrome. Lancet1980;1(8166):465–466.
51.
ToungTCameronJL. Cimetidine as a preoperative medication to reduce the complications of aspiration of gastric contents. Surgery1980;87:205–208.
52.
CantuTGKorekJS. Central nervous system reactions to histamine-2 receptor blockers. Annals of Internal Medicine1991;114:1027–1034.
53.
WelageLSWingPESchentagJJWilliamsJSRootJKBerlinRG. An evaluation of intravenous famotidine versus cimetidine therapy in the critically ill. Gastroenterology1988;94:A491.
54.
DasAFFrestonJWJacobsJFoxNAMortonRE. An evaluation of safety in 37,252 patients treated with cimetidine or ranitidine. Internal Medicine for the Specialist1990;11:3–14.
55.
LipowskyZJ. Delirium, clouding of consciousness and confusion. Journal of Nervous and Mental Disease1967;145:227–255.
56.
FrancisJKapoorWN. Delirium in hospitalized elderly. Journal of General Internal Medicine1990;5:65–79.
57.
GehiMStrainJJWeltzNJacobsJ. Is there a need for admission and discharge cognitive screening for the medically ill? General Hospital Psychiatry1980;2:186–191.
58.
CavanaughS vonAmmon. The prevalence of emotional and cognitive dysfunction in a general medical population: Using the MMSE, GHQ, and BDI. General Hospital Psychiatry1983;5:15–24.
59.
LitovitzGLHedbergMWiseTNWhiteJDMannLS. Recognition of psychological and cognitive impairments in the emergency department. American Journal of Emergency Medicine1985;3:400–402.
60.
McCartneyJRPalmateerLM. Assessment of cognitive deficit in geriatric patients: A study of physician behavior. Journal of American Geriatric Society1985;33:467–471.
61.
FolsteinMFFolsteinSEMcHughPR. “Mini-mental state.” A practical method for grading the cognitive state of patients for the clinician. Journal of Psychiatry Residency1975;12:189–198.
62.
SmithLWDimsdaleJE. Postcardiotomy delirium: Conclusions after 25 years? American Journal of Psychiatry1989;146:452–458.
63.
GalaskoDKlauberMRHofstetterCRSalmonDPLaskerBThalLJ. The Mini-Mental State Examination in the early diagnosis of Alzheimer's disease. Archives of Neurology1990;47:49–52.
