Defective products are often recalled to limit harm to consumers and damage to the firm. However, little is known about why the timing of product recalls varies after an investigation is opened. Likewise, there is little evidence on whether recall timing affects stock markets. This study tests the effect of problem severity on time to recall, the role of brand characteristics in moderating this relationship, and the stock market impact of time to recall. The authors test the hypotheses on a sample of 381 recall investigations in the automobile industry between 1999 and 2012. The results show that although problem severity increases time to recall, this relationship is weaker when the brand under investigation (1) has a strong reputation for reliability and (2) has experienced severe recalls in the recent past. However, the relationship between problem severity and time to recall is stronger when the brand is diverse. Importantly, the results reveal that stock markets punish recall delays. The study suggests that time to recall has significant implications for managers and policy makers.
ArgoteLinda, and GreveHenrich R. (2007), “A Behavioral Theory of the Firm—40 Years and Counting: Introduction and Impact,”Organization Science, 18 (3), 337–49.
2.
BermanBarry (1999), “Planning for the Inevitable Product Recall,”Business Horizons, 42 (2), 69–78.
3.
BertrandMarianne, DufloEsther, and MullainathanSendhil (2004), “How Much Should We Trust Differences-in-Differences Estimates?”Quarterly Journal of Economics, 119 (1), 249–75.
4.
BorahAbhishek, and TellisGerard J. (2016), “Halo (Spillover) Effects in Social Media: Do Product Recalls of One Brand Hurt or Help Rival Brands?”Journal of Marketing Research, 53 (March), 143–60.
5.
CarhartMark M. (1997), “On Persistence in Mutual Fund Performance,”Journal of Finance, 52 (1), 57–82.
6.
CarrollGlenn R., and SwaminathanAnand (2000), “Why the Microbrewery Movement? Organizational Dynamics of Resource Partitioning in the US Brewing Industry,”American Journal of Sociology, 106 (3), 715–62.
CheahEng Tuck, ChanWen Li, and ChiengCorinne Lin (2007), “The Corporate Social Responsibility of Pharmaceutical Product Recalls: An Empirical Examination of U.S. and U.K. Markets,”Journal of Business Ethics, 76 (4), 427–49.
9.
ChenMing-Jer, and HambrickDonald C. (1995), “Speed, Stealth, and Selective Attack: How Small Firms Differ from Large Firms in Competitive Behavior,”Academy of Management Journal, 38 (2), 453–82.
10.
ChenYubo, GanesanShankar, and LiuYong (2009), “Does a Firm's Product-Recall Strategy Affect Its Financial Value? An Examination of Strategic Alternatives During Product-Harm Crises,”Journal of Marketing, 73 (November), 214–26.
11.
CleerenKathleen, DekimpeMarnik G., and HelsenKristiaan (2008), “Weathering Product-Harm Crises,”Journal of the Academy of Marketing Science, 36 (2), 262–70.
12.
CleerenKathleen, van HeerdeHarald J., and DekimpeMarnik G. (2013), “Rising from the Ashes: How Brands and Categories Can Overcome Product-Harm Crises,”Journal of Marketing, 77 (March), 58–77.
13.
CyertRichard M., and MarchJames G. (1992), A Behavioral Theory of the Firm, 2nd ed. Englewood Cliffs, NJ: Wiley-Blackwell.
14.
DaniSamir, and DeepAman (2010), “Fragile Food Supply Chains: Reacting to Risks,”International Journal of Logistics: Research & Applications, 13 (5), 395–410.
15.
DawarNiraj, and PillutlaMadan M. (2000), “Impact of Product-Harm Crises on Brand Equity: The Moderating Role of Consumer Expectations,”Journal of Marketing Research, 37 (May), 215–26.
16.
DobrevStanislav D. (2000), “Decreasing Concentration and Reversibility of the Resource Partitioning Process: Supply and Deregulation in the Bulgarian Newspaper Industry,”Organization Studies, 21 (2), 383–404.
17.
FamaEugene F. (1998), “Market Efficiency, Long-Term Returns, and Behavioral Finance,”Journal of Financial Economics, 49 (3), 283–306.
18.
FamaEugene F., and FrenchKenneth R. (1993), “Common Risk Factors in the Returns on Stocks and Bonds,”Journal of Financial Economics, 33 (1), 3–56.
19.
FisherMarshall, RamdasKamalini, and UlrichKarl (1999), “Component Sharing in the Management of Product Variety: A Study of Automotive Braking Systems,”Management Science, 45 (3), 297–315.
20.
FolkesValerie S., and KotsosBarbara (1986), “Buyers’ and Sellers’ Explanations for Product Failure: Who Done It?”Journal of Marketing, 50 (April), 74–80.
21.
GaoHaibing, XieJinhong, WangQi, and WilburKenneth C. (2015), “Should Ad Spending Increase or Decrease Before a Recall Announcement? The Marketing–Finance Interface in Product-Harm Crisis Management,”Journal of Marketing, 79 (September), 80–99.
22.
GatignonHubert, AndersonErin, and HelsenKristiaan (1989), “Competitive Reactions to Market Entry: Explaining Interfirm Differences,”Journal of Marketing Research, 26 (February), 44–55.
23.
GeyskensInge, GielensKatrijn, and DekimpeMarnik G. (2002), “The Market Valuation of Internet Channel Additions,”Journal of Marketing, 66 (April), 102–19.
24.
HaunschildPamela R., and RheeMooweon (2004), “The Role of Volition in Organizational Learning: The Case of Automotive Product Recalls,”Management Science, 50 (11), 1545–60.
25.
HaunschildPamela R., and SullivanBilian N. (2002), “Learning from Complexity: Effects of Prior Accidents and Incidents on Airlines’ Learning,”Administrative Science Quarterly, 47 (4), 609–43.
HeathTimothy B., and ChatterjeeSubimal (1995), “Asymmetric Decoy Effects on Lower-Reliability Versus Higher-Reliability Brands: Meta-Analytic and Experimental Evidence,”Journal of Consumer Research, 22 (3), 268–84.
28.
HendricksKevin B., and SinghalVinod R. (1996), “Quality Awards and the Market Value of the Firm: An Empirical Investigation,”Management Science, 42 (3), 415–36.
29.
HoraManpreet, BapujiHari, and RothAleda V. (2011), “Safety Hazard and Time to Recall: The Role of Recall Strategy, Product Defect Type, and Supply Chain Player in the U.S. Toy Industry,”Journal of Operations Management, 29 (7/8), 766–77.
30.
IngramPaul, and BaumJoel A.C. (1997), “Opportunity and Constraint: Organizations’ Learning from the Operating and Competitive Experience of Industries,”Strategic Management Journal, 18 (1), 75–98.
JarrellGregg, and PeltzmanSam (1985), “The Impact of Product Recalls on the Wealth of Sellers,”Journal of Political Economy, 93 (3), 512–36.
33.
JayachandranSatish, and VaradarajanRajan (2006), “Does Success Diminish Competitive Responsiveness? Reconciling Conflicting Perspectives,”Journal of the Academy of Marketing Science, 34 (4), 284–94.
34.
JayaramanVaidyanathan, PattersonRaymond A., and RollandErik (2003), “The Design of Reverse Distribution Networks: Models and Solution Procedures,”European Journal of Operational Research, 150 (1), 128–49.
KalaignanamKartik, KushwahaTarun, and EilertMeike (2013), “The Impact of Product Recalls on Future Product Reliability and Future Accidents: Evidence from the Automobile Industry,”Journal of Marketing, 77 (March), 41–57.
38.
KalaignanamKartik, KushwahaTarun, SteenkampJan-Benedict E.M., and TuliKapil R. (2013), “The Effect of CRM Outsourcing on Shareholder Value: A Contingency Perspective,”Management Science, 59 (3), 748–69.
39.
KellerKevin Lane (1993), “Conceptualizing, Measuring, and Managing Customer-Based Brand Equity,”Journal of Marketing, 57 (January), 1–22.
LeeRuby P., and GrewalRajdeep (2004), “Strategic Responses to New Technologies and Their Impact on Firm Performance,”Journal of Marketing, 68 (October), 157–71.
42.
LeiJing, DawarNiraj, and LemminkJos (2008), “Negative Spillover in Brand Portfolios: Exploring the Antecedents of Asymmetric Effects,”Journal of Marketing, 72 (May), 111–23.
43.
LiangKung-Yee, and ZegerScott L. (1986), “Longitudinal Data Analysis Using Generalized Linear Models,”Biometrika, 73 (1), 13–22.
44.
LiuYan, and ShankarVenkatesh (2015), “The Dynamic Impact of Product-Harm Crises on Brand Equity and Advertising Effectiveness: An Empirical Analysis of the Automobile Industry,”Management Science, 61 (10), 2514–35.
45.
MackelprangAlan W., HabermannMarco, and SwinkMorgan (2015), “How Firm Innovativeness and Unexpected Product Reliability Failures Affect Profitability,”Journal of Operations Management, 38, 71–86.
46.
MadsenPeter M., and DesaiVinit (2010), “Failing to Learn? The Effects of Failure and Success on Organizational Learning in the Global Orbital Launch Vehicle Industry,”Academy of Management Journal, 53 (3), 451–76.
47.
MarucheckAnn, GriesNoel, MenaCarlos, and CaiLinning (2011), “Product Safety and Security in the Global Supply Chain: Issues, Challenges and Research Opportunities,”Journal of Operations Management, 29 (7/8), 707–20.
MitchellMark L., and StaffordErik (2000), “Managerial Decisions and Long-Term Stock Price Performance,”Journal of Business, 73 (3), 287–329.
50.
MoultonBrent R. (1986), “Random Group Effects and the Precision of Regression Estimates,”Journal of Econometrics, 32 (3), 385–97.
51.
PetrinAmil, and TrainKenneth (2010), “A Control Function Approach to Endogeneity in Consumer Choice Models,”Journal of Marketing Research, 47 (February), 3–13.
RaassensNéomie, WuytsStefan, and GeyskensInge (2014), “The Performance Implications of Outsourcing Customer Support to Service Providers in Emerging Versus Established Economies,”International Journal of Research in Marketing, 31 (3), 280–92.
54.
RamdasKamalini, and RandallTaylor (2008), “Does Component Sharing Help or Hurt Reliability? An Empirical Study in the Automotive Industry,”Management Science, 54 (5), 922–38.
55.
RheeMooweon (2009), “Does Reputation Contribute to Reducing Organizational Errors? A Learning Approach,”Journal of Management Studies, 46 (4), 676–703.
56.
RheeMooweon, and HaunschildPamela R. (2006), “The Liability of a Good Reputation: A Study of Product Recalls in the U.S. Automotive Industry,”Organization Science, 17 (1), 101–17.
57.
RubelOlivier, NaikPrasad A., and SrinivasanShuba (2011), “Optimal Advertising When Envisioning a Product-Harm Crisis,”Marketing Science, 30 (6), 1048–65.
58.
RuppNicholas G. (2004), “The Attributes of a Costly Recall: Evidence from the Automotive Industry,”Review of Industrial Organization, 25 (1), 21–44.
59.
RuppNicholas G., and TaylorCurtis R. (2002), “Who Initiates Recalls and Who Cares? Evidence from the Automobile Industry,”Journal of Industrial Economics, 50 (2), 123–49.
SiomkosGeorge J., and KurzbardGary (1994), “The Hidden Crisis in Product-Harm Crisis Management,”European Journal of Marketing, 28 (2), 30–41.
62.
SitkinSim B. (1992), “Learning Through Failure: The Strategy of Small Losses,”Research in Organizational Behavior, 14, 231–66.
63.
SmithCraig N., ThomasRobert J., and QuelchJohn A. (1996), “A Strategic Approach to Managing Product Recalls,”Harvard Business Review, 74 (5), 102–12.
64.
SmithKen G., GrimmCurtis M., GannonMartin J., and ChenMing-Jer (1991), “Organizational Information Processing, Competitive Responses, and Performance in the U.S. Domestic Airline Industry,”Academy of Management Journal, 34 (1), 60–85.
65.
SorescuAlina, ShankarVenkatesh, and KushwahaTarun (2007), “New Product Preannouncements and Shareholder Value: Don't Make Promises You Can't Keep,”Journal of Marketing Research, 44 (August), 468–89.
66.
StahlFlorian, HeitmannMark, LehmannDonald R., and NeslinScott A. (2012), “The Impact of Brand Equity on Customer Acquisition, Retention, and Profit Margin,”Journal of Marketing, 76 (July), 44–63.
67.
StawBarry M., SandelandsLance E., and DuttonJane E. (1981), “Threat Rigidity Effects in Organizational Behavior: A Multilevel Analysis,”Administrative Science Quarterly, 26 (4), 501–24.
68.
TangChristopher S. (2008), “Making Products Safe: Process and Challenges,”International Commerce Review, 8 (1), 48–55.
69.
ThirumalaiSriram, and SinhaKingshuk K. (2011), “Product Recalls in the Medical Device Industry: An Empirical Exploration of the Sources and Financial Consequences,”Management Science, 57 (2), 376–92.
70.
ThomasKen (2005), “Government to Investigate 3.7 Million Ford Motor Co. Pickups and SUVs,”Associated Press (March 23).
Van HeerdeHarald, HelsenKristiaan, and DekimpeMarnik G. (2007), “The Impact of a Product-Harm Crisis on Marketing Effectiveness,”Marketing Science, 26 (2), 230–43.
73.
WiederBen (2011), “NHTSA Doesn't Analyze Its Recall Data to ID Worst Car Manufacturers, GAO Says,”The Center for Public Integrity (June 16), https://www.publicintegrity.org/node/4925.
Supplementary Material
Please find the following supplemental material available below.
For Open Access articles published under a Creative Commons License, all supplemental material carries the same license as the article it is associated with.
For non-Open Access articles published, all supplemental material carries a non-exclusive license, and permission requests for re-use of supplemental material or any part of supplemental material shall be sent directly to the copyright owner as specified in the copyright notice associated with the article.
