The videofluoroscopic and nasopharyngoscopic observations of velopharyngeal movements during speech were compared in 80 subjects with hypernasal speech. An endviewing flexible fiberoptic endoscope was used for nasopharyngoscopic examination. This failed to demonstrate movements of the lateral pharyngeal walls that were videofluoroscopically documented in one third of the patients. In the cases of disagreement, the angle of view was impaired because of the presence of adenoid tissue. The misinterpretation at nasopharyngoscopy was explained by an unfavorable observation position of the flexible scope and failure to pass it further into the pharynx. Conclusions are satisfactory that videofluoroscopy is an indispensable procedure for assessing velopharyngeal function.
ArgamasoR.V.. The pharyngeal flap. In: KernihanD., RosensteinS., eds. Cleft palate: a system of management.Boston: Little, Brown, 1989; 263–269.
2.
ArgamasoR.V.. The role of lateral pharyngeal wall motion in pharyngeal flap surgery.Plast Reconstr Surg1980; 66: 214–219.
3.
BensonD.. Roentgenographic cephalometric study of the palatopharyngeal closure of normal adults during vowel phonation.Cleft Palate J1972; 9: 43–50.
4.
CottonR.T., QuattromaniF.. Lateral defects in velopharyngeal insufficiency.Arch Otolaryngol1977; 103: 90–93.
5.
CroftC.B., ShprintzenR.J., DannilerA., LewinM.L.. The occult submucous cleft palate and the musculus uvulae.Cleft Palate J1978; 15: 150–154.
6.
DavidD.J., WhiteJ., SprodR., BagnallA.. Nasoendoscopy: significant refinements of a direct-viewing technique of the velopharyngeal sphincter.Plast Reconstr Surg1982; 70: 423–428.
7.
GilbertS.T.J., PigottR.W.. The feasibility of nasal pharyngoscopy using the 70 degree Storz-Hopkins nasopharyngoscope.Br J Plast Surg1982; 35: 14–18.
8.
Golding-Kushner. Standardization for the reporting of nasopharyngoscopy and multiview videofluoroscopy: a report from an international working group.Cleft Palate J1990; 27: 337–347.
9.
HonjoI., MitomaT., UshiroK., KawanoM.. Evaluation of velopharyngeal closure by CT scan and endoscopy.Plast Reconstr Surg1984; 74: 620–627.
10.
KarnellM.P., IbukiK., MorrisH.L., Van DenmarkD.R.. Reliability of the nasopharyngeal fiberscope (NPF) for assessing velopharyngeal function: analysis by judgement.Cleft Palate J1983; 20: 199–208.
11.
La RossaD., BrownA., CohenM., SpackmanT.. Videoradiography of the velopharyngeal portal using the Towne's view.J Maxillofac Surg1980; 8: 203–205.
12.
LewinM.L., CroftC.B., ShprintzenR.J.. Velopharyngeal insufficiency due to hypoplasia of the musculus uvulae and the occult submucous cleft palate.Plast Reconstr Surg1980; 65: 585–591.
13.
McWilliamsB.J., MusgraveR.H., CrozierP.A.. The influence of head position upon velopharyngeal closure.Cleft Palate J1968; 5: 117–124.
14.
McWilliamsB.J., GlaserE.R., PhilipsB.J., LawrenceC., LavoratoA.S., BeeryQ., SkolnickM.L.. A comparative study of four methods of evaluating velopharyngeal closure.Plast Reconstr Surg1981; 68: 1–9.
15.
MiyazakiT., MatsuyaT., YamaokaM.. Fiberoptic methods for assessment of velopharyngeal closure during various activities.Cleft Palate J1975; 12: 107–114.
16.
PigottR.W.. The nasoendoscopic appearance of the normal palato-pharyngeal valve.Plast Reconstr Surg1969; 43: 19–24.
17.
PigottR.W., MakepeaceA.P.. Some characteristics of endoscopie and radiological systems used in elaboration of the diagnosis of velopharyngeal incompetence.Br J Plast Surg1982; 35: 19–32.
18.
QuattromaniF.L., BentonC., CottonR.. The Towne projection for evaluating of the velopharyngeal sphincter.Radiology1977; 125: 540–542.
19.
SheltonR.L., TrierW.C.. Issues involved in the evaluation of velopharyngeal closure.Cleft Palate J1976; 13: 127–137.
20.
ShprintzenR.J.. An invited commentary on the preceding article by Ibuki, Karnell, and Morris.Cleft Palate J1983; 20: 105–107.
21.
ShprintzenR.J.. Conceptual framework for pharyngeal flap surgery. In: BardachJ., MorrisH., eds. Management of unilateral cleft lip and cleft palate.Philadelphia: WB Saunders, 1990: 806–809.
22.
ShprintzenR.J.. A comprehensive study of pharyngeal flap surgery: tailor made flaps.Cleft Palate J1979; 16: 46–55.
23.
ShprintzenR.J., Golding-KushnerK.. Evaluation of velopharyngeal insufficiency.Otolaryngol Clin North Am1989; 22: 519–536.
24.
Siegel-SadewitzV.L., ShprintzenR.J.. Changes in velopharyngeal valving with age.Int J Pediatr Otorhinolaryngol1986; 11: 171–182.
25.
SinclairS.W., DaviesD.M., BrackaA.. Comparative reliability of nasal pharyngoscopy and videofluoroscopy in the assessment of velopharyngeal incompetence.Br J Plast Surg1982; 35: 113–117.
26.
SkolnickM.L.. Video velopharyngography in patients with nasal speech, with emphasis on lateral pharyngeal motion in velopharyngeal closure.Radiology1969; 93: 747–755.
27.
SkolnickML.. Videofluoroscopic examination of the velopharyngeal portal during phonation in lateral and base projections: a new technique for studying in mechanics of closure.Cleft Palate J1970; 7: 803–816.
28.
SkolnickM.L., McCallG.N.. Velopharyngeal competence and incompetence following pharyngeal flap service: Videofluoroscopic study in multiple projections.Cleft Plate J1972; 9: 1–12.
29.
SkolnickM.L., McCallG.N., BarnesM.. The sphincteric mechanism of velopharyngeal closure.Cleft Palate J1973; 10: 286–305.
30.
SkolnickM.L., ShprintzenR.J., McCallG.N., RakoffS.. Patterns of velopharyngeal closure in subjects with repaired cleft palate and normal speech: a multi-view videofluoroscopic analysis.Cleft Palate J1975; 12: 369–376.
31.
StringerD.A., WitzelM.A.. Velopharyngeal insufficiency on videofluoroscopy: Comparison of projections.Am J Radiol1986; 146: 15–19.
32.
SubtelnyJ.D.. A cephalometric study of the growth of the soft palate.Plast Reconstr Surg1957; 19: 49–62.
33.
WilliamsW.N., EisenbachC.R.. Assessing VP function: the lateral still technique vs cinefluorography.Cleft Palate J1981; 18: 45–50.
34.
ZwitmanD.H., GyepesM.T., WardP.H.. Assessment of velar and lateral wall movement by oral telescope and radiographie examination in patients with velopharyngeal inadequacy and in normal subjects.J Speech Hear Disord1976; 41: 381–389.
35.
IglesiasA., KuehnD.P., MorrisH.L.. Simultaneous assessment of pharyngeal wall and velar displacement for selected speech sounds.J Speech Hear Res1980; 23: 429–446.
