This study investigates whether the traditional underwriting loan metrics, loan-to-value (LTV), debt coverage ratio (DSCR), and debt yield (DY) ratio, can predict lodging commercial mortgage-backed securities (CMBS) loan defaults. Using a data set of 5,266 fixed-rate lodging whole loans that were securitized into CMBS between 1996 and 2015, the results of the study provide evidence of significant relationships between all three metrics and the likelihood of default. The LTV varies positively with default, while the DSCR and DY are negatively related to default. These results hold for a subsample analysis of loans originated prior to the global financial crisis (GFC). Finally, the results show the DY spreads to be adequate proxies for the DY ratio.
AmbroseB.SandersA. (2003). Commercial mortgage-backed securities: Prepayment and default. Journal of Real Estate Finance and Economics, 26, 179-196.
2.
AnX.DengY.GabrielS. (2011). Asymmetric information, adverse selection, and the pricing of CMBS. Journal of Financial Economics, 100, 304-325.
3.
ArcherW.ElmerP.HarrisonD.LingD. (2002). Determinants of multifamily mortgage default. Real Estate Economics, 30, 445-473.
4.
CiochettiB.DengY.LeeG.ShillingJ.YaoR. (2003). A proportional hazards model of commercial mortgage default with originator bias. Journal of Real Estate Finance and Economics, 27, 5-23.
5.
ClaytonJ. (2009). Debt matters: Leverage, liquidity, and property valuation. Journal of Real Estate Portfolio Management, 15, 101-113.
CorcoranP. (2009). Commercial mortgage default and refinancing risk: A primer. Journal of Portfolio Management, 35, 70-79.
9.
CorgelJ. (2008). New beats old nearly every day: The countervailing effects of renovations and obsolescence on hotel prices. Cornell Hospitality Reports, 8(13), 6-17.
10.
CorgelJ. (2012). Demystifying debt yields [Electronic article]. Center for Real Estate and Finance Reports, 1(4), 3-6.
11.
CorgelJ.WallsA. (2010). An analysis of future delinquency for hotel CMBS loans. In Trends in the hotel industry USA 2010 (pp. 12-18). Atlanta, GA: PKF Hospitality Research.
12.
DentonG. (2009). The historical context of the hotel industry and hotel asset management. In G. Denton, L. Raleigh, & A. J. Singh (Eds.), Hotel asset management: Principles & practices (2nd ed., pp. 3-27). Lansing, MI: American Hotel and Lodging Educational Institute.
13.
deRoosJ.LiuC.QuanD.UkhovA. (2014). The dynamics of credit spreads in hotel mortgages and signaling implications. Journal of Real Estate Research, 36, 137-167.
14.
Fitch Ratings. (2012). 2012 Outlook: Cross-sector lodging and timeshare—The penthouse view (Corporates Outlook report). New York, NY: Fitch Ratings, January19, Author.
GrovensteinR.HardingJ.SirmansC.ThebpanyaS.TurnbullG. (2005). Commercial mortgage underwriting: How well do lenders manage the risks?Journal of Housing Economics, 14, 355-383.
19.
JacobD.ManziJ. (2005). CMBS credit protection and underwriting standards: Have they declined so far?The Journal of Portfolio Management, 31(5), 80-90.
20.
KonecnyD. (2014, November19-December2). What is debt yield and why is it important to commercial lenders?Colorado Real Estate Journal, 20.
LiuP.QuanD. (2011). Measuring hotel risk and financing. In SturmanM.CorgelJ.VermaR. (Eds.), The Cornell School of Hotel Administration on hospitality: Cutting edge thinking and practice (pp. 333-350). New York, NY: John Wiley.
25.
LongJ. S.FreeseJ. (2014). Regression models for categorical dependent variables using Stata (3rd ed.). College Station, TX: Stata Press.
26.
LushtK. (1997). Real estate valuation: Principles and applications. Chicago, IL: Richard D. Irwin.
ManningC.O’NeillJ.SinghA. J.HoodS.LiuC.BloomB. (2015). The emergence of hotel/lodging real estate research. Journal of Real Estate Literature, 23, 1-26.
NagpalA.SheelA. (2002). An examination of commercial mortgage-backed securities—Some useful insights for borrowers. Journal of Hospitality Financial Management, 10, 35-48.
33.
O’NeillJ. (2004). An automated valuation model for hotels. Cornell Hotel and Restaurant Administration Quarterly, 45, 260-268.
34.
QuanD.LebretD. (2006). Delinquency and default of securitized hotel mortgages (Working paper). Cornell University School of Hotel Administration, Ithaca, NY.
35.
RushmoreS. (2011, June15). Making sense of debt yield ratios. Lodging Hospitality, 18-20.
36.
RushmoreS.MeleM.XuC.LeeR. (2012, January). 2011 U.S. Hotel Valuation Index. HVS Global Hospitality Services. Retrieved from http://www.hvs.com/Content/3208.pdf
37.
SeagravesP. (2012). A multi-factor probit analysis of non-performing commercial mortgage-backed security loans (Unpublished doctoral dissertation). Robinson College of Business, Georgia State University, Atlanta.
38.
SeagravesP.WileyJ. (2015). The cap rate spread: A new metric for commercial underwriting. Real Estate Economics, 44, 490-520.
39.
Securities and Exchange Commission. (2014, October22). Credit risk retention (17 CFR Part 246 Release No. 34-73407). Washington, DC: Author. Retrieved from https://www.sec.gov/rules/final/2014/34-73407.pdf
40.
Securities and Exchange Commission. (2016). Edgar database: Company filings. Washington, DC: Author.
41.
SnydermanM. (1991). Commercial mortgages: Default occurrence and estimated yield impact. Journal of Portfolio Management, 18, 82-87.
42.
Standard & Poor’s. (2010, June14). CMBS: Methodology and assumptions for analyzing the major property types in U.S. CMBS transactions (Structured Finance). New York, NY: Standard and Poor’s Ratings Services.
43.
Standard & Poor’s. (2012, September5). CMBS: CMBS global property evaluation methodology (Structured finance). New York, NY: Standard and Poor’s Ratings Services.
44.
STR Analytics. (2015). HOST Almanac 2015: U.S. hotel operating statistics for the year 2014. Broomfield, CO: Author.
45.
TitmanS.TompaidisS.TsyplakovS. (2005). Determinants of credit spreads in commercial mortgages. Real Estate Economics, 33, 711-738.
VandellK.BarnesW.HartzellD.KraftD.WendtW. (1993). Commercial mortgage defaults: Proportional hazards estimation using individual loan histories. American Real Estate and Urban Economics Association Journal, 21, 451-480.
49.
WheelerD.ManziJ.ChevanceN. (2016). Historical property revenue volatility analysis suggests caution in evaluating U.S. hotels. CRE Finance World, 18, 24-29.
