Maintaining savings is an important financial goal. Yet there are times when savings should be spent, such as when people face unavoidable costs, and spending their savings allows them to avoid high interest rate debt. Existing behavioral research has focused on consumer decisions between savings and discretionary spending and has proposed interventions to promote savings in these contexts. However, when spending is not discretionary, such interventions could risk exacerbating a pattern found in economic research in which people borrow high interest rate debt while maintaining savings that earn low levels of interest. To examine how mental accounting interacts with considerations of personal responsibility and guilt to contribute to this pattern, this article explores whether people spend their savings when they need money most: during emergencies. Six studies reveal that people's tendency to preserve savings by borrowing from a high interest rate credit option varies as a function of the savings’ intended use. Paradoxically, people are most likely to turn to high interest rate credit with the belief that doing so is the responsible option.
BalandJean-Marie, GuirkingerCatherine, and MaliCharlotte (2011), “Pretending to be Poor: Borrowing to Escape Forced Solidarity in Cameroon,”Economic Development and Cultural Change, 60 (1), 1–16.
2.
BartelsDaniel M. and UrminskyOleg (2011), “On Intertemporal Selfishness: How the Perceived Instability of Identity Underlies Impatient Consumption,”Journal of Consumer Research, 38 (June), 182–98.
3.
Basu, Karna (2010), “A Behavioral Model of Simultaneous Borrowing and Saving,” Munich Personal RePEc Archive, w20442.
4.
BelkRussell W. and WallendorfMelanie (1990), “The Sacred Meanings of Money,”Journal of Economic Psychology, 11 (1), 35–67.
5.
BenabouR. and TiroleJ. (2004), “Willpower and Personal Rules,”Journal of Political Economy, 112 (4), 848–86.
6.
BenartziShlomo, PelegEhud, and ThalerRichard H. (2013), “Choice Architecture and Retirement Saving Plans,” in The Behavioral Foundations of Public Policy, ShafirE., ed. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press, 245–63.
7.
Beshears, John, James J. Choi, David Laibson, Brigitte Madrian, and Jung Sakong (2011), “Self Control and Liquidity: How to Design a Commitment Contract,” working paper, RAND Corporation Publications Department.
8.
BianchiNicholas and LevyRob (2013), “Know Your Borrower: The Four Need Cases of Small-Dollar Credit Consumers,”Center for Financial Services Innovation, [available at http://www.cfsinnovation.com/CFSI_KnowYourBorrower.pdf].
9.
BryanChristopher J. and HershfieldHal E. (2012), “You Owe It to Yourself: Boosting Retirement Saving with a Responsibility-Based Appeal,”Journal of Experimental Psychology. General, 141 (3), 429–32.
10.
CarrollGabriel D., ChoiJames, LaibsonDavid, MadrianBrigitte C., and MetricAndrew (2009), “Optimal Defaults and Active Decisions,”Quarterly Journal of Economics, 124 (November), 1639–74.
11.
CheemaAmar and SomanDilip (2006), “Malleable Mental Accounting: The Effect of Flexibility on the Justification of Attractive Spending and Consumption Decisions,”Journal of Consumer Research, 16 (1), 33–34.
ColbyHelen and ChapmanGretchen (2013), “Savings, Subgoals, and Reference Points,”Judgment and Decision Making, 8(1), 16–24.
14.
College Savings Plan Network (2013), “College Savings Plans Network 529 Report: An Exclusive Mid-Year Review of 529 Plan Activity,” (accessed October 28, 2013), [available at http://www.collegesavings.org/index.aspx].
15.
DeMasters, Karen (2012), “How Much Do People Really Have in IRAs?” Financial Advisor, (June 6), (accessed January 30, 2014), [available at: http://www.fa-mag.com/].
16.
EpleyNick, MakDennis, and IdsonLorraine Chen (2006), “Bonus or Rebate? The Impact of Income Framing on Spending and Saving,”Journal of Behavioral Decision Making, 19 (3), 213–27.
17.
FrederickShane, LoewensteinGeorge, and O'DonoghueTed (2002), “Time Discounting and Time Preference: A Critical Review,”Journal of Economic Literature, 40 (2), 351–401.
18.
GriskeviciusVladas, TyburJoshua M., AckermanJoshua M., DeltonAndrew W., RobertsonTheresa E., and WhiteAndrew E. (2012), “The Financial Consequences of Too Many Men: Sex Ratio Effects on Saving, Borrowing, and Spending,”Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 102 (1), 69–80.
19.
GrossDavid B. and SoulelesNicholas S. (2002), “Do Liquidity Constraints and Interest Rates Matter for Consumer Behavior? Evidence from Credit Card Data,”Quarterly Journal of Economics, 117 (1), 149–85.
20.
HadarLiat, SoodSanjay, and FoxCraig R. (2013), “Subjective Knowledge in Consumer Financial Decisions,”Journal of Marketing Research, 50 (June), 303–16.
21.
Hastings, Justine and Olivia S. Mitchell (2011). “How Financial Literacy and Impatience Shape Retirement Wealth and Investment Behaviors,” NBER Working Paper No. 16740.
22.
HayesA.F. (2013), Introduction to Mediation, Moderation, and Conditional Process Analysis: A Regression-Based Approach. New York: Guilford Press.
23.
HeathChip and SollJack B. (1996), “Mental Budgeting and Consumer Decisions,”Journal of Consumer Research, 23 (1), 40–52.
24.
KahnemanDaniel and TverskyAmos (1984), “Choices, Values, and Frames,”American Psychologist, 39 (4), 341–50.
25.
Kast, Felipe, Stephan Meier, and Dian Pomeranz (2012), “Under-Savers Anonymous: Evidence on Self-Help Groups and Peer Pressure as a Savings Commitment Device,” Harvard Business School Working Paper No. 12-060, October.
26.
Laibson, David, Andrea Repetto, and Jeremy Tobacman (2000), “A Debt Puzzle,” NBER Working Paper No. w7879.
27.
LaibsonDavid, RepettoAndrea, TobacmanJeremy, HallRobert E., GaleWilliam G., and AkerlofGeorge A. (1998), “Self-Control and Saving for Retirement,”Brookings Papers on Economic Activity, 29 (1), 91–196.
28.
LoewensteinGeorge, and ElsterJon, eds. (1992), Choice over Time. New York: Russell Sage.
29.
LoewensteinGeorge, ReadDaniel, and BaumeisterRoy F., eds. (2003), Time and Decision: Economic and Psychological Perspectives on Intertemporal Choice. New York: Russell Sage.
30.
LynchJohn G. and ZaubermanGal (2006), “When Do You Want It? Time, Decisions, and Public Policy,”Journal of Public Policy & Marketing, 25 (Spring), 67–78.
31.
MadrianBrigitte and SheaDennis (2001), “The Power of Suggestion: Inertia in 401(k) Participation and Savings Behavior,”Quarterly Journal of Economics, 116(4), 1149–87.
32.
McGrawA. Peter, TetlockPhilip E., and KristelOrie V. (2003), “The Limits of Fungibility: Relational Schemata and the Value of Things,”Journal of Consumer Research, 30 (2), 219–29.
33.
McKenzieCraig R.M. and LierschMichael J. (2011), “Misunderstanding Savings Growth: Implications for Retirement Savings Behavior,”Journal of Marketing Research, 48 (Special Issue), S1–S13.
34.
MorduchJonathan (2009), Borrowing to Save: Perspectives from Portfolios of the Poor.Financial Access Initiative.
35.
O'DonoghueTed and RabinMatthew (1999), “Doing It Now or Later,”American Economic Review, 89 (1), 103–24.
36.
RavenJ.C. (1965), Advanced Progressive Matrices: Sets I and II. London: Lewis.
37.
RavenJ.C. (1976), Standard Progressive Matrices: Sets A, B, C, D & E. Oxford, UK: Oxford Psychologists Press.
38.
ReadDaniel (2004), “Intertemporal Choice,” in The Blackwell Handbook of Judgment and Decision Making, KoehlerD.J. and HarveyN., eds. Oxford, UK: Blackwell, 424–43.
ShefrinHersh M. and ThalerRichard H. (1988), “The Behavioral Life-Cycle Hypothesis,”Economic Inquiry, 26 (4), 609–43.
41.
SomanDilip (2001), “Effects of Payment Mechanism on Spending Behavior: The Role of Rehearsal and Immediacy of Payments,”Journal of Consumer Research, 27 (4), 460–74.
42.
SomanDilip and CheemaAmar (2011), “Earmarking and Partitioning: Increasing Saving by Low-Income Households,”Journal of Marketing Research, 48 (Special Issue), S14–22.
43.
SomanDilip and LamVivian M. (2002), “The Effects of Prior Spending on Future Spending Decisions: The Role of Acquisition Liabilities and Payments,”Marketing Letters, 13 (4), 359–72.
44.
SomanDilip and ZhaoMin (2011), “The Fewer the Better: Number of Goals and Savings Behavior,”Journal of Marketing Research, 48 (December), 944–57.
45.
StilleyKaren M., InmanJ. Jeffrey, and WakefieldKirk L. (2010), “Spending on the Fly: Mental Budgets, Promotions, and Spending Behavior,”Journal of Marketing, 74 (May), 34–47.
46.
SussmanAbigail B. and ShafirEldar (2011), “On Assets and Debt in the Psychology of Perceived Wealth,”Psychological Science, 23 (1), 101–08.
47.
TamLeona and DholakiaUtpal (2014), “Saving in Cycles: How to Get People to Save More Money,”Psychological Science, 25 (2), 531–37.
ThalerRichard H., and BenartziShlomo (2004), “Save More Tomorrow™: Using Behavioral Economics to Increase Employee Saving,”Journal of Political Economy, 112 (S1), S164–87.
52.
ThalerRichard H and ShefrinHersh (1981), “An Economic Theory of Self-Control,”Journal of Political Economy, 89 (2), 392–406.
53.
ThalerRichard H and SunsteinCass R. (2008), Nudge: Improving Decisions About Health, Wealth and Happiness. New Haven, CT: Yale University Press.
54.
TelyukovaIrina A. (2013), “Household Need for Liquidity and the Credit Card Debt Puzzle,”Review of Economic Studies, 80 (3), 1148–77.
55.
TverskyAmos and KahnemanDaniel (1981), “The Framing of Decisions and the Psychology of Choice,”Science, 211 (4481), 453–58.
56.
ÜlkümenGulden and CheemaAmar (2011), “Framing Goals to Influence Personal Savings: The Role of Specificity and Construal Level,”Journal of Marketing Research, 48 (December), 958–69.
57.
UrminskyOleg and GalZauberman (2015), “The Psychology of Intertemporal Preferences,” in Blackwell Handbook of Judgment and Decision Making, GeorgeWu and GideonKeren, eds. Chichester, UK: Wiley-Blackwell.
58.
WatsonDavid, ClarkLee A., and TellegenAuke (1988), “Development and Validation of Brief Measures of Positive and Negative Affect: The PANAS Scales,”Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 54(6), 1063–70.
Supplementary Material
Please find the following supplemental material available below.
For Open Access articles published under a Creative Commons License, all supplemental material carries the same license as the article it is associated with.
For non-Open Access articles published, all supplemental material carries a non-exclusive license, and permission requests for re-use of supplemental material or any part of supplemental material shall be sent directly to the copyright owner as specified in the copyright notice associated with the article.
