Online chatter is important because it is spontaneous, passionate, information rich, granular, and live. Thus, it can forewarn and be diagnostic about potential problems with automobile models, known as nameplates. The authors define “perverse halo” (or negative spillover) as the phenomenon whereby negative chatter about one nameplate increases negative chatter for another nameplate. The authors test the existence of such a perverse halo for 48 nameplates from four different brands during a series of automobile recalls. The analysis is by individual and panel vector autoregressive models. The study finds that perverse halo is extensive. It occurs for nameplates within the same brand across segments and across brands within segments. It is strongest between brands of the same country. Perverse halo is asymmetric, being stronger from a dominant brand to a less dominant brand than vice versa. Apology advertising about recalls has harmful effects on both the recalled brand and its rivals. Furthermore, these halo effects affect downstream performance metrics such as sales and stock market performance. Online chatter amplifies the negative effect of recalls on downstream sales by about 4.5 times.
ArellanoManuel and BondStephen (1991), “Some Tests of Specification for Panel Data: Monte Carlo Evidence and an Application to Employment Equations,”Review of Economic Studies, 58 (2), 277–97.
3.
ArellanoManuel and BoverOlympia (1995), “Another Look at the Instrumental Variable Estimation of Error-Components Models,”Journal of Econometrics, 68 (1), 29–51.
BaeYong-Kyun and Benítez-SilvaHugo (2013), “The Effects of Automobile Recalls on the Severity of Accidents,”Economic Inquiry, 51 (2), 1232–50.
6.
BarsalouLawrence W. (1992), Cognitive Psychology: An Overview for Cognitive Psychologists. Hillsdale, NJ: Lawrence Erlbaum Associates.
7.
BlackshawPete and NazzaroMike (2006), Consumer-Generated Media (CGM) 101: Word-of-Mouth in the Age of the Web-Fortified Consumer, 2nd ed. New York: BuzzMetrics.
8.
BlundellRichard and BondStephen (1998), “Initial Conditions and Moment Restrictions in Dynamic Panel Data Models,”Journal of Econometrics, 87 (1), 115–43.
9.
ChenYubo, GanesanShankar, and LiuYong (2009), “Does a Firm's Product Recall Strategy Affect Its Financial Value? An Examination of Strategic Alternatives During Product-Harm Crises,”Journal of Marketing, 73 (November), 214–26.
10.
ChevalierJudith A. and MayzlinDina (2006), “The Effect of Word of Mouth on Sales: Online Book Reviews,”Journal of Marketing Research, 43 (August), 345–54.
11.
ChoiYoonhyeung and LinYing-Hsuan (2009), “Consumer Responses to Mattel Product Recalls Posted on Online Bulletin Boards: Exploring Two Types of Emotion,”Journal of Public Relations Research, 21 (2), 198–207.
12.
ChowStirling and RodgersPeter (2005). “Constructing Area-Proportional Venn and Euler Diagrams with Three Circles,”paper presented at Euler Diagrams workshop, Paris (September 29–30), [available at http://kar.kent.ac.uk/14285/].
13.
ChuTing-Heng, LinChe-Chun, and PratherLarry J. (2005), “An Extension of Security Price Reactions Around Product Recall Announcements,”Quarterly Journal of Business and Economics, 44 (3/4), 33–47.
14.
CleerenKathleen, DekimpeMarnik G., and HelsenKristiaan (2008), “Weathering Product-Harm Crises,”Journal of the Academy of Marketing Science, 36 (2), 262–70.
15.
CollinsAllan M. and LoftusElizabeth F. (1975), “A Spreading-Activation Theory of Semantic Processing,”Psychological Review, 82 (6), 407–28.
16.
DawarNiraj (1998), “Product-Harm Crises and the Signaling Ability of Brands,”International Studies of Management and Organization, 28 (3), 109–19.
17.
DawarNiraj and PillutlaMadan M. (2000), “Impact of Product-Harm Crises on Brand Equity: The Moderating Role of Consumer Expectations,”Journal of Marketing Research, 37 (May), 215–26.
18.
DeightonJohn A. and KornfeldLeora (2008), “Obama Versus Clinton: The YouTube Primary,”Case No. 509-032, Harvard Business School (October).
19.
DeightonJohn A. and KornfeldLeora (2010), “United Breaks Guitars,”Case No. 510-057, Harvard Business School (January).
20.
DekimpeMarnik G. and HanssensDominique M. (1995), “The Persistence of Marketing Effects on Sales,”Marketing Science, 14 (1), 1–21.
21.
DellarocasChrysanthos, ZhangXiaoquan Michael, and AwadNeveen F. (2007), “Exploring the Value of Online Product Reviews in Forecasting Sales: The Case of Motion Pictures,”Journal of Interactive Marketing, 21 (4), 23–45.
22.
DrakosKonstantinos and KonstantinouPanagiotis T. (2014), “Terrorism, Crime, and Public Spending: Panel VAR Evidence from Europe,”Defence and Peace Economics, 25 (4), 349–61.
23.
FarquharPeter H., HerrPaul M., and FazioRussell H. (1990), “A Relational Model for Category Extensions of Brands,”Advances in Consumer Research, 17 (1), 856–60.
24.
FazioRussell H. (1987), “Category-Brand Associations and Their Activation from Memory,”working paper, Ogilvy Center for Research and Development.
25.
FeldmanJack M. and LynchJohn G. (1988), “Self-Generated Validity and Other Effects of Measurement on Belief, Attitude, Intention, and Behavior,”Journal of Applied Psychology, 73 (3), 421–35.
GoldenbergJacob, LibaiBarak, MoldovanSarit, and MullerEitan (2007), “The NPV of Bad News,”International Journal of Research in Marketing, 24 (3), 186–200.
28.
GornGerald J. and WeinbergCharles B. (1984), “The Impact of Comparative Advertising on Perception and Attitude: Some Positive Findings,”Journal of Consumer Research, 11 (2), 719–27.
29.
GrangerClive W.J. (1969), “Investigating Causal Relations by Econometric Models and Cross-Spectral Methods,”Econometrica, 37 (3), 424–38.
30.
GrangerClive W.J. and NewboldPaul (1986), Forecasting Economic Time Series, 2d ed. Orlando, FL: Academic Press.
31.
GretoMichael, SchotterAndreas, and TeagardenMary B. (2010), “Toyota: The Accelerator Crisis,”Case No. TB0243, Thunderbird School of Global Management.
32.
HanssensDominique M. (1998), “Order Forecasts, Retail Sales, and the Marketing Mix for Consumer Durables,”Journal of Forecasting, 17 (34), 327–46.
33.
HauserJohn R. and ShuganSteven M. (1983), “Defensive Marketing Strategy,”Marketing Science, 2 (4), 319–60.
Holtz-EakinDouglas, NeweyWhitney, and RosenHarvey S. (1988), “Estimating Vector Autoregressions with Panel Data,”Econometrica, 56 (6), 1371–95.
36.
HongSung-Tai and WyerRobert S.Jr. (1989), “Effects of Country-of-Origin and Product-Attribute Information on Product Evaluation: An Information Processing Perspective,”Journal of Consumer Research, 16 (2), 175–87.
37.
HongSung-Tai and WyerRobert S.Jr. (1990), “Determinants of Product Evaluation: Effects of the Time Interval Between Knowledge of a Product's Country of Origin and Information About Its Specific Attributes,”Journal of Consumer Research, 17 (3), 277–88.
38.
HoraManpreet, BapujiHari, and RothAleda V. (2011), “Safety Hazard and Time to Recall: The Role of Recall Strategy, Product Defect Type, and Supply Chain Player in the U.S. Toy Industry,”Journal of Operations Management, 29 (7), 766–77.
39.
JanakiramanRamkumar, SismeiroCatarina, and DuttaShantanu (2009), “Perception Spillovers Across Competing Brands: A Disaggregate Model of How and When,”Journal of Marketing Research, 46 (August), 467–81.
JoshiAmit and HanssensDominique M. (2010), “The Direct and Indirect Effects of Advertising Spending on Firm Value,”Journal of Marketing, 74 (January), 20–33.
42.
KalaignanamKartik, KushwahaTarun, and EilertMeike (2013), “The Impact of Product Recalls on Future Product Reliability and Future Accidents: Evidence from the Automobile Industry,”Journal of Marketing, 77 (March), 41–57.
43.
KimKwang Ho and TsaiWenpin (2012), “Social Comparison Among Competing Firms,”Strategic Management Journal, 33 (2), 115–36.
44.
KraljicPeter (1983), “Purchasing Must Become Supply Management,”Harvard Business Review, 61 (5), 109–17.
45.
KwakHaewoon, LeeChanghyun, ParkHosung, and MoonSue (2010), “What Is Twitter, a Social Network or a News Media?” in Proceedings of the 19th International Conference on World Wide Web. New York: Association for Computing Machinery, 591–600.
LiuYong (2006), “Word-of-Mouth for Movies: Its Dynamics and Impact on Box Office Revenue,”Journal of Marketing, 70 (July), 74–89.
48.
LokenBarbara and WardJames (1990), “Alternative Approaches to Understanding the Determinants of Typicality,”Journal of Consumer Research, 17 (2), 111–26.
49.
LoveInessa and ZicchinoLea (2006), “Financial Development and Dynamic Investment Behavior: Evidence from Panel VAR,”Quarterly Review of Economics and Finance, 46 (2), 190–210.
50.
LuoXueming (2009), “Quantifying the Long-Term Impact of Negative Word of Mouth on Cash Flow and Stock Price Volatility,”Marketing Science, 28 (1), 148–65.
51.
MaheswaranDurairaj (1994), “Country of Origin as a Stereotype: The Effects of Consumer Expertise and Attribute Information on Product Evaluations,”Journal of Consumer Research, 21 (2), 354–65.
52.
MaheswaranDurairaj and ChenCathy Yi (2006), “Nation Equity: Incidental Emotions in Country-of-Origin Effects,”Journal of Consumer Research, 33 (3), 370–76.
53.
McCombsMaxwell E. and ShawDonald L. (1972), “The Agenda-Setting Function of Mass Media,”Public Opinion Quarterly, 36 (2), 176–87.
54.
NeweyWhitney K. and WestKenneth D. (1987), “A Simple, Positive Semi-Definite, Heteroskedasticity and Autocorrelation Consistent Covariance Matrix,”Econometrica, 55 (3), 703–08.
NijsVincent R., SrinivasanShuba, and PauwelsKoen (2007), “Retail-Price Drivers and Retailer Profits,”Marketing Science, 26 (4), 473–87.
57.
OlivaresMarcelo and CachonGérard P. (2009), “Competing Retailers and Inventory: An Empirical Investigation of General Motors’ Dealerships in Isolated U.S. Markets,”Management Science, 55 (9), 1586–1604.
58.
PauwelsKoen, HanssensDominique M., and SiddarthS. (2002), “The Long-Term Effects of Price Promotions on Category Incidence, Brand Choice, and Purchase Quantity,”Journal of Marketing Research, 39 (4), 421–39.
59.
PauwelsKoen and SrinivasanShuba (2004). “Who Benefits from Store Brand Entry?”Marketing Science, 23 (3), 364–90.
QuelchJohn A., KnoopCarin-Isabel, and JohnsonRyan (2010). “Toyota Recalls (A): Hitting the Skids,”Case No. 9-511-016, Harvard Business School.
62.
RheeMooweon and HaunschildPamela R. (2006), “The Liability of Good Reputation: A Study of Product Recalls in the U.S. Automobile Industry,”Organization Science, 17 (1), 101–17.
63.
RoehmMichelle L. and TyboutAlice M. (2006), “When Will a Brand Scandal Spill Over, and How Should Competitors Respond?”Journal of Marketing Research, 43 (August), 366–73.
SimsChristopher A. and ZhaTao (1999), “Error Bands for Impulse Responses,”Econometrica, 67 (5), 1113–55.
67.
SiomkosGeorge and ShrivastavaPaul (1993), “Responding to Product Liability Crises,”Long Range Planning, 26(5), 72–79.
68.
SmithEdward E. and MedinDouglas L. (1981), Categories and Concepts. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.
69.
SnyderCharles Richard, HigginsRaymond L., and StuckyRita J. (1983), Excuses: Masquerades in Search of Grace. New York: JohnWiley & Sons.
70.
SnyderCharles Richard, Anne LassegardMary, and FordCarol E. (1986), “Distancing After Group Success and Failure: Basking in Reflected Glory and Cutting off Reflected Failure,”Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 51 (2), 382–88.
StephenAndrew T. and GalakJeff (2012), “The Effects of Traditional and Social Earned Media on Sales: A Study of a Microlending Marketplace,”Journal of Marketing Research, 49 (October), 624–39.
73.
StockJames H. and WatsonMark W. (2001), “Vector Autoregressions,”Journal of Economic Perspectives, 15 (4), 101–15.
74.
TellisGerard J. and FransesPhilip Hans (2006), “Optimal Data Interval for Estimating Advertising Response,”Marketing Science, 25 (3), 217–29.
75.
TirunillaiSeshadri (2014), “Mining Marketing Meaning from Online Chatter: Strategic Brand Analysis of Big Data Using Latent Dirichlet Allocation,”Journal of Marketing Research, 51 (August), 463–79.
76.
TirunillaiSeshadri and TellisGerard J. (2012), “Does Chatter Really Matter? Impact of User Generated Content on Stock Market Performance,”Marketing Science, 31 (2), 198–215.
77.
TrusovMichael, BucklinRandolph E., and PauwelsKoen (2009), “Effects of Word-of-Mouth Versus Traditional Marketing: Findings from an Internet Social Networking Site,”Journal of Marketing, 73 (September), 90–102.
78.
Van HeerdeHarald, HelsenKristiaan, and DekimpeMarnik G. (2007), “The Impact of a Product-Harm Crisis on Marketing Effectiveness,”Marketing Science, 26 (2), 230–45.
YangYufeng and YuWeiping (2014), “Brand Scandals Spillover Model Based on the GMDH,” in Proceedings of the Seventh International Conference on Management Science and Engineering Management. Berlin: Springer, 591–601.
81.
ZellnerArnold (1962), “An Efficient Method of Estimating Seemingly Unrelated Regressions and Tests for Aggregation Bias,”Journal of the American Statistical Association, 57 (298), 348–68.
Supplementary Material
Please find the following supplemental material available below.
For Open Access articles published under a Creative Commons License, all supplemental material carries the same license as the article it is associated with.
For non-Open Access articles published, all supplemental material carries a non-exclusive license, and permission requests for re-use of supplemental material or any part of supplemental material shall be sent directly to the copyright owner as specified in the copyright notice associated with the article.
