Prior research indicates that mandatory disclaimers increase consumer confusion and lead to inferior decisions. The authors examine the implications of these findings in the context of mandatory disclosures required by federal law for mortgage loan transactions. Research suggests that consumers can be confused when too much information is presented or disclosure information is too complex but falls short of concluding that all mandatory disclaimers increase consumer confusion and lead to inferior decisions. The literature lacks conclusive evidence of the effects of disclosures on decisions and outcomes, such as loan choice or performance, and research examining the role of disclosures in light of other social, contextual, or informational influences is scarce. Longitudinal, experimental evidence that controls for these factors is necessary to examine the effects of disclosures on decision quality. Better-designed research in this area could lead to significant improvements in public policy and consumer protection and result in a more efficient allocation of public resources.
ScottArmstrong J., and PatnaikSandeep (2010), “Using Quasi-Experimental Data to Develop Principles for Persuasive Advertising,”Journal of Advertising Research, 49(2), 170–75.
Ben-ShaharOmri, and SchneiderCarl E. (2011), “The Failure of Mandated Disclosure,”University of Pennsylvania Law Review, 159, 647–749.
4.
BertrandMarianne, KarlanDean, MullainathanSendhil, ShafirEldar, and ZinmanJonathan (2010), “What's Advertising Content Worth? Evidence from a Consumer Credit Marketing Field Experiment,”Quarterly Journal of Economics, 125(1), 263–305.
5.
BertrandMarianne, KarlanDean, MullainathanSendhil, ShafirEldar, and MorseAdair (2011), “Information Disclosure, Cognitive Biases, and Payday Borrowing,”Journal of Finance, 66(6), 1865–93.
6.
BettmanJames R., LuceMary Frances, and PayneJohn W., (1998), “Constructive Consumer Choice Processes,”Journal of Consumer Research, 25(3), 187–217.
7.
BuiMy, BurtonScot, HowlettElizabeth, and KozupJohn (2008), “What Am I Drinking? The Effects of Serving Facts Information on Alcohol Beverage Containers,”Journal of Consumer Affairs, 42(1), 81–99.
FeinbergRobert, KuehnDaniel, McKernanSigne-Mary, WissokerDouglas A., and ZhangSisi (2012), “What Explains Variation in Title Charges? A Study of Five Large Markets,” prepared for U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development, Office of Policy Development Research, (accessed August 13, 2012), [available at http://www.urban.org/UploadedPDF/1001625-What-Explains-Variation-in-Title-Charges.pdf].
FiskeSusan T., and TaylorShelley E., (1984), Social Cognition.Reading, MA: Addison-Wesley.
15.
GreenKesten C., and Scott ArmstrongJ. (2012), “Evidence on the Effects of Mandatory Disclosures in Advertising,”Journal of Public Policy & Marketing, 31(Fall), [DOI: 10.1509/jppm.12.053].
16.
GreenRichard K. (2008), “Imperfect Information and the Housing Finance Crisis: A Descriptive Overview,”Journal of Housing Economics, 17(4), 262–71.
17.
HillRonald P., and KozupJohn C. (2007), “Consumer Experiences with Predatory Lending Practices,”Journal of Consumer Affairs, 41(1), 29–46.
KozupJohn C., BurtonScot, and CreyerElizabeth H. (2006), “The Provision of Trans Fat Information and Its Interaction with Consumer Knowledge,”Journal of Consumer Affairs, 40(1), 163–76.
26.
KozupJohn C., BurtonScot, and CreyerElizabeth H. (2006), “Boundary Conditions of the Impact of a Hypervigilant Coping Style on the Subjective Decision-Making Experience,”Psychology and Marketing, 23(11), 905–925.
27.
KozupJohn C., TaylorCharles R., CapellaMichael L., and KeesJeremy (2012), “Sound Disclosures: Assessing When a Disclosure Is Worthwhile,”Journal of Public Policy & Marketing, 31(Fall), [DOI: 10.1509/jppm.12.047].
28.
LackoJames M., and PappalardoJanis K. (2004), “The Effect of Mortgage Broker Compensation Disclosures on Consumers and Competition: A Controlled Experiment,” Federal Trade Commission Bureau of Economics Staff Report, (February).
29.
LackoJames M., and PappalardoJanis K. (2010), “The Failure and Promise of Mandated Consumer Mortgage Disclosures: Evidence from Qualitative Interviews and a Controlled Experiment with Mortgage Borrowers,”American Economic Review, 100(2), 516–21.
30.
LeeJinkook, and HogarthJeanne M. (2000), “Consumer Information Search for Home Mortgages: Who, What, How Much, and What Else?”Financial Services Review, 9(3), 277–93.
31.
LevyAlan S., and FeinSara B. (1998), “Consumers Ability to Perform Tasks Using Nutrition Labels,”Journal of Nutrition Education and Behavior, 30(4), 210–17.
32.
LoewensteinGeorge, CainDiylian, and SahSunita (2011), “The Limits of Transparency: Pitfalls and Potential of Disclosing Conflicts of Interest,”American Economic Review, 101(3), 423–28.
33.
LoewensteinGeorge, CainDiylian, and PrelecDrazen (1992), Choices Over Time.New York: Russell Sage Foundation.
MalhotraNaresh K. (1984), “Reflections on the Information Overload Paradigm in Consumer Decision Making,”Journal of Consumer Research, 10(March), 436–40.
36.
MathiosAlan D. (2000), “The Impact of Mandatory Disclosure Laws on Product Choices: An Analysis of the Salad Dressing Market,”Journal of Law and Economics, 43(2), 651–77.
37.
McCoyPatricia A. (2007), “Rethinking Disclosure in a World of Risk-Based Pricing,”Harvard Journal on Legislation, 44, 123.
38.
Morgan FredW., and StoltmanJeff J. (2002), “Television Advertising Disclosures: An Empirical Assessment,”Journal of Business and Psychology, 16(4), 515–36.
39.
PerryVanessa G., and LeeJ.D. (2012), “Marble, Maple, and a Mortgage: Home Shopping, Resource Depletion, and Loan Choice,”International Journal of Consumer Studies, forthcoming.
40.
PettyRichard E., and CacioppoJohn T. (1986), Communication and Persuasion: Central and Peripheral Routes to Persuasion.New York: Springer-Verlag.
41.
RetsinasNicolas P., and BelskyEric S. (2008), Borrowing to Live: Consumer and Mortgage Credit Revisited.Cambridge, MA: Brookings Institution Press and Joint Center for Housing Studies, Harvard University.
42.
RoeBrian, Alan LevyS., and DerbyBrenda M. (1999), “The Impact of Health Claims on Consumer Search and Product Evaluation Outcomes: Results from FDA Experimental Data,”Journal of Public Policy & Marketing, 18(1), 89–105.
WarrenElizabeth (2008), “Product Safety Regulation as a Model for Financial Services Regulation,”Journal of Consumer Affairs, 42(3), 452–60.
45.
Woodward SusanE., and HallRobert E. (2010a), “Diagnosing Consumer Confusion and Sub-Optimal Shopping Effort: Theory and Mortgage-Market Evidence,” NBER Working Paper Series w16007.
46.
Woodward SusanE., and HallRobert E. (2010b), “Consumer Confusion in the Mortgage Market: Evidence of Less Than a Perfectly Transparent and Competitive Market,”American Economic Review, 100(2), 511–15.
47.
YadavManjit S. (1994), “How Buyers Evaluate Product Bundles: A Model of Anchoring and Adjustment,”Journal of Consumer Research, 21(September), 342–53.
