Prevention and Transition

Abstract

Strategies to protect workers' health and the environment outside of the workplace, were, respectively, once based on the notion of control: a series of controls (engineering and administrative) in the workplace and emission controls to protect the public environment. Two parallel changes occurred. The first was a shift from the general principles of control to the notion of a hierarchy of control measures and the second was a recasting of the Hierarchy of Controls into what has been called a Hierarchy of Prevention and Controls. This article cites the Canadian experience to show that this twofold shift is a progressive and constructive move; the United States provides both the sources of the problem and some solutions. “Just Transition” for workers during environmental change was developed in the context of chemical bans and phase-outs. The concept is now much broader. The article argues that certain pollution prevention measures have been construed as an attack on workers' rights; but this problem can be resolved to the benefit of both workers' health and environmental protection. Explanation of the relation of pollution prevention to Just Transition is a part of the solution.

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Proctor

N. H.

Hughes

J. P.

, Chemical Hazards of the Workplace, Philadelphia and Toronto, 1978.

Sax

N. Irving

, Dangerous Properties of Industrial Materials, Fifth Edition, Section 1, Page 10, New York, 1979.

Plog

B. A.

(ed.), Fundamentals of Industrial Hygiene, Third Edition, pp. 457–458. National Safety Council, 1988 (originally published in 1971). Ironically, a contemporary example is the furthest removed from the grading of control methods in terms of preference: see The Occupational Environment—Its Evaluation, and Control, DiNardi

S. P.

(ed.), Chapter 31 by D. J. Burton, pp. 829–830, American Public Health Association, 1997.

Stellman

J. M.

Daum

, Work is Dangerous to Your Health, Chapter 9, pp. 290–326, Controlling Pollution in the Workplace, New York, 1971.

Occupational Health and Safety. A Training Manual, Chapter 6, Principles of Control, published by the (Ontario) Workers' Health and Safety Centre, 1992.

See, e.g., Clark

D. W.

McMahon

, Preventive and Community Medicine, Second Edition, Little Brown & Company, Boston, p. 8, 1991.

These issues are discussed in Bennett

, Occupational Health. A Discipline Out of Focus, Journal of Public Health Policy, 14:3, pp. 276–298, Autumn 1993.

In the project to amend Part II of the Canada Labour Code, the Canadian Labour Congress argued successfully for a Prevention Regulation under the revised statute.

10.

Commoner

, Making Peace with the Planet, Pantheon Books, New York, p. 43, 1990.

11.

Draft Code Of Practice On Safety In The Use of Synthetic Vitreous Fibre Insulation Wools, Geneva, p. 2, 1999.

12.

This is from the definition of pollution prevention by the Government of Canada in its 1995 publication Pollution Prevention. A Federal Strategy for Action.

13.

One of the first publications pointing out the perils of confusing prevention and control was Rossi

Ellenbecker

Geiser

, Techniques in Toxics Use Reduction, New Solutions, 2:2, pp. 26–27, Fall 1991. (The authors see TUR as a subset of pollution prevention techniques.)

14.

See, principally, Ginsburg

, Quantitative Risk Assessment and The Illusion of Safety, New Solutions, 3:2, Winter 1993; also Risk Assessment As a Regulatory Device, two articles with the same title by Bennett

and Winfield

respectively, in Regulatory Efficiency and the Role of Risk Assessment, Mehta

M. D.

(ed.), Queen's University, Kingston, Ontario, 1995.

15.

See Mirer

, UAW testimony to the U.S. Senate on S. 981, The Regulatory Improvement Act, reprinted in Great Lakes United, 12:1, Winter/Spring 1998.

16.

See The Workplace Killer: Occupational Cancer Should Be Called an Epidemic, Outfront, the magazine of the Canadian Labour Congress, 2:3, Fall 1998; also the CLC National Pollution Prevention Strategy, Ottawa, 1998, an advanced version of a strategy reported in New Solutions, 3:3, Spring 1993.

17.

The Hierarchy of Prevention and Controls was derived from an entirely original idea, Towards A New Hierarchy of Controls, on the part of J. Penney, a doctoral candidate in the Department of Work Environment, University of Massachusetts Lowell.

18.

See Worker Empowerment in a Changing Economy, Wykle

Morehouse

Dembo

, The Apex Press, New York, 1991.

19.

The Canadian Labour Congress Policy on Just Transition For Workers During Environmental Change was endorsed by the CLC Executive Council on April 29, 1999.

20.

See the ICFTU-TUAC Convention Trade Union Statement to the U.N. Climate Change Convention Conference of the Parties (COP4), November 1998.

21.

Wages

, President of OCAW, Hazards, 63, 1998.

22.

A Just Transition For Jobs and The Environment, produced by the Public Health Institute and the Labor Institute, New York, p. 81, 1998.

23.

New Solutions, 1:3, Winter 1991. More clearly, Miller

Lewis

S. J.

drew transition and chemical bans together in “Orderly Transition for Chemical Sunsetting,” New Solutions, 5:1, Fall 1994.

24.

Principally, Kazis

Grossman

R. L.

in Fear At Work, Pilgrim Press, New York, 1982. See also the open letter from L. Leopold and S. Kieding to the editor, New Solutions, 7:3, Spring 1997.