This article discusses the implications of sonochemical research for the treatment of antiquities composed of organic or inorganic materials. It provides a review of some of the present uses of ultrasonic devices and contrasts these empirical applications with the scientific data on how the observed effects are interpreted as cleaning versus damage.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
AbdullaRiaz F.1988Ultrasound in Organic Synthesis, Aldrichimica Acta, 21:1, pp. 31–42.
2.
AlexanderP.1951Emulsification with Sound Waves, Manufacturing Chemist, 22, pp. 5–8,12.
3.
ANONYMOUS1988Shaping a Conservation Plan through General Surveys, (Editorial), Newsletter, American Institute for Conservation, 13:2, March, pp. 1–2.
4.
ApfelbaumBarbara1987Criteria for Treatment: Reversibility, Journal of the American Institute for Conservation, 26:2, pp. 65–74.
5.
BairdD. C.1962Experimentation: An Introduction to Measurement Theory and Experimental Design, Prentice-Hall, Englewood, New Jersey.
6.
BarrettTimothy D.1989Early European Papers/Contemporary Conservation Papers: A Report on Research Undertaken from Fall 1984 to Fall 1987, The Paper Conservator, 13, (section 2.6 “Ultrasonic Properties”), pp. 49–53.
7.
BartonGerry and WeikSabine1986Ultrasonic Cleaning of Ethnographic Featherwork in Aqueous Solutions, Studies in Conservation, 31:3, pp. 125–132.
8.
BornHermann1988Ban Chiang Bronzes: Manufacturing Techniques and Restoration, in The Conservation of Far Eastern Art, MillsJ. S. (ed.), IIC Conference, pp. 130–132.
9.
Leo CaldararoNiccolo1984A Note on the Archaeological Report, North American Archaeologist, 6:1, pp. 63–80.
10.
Leo CaldararoNiccolo1987An Outline History of Conservation in Archaeology and Anthropology as Presented Through its Publications, Journal of the American Institute for Conservation, 26, pp. 85–104.
11.
Leo CaldararoNiccolo1988Paper Treatments. AIC Newsletter, 13:3, May, pp. 10–11 and 13:4, p. 10. Reprinted with revisions in Paper Conservation News, #55, Sept. 1990, pp. 6–7.
12.
Leo CaldararoNiccolo1991Mounting Two Plains Indian Hide Paintings, Curator, 34:3, pp. 187–198.
13.
ChamberlinRobin1990Report on Getty Conservation Institute Course on the Consolidation of Ethnographic Objects, 11–29 June 1990. WAAC Newsletter, 12:3, 9:19.
14.
CharbeneauG. T.1961Use of Ultrasonic Techniques for Cleaning Instruments and Appliances, Journal of Prosthetic Dentistry, 11, pp. 573, May-June.
15.
ChaseW. T.1983Conservation for an Exhibition of Ancient Chinese Objects: A Case History, AIC Preprints, pp. 18–29.
16.
CookeW. D.1989A Pilot Study in the Use of Ultrasonic Cleaning in Textile Conservation, The Conservator, 13, pp. 41–48.
17.
CrawfordA. E.1955Ultrasound Engineering, with Particular Reference to High Power Applications, Butterworths, London.
18.
CurtinBonnie Rose1988Effect on Paper pH and Alkaline Reserve from Magnesium Bicarbonate Introduced via Ultrasonic Humidification, Book and Paper Group Annual, 7, pp. 1–6.
19.
DalyDebra19798 An Investigation into the Use of Several Substances as Fixatives for Works of Art in Pastel, Master's Thesis, Queen's University, Ontario, Canada.
20.
FellerR. L.1967Studies in the Darkening of Vermillion by Light, National Gallery of Art Report and Studies in the History of Art.
21.
FirthJ. N. M.1960The Cleaning of Fossils by Ultrasonic Waves, London, Museum Journal, 60:1, pp. 17–18.
22.
FlintEdward B. and SuslickKenneth S.1991The Temperature of Cavitation, Science, 253, pp. 1397–1399.
23.
FordRichard1977Systematic Research Collections in Anthropology, Peabody Museum, Cambridge, Massachusetts.
24.
FraserDouglas1971The Discovery of Primitive Art, in Anthropology and Art, OttenCharlotte M. (ed.), American Museum Sourcebooks in Anthropology, The Natural History Press, Garden City, New York, pp. 20–38.
25.
GainesAlan M., and HandyJulia L.1977Ultrasonic Disaggregation of Potsherds for Mineral Separation and Analysis, American Antiquity, 42:2, pp. 252–254.
26.
GipsonM.1963Ultrasonic Disaggregation of Shale, Journal of Sedimentary Petrology, 33, pp. 955–958.
27.
GolbuevS. V., and SemchikovYu D.1983Ultrasonic Degradation of Poly-Methacrylate in Solution, Izvestia Vysshikh Uchebnykh Zavedenii Khim. iKhim Tekh., 26:12, p. 1483.
28.
GoubitzOlaf1982The Cleaning of Archaeological Objects with an Ultrasonic Probe, Conservation News, (UKIC Newsletter), 18, pp. 8–10.
29.
GovierT.1970Feathers and Featherwork, in Recent Advances in Conservation, U.K.G.-I.I.C., 30 April Lecture Notes.
30.
GowersHarold J.1968Featherwork and its Conservation, U.K.G.-I.I.C., Lecture Notes, March 14.
31.
GowersHarold J.1972Ethnographical Featherwork, in Textile Conservation, LeeneJ., Butterworths, London, pp. 229–234.
32.
GrattanD. W.1980The Oxidative Degradation of Organic Materials and its Importance in Deterioration of Artifacts, J.I.I.C.-C.G., pp. 17–26.
33.
GreenSara Wolf and StorchPaul S.1986An Evaluation of Feather Cleaning Techniques, in The Care and Preservation of Ethnological Materials, Proceedings, Symposium 86, BarclayR.GilbergM.McCawleyJ. C. and StoneT. (eds.), Canadian Conservation Institute, pp. 31–36.
34.
HallE. T.1959Some Uses of Physics in Archaeology, in Proceedings of a Seminar on Applications of Science in Examinations of Works of Art, Sept. 15–18, Museum of Fine Arts, Boston, pp. 181–193.
35.
HempelK. F. B.1969The Restoration of Two Marble Statues by Antonius Corrudius, Studies in Conservation, 14, p. 126.
36.
HildebrandJoel H.1963An Introduction to Molecular Kinetic Theory, Reinhold, New York.
37.
KatzBarry and MannEugene H.1978The Effects of Implications of Ultrasonic Cleaning on the Amino Acid Geochemistry of Formaninifera, Biogeochemistry Amino Acids, Pap. Conference, pp. 215–222.
38.
KerschnerRichard L.1992A Practical Approach to Environmental Requirements for Collections in Historic Buildings, JAIC, Spr. 13:1, pp. 65–76.
39.
KramerW.1964In Restaurierung und Konservierung, Verlag Bruno Hessling, Berlin.
40.
LazzariniL.1981La Oulitura dei Materiali Lapidea da Construzione e Scultura — Metodi Industriali e de Restauro (The Cleaning of Stone Material in Building and Sculpture-Industrial Methods of Restoration), CED AM — Casa Editrice Dott.Antonio, Milani.
41.
LemmerMichael1972The Cleaning and Protective Coating of Ferrous Metals, International Institute for Conservation, Bulletin, 12:2, pp. 97–108.
42.
LewisBrian1981A Preliminary Report on the Relative Effectiveness of Ultrasonic Cleaning versus Soaking in the Conservation of Clay Tablets, Iraq, 43:1, pp. 76–78.
43.
LoyThomas H.1983Prehistoric Blood Residues: Detection on Tool Surfaces and Identification of Species of Origin, Science, 220, June 17, pp. 1269–1271.
44.
MasudaKatsuhiko1988Kaiga no Kyokubu cleaning ni taisuru suction-table to choonpa hassinki no koka (Efficiency of a suction-table combined with an ultrasonic transmitter for local cleaning of paintings on silk or paper), Hozon Kagaku, 27 March, pp. 21–24.
45.
MazurekJ.1985A Method of Evaluating the Compression Strength in Plaster with Ultrasonic Waves, Polish Academy of Science, October.
46.
MazurekJ.1985Method of Verification of Plaster and Substrate Bonding, Polish Academy of Science, November.
47.
McCRONE ASSOCIATES1966The Report on Testing Book Cleaning Materials, Report to the Library Technology Project, 50, July.
48.
McInnisKerry1980Two Studies in Paper Conservation Practice, ICCMBulletin, 6, June.
49.
MolkenboerJ. A.1980Ultrasonic Cleaning and Degreasing, Metalloberflaeche, 34:4, pp. 159–162.
50.
MuhlethalerB.1973Conservation of Waterlogged Wood and Wet Leather, Paris, p. 67.
51.
NaodiF.MitsuishiY.HayashiT., and OkutamaH.1985Spotting of Water-Soluble Stains on Japanese Silk Kimonos, Part 2: The Removal Effect of Stains on Colorfastness of Kimonos by Drug Cleaning, Journal of Japan Research Association for Textile End-Users, 26:1, pp. 302–310.
52.
OrganR.1959Treatment Using Ultrasonic Vibrations, Studies in Conservation, 4, pp. 35–38.
53.
OrganR.1968Design for Scientific Conservation of Antiquities, IIC, Smithsonian Press, Washington, D.C.
54.
PearlsteinCabelliE. J. D.KingA., and IndictorN.1982Effects of Eraser Treatment on Paper, JAIC, 22:1, pp. 1–12.
55.
PetersonKaren Stemann and Sommer-LarsonAnne1983Cleaning of Ethnographic Feather Garments, Meddelelser om Konservering, IIC Nordic Group, 3:6, pp. 201–216.
56.
PetersonKaren Stemann and Sommer-LarsonAnne1984Cleaning of Early Feather Garments from South America and Hawaii, IIC 1984 Conference Preprints, pp. 84.3.13–16.
57.
PlestersJoyceAshokRoy, and BomfordDavid1982Interpretation of the Magnified Image of Paint Surfaces and Samples in Terms of Condition and Appearance of the Picture, in IIC, Preprints of the Washington Congress on Science and Technology in the Service of Conservation, pp. 169–176.
58.
RathH. and MerkH.1953The Influence of Sonic Vibration on Fibrous Materials, Melliand Textilberichte International, 34, pp. 653–656.
59.
ReedyTerry J. and ReedyChandra L.1988Statistical Analysis in Art Conservation Research, Research in Conservation Series, The Getty Conservation Institute, #1.
60.
RoseIngridEfremovYvonne, and Mihailupu1987Microscopic Examination of Art on Paper During Treatment in Order to Determine the Effects of Treatment Methods on Fibers and Pigments, Working Group 14, ICOM Committee for Conservation, Getty Conservation Institute, Los Angeles, pp. 719–726.
61.
SchumbW.SatterfieldD. and WentworthR.1955Hydrogen Peroxide, Rheinhold, New York.
62.
SenkoE. and ThorpeJ.1985On-line Ultrasonic Measurement of Sheet Modulus, Tappi Journal, 68:2, pp. 95–99.
63.
ShanerE. O.1961Cleaning Dental Instruments with Ultrasonic Equipment, Dental Assistant, 30, p. 20.
64.
SmithMerrily A.JonesNorvell M. M.PageSusan L., and PeckDirda Marian1984Pressure-sensitive Tape and Techniques for its Removal from Paper, JAIC, 23:2, pp. 101–103.
65.
SpenceK.1975Keeping a Cathedral Alive, Country Life, CLVIII(4070), pp. 6–8.
66.
SpierR. F. G.1961Ultrasonic Cleaning of Artifacts: A Preliminary Consideration, American Antiquity, 25:3, pp. 410–414.
67.
SuslickK. S. (ed.) 1988Ultrasound: Its Chemical, Physical and Biological Effects, VCH, New York.
68.
SuslickKenneth and DoktyczStephen1990aInterparticle Collisions Drive by Ultrasound, Science, 2 March, 247, pp. 1067–1069.
69.
SuslickKenneth and DoktyczStephen1990Sounding Out New Chemistry, New Scientist, 3 February, pp. 50–53.
70.
Van DienstE.1985Some Remarks on the Conservation of Wet Archaeological Leather, Studies in Conservation, 30, pp. 86–92.
71.
WebsterLaurie1990Altered States: Documenting Changes in Anthropology Research Collections, Curator, 33:2, pp. 130–160.
72.
WolfSara J.1978Conservation: Feathers, American Indian Art Magazine, 3:4, pp. 77–81.
73.
WolfSara J.1981Feather Preservation, Four Winds, Winter, pp. 67–68.
74.
WolfSara J.1982Feathers: Deterioration and Conservation, in Indian Feathers: Yesterday's Tradition, Today's Care, Tomorrow's Prize, Horse-CaptureG. P. (ed.), Buffalo Bill Historical Center, Cody, Wyoming, pp. 22–30.
75.
YoungGregory S.1986Disruption of Feather Structure by Ultrasonic Cleaning in Aqueous Detergent Baths, in The Care and Preservation of Ethnological Materials, Proceedings, Symposium 86, Canadian Conservation Institute, BarclayR.GilbergM.McCawleyJ. C., and StoneT. (eds.), pp. 37–43.
